• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Arkham Asylum Mafia |OT| It's time to kill the Bat

B

batsnacks

Member
Lifeline said:
There have been some people here that voted randomly to pressure people or voted inactives to force them to post, but ended up changing their votes without actually getting the inactives or randoms to start talking. That sounds more suspicious to me.
Click to expand...
batsnacks said:
who?
Click to expand...
batsnacks said:
for emphasis, if Lifeline can actually name some names here I think this would be the first time in the game he said someone was scummy for non-association stuff. :O
Click to expand...

This is really important. Lifeline is just making stuff up.
 
F

franconp

Member
QUICK DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Terrabyte20xx 3
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689

Mazre 3
Natiko 632
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745

Lifeline 4
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Sorian 781

batsnacks 2
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753

Natiko 3
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
Splinter 799

Kalor 1
MickD 533

No vote
AbsolutBro
Mazre
Nudull
StarSketch
That Dude John
Verelios
 
S

Sorian

Banned
Faddy said:
Personally, I think we should lynch Natiko
Click to expand...

I've been watching this developing saga and I just don't see it. Part of that is because the person who argues me down for a huge chunk of day 1 rarely ever ends up being scum but aside from Natiko definitely taking safer votes, I don't see what's scummy. I've used lazy town a few times now because it reminds me of when I just want a more laid back reactive game instead of the usual in your face kind. None of his votes or logic has been inconsistent.

On a side note I still don't know how to take you either Faddy. You've seemed really agreeable to a lot of my points during the middle portion of the day which probably means nothing specific but has weirded me out since you came in down on me early which I guess may not have been the case? Still unsure. But you also seem agenda driven like bats just to a much lesser extent.
 
S

*Splinter

Member
I'm still down for a Kalor lynch if people post quick, but with MickD being the only vote there I assumed it's not happening.


StarSketch said:
He's pulled this same move in past games as both scum and town, actually. He freaks out whenever there's significant pressure on him.
Click to expand...
Yeah that wasn't a scumread that was a "dude don't hold the game hostage".
 
V

Verelios

Member
I'm not going to snipe the vote, the person I feel showed the most suspect behavior this day is Terra. Not because he placated Lifeline and not because he changed his vote but because he changed it under pressure, which is a strong tell for me that something's wrong.

Vote:Terrabyte20xx
 
S

Sorian

Banned
*Splinter said:
Not a huge fan of any of these options... Was considering an "eh fuck it" vote on Mazre but it's not based on much and he just made this post:


which I found myself agreeing with (except I'd swap Worm for Sorian in that last sentence).

That leaves me with Natiko. I think I'd prefer to lynch Acohrs first. I remember thinking "if acohrs is scum then Natiko probably is too, but I don't know what lead me to that.

Apart from that I've had a few small suspicions about Natiko... nothing I could ever put my finger on but a few others have raised similar concerns.

"Eh fuck it"

VOTE: Natiko
Click to expand...

What was troubling about my vote? I wanted pressure there and more dialogue about it. I got my wish even if the day did take a weird turn for my tastes.

StarSketch said:
For drunk posting last night? pretty bad, though if he keeps that up I wouldn't mind.
Click to expand...

If he pops in once a day phase and spiuts gibberish for 10 or so posts, you wouldn't mind?
 
K

Kalor

Member
I don't feel good about any of these options. Everyones sort of equally ambiguous. I'll go with Lifeline. I know that I said I thought they felt more like town earlier but the fact they aren't giving batsnacks names might be telling.

Vote: Lifeline
 
L

Lifeline

Member
My Batsnacks vote comes from this:

- Snacks started the Kalor bandwagon, something i've been against since the beginning
- Snacks and Sorian conversations in the beginning felt forced and I have Sorian already pegged as Mafia
- Snacks jumped on the Terra bandwagon too easily and once that bandwagon really started going, he jumped off.
- He also pretty much started the lifeline bandwagon
- Dr. Worm told me to pick someone that voted for Kalor, and that's when i started looking at Snacks more closely and everything looked more and more suspicious.
- I would still lynch Acorns over Snacks, but since Snacks is more likely, that's where i'll keep my vote.

I'll end with this:


Sorian said:
If you are going to struggle against my vote, you would have been better off pointing out that I've been town reading you all day and now suddenly changed my mind, I give no shits that you have me pegged as scum. That's been your read of me all day, it's always been about how others have interacted with me and never about what I, myself, have done even though there are easy criticisms that could be laid on me. The stuff you do target that I did, never actually happened and when I point out to you that the posts you are quoting from me don't mean at all what you are trying to tell everyone they mean, you've ignored me.
Click to expand...

This post and it's tone seems completely out of place from your previous post throughout the day phase. I haven't played with you before, but maybe others that have see the difference too. Your sudden switch off batsnacks is also weird.

