Support NeoGAF

catotheyounger · Apr 11, 2012

Jeels said:
Can someone explain this to me? I get that it's a line spoken in that last episode, but why is it so funny to everyone/meme status?

The commentary track on that particular episode revealed that that line was not part of the script. Rather, it was an ad-lib that was inadvertently left in the final cut - making it somewhat of a special line for fans.
Edit: Beaten like Sansa.

Fuzzy · Apr 11, 2012

Jeels said:
Can someone explain this to me? I get that it's a line spoken in that last episode, but why is it so funny to everyone/meme status?

Because it wasn't supposed to be in the show and nobody caught it. They talk about it during the audio commentary.

Steelyuhas · Apr 11, 2012

Jeels said:
Can someone explain this to me? I get that it's a line spoken in that last episode, but why is it so funny to everyone/meme status?

EDIT: Beaten so horribly

q_q · Apr 11, 2012

The Lamonster said:
It was just an adlib from an extra in the scene. A possible allusion to the fact that Renly is gay.

I think he was referring to the fact that Renly wasn't the rightful heir, not that he was gay.

fallengorn · Apr 11, 2012

Fuzzy said:
Because it wasn't supposed to be in the show and nobody caught it. They talk about it during the audio commentary.

Also, he interjects when they're not even talking about Renly at that point. They were talking about Stannis. It's like the guy is half paying attention to the conversation and was like, "Did someone mention a Baratheon? RENLY IS NOT RIGHT!"

Jarmel · Apr 11, 2012

So how are they going to adapt AFFC and ADWD? Didn't they say they were going chronologically? Also would they need three seasons or could they condense it to two?

Emerson · Apr 11, 2012

catotheyounger said:
The commentary track on that particular episode revealed that that line was not part of the script. Rather, it was an ad-lib that was inadvertently left in the final cut - making it somewhat of a special line for fans.
Edit: Beaten like Sansa.

It's an interesting piece of trivia but like most other memes it's not actually very humorous and was certainly run into the ground pretty quickly.

Famassu · Apr 11, 2012

Jarmel said:
So how are they going to adapt AFFC and ADWD? Didn't they say they were going chronologically? Also would they need three seasons or could they condense it to two?

They are obviously going to combine them for at least two seasons. They've said numerous times that this isn't an adaptation of the books, it's an adaptation of the whole A Song of Ice and Fire, so they don't really think about it in a "Season 3 will be ASOS part 1, Season 4 will be ASOS part 2, Season 5 will be AFFC" way, though the seasons might start at end roughly at the same points as the books (but contain some storylines from future or past books).

Snake · Apr 11, 2012

Cornballer said:
Is there a list of movies/tv shows with multiple GoT cast members in them? I know a few other combinations have been mentioned, but I can't remember them off hand.

Just to add:
The Masterpiece Classic version of Great Expectations that just aired on PBS had both Viserys Targaryen (Harry Lloyd) and King Robert (Mark Addy) in prominent roles. Unfortunately, the Usurper never shares a scene with Westeros' most golden King.

PairOfFilthySocks · Apr 11, 2012

Between Gendry and Gilly we've got two of the actors from the TV show Skins on Game of Thrones. I'd love to see Cook's actor get in on this(CoK)

as Ramsay Bolton lol

Magnus · Apr 12, 2012

I had no idea he was on Skins UK!

NSFW:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRLmhqWusCg

Dude's naked all over the place. Love it.

Subitai · Apr 12, 2012

Magnus said:
I had no idea he was on Skins UK!

NSFW:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRLmhqWusCg

Dude's naked all over the place. Love it.

I found out about Skins through Gendry. lol

timetokill · Apr 12, 2012

q_q said:
I think he was referring to the fact that Renly wasn't the rightful heir, not that he was gay.

Ever heard of a double meaning, or double entendre?

apana · Apr 12, 2012

I have to say she hasn't been mentioned much this season but Michelle Fairley is doing an incredible job as Catelyn. I liked her scene with Robb, both her and Maise should get nominated in the actress categories come awards season.

Plywood · Apr 12, 2012

Cornballer said:
That's a remarkable amount of black text from this thread tonight, gentlemen. Fine work.

I did a rewatch of The Night Lands tonight. The Arya-Gendry-Hot Pie-Lommy scene at the river is pure gold. Hot Pie is hilarious.

A couple potentially gif-able moments if Plywood has the time/interest:
- Bronn's smile when they arrest Janos Slynt
- Arya shoving Gendry
- Theon's "I bet you can" and look at Yara
- Balon ripping the necklace/cloak off Theon

Didn't catch your post til' now, will definitely get to it later today.

