-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
Sword Of Doom
Member
Yeah looks beautiful
shinra-bansho
Member
If that's a hardware thing it's going to look terribad on people's TVs considering I imagine a lot are still set at factory/display settings with sharpness cranked up. :/
Anyway, here's a gif of the same scene, no sharpen applied. The only thing "corrected" in the PS4 image is colour space. From DF's image gallery.
http://abload.de/img/1920x-1clqcs.gif
Anyway, here's a gif of the same scene, no sharpen applied. The only thing "corrected" in the PS4 image is colour space. From DF's image gallery.
http://abload.de/img/1920x-1clqcs.gif
GANGSTERKILLER
Member
Damn at those gifs! It looks good.
Dice has surprised me...
Dice has surprised me...
Just for PS4!?
Looks great.
PS4 looks closest to PC.
XO uses filters to make the image look horrible, losing all detail in dark areas with jaggies and artifacts everywhere.
If you want the ps4 version to look just as horrible but with less jaggies you can turn your saturation to 100, sharpness to 10, contrast/brightness to make everything as dark as possible on your TV.
plagiarize
Banned
not true. they set the Xbone to output full RGB. it didn't. for some reason still being investigated. I don't see how that's DFs fault. you can only fault them for not noticing what was going on.
the artificial sharpening is apparent in all of the Xbox One footage I have seen on every site. DF definitely did not add it. the 'soft' look to the PS4 version is apparent in all the PS4 versions I have seen from other sites. DF definitely did not add it.
there is no conspiracy.
It's still there in the SP and Coop modes. I don't know about MP, I'll have to check when I get home.
cyberheater
PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
Really?
Ascended Saiyan
Banned
aa comparison
My eyes..why!?
aa comparison
I know which is which, but you should still label them...
Just noticed that there is a pop in on the left side for both PS4 and Xbone.
Kibbles
Member
There's an option to disable anti aliasing on the PS3 version of BF3.
If it's the same on BF4 for PS4 it will solve the blurry, vasaline textures some of you have been complaining about.
Hopefully this time it allows you to choose between low medium and high. High blurs way too much, medium and low look pretty good.
Slipped meaning?
no idea all he say's is ps4 version on his twitter.
Dreams-Visions
Member
well this looks clean. what version is this?
SwiftDeath
Member
Wonder what that's about
phosphor112
Banned
It's fun to see people guess.
PS4, I think.
I don't see any press releases or anything. Just a new trailer.
iJudged
Banned
I see some difference there nice gif, thnx. One thing that concers me is motion blur, I never liked it, yall think that we can disable that?aa comparison
One
PS4
edit: jayu26: done.
bigboss370
Member
Make a thread? May be one of our insiders comes up with something...
SwiftDeath
Member
Amazon has Dec 31st for both PS4 and XB1 versions
Has Nov 19th for current gen
Probably nothing though
TheRealTalker
Banned
double agree with this.... wasn't really pumped for it before but now my PS4 will have
KZ SF
Knack
BF4
The One Who Knocks
Member
As Zomg mentioned above, Digital Foundry are blaming the Xbox One itself and have said that because elsewhere was using the "Elgato Game Capture HD consumer-level devices" provided by EA (which, according to Digital Foundry is "unsuitable for DF work because they cannot acquire 1080p at 60 frames per second and they do not provide lossless video"). Digital Foundry "claimed that footage from " [the] Xbox One was also acquired at full range 0-255 RGB with the dash set accordingly, in line with the other versions - exactly how we approach every Face-Off." but that "the EA event was set by default to limited range RGB" which resulted in the crushed blacks.
So, honestly, it really is not clear if this is solely a Digital Foundry problem, an Xbox One issue, or a Dice issue (which I don't think is the case). This:
must be taken with caution at the current time but is implying that it is an Xbox One issue.
bigboss370
Member
TheBanditKing
Member
So from what I've read: The PS4 version, has a higher global framerate, has a higher resolution, better effects (OA), anti-alising and an unfortunate filter that softens some of that.
The X1 version: Lower more inconsistent frame rate, lower resolution, and currently has some sort of an RGB issue that is crushing blacks and may or may not get patched with some of the missing effects.
The team overall was a bit sloppy with this port but the technical aspects here point to X1 being underpowered or having a steep learning curve. Neither being good imo because it never helped last gen when PS3 was in that spot.
The X1 version: Lower more inconsistent frame rate, lower resolution, and currently has some sort of an RGB issue that is crushing blacks and may or may not get patched with some of the missing effects.
The team overall was a bit sloppy with this port but the technical aspects here point to X1 being underpowered or having a steep learning curve. Neither being good imo because it never helped last gen when PS3 was in that spot.
SwiftDeath
Member
lol, do you get them confused too?
Is he like, several weeks LTTP when it was announced that the PS4 version was pushed back one week?
Dreams-Visions
Member
YO HOLY SHIT.
I didn't know who this was so I looked up his Youtube channel
http://www.youtube.com/user/jackfrags/videos
The PS4 version looks so much cleaner it's ridiculous. Microsoft, you don fucked up.
rain elbows
Member
Those MP videos have sold me on this game. Agree 100%, mandatory viewing.
BakedSardine
Banned
Full disclosure - I'm only keeping a PS4.
That being said, all of these comparisons show me one thing - for your "average" consumer, they will not see much difference at all in their experience with either game based on what has been shown. I haven't seen much/any Xbone MP videos and there is always the question of how the online experience on both consoles will pan out, but if differences like these are what you think will swing the public one way or the other, you vastly overestimate the public.
I worked in a game store when the PSX and the original Tomb Raider came out and one customer, looking right at Tomb Raider and some 2D platformer on Sega Saturn could not understand why Tomb Raider was revolutionary at the time. The $399 vs. $499 price point will be FAR more important in this race.
That being said, all of these comparisons show me one thing - for your "average" consumer, they will not see much difference at all in their experience with either game based on what has been shown. I haven't seen much/any Xbone MP videos and there is always the question of how the online experience on both consoles will pan out, but if differences like these are what you think will swing the public one way or the other, you vastly overestimate the public.
I worked in a game store when the PSX and the original Tomb Raider came out and one customer, looking right at Tomb Raider and some 2D platformer on Sega Saturn could not understand why Tomb Raider was revolutionary at the time. The $399 vs. $499 price point will be FAR more important in this race.
Moral Panic
Member
Same, I thought that Kagari got de-modded for a second.
GribbleGrunger
Dreams in Digital
I don't think MS should sort that out. People LOVE it!
One correction - there's no 'softening' filter on the PS4, but there is a sharpening filter on the X1. I think also both have the same AA solution, just more resolution on PS4 obviously reduces the appearance of aliasing.
gioGAF
Member
I think the masses from both camps should be happy with how this launch + cross gen title looks.
I do find the Digital Foundry situation appalling. I can understand if some noob puts up a video/images and messes up the settings on one platform, but for Digital Foundry to put something like their "Face-Off Preview" up is just shameful. Especially when there are multiple other sources that better showcase the same content.
I do find the Digital Foundry situation appalling. I can understand if some noob puts up a video/images and messes up the settings on one platform, but for Digital Foundry to put something like their "Face-Off Preview" up is just shameful. Especially when there are multiple other sources that better showcase the same content.
No, just wait for an official announcement if any.
His videos are why I don't get people saying this game doesn't look good on next gen. Shit looks awesome.
There is no "soften" in PS4 version.
Xbone uses just sharpen filter and you can add sharpen via your remote for TV.
Sharpen in Xbone version isn't "better" it is worse because it makes aliasing even more noticeable