Seems like you're getting ready for a defense after you get a town lynched.

batsnacks said:
This is really important. Lifeline is just making stuff up.
Click to expand...

I've been on mobile, and can't go back quoting posts. But look at all the random votes that were done early game, what exactly did they accomplish before changing their votes?
 
S

Sorian

Banned
Fat4all said:
Quite the spread of votes. 3 with 3 and 1 with 4.

This could go anywhere.
Click to expand...

Well now there's two with 4, I do agree that we need to consolidate in some way now though, this is easy to tie if someone really feels like it.

While waiting for the 60 seocond timer, it is not 5-4.
 
S

*Splinter

Member
Sorian said:
What was troubling about my vote? I wanted pressure there and more dialogue about it. I got my wish even if the day did take a weird turn for my tastes.



If he pops in once a day phase and spiuts gibberish for 10 or so posts, you wouldn't mind?
Click to expand...
Not the vote itself, more the continuing to push for what I think is a bad lynch.


That's a weird way of reading Sketch's post btw
 
S

Sorian

Banned
Lifeline said:
My Batsnacks vote comes from this:

- Snacks started the Kalor bandwagon, something i've been against since the beginning
- Snacks and Sorian conversations in the beginning felt forced and I have Sorian already pegged as Mafia
- Snacks jumped on the Terra bandwagon too easily and once that bandwagon really started going, he jumped off.
- He also pretty much started the lifeline bandwagon
- Dr. Worm told me to pick someone that voted for Kalor, and that's when i started looking at Snacks more closely and everything looked more and more suspicious.
- I would still lynch Acorns over Snacks, but since Snacks is more likely, that's where i'll keep my vote.

I'll end with this:




This post and it's tone seems completely out of place from your previous post throughout the day phase. I haven't played with you before, but maybe others that have see the difference too. Your sudden switch off batsnacks is also weird.

Seems like you're getting ready for a defense after you get a town lynched.



I've been on mobile, and can't go back quoting posts. But look at all the random votes that were done early game, what exactly did they accomplish before changing their votes?
Click to expand...

Aside from the annoyance of being wrong and the limited information it gives me, I wouldn't care that you were town, I also wouldn't need to get ready a defense. Town gets lynched, that's a fact of life, I'm voting you at this late stage because I don't think you're town. It's that simple, it's not even a case of my arm being twisted and I'm being forced to choose the lesser of two evils, your mask seemed to crack a bit which is why my mind changed.
 
L

Lifeline

Member
I meant to write:

I'll end with this: do you really think for a vote this close, mafia will let one of their own get lynched day 1. They have the numbers to make it any of three other people.
 
S

Sorian

Banned
*Splinter said:
Not the vote itself, more the continuing to push for what I think is a bad lynch.


That's a weird way of reading Sketch's post btw
Click to expand...

I plopped the vote down, disagreed with you about preserving certain players day 1, took a nap, then came back and changed my vote. That's not really a push.

And yeah, you said that and I went to read it again, I get what she meant now.
 
S

*Splinter

Member
Lifeline said:
I meant to write:

I'll end with this: do you really think for a vote this close, mafia will let one of their own get lynched day 1. They have the numbers to make it any of three other people.
Click to expand...
If Mafia want to expose themselves this early I'm all for it.


I don't like the Terra vote (especially seeing acohrs, SexyFish and Fat4all leading it) and the Lifeline vote isn't much better. If Natiko doesn't pick up any more votes I'll swap to Kalor, but it would take quite a swing to lynch him now.
 
Y

YesNOnoNOYes

Member
DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Lifeline (6)
Terrabyte20xx 214 449
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Sorian 781
Kalor 810
Royal_Flush 814

Terrabyte20xx (4)
Kalor 434 777
Natiko 450 632
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
Verelios 808

Natiko (3)
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
*Splinter 799

batsnacks (2)
Sorian 669 781
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753

Mazre (2)
acohrs 422 689
Natiko 632
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745 814
Lifeline 747 750

Kalor (1)
batsnacks 140 702
*Splinter 235 579
SexyFish 289 688
MickD 533
Lifeline 693 747

Fat4all (0): *Splinter 579 799

Timeaisis (0): Sorian 78 287, SexyFish 270 289

acohrs (0): Lifeline 173 216, Lifeline 374 496, Terrabyte20xx 449 501

Dr. Worm (0): Sorian 491 669, Lifeline 496 506

StarSketch (0): Natiko 232 450

Sorian (0): Faddy 98 499

SexyFish (0): Timeaisis 207 511, Sorian 287 491, Dr. Worm 318 753

No active vote for Day 1: AbsolutBro, Mazre, Nudull, StarSketch, That Dude John

Day 1 Postcount: *Splinter 24, AbsolutBro 14, acohrs 40, batsnacks 43, Dr. Worm 55, Faddy 44, Fat4all 78, Fireblend 26, Kalor 20, Lifeline 56, Mazre 10, MickD 27, Natiko 51, Nudull 6, Royal_Flush 15, SexyFish 25, Sorian 80, StarSketch 14, Terrabyte20xx 30, That Dude John 3, Timeaisis 22, Verelios 23, Zippedpinhead 12


Day 1 ends:
red_1492988400.png



13 votes for majority
 
L

Lifeline

Member
I don't know how wills work, but i'll leave this here before i leave:

- Look at all the people that decided I was town, but this very last second decided to switch to putting me as Scum.