Micerider · Apr 12, 2012

apana said:
I have to say she hasn't been mentioned much this season but Michelle Fairley is doing an incredible job as Catelyn. I liked her scene with Robb, both her and Maise should get nominated in the actress categories come awards season.

Yeah, This is one of the characters that got better in the series than in the books for me. Can't wait to see her down south, we need to see more Renly too (I hated him in Season 1, but I've been positively surprised by his new "appearance" in the few shots from trailers).

Socreges · Apr 12, 2012

IAmtheFMan said:
Cornballer should just be a mod at this point.

The mod in the North!

DeSo · Apr 12, 2012

apana said:
I have to say she hasn't been mentioned much this season but Michelle Fairley is doing an incredible job as Catelyn. I liked her scene with Robb, both her and Maise should get nominated in the actress categories come awards season.

Couldn't agree more, I've loved her portrayal.

Dmax3901 · Apr 12, 2012

Socreges said:

Awesome.

Deleted member 30609 · Apr 12, 2012

Yeah, Catelyn's portrayal on the show has been one of my favourite parts about the series.

I still have my own version of, say, Tyrion in my mind (despite Dinklage's awesome take on it), but Catelyn has almost been completely over-taken by Fairley. The actor who plays Tywin did the same thing for his character.

Cornballer · Apr 12, 2012

- Via io9: A mockup for a fake GoT fighting game

- WiC.net: Curtain Call: Elyes Gabel (Rakharo)
- HBO Content: GRRM and others talk about "Religions of Westeros" (youtube)

Plywood said:
Didn't catch your post til' now, will definitely get to it later today.

Thanks!

bengraven · Apr 12, 2012

Oh fuck yes.

Pollux · Apr 12, 2012

Cornballer said:
- Via io9: A mockup for a fake GoT fighting game

Someone needs to make this a reality.

Lactose_Intolerant · Apr 12, 2012

Cornballer said:
- Via io9: A mockup for a fake GoT fighting game

Needs to have Grey Wind next to him in the fight.
Like this:

The Lamonster · Apr 12, 2012

I would be way into a fighting game. There are so many potential characters with their own style!

Funny how I've never really considered it before, usually a fantasy series screams RPG but a fighting game almost makes more sense for ASOIAF.

suzu · Apr 12, 2012

Grey Wind would be his projectile or super.

ultron87 · Apr 12, 2012

Having it be Soul Calibur style would make more sense I'd think. It's not like you'll have anyone throwing fireballs.

agrajag · Apr 12, 2012

The Lamonster said:
I would be way into a fighting game. There are so many potential characters with their own style!

Funny how I've never really considered it before, usually a fantasy series screams RPG but a fighting game almost makes more sense for ASOIAF.

Fuck yeah. Syrio Forel vs. Gregor Clegane!

The Lamonster · Apr 12, 2012

agrajag said:
Fuck yeah. Syrio Forel vs. Gregor Clegane!

Ser Barristan vs. Kingslayer
Robert Baratheon vs. Melisandre

omg this must happen

Kilrogg · Apr 12, 2012

The Lamonster said:
I would be way into a fighting game. There are so many potential characters with their own style!

Funny how I've never really considered it before, usually a fantasy series screams RPG but a fighting game almost makes more sense for ASOIAF.

Or a Sim-City like kingdom manager. Sim Thrones. Sim Westeros, Something like that.

Cornballer · Apr 12, 2012

The guy who drew that says he's working on a Tyrion versus Cersei version right now.

Puddles · Apr 12, 2012

Ideal first game roster:

Ned Stark (Ice)
Robb Stark (Longsword)
Arya Stark (Needle)
Jon Snow (Longclaw)
Robert Baratheon (War Hammer)
Joffrey Baratheon (Lion's Paw)
Jaime Lannister (Longsword)
Sandor Clegane (Broadsword)
Gregor Clegane (Biggest Broadsword)
Syrio Forrel (Rapier)
Khal Drogo (Arakh)
Loras Tyrell (lance)

Later games could have:

Oberyn Martell (spear)
Brienne (broadsword)
Rorge (huge battle axe)
Victarion (whichever weapons, I forget)
Asha Greyjoy (smaller axe)

The Lamonster · Apr 12, 2012

Kilrogg said:
Or a Sim-City like kingdom manager. Sim Thrones. Sim Westeros, Something like that.

There is a game like that, but I can't remember the name. Not related to ASOIAF though.

It has houses (families) and politics stuff though. Anybody know what I'm talking about?

Basileus777 · Apr 12, 2012

The Lamonster said:
There is a game like that, but I can't remember the name. Not related to ASOIAF though.

