• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Zero Punctuation Thread

NeverDead

He actually made me wanna play that game ...

Me too... until he got to the part about escort missions and QTEs and how your unkillable character can be killed. I had never heard of this game until this video and now I hate it. It would be better for it to not exist than for it to exist and waste its awesome potential.
 
Those little things that suck you in and instant kill you are a disgusting game mechanic. They exist only because the devs realized the game was too easy and had to stick something in there to try and reign that in.
 

ZealousD

Makes world leading predictions like "The sun will rise tomorrow"
How is it about spoilers? I've been afraid to watch it.

Minor spoilers concerning potential squadmates, romance options, and the location of the final mission. He basically glosses over the ending completely (basically just acknowledges that he knows there are complaints but says "it could have been worse") and he doesn't mention any of the major missions in any detail. It also seems pretty clear that he didn't touch the day one DLC.

Honestly, he doesn't really say a whole heck of a lot about the game.
 
Mass Effect 3



If you're looking for Yahtzee to tear the ending a new asshole, you won't find it here.

"Could've been worse" the best compliment one could give the ending.

How is it about spoilers? I've been afraid to watch it.


Pretty spoiler lite. Couple of super minor things like how many squad mates you get, but that's about it. Doesn't name names or tell you of any deaths and events I don't think.
 

Jackpot

Banned
as his biggest fan that review was pretty embarassing. I know he straight up said he could only blast through the main missions, but still.
 

massoluk

Banned
I was totally expecting him to trash the ending, since trashing the story is usually what he does. Feels weird that Mass Effect 3 got off so easily on that aspect. This whole review is very meh compared to every review he's done.
 
I was totally expecting him to trash the ending, since trashing the story is usually what he does. Feels weird that Mass Effect 3 got off so easily on that aspect. This whole review is very meh compared to every review he's done.

I thought it was pretty right on the money actually. Most of his concerns were simply gameplay and 'story excuse' oriented, which is something completely missing from every other review out there. The ending is not as brutal if you do not invest that much time in it, much like every other game out there.

The issue begins with the 'critical mass' of actually giving a fuck about it. Once you do, there's no way you could consider the ending any good. If you don't, then the ending is 'meh' and you return the rental.

Pretty much every reviewer deals with games in a 'rental' fashion, so his response to it is understandable.
 

Rufus

Member
Honestly, I think he himself takes what he says quite seriously. He plays fast and loose with what's usually considered to be important for reviews and exaggerates points for comedic effect, but if you've read any of his Extra Punctuation columns (which are a whole lot less entertaining or interesting) you'll see that he's quite earnest about game design and how he thinks developers should do things. Pretty sure he thinks of himself as a critic, not an entertainer.
 

Riposte

Member
I know ZP reviews are not meant to be taken seriously but I feel put off purchasing Twisted Metal now.

Twisted Metal is primarily a multiplayer game. That may be a deal breaker, but in any case, Yahtzee isn't a good place that kind of decision. (Then again, I'd go as far as to say he is not good for anything but the occasional laugh.)
 
He hates on the nightmare story but honestly it's a big draw for me. It is annoying they couldn't come up with a better control scheme to default to.
 

Revan

Member
Ninja Gaiden 3

I've felt like Yahtzee has been off lately, but this one brought me back. lol

He hit the nail right on the head with this review - NG3 is by far the worst game I've played in the last couple of years and it holds the #1 spot (right now) for the worst I've played this gen.

It's so incredibly terrible I don't even know where to begin..
 
Top Bottom