- Sorian, Kalor, Batsnacks in particular stand out in this ending of the first day phase.

Good luck, see ya on the other side.
 
S

StarSketch

Banned
Sorian said:
What was troubling about my vote? I wanted pressure there and more dialogue about it. I got my wish even if the day did take a weird turn for my tastes.



If he pops in once a day phase and spiuts gibberish for 10 or so posts, you wouldn't mind?
Click to expand...

"If he pulls this again, I wouldn't mind"


Anyway:

vote: lifeline
 
S

Sorian

Banned
VOTE: Terrabyte20xx

I thought about going back to Kalor for a second but realized it just can't happen in this small amount of time without fear of ties.

This make the two wagons 5-5 now though, people need to make choices now, it's time.
 
N

Natiko

Banned
Lifeline said:
I don't know how wills work, but i'll leave this here before i leave:

- Look at all the people that decided I was town, but this very last second decided to switch to putting me as Scum.

- Sorian, Kalor, Batsnacks in particular stand out in this ending of the first day phase.

Good luck, see ya on the other side.
Click to expand...

You're not dead...yet.

Let's at least try and make it interesting.

VOTE: Terrabyte20xx
 
R

Royal_Flush

Member
Sorian said:
With the last 10 minutes remaining, am I supposed to have background reasoning on this vote? Seems drive-by as hell unless I'm missing something.
Click to expand...
Sorry, I thought it was obvious from my earlier posts. Terra still is dangerously close to being lynched and my second favorite lynch candidate is vote leader so I swing over to create additional buffer.
 
S

Sorian

Banned
6-5 since I didn't see Star's vote, I still want fence sitters off the fence.

Also, @Lifeline, it's fascinating that I gave you that ammo and you loaded it up right away, you didn't seem to care about my opinion changing until I said something.
 
Y

YesNOnoNOYes

Member
DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Lifeline (6)
Terrabyte20xx 214 449
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Sorian 781 825
Kalor 810
Royal_Flush 814
StarSketch 823

Terrabyte20xx (6)
Kalor 434 777
Natiko 450 632
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
Verelios 808
Sorian 825
Natiko 826

Kalor (2)
batsnacks 140 702
*Splinter 235 579
SexyFish 289 688
MickD 533
Lifeline 693 747
*Splinter 827

batsnacks (2)
Sorian 669 781
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753

Natiko (2)
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
*Splinter 799 827

Mazre (1)
acohrs 422 689
Natiko 632 826
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745 814
Lifeline 747 750

Timeaisis (0): Sorian 78 287, SexyFish 270 289

Dr. Worm (0): Sorian 491 669, Lifeline 496 506

Sorian (0): Faddy 98 499

acohrs (0): Lifeline 173 216, Lifeline 374 496, Terrabyte20xx 449 501

Fat4all (0): *Splinter 579 799

StarSketch (0): Natiko 232 450

SexyFish (0): Timeaisis 207 511, Sorian 287 491, Dr. Worm 318 753

No active vote for Day 1: AbsolutBro, Mazre, Nudull, That Dude John,

Day 1 Postcount: *Splinter 26, AbsolutBro 14, acohrs 40, batsnacks 43, Dr. Worm 55, Faddy 44, Fat4all 80, Fireblend 26, Kalor 20, Lifeline 57, Mazre 10, MickD 27, Natiko 52, Nudull 6, Royal_Flush 16, SexyFish 25, Sorian 83, StarSketch 15, Terrabyte20xx 30, That Dude John 3, Timeaisis 22, Verelios 23, Zippedpinhead 12


Day 1 ends:
red_1492988400.png



13 votes for majority
 
F

franconp

Member
QUICK DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Terrabyte20xx 6
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
Verelios
Sorian 825
Natiko 826

Mazre 1
Terrabyte20xx 648

Lifeline 6
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Kalor 810
Royal_Flush 814
StarSketch 823

batsnacks 2
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753

Natiko 2
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676

Kalor 2
MickD 533
Splinter 827

No vote
AbsolutBro
Mazre
Nudull
That Dude John
 
L

Lifeline

Member
Sorian said:
VOTE: Terrabyte20xx

I thought about going back to Kalor for a second but realized it just can't happen in this small amount of time without fear of ties.

