Good point. I highly doubt they're jumping with joy over at Bioware/EA right now.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Mass Effect: Andromeda | Review Thread (READ MOD POST)
- Thread starter kubus
- Start date
Reckheim
Member
Now this, I can get behind.
iRAWRasaurus
Banned
:lol you should just start buying those lewd VN games.
Edmonton was doing Inquisition and then moved onto Casey Hudson's new IP.
It might be cheaper and um, quicker too.
And the quality of the writing doesn't seem too different.
PM for lewd websites with good narrative
Whom_Gods_Annoy
Banned
So they should be proud that the game actually got released? That's an unrealistic low bar to set, and not how the AAA industry works.
His Majesty
Banned
I heard something entirely different about the meat.
Mac Walters needs to go. I can excuse the other staff but he needs to go. He along with Chris Schlerf had almost near complete freedom to shape the writing however they wanted. This is the best they can come up with after 3-4 years? There can be a whole assortment of reasons as to why there might be bugs/glitches/bad animations however there is zero excuse for the writing, especially the dialogue, being garbage.
I didn't, but reviewers did.
I think we can almost all agree that this failed to meet ME series expectations. That's not something I'd be happy about if I had worked on it, but I could absolutely be proud of my individual achievements with the game. Some roles seemingly more than others.
I'll continue to be leery of this sort of BIG-NAME-sparse-details marketing style since Fallout 4 and now MEA. They seem to figure that showing the game will only serve to dissuade people from buying it, and rely on the brand and preorders to carry it.
I'll continue to be leery of this sort of BIG-NAME-sparse-details marketing style since Fallout 4 and now MEA. They seem to figure that showing the game will only serve to dissuade people from buying it, and rely on the brand and preorders to carry it.
EventHorizon
Member
I think you'll think the game is 'ok' but nothing great. The real question is whether you'll feel like you've wasted your money or not. If money isn't an issue and you buy every game you want, then you'll be fine. If on the other hand you pass on some other highly rated game, good, or service to buy Andromeda, I think you'll feel cheated.
Based on the reception, I expect to see price drops relatively soon. EA will want to keep up multiplayer numbers for the microtransactions. Since there isn't anything about Andromeda that screams "Must play now!", I think the best bet for most people is to wait.
From what I have caved and watched, I honestly think I will as well. Despite whatever warts and niggles may arise. It looks like Mass Effect, with gorgeous locations and combat that is vastly improved upon. And by vastly, I mean imagine Vanquish on steroids with force powers.
RedlineRonin
Member
Saw this on twitter
Damn. Even Metacritic.
Patrick was right.
https://waypoint.vice.com/en_us/article/everyone-seems-ready-to-rip-mass-effect-andromeda-to-shreds
joecanada
Member
Well I mean some people go into business for short term gain I'm sure but I wouldn't recommend it. Generally not worth it but just my opinion and getting off topic.
I expect they'll be working on this game for some time to come. But in the long term I actually wouldn't be surprised to see EA cut their studios down honestly.
(depending totally on sales though of course).
The reviews on average are pretty analogous to what I would give the game after roughly 6-7 hours.
Of course that means it's a classic 70s or 7/10 kind of game - people are going to have wildly differing reactions to it. Personally, I'm enjoying it a lot.
Especially the noticeable nods to the first game.
Of course that means it's a classic 70s or 7/10 kind of game - people are going to have wildly differing reactions to it. Personally, I'm enjoying it a lot.
Especially the noticeable nods to the first game.
I used to not be too hard on the guy for the ME3 ending because the game was obviously rushed (and he gave us Garrus). But yeah maybe I was too nice after all. I doubt the "grunt" are to blame in that case
D4rth Man7iz
Member
Saw this on twitter
This hurts bad!
I'm getting the game regardless of the reviews, but it won't be easy to get over of such a lukewarm reception.
Because this is a review thread for the entire game and not just one trial mission?
SlaughterX
Banned
Man, the Gamespot review worries me. Might have to wait for it to go on sale.
RedlineRonin
Member
I would. There's Nier, Nioh, Horizon, Zelda..... probably a bunch of other stuff.
The animations have been discussed to death, rebirth, and then death again so I won't bother with them. Until I eventually play the game proper I just can't hide my disappointment at how such an amazing premise was ruined.
Essentially, Andromeda's basic elevator pitch is "you are head of a group colonizing a far-flung galaxy." That sounds amazing and practically writes itself. Internal politics, mutinies, harsh alien environments, natives you need to negotiate with and understand or kill and conquer. Instead, the game decides to focus on the most generic "chosen one must fight big bad" storyline out there and, as I've explained in other threads, doesn't even accomplish it all that well. Playing through the opening I got no sense of things being alien, or new, I was fighting a race of identical-looking dudes with an evil leader, I was still fighting the Reapers/Geth/Cerberus. Then when I got back to the not-Citadel I just became Shepherd: Slightly Awkward Edition, a guy/girl who has to defeat a faceless alien threat in order to save everyone, I wanted to be Picard: Slightly Awkward Edition instead. The game even sets up a potential power struggle in Cora yet brushes it aside almost immediately.
