Support NeoGAF

SatelliteOfLove · Mar 27, 2007

Cover: BIOSHAWK!!!!

Editorial: Dave grousing over the lukewarm or warmed over 3rd party Wii titles.

Embarrassing Halversonism of the Ish by...Heather Campbell?: "The problem with Paper Mario is that there is a story" It's an ARPG...

Interviews:

Ken Levine of BioSHAWK.

With a TON of Gamecock Media Group's developers (David Stiller gets down on niche games...which he's making...)

Reviews:

TMNT: 8.5

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

SSX Blur: 7

Sonic and the Secret Rings: 7

God of War II: 9.5 (GOTM)

Brave: 8

Formula One Championship Edition: 9

Flow: 7

Death Jr. and the Science Fair of Doom: 8

300: 8.5

Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

Silverfall: 6

Titan Quest Immortal Throne: 8

Bad_Boy · Mar 27, 2007

SatelliteOfLove said:
God of War II: 9.5 (GOTM)

SatelliteOfLove said:
Formula One Championship Edition: 9

farnham · Mar 27, 2007

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

Formula One Championship Edition: 9

Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

Okay i predict

IGN 7.5
GS 6.5
GI 5.5
1up 4.5

for SPM now

maynerd · Mar 27, 2007

SatelliteOfLove said:
Super Paper Mario: 8.5

How is this not a 10? Bias confirmed.

Krowley · Mar 27, 2007

Add "first paper mario review" to the title and this thread will explode like an atom bomb.

Wario64 · Mar 27, 2007

I knew Super Paper Mario wouldn't be that great

Emowii · Mar 27, 2007

farnham said:
Super Paper Mario: 8.5

Okay i predict

IGN 7.5
GS 6.5
GI 5.5
1up 4.5

for SPM now

:lol It's funny cause it's true.

Sinatar · Mar 27, 2007

SatelliteOfLove said:
300: 8.5

:lol

besiktas1 · Mar 27, 2007

SatelliteOfLove said:
TMNT: 8.5
Super Paper Mario: 8.5

Ruh roh?

cw_sasuke · Mar 27, 2007

Wario64 said:
I knew Super Paper Mario wouldn't be that great

8.5 = Bad Game Confirmed

Tieno · Mar 27, 2007

What's Super Paper Mario?

farnham · Mar 27, 2007

i mean its on par with TMNT

the game must suck ballz.. so much for my eternal fate in Inteligent System.. Failed Developer confirmed!

Alpha_eX · Mar 27, 2007

Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

What!?

fatigues_gasolini · Mar 27, 2007

so did they review 300 the movie, or the really shitty game?

Wario64 · Mar 27, 2007

cw_sasuke said:
8.5 = Bad Game Confirmed

When it's Play Magazine, it is. Their scale range is usually 7 to 10.

Mirimar · Mar 27, 2007

Tieno said:
What's Super Paper Mario?

I actually don't know either..but people seem to like it.

infiniteloop · Mar 27, 2007

Bad_Boy said:

Noddy!

Dave!

Tieno · Mar 27, 2007

Wario64 said:
When it's Play Magazine, it is. Their scale range is usually 7 to 10.

So it's a 5/10?

Canti · Mar 27, 2007

Alpha_eX said:
Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

What!?

I was going to post the same thing. Wario has been slammed everywhere, and Wario > SPM?!?

;_;

MiamiWesker · Mar 27, 2007

So SPM is on par with TMNT and 300 the game... yeah something is very wrong here.

Wario64 · Mar 27, 2007

Tieno said:
So it's a 5/10?

It's as good as Killzone Liberation and a bit better than DOAX2

underfooter · Mar 27, 2007

[Clark Gable] · Mar 27, 2007

I wish company sent me moneyhats.

Krowley · Mar 27, 2007

Gamespot seems to be loving SPM in their previews, but they are very spoilerific so watch out..

Oh and to the people who are wondering what it is.. It's basicly the messiah in game form (and a wii exclusive to boot) and therefore this score is pretty much blasphemy.

Imperial Hot · Mar 27, 2007

300 PSP = Super Paper Mario! CONFIRMED!

jvalioli · Mar 27, 2007

SatelliteOfLove said:
Embarrassing Halversonism of the Ish by...Heather Campbell?: "The problem with Paper Mario is that there is a story" It's an ARPG...