This make the two wagons 5-5 now though, people need to make choices now, it's time.
Click to expand...

This switch is suspicious, don't let this throw you off. Know that Mafia has nothing to lose here, Terra and me are both town.
 
M

Mazre

Member
I chose neither Lifeline nor Terrabyte.

My best read on scum right now is Dr. Worm. I think there's at most 2 scum among the list of Lifeline and Terra voters as well.

VOTE: Dr. Worm
 
A

AbsolutBro

Member
Vote: Faddy

A lot of his early posts are pure shade throwing. There's the "feud"(?) with Natiko, but not much else. I realize "not much else" is a serious pot/kettle situation. I thought about waiting until next day phase to bring this up, but I'm not big on either current leader so
 
K

Kalor

Member
Lifeline feels genuine and I was split on who to vote even when I chose him. No-one else is viable so I'll add to the buffer.

Vote: Terrabyte20xx
 
L

Lifeline

Member
Sorian said:
6-5 since I didn't see Star's vote, I still want fence sitters off the fence.

Also, @Lifeline, it's fascinating that I gave you that ammo and you loaded it up right away, you didn't seem to care about my opinion changing until I said something.
Click to expand...

you clearly said that because you knew people were going to use the change in reads against you in day two after they find out you lynched a town. You set up a defense for yourself.

I want people to know to look past that BS
 
F

franconp

Member
QUICK DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Terrabyte20xx 7
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
Verelios
Sorian 825
Natiko 826
Kalor 837

Mazre 1
Terrabyte20xx 648

Lifeline 5
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Royal_Flush 814
StarSketch 823

batsnacks 2
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753

Natiko 2
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676

Kalor 2
MickD 533
Splinter 827

Dr Worm 1
Mazre 834

Faddy 1
AbsolutBro

No vote
Nudull
That Dude John
 
S

Sorian

Banned
VOTE: Lifeline

Still my favored choice. This is my last time moving the needle. It's only a 1 vote buffer regardless of where I am.
 
L

Lifeline

Member
If you want to save a town's life, vote against me. Tie it up.

Like i said, mafia have nothing to lose here. We're both towns.
 
Y

YesNOnoNOYes

Member
DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Lifeline (6)
Terrabyte20xx 214 449
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Sorian 781 825
Kalor 810 837
Royal_Flush 814
StarSketch 823
Sorian 842

Terrabyte20xx (6)
Kalor 434 777
Natiko 450 632
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
Verelios 808
Sorian 825 842
Natiko 826
Kalor 837

Kalor (2)
batsnacks 140 702
*Splinter 235 579
SexyFish 289 688
MickD 533
Lifeline 693 747
*Splinter 827

batsnacks (2)
Sorian 669 781
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753

Natiko (2)
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
*Splinter 799 827

Mazre (1)
acohrs 422 689
Natiko 632 826
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745 814
Lifeline 747 750

Dr. Worm (1)
Sorian 491 669
Lifeline 496 506
Mazre 834

Faddy (1)
AbsolutBro 836

Sorian (0): Faddy 98 499

Timeaisis (0): Sorian 78 287, SexyFish 270 289

Fat4all (0): *Splinter 579 799

acohrs (0): Lifeline 173 216, Lifeline 374 496, Terrabyte20xx 449 501

SexyFish (0): Timeaisis 207 511, Sorian 287 491, Dr. Worm 318 753

StarSketch (0): Natiko 232 450

No active vote for Day 1: Nudull, That Dude John, TheWorthyEdge

Day 1 Postcount: *Splinter 28, AbsolutBro 15, acohrs 40, batsnacks 43, Dr. Worm 55, Faddy 44, Fat4all 81, Fireblend 26, Kalor 21, Lifeline 60, Mazre 12, MickD 27, Natiko 52, Nudull 6, Royal_Flush 16, SexyFish 25, Sorian 86, StarSketch 15, Terrabyte20xx 30, That Dude John 3, TheWorthyEdge 0, Timeaisis 22, Verelios 23, Zippedpinhead 12


Day 1 ends:
red_1492988400.png



13 votes for majority
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Variety: When Superman and Batman Copyrights Expire in a Decade, Will It Be Kryptonite for DC?
20
2K
Skyfox replied
Hot Take: Video games talk too damn much.
Opinion 2 3
124
4K
DonkeyPunchJr replied
Opinion: Nolan and Burton Batman annihilate Reeves Batman
2
74
3K
PrimetimeKnight replied
Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League |OT| Sent to Die
18 19 20 21 22
1K
55K
MAX PAYMENT replied
Art For Art's Sake - Captivating Comic Illustrations
Social NSFW Community
34
2K
CAPSOL replied
Top Bottom