I was one of the few people who first played Eternal Darkness before playing any Resident Evil game. All i could remember when i finally got around to playing remake is of how much of a struggle it was after Eternal Darkness. The controls,camera,combat and story and voice acting sucked big time. Since then i have gained more appreciation for RE but back then going from Eternal Darkness into other horror games was rough. While Eternal Darkness has some shortcomings it was quite ambitious and was in some ways ahead of its time.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
LTTP: Eternal Darkness (OMG, whaaaaaat?)
- Thread starter The perfect Dark
- Start date
The mythos of the old ones is far more expansive, for one, and there's a much more deathly gravitas than what's presented in the game. The descent into madness typically doesn't hit like a ton of bricks either, nor are people regularly swashbuckling waves of zombies. Or, are you limiting my answer to one story at a time to suit your argument?
I mean, I don't see why it's so hard to admit that concepts were abbreviated and made more lighthearted. "So far beyond," and "dark, sophisticated," is putting words in my mouth. Lovecraft is often very messy.
Edit: Polaris is a good starting point though. You're not sure if the guy's just crazy or if he's transporting or given glimpses of what's happening or happened. Maybe all three in some way. That's a more complex situation than anything that occurs in the game. I think the matter-of-factness about the game it is more suited towards children too.
Tavernacle12
Member
I played it for the first time fairly recently (two or three years ago) and loved it. That second level of the Roivas mansion made me exceedingly uneasy before I quite realized why. That
My only real complaint is that, other than the corpses, the enemies themselves aren't really frightening on their own.
hall with the creepy window at one end and the empty space where a door SHOULD be but isn't.
My only real complaint is that, other than the corpses, the enemies themselves aren't really frightening on their own.
The perfect Dark
Banned
Does the game have multiple endings and/ or unlockables?
Skiptastic
Member
I'm sure I will never play it again but the time that I did I absolutely loved it.
Paul Luther.
ReyVGM
Member
You pretty much have to
beat the game 3 times to get the full story.
Each time you finish, you restart a new game and have to pick a different last boss path until you do all three.
Nostremitus
Member
Man, I replayed this on all the different variations so many times. Loved the shit out of it...
Schopenhauerian
Member
Yeah, its interesting to look back at this era: Nintendo was making an effort to appeal to the hardcore and mature demographics (one / two), and it's unfortunate that it did not quite work out for them, commercially:
Nintendo's new approach to widening their playerbase and gaining the attention of the general public (with the Wii) was indeed commercially successful, but it not only alienated hardcore gamers, it also alienated also some key development partners (like Silicon Knights), whose ambitions were in some cases dependent upon technically demanding 3D worlds. Interesting in this context to contrast the Dyack/Silicon Knights/Microsoft situation with the Retro/Armature situation (these two cases being somewhat different from the Rare/Free Radical or Rare/Microsoft situations).
I am Christina Aguilera
Member
Still haven't beaten it, but I spent most of what I've played of the game so far with my health and sanity meters deliberately super low and very much enjoyed the Lovecraftian ride
The perfect Dark
Banned
The perfect Dark
Banned
This game is getting better with every new chapter. Amazing, what a great game. (6 hours in btw)
What chapter are you at currently?
The perfect Dark
Banned
Gotta give a shout out to my main man Pious Augustus
The most frustrating level in the game is the insta death traps at the First visit to the Aztec temple. Probably had more to do with having a terrible tv at the time though
Having the journey through time plot allows for some efficient ways to reuse the levels without it being frustrating or boring. Big kudos to that as well. it really ramps up great in the last few levels because of it as well.
The most frustrating level in the game is the insta death traps at the First visit to the Aztec temple. Probably had more to do with having a terrible tv at the time though
Having the journey through time plot allows for some efficient ways to reuse the levels without it being frustrating or boring. Big kudos to that as well. it really ramps up great in the last few levels because of it as well.
Leafhopper
Banned
Not being the scrappy, experimental Nintendo that I liked from the Gamecube days.
BumblebeeCody
Member
I'm really not a fan of the game. If you're into high class story telling and writing like Soul Reaver then that's cool but I've never been able to get into it like others have.
I think the combat is terrible.