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

I usually don't comment on reviews on games I've never played but...WHAT?

cw_sasuke · Mar 27, 2007

Alpha_eX said:
Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

What!?

must be a ****in joke

Y2Kev · Mar 27, 2007

Silverfall must be the worst game ever.

meltpotato · Mar 27, 2007

TMNT: 8.5

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

WOW

ShockingAlberto · Mar 27, 2007

I didn't know anyone took Play's scores seriously after Sonic 360.

Yoshi · Mar 27, 2007

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages4/929717.asp

so it's on par with Sonic the Hedgehog 360? Worst IS game ever confirmed!

Krowley · Mar 27, 2007

jvalioli said:
I usually don't comment on reviews on games I've never played but...WHAT?

Sounds like they just wanted a regular mario platformer without any adventure/RPG elements.

Oblivion · Mar 27, 2007

Tieno said:
What's Super Paper Mario?

Nothing worth worrying about.

ant1532 · Mar 27, 2007

I was deciding whether to get TMNT or Super Paper Mario... I thought Super Paper Mario was goin to be better but I guess I'll just opt them both out and get Wario DS.

radeonxt · Mar 27, 2007

Formula One Championship Edition: 9

300: 8.5

WHAT?? Even a 6 is a high score for those games.

Super Paper Mario: 8.5

WHAT??

Nuclear Muffin · Mar 27, 2007

Nintendo obviously didn`t give any moneyhats to play. Don`t worry SPM will be godly!

Oblivion · Mar 27, 2007

More leik InCOMPETENT Systems, amirite?

Wario64 · Mar 27, 2007

I'll wait for the Game Informer review before I write off Super Paper Mario.

LOCK · Mar 27, 2007

Obviously Play is stupid.

zallaaa · Mar 27, 2007

Wario 9, SPM 8.5? egotism and need of attention confirmed?

"The problem with Paper Mario is that there is a story"

what does it mean?????

AniHawk · Mar 27, 2007

SatelliteOfLove said:
Super Paper Mario: 8.5
Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

Miguga64 · Mar 27, 2007

I better buy TMNT...

WTF!!

ant1532 · Mar 27, 2007

AniHawk said:
Super Paper Mario: 8.5
Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

schuelma · Mar 27, 2007

I read the SPM review- basically the only complaint with the game was that the "story" interfered with the game/platforming elements too much. The reviewer apparently expected a complete platformer and docked it for having the nerve to still have a story and RPG elements.

Kusagari · Mar 27, 2007

Does the 300 game really suck?

Krowley · Mar 27, 2007

schuelma said:
I read the SPM review- basically the only complaint with the game was that the "story" interfered with the game/platforming elements too much. The reviewer apparently expected a complete platformer and docked it for having the nerve to still have a story and RPG elements.

Well if that's true then we can safley ignore this review... Most of GAF knows what to expect from the game.

cw_sasuke · Mar 27, 2007

schuelma said:
I read the SPM review- basically the only complaint with the game was that the "story" interfered with the game/platforming elements too much. The reviewer apparently expected a complete platformer and docked it for having the nerve to still have a story and RPG elements.

thath`s the only negative point ?

jmdajr · Mar 27, 2007

Sonic and the Secret rings got a lower score than the ps3/360 games.

also

I bought NANObreaker for 2 bux!

Play gave it a 9!

tanod · Mar 27, 2007

SatelliteOfLove said:
Wario: Masters of Disguise: 9

Did you see this on the 1UP show? April Fool's?

brandonh83 · Mar 27, 2007

TMNT is NOT an 8.5 :lol :lol

Support NeoGAF

April Play Scores 'n Such (Super Paper Mario = Sonic 360)

Member

time to take my meds

Banned

Banned

Member

works for Gamestop (lol)

Banned

Official GAF Bottom Feeder

Member

If all DLC came tied to $13 figurines, I'd consider all DLC to be free

Member

Banned

Member

Member

works for Gamestop (lol)

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

works for Gamestop (lol)

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

If all DLC came tied to $13 figurines, I'd consider all DLC to be free

TLG Fan Caretaker Est. 2009

Member

Member

Headmaster of Console Warrior Jugendstrafanstalt

Member

Fetishing muscular manly men in skintight hosery

Banned

Member

Banned

Fetishing muscular manly men in skintight hosery

works for Gamestop (lol)

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Wastes hours checking old Famitsu software data, but that's why we love him.

Member

Member

If all DLC came tied to $13 figurines, I'd consider all DLC to be free

Member

when is my burrito

Banned

Similar threads