Do you mean Crusader Kings?

The Lamonster · Apr 12, 2012

Basileus777 said:
Do you mean Crusader Kings?

Yes. Thanks!

Pollux · Apr 12, 2012

Puddles said:
Ideal first game roster:

Ned Stark (Ice)
Robb Stark (Longsword)
Arya Stark (Needle)
Jon Snow (Longclaw)
Robert Baratheon (War Hammer)
Joffrey Baratheon (Lion's Paw)
Jaime Lannister (Longsword)
Sandor Clegane (Broadsword)
Gregor Clegane (Biggest Broadsword)
Syrio Forrel (Rapier)
Khal Drogo (Arakh)
Loras Tyrell (lance)

Later games could have:

Oberyn Martell (spear)
Brienne (broadsword)
Rorge (huge battle axe)
Victarion (whichever weapons, I forget)
Asha Greyjoy (smaller axe)

Tyrion (Bronn)

The Lamonster · Apr 12, 2012

zmoney said:
Tyrion (Bronn)

hahaha true

Fry · Apr 12, 2012

Carice van Houten is soooooo hot. Hotter than Emilia Clarke actually.

Pollux · Apr 12, 2012

Fry8 said:
Carice van Houten is soooooo hot. Hotter than Emilia Clarke actually.

...Let's not get carried away here....

Pai Pai Master · Apr 12, 2012

Fry8 said:
Carice van Houten is soooooo hot. Hotter than Emilia Clarke actually.

WHAOH NOW.

Puddles · Apr 12, 2012

zmoney said:
Tyrion (Bronn)

Shit, of course. Barristan Selmy could also be in there.

Another great character for the sequel would be

Strong Belwas

agrajag · Apr 12, 2012

Puddles said:
Ideal first game roster:

Ned Stark (Ice)
Robb Stark (Longsword)
Arya Stark (Needle)
Jon Snow (Longclaw)
Robert Baratheon (War Hammer)
Joffrey Baratheon (Lion's Paw)
Jaime Lannister (Longsword)
Sandor Clegane (Broadsword)
Gregor Clegane (Biggest Broadsword)
Syrio Forrel (Rapier)
Khal Drogo (Arakh)
Loras Tyrell (lance)

Later games could have:

Oberyn Martell (spear)
Brienne (broadsword)
Rorge (huge battle axe)
Victarion (whichever weapons, I forget)
Asha Greyjoy (smaller axe)

I would remove Arya and Joffrey. THey shouldn't be anywhere near competetive with any of the other fighters. I'd include

Biter, Mance Rayder, and maybe a troll or something

Puddles · Apr 12, 2012

agrajag said:
I would remove Arya and Joffrey. THey shouldn't be anywhere near competetive with any of the other fighters. I'd include

Biter, Mance Rayder, and maybe a troll or something

(series)

They could go with Book 5 Arya

Joffrey would be a joke character, obviously. Or maybe he could come on as a special attack for another character.

bengraven · Apr 12, 2012

zmoney said:
Tyrion (Bronn)

More like the other way around. Or have Tyrion on Bronn's shoulders like in Revenge of Death Adder or Thunderdome. ha]

agrajag said:
I would remove Arya and Joffrey. THey shouldn't be anywhere near competetive with any of the other fighters. I'd include

Biter, Mance Rayder, and maybe a troll or something

Arya could hold her own. Give her Needle and some stealth moves and she'd be good. Joff can't fight, though.

Cornballer · Apr 12, 2012

- Huffington Post: Richard Madden On Robb Stark Growing Up *series spoilers*

The Lamonster · Apr 12, 2012

Richard Madden is such an old man's name.

Basileus777 · Apr 12, 2012

bengraven said:
Arya could hold her own. Give her Needle and some stealth moves and she'd be good. Joff can't fight, though.

Joffrey doesn't need to fight. Just have him in the background Shao Kahn style. He can serve as the announcer too.

IAmtheFMan · Apr 12, 2012

Socreges said:

Well done sir.

Puddles · Apr 12, 2012

I picture Arya as a combination of Soul Calibur's Xianghua and Tali.

fallengorn · Apr 12, 2012

An ASOIAF fighting game should be as "realistic" as Bushido Blade to mimic the reality of the series.

...also I just want another Bushido Blade.

Support NeoGAF

Game of Thrones - Season 2 - George RR Martin's Song of Ice and Fire - Sundays on HBO

Member

I would bang a hot farmer!

Member

Member

Bitches love smiley faces

Banned

May contain jokes =>

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

NeoGAF's smiling token!

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Deleted member 30609

Unconfirmed Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

paid requisite penance

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Bitches love smiley faces

Similar threads