I always have gotten the vibe that, save for Greg, Rose was basically a mother for every living thing ever, while i see why people would feel Amethyst and Pearl had romantic feelings for Rose, i sort of see it as them actually loving her as a mother.
Amethyst's beef with Greg kinda reflects that of childish jelousy of seeing her "mom" dating someone; While Pearl's deal was more along of thinking she was the "favorite child" which also falls in line with middle children and overachieving children (traits that fit Pearl), the way Rose said "My Pearl" can be taken as romantic, but also it's not unlike how mothers talk to their children.
I think for me this mostly comes from the way the series is building up Rose to be this "Mother Goddess" figure, her powerset is Healing, Protecting and giving life, she loved all the creatures of earth, it just screams "Mother" to me.
Pearl and Amethyst fusing could even possibly have been used as "make up with your sister" bonding experience too.
I don't think Amethyst had romantic feelings for Greg or Rose, that was more jealousy that her best bud was being taking away by another friend, which I'm sure plenty of people have experienced that "third wheel" feeling in the past. It's relatable.
But Pearl, after watching the season I do think her feelings might go beyond mere friendship to something a bit more intimate to say the least. I think that's why she is the one that seems most hurt by everything regarding Rose, because she had fused with Rose a lot and might have feelings for her much the same way Ruby and Sapphire have feelings for another that go 'deeper' than mere friends.
Just speculation, but it connects a lot of the dots in my mind about why Pearl seems so disproportionately upset about Rose compared to Amethyst and Garnet. They all clearly are upset over it, but that episode about Pearl thinking Rose told her everything only to find out otherwise really put that relationship in the spotlight that started me wondering if it did not go further between the two.
Anyway, this show got incredibly strong by the second half of the first season, now I appreciate the whole season a lot more and really think this is one of the better cartoons on TV.
You make very good points, but the person you quoted wasn't talking about fusions, he was talking about shape-shifting. So far, aside from Garnet getting stretchy arms that one time, Amythist is the only gem that actively shape shifts and seems to enjoy doing it. She uses it to mimic and mock the other gems, she's turned into animals, and turned into the male Purple Puma wrestler. Garnet seems indifferent to it, Pearl like... actively dislikes it, and Steven ... well, after what happened the one time he tried, can't really blame him for not giving it another go yet.
Shit, you're right the poster I quoted was talking about shapeshifting. Must be tired or something.
Yeah, I purely meant fusions. Shapeshifting I don't think has any particular undercurrent to it as I was discussing it, except Amethyst is inherently more of a wild child and may by default be more drawn to being, well, wild animals and generally crazy with her abilities.
Still, I do think as it relates to fusions, after watching the episodes out again that this is the way I feel about it and the characters relationship with that ability. Shapeshifting doesn't seem to carry as many
emotional strings to it as fusions do, ya know?