Honestly, that sanity meter is a huge gimmick that I thought was more funny to talk about with friends when I was 12 than how I felt more absorbed into the game. Having your save delete or the game restart or your characters head fall off is just a gimmick. It doesn't add anything to the game.
I do think the fans deserve a remake or the next entry into the series. It's a fascinating game.
I think the combat is terrible.
Honestly, that sanity meter is a huge gimmick that I thought was more funny to talk about with friends when I was 12 than how I felt more absorbed into the game. Having your save delete or the game restart or your characters head fall off is just a gimmick. It doesn't add anything to the game.
I do think the fans deserve a remake or the next entry into the series. It's a fascinating game.
V
Vilix
Unconfirmed Member
The best voice acting for its time. One hell of a game.
The perfect Dark
Banned
I really love that you can take control of so much different characters. Every chapter is unique. And between these chapters...it's pretty much Resident Evil. What an amzing experience this game is....WOOOW.
Yeah Pious was great. I loved that the game is set up so you play as just some random dude who turns out to be the main villain and is responsible for the major events that happen through history. I cant think of a single game that has this kind of setup even to this day. Also you are completely right in how this game handles level reuse. It never feels repetitive since the areas change significantly each time giving them that nice fresh feel while also being familiar.
crisdecuba
Member
I really enjoyed this game, and both my siblings and later on my wife enjoyed watching the story unfold. It has an interesting set up that is fun to unravel as the story progresses. It also made playing through the game multiple times at least somewhat interesting when you do it from the different perspectives. The voice acting was excellent overall, and the magic system was interesting in that you could create spells without having learned them once you understand the language.
One thing I would have changed is to remove the visible sanity meter. You should not be able to tell how sane or insane you are at a given moment.
One thing I would have changed is to remove the visible sanity meter. You should not be able to tell how sane or insane you are at a given moment.
The perfect Dark
Banned
The perfect Dark
Banned
Earthbound64
Banned
I turned the game off and never played it again after that.
The perfect Dark
Banned
Zap Rowsdower
Banned
The best part is that
absolutely nothing else happens in the Roivas mansion as Alex until the very end of the game.
chixdiggit
Member
Loved it as well. Is the only way to play this on a Gamecube?
Earthbound64
Banned
Yeah.
F*** that.
If I'd known that, I actually could have finished the game.
You can play it on the original Wii as well.
"At the time" or...."until today"?
It's a very unique experience as far as I can tell.
Well. you have games like Amnesia following some of its footsteps. But you might be right. The sanity meter in the game was amazing.
The perfect Dark
Banned
There's a chapter where you return
to the mansion
Amnesia is a good game but the puzzles were easy and there's no combat. The storytelling is very simple, too. Compared to Eternal Darkness at least.
i completely agree. Some of the principles are there. Just not turned to 11 like in Eternal Darkness. So much stuff happening at all times. Got excited for the sequel but i think that project ended up getting canned? I think it even tried to get kickstarted? I forget, but i do remember the tech demo they were showing.
The perfect Dark
Banned
They tried to make a sequel? Wow, I didn't know that. Nintendo wasn't involved, right? Because they should. I have no idea how much Nintendo was involved in the development of Eternal Darkness but I'm pretty sure they did more than just producing. It feels like a Nintendo product.
Silicon Knights fucked up even harder since Too Human happened right after this.
Nintendo's biggest mistake was not making a new studio to keep the series alive but that could apply to every franchise they own that doesn't get sequels nowadays.
Yea!
Check it out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ue7Zhwpzvtg
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2...f-the-eternals-still-alive-denis-dyack-claims
I guess maybe more of a spiritual successor in its name?
The perfect Dark
Banned
Oh my god, what the hell. I want this game!!!! It's a little too colorful though, imo.
haha. kickstarter failed twice. I guess now its developed under something else? who knows at this point tho. But at the time i was excited just to hear anything related to Eternal Darkness.
Code Name Steam is a kids cartoon version of Lovecraft (It actually directly uses Cthulhu and friends rather than facsimiles). Good stuff. Recommend it!
Yeah your right but at the same time Nintendo completely failed to market this game in fact it barely had any pre release marketing at all. Most people just shrugged it off as a cheap RE clone.Which it was not at all. Some even thought it was completely cancelled after it shifted development to the Gamecube.