TrojanBlade
Member
Just saw JackFrags video...PS4 looks so much better even in MP...come on DF you jokers!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oWkgNO2coc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oWkgNO2coc
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
GillianSeed79
Member
No, seriously. Why does the XO version look better? Again, I have a PS4 preordered, but the difference is obvious to me even though the PS4 has a higher resolution. I'm sorry, to me, the XO version just looks better. The PS4 version looks they have vasoline rubbed all over the screen and turned the brightness up to 100.
Pseudo judo
Member
Different camo on the uni, clouds are missing in the background and some areas inside the chopper look "burnt" due to distortion brought on by the blacks being crushed.
If this shot was indicative of the comparison between PS4 and X1 I'd say the winner is clear cut but it's not as seen by numerous comparisons so far.
There isn't any better textures on XB1, it's just the color difference. If you up the contrast level on the PS4 screen you can see the hair better as well.
And it seems DF made this, they really have some explanations to do like some people already said.
CassidyIzABeast
Member
This thread is moving a mile a minute but this post is such thinly veiled fanboy bullshit I can't let it go.
You specifically picked out the second the frame rate was the biggest in difference, and not a few seconds beforehand where the PS4 was 38 against the xbox at 34 or the second after where it dips to 44 vs. the xbox one at 42. It has a clear frame and aliasing advantage, but jeez man.
As for the crushed blacks, the xbox shot is IN A SHADOW. He's covered by something. Within the next few seconds he walks out, you see it pass, and he's out in the light again. Shown in action here:
But of course you know that, you just scoped the footage. I don't even want to get into a tech discussion but horsehit like your post just muddies the water. Disgusting and pathetic.
Please tell me you're calling artist a Xbox fanboy
Zombie James
Banned
Hm, so does this imply that DF fucked up the comparison?
Mashin Haters
Member
thats it. more jaggies on XO. thats all u guys need to know.
interesting. Hopefully its just the shitty development tools on the X1
RedAssedApe
Banned
it does indeed. has youtube always had 1440p? Or is this just my new retina macbookpro? :O
It looks gorgeous, this video just shot my hype up even more...
i like the map even though i didn't think i would due to it looking like another metro, i love the way the game looks and i love the 60fps... also the megaton for me is that theres people everywhere, 64 players really shows in that video.
no more looking for people on consoles, woot.
SRTtoZ
Member
Serious? Look at the steps, look at the lights. Look how the lighting on the steps goes from blocks on the XB1 to an actual design on the PS4. This is easy stuff man. Look at the jaggies everywhere. All the XB1 has is the darker image which was added via Digital Foundry or can be found on most TV's.
See You Next Wednesday
Banned
Any GAF experts can tell the AA BF4 is running on XBone from this pic?
I'm just shocked, GTAV doesn't look this bad on my 7 year old 360 & GTAV is jaggy as fuck.
I'm just shocked, GTAV doesn't look this bad on my 7 year old 360 & GTAV is jaggy as fuck.
You're looking at it.
Relaxed Muscle
Member
X1 frag video:
DF needs to come clear on this one.
Kenshin001
Member
They don't look that different to me. In fact some shots the XBone looks better which is what a lot of people are saying. Of course difference in resolution, framerate and there are jaggies but to most of the public they probably look the same. It's PS3 vs 360 all over again though now the shoe is on the other foot.
Much ado about nothing.
Kibbles
Member
Ahh thanks for this. Res is pretty shitty on this video but no crushing.
Can't wait to see Ghost's fish AI then.
HeHe
It doesn't. When you turn up the contrast, it gives the illusion of having more details.
Right on.
It's why TVs are set to their horrible "Vivid" settings in showrooms to attract customers, but when you get them home the last thing you want is your eyes blown out to smithereens.
I cant wait for that.
Step outside yourself for a second
You honestly think most people are going to arrive to that conclusion? how many acerage many gamers have their HDTVs calibrated correctly?
so beyond the better resolution, higher framerate and better ambient occlusion, is it just me or are some of the things rendered differently? maybe it's just the HBAO but the statues in the water look different. THe fact that some surfaces are being lit on xbone that shouldn't be and they don't look lit on ps4 I can chalk up to the HBAO but those statues man, they look weird.
I posted a comparison earlier, and during an identical scene, he's darker and almost completely blacked out for huge portions of the scene. Look for yourself:
It DOES crush blacks like a mofo, not denying that. but his post specifically is when the gun is ONLY in a shadow on xbox one and he knew that. Within the same scene he walks out and you can see the gun clearly.
GodParticle
Member
That's what I mean. Most people aren't going to watch any comparison videos. And unless I saw them side-by-side, I wouldn't know the difference =P
Oh boy, the first melt down of the thread so far.
WetPotatoBread
Banned
Yup best vid i've seen.
krypt0nian
Banned
Any GAF experts can tell the AA BF4 is running on XBone from this pic?
I'm just shocked, GTAV doesn't look this bad on my 7 year old 360 & GTAV is jaggy as fuck.
Is Kill It With Fire a AA setting?
EmptySpace
Banned
Alright here we go.
Here is the Jack upload vs. the DF upload screens
Top is the DF video, you can see the crushed blacks
Bottom is the Jack upload, same scene you can see the difference in the wheel black
DF did it on purpose from what I see
There's something fishy about the DF captures, someone needs to get to the bottom of it.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
PS4 version seems to be using some very aggressive blur/smooth filter, all the ground textures etc closer to the player seem higher resolution on XO, but I assume they're equal resolution and just being blurred due to whatever the PS4 version is doing.
AgentP
Thinks mods influence posters politics. Promoted to QAnon Editor.
I guess the the softness on the pc image is a byproduct of the 1080p native rendering solution?
Has the master race been officially taken over by xbox one?
Ya, I think DF got that wrong, maybe on purpose. There is probably not a scaling issue, just a lack of over sharpening.
MutonCommander
Banned
PC is clearly in a league of its own and it's the platform to play on if you want the definitive Battlefield experience. As for the console comparison, it's clear that the PS4 is more powerful but I doubt that the average consumer will be able to easily tell the difference.
Kibbles
Member
X1 frag video:
DF needs to come clear on this one.
That bottom pic looks oversaturated as fuck. Like I said, DF had their Xbox on Expanded, Jacks didn't. Jacks also seems to have color adjusted it like a lot of youtubers tend to do and that's why the colors are way unnaturally over-saturated on the bottom.
Wow, this looks excellent.
Garrett 2U
Member
a mess
Surface of Me
I'm not an NPC. And neither are we.
$100 for exclusive games, or do you only play multiplatform games on your console?
chickdigger802
Banned
gertsmann said:
Hmmmm
CassidyIzABeast
Member
Read his post wrong. My mistake.