That its gameplay seems to be so in line with DA:I in terms of overall structure just further adds to my disappointment, but the main thing I dislike is how such a unique subject matter for a story has been completely mishandled.
Essentially, Andromeda's basic elevator pitch is "you are head of a group colonizing a far-flung galaxy." That sounds amazing and practically writes itself. Internal politics, mutinies, harsh alien environments, natives you need to negotiate with and understand or kill and conquer. Instead, the game decides to focus on the most generic "chosen one must fight big bad" storyline out there and, as I've explained in other threads, doesn't even accomplish it all that well. Playing through the opening I got no sense of things being alien, or new, I was fighting a race of identical-looking dudes with an evil leader, I was still fighting the Reapers/Geth/Cerberus. Then when I got back to the not-Citadel I just became Shepherd: Slightly Awkward Edition, a guy/girl who has to defeat a faceless alien threat in order to save everyone, I wanted to be Picard: Slightly Awkward Edition instead. The game even sets up a potential power struggle in Cora yet brushes it aside almost immediately.
That its gameplay seems to be so in line with DA:I in terms of overall structure just further adds to my disappointment, but the main thing I dislike is how such a unique subject matter for a story has been completely mishandled.
Shifty1897
Member
Hey the new Mass Effect looks pretty good let's see what GAF thinks
JeffG
Member
How many hours in are you?
ToysAndMoreClub
Member
I haven't played the game, but the issues with the game, are they something that could be resolved with an update? Thinking this may be something better to jump into later on if there will be fixes.
VlaudTheImpaler
tl;dr
I've had a vision and here is what I think is going to happen.
The majority of people that wind up getting this now or in the future are going to play it. They are going to have fun. And then they are going to agree with the score. Loving the game and the time they had with it while at the same time wanting things to get better in the future.
The majority of people that wind up getting this now or in the future are going to play it. They are going to have fun. And then they are going to agree with the score. Loving the game and the time they had with it while at the same time wanting things to get better in the future.
BlazingDarkness
Member
So, how does the game deal with us being the coloniser? I'd have thought that would provide some interesting tensions and whatnot.
EventHorizon
Member
What happened to Andromeda wasn't a mistake. They intentionally reduced the intensity of the story, lightened the tone, and lessened consequences. From the first moment I heard what they wanted to do I said this game was in trouble. I can't beleive that got past the planning stages.
As for the technical problems, oh boy, who knows what went so wrong. Maybe that's a result of so many people leaving to work on their other project.
Space PI sounds interesting.
If there's one thing Montreal has proven to be very good at since ME3 it's combat.
Given my impression of the trial that sounds very likely. It's not a disaster at all but it's very flawed even for bioware standard
VlaudTheImpaler
tl;dr
This will always be at the forefront of my issues with the trial. Honestly thought the animation criticism was a bit overblown as during my playthrough it wasn't something I really noticed that much. But the very second you meet the Kett (one of TWO new alien races in a new galaxy, really?) they start shooting at you with what might as well be the same weapons that you have.
So much potential, but the result feels creatively bankrupt.
Fruitster
Member
This is such a pity. The technical issues that many of these reviews mention is the most troubling aspect for me, but hopefully things can be improved with some time and patches. I'm still very much looking forward to playing Andromeda, but the issues are certainly dissapointing.
Sniffynose
Member
I don't know what the hell they were thinking with this one, it seems like a step back from DA:I even. With my current backlog it's very easy to pass on this.
I've liked that idea ever since I talked to that C-Sec bloke in ME1. I think GiantBomb also mentioned that would be an interesting idea in their Andromeda stream.
Gamer @ Heart
Member
She probably will. As would most people who are free to come to their own conclusions rather than the rampant negativity of the internet.
I enjoyed so many more games back in the ps2/GC/Xbox era before I became a forum junkee.
Star wars bounty hunter was great dammit
Kett are basically bony Protheans.
I sank 100 hours into Inquisition as well and was ok with that. Then Witcher 3 came out and it changed my entire perspective.
It really is a pre Witcher world vs a post Witcher world. If DA:I had come out after Witcher 3 it would not have won GOTY and its review score would have been lower. If I had to play DA:I after I played Witcher 3 I would not have had near as much fun with it as I did.
I will probably end up buying ME:A at some point but I want to see their plan for fixing some key things first before I throw my money at them. I cancelled my preorder and it hurt to do it. I even scheduled a week off of work to really sink into ME:A in a couple weeks. Guess I'll find other stuff to do. Maybe Persona or something.
Another thing ME:A has going against it is launching just after two RPG's who really knocked it out of the park on their respective platforms with Horizon and Zelda. It makes ME:A look bush league. It's like a AAA title that somehow came out looking like it came from Steam Early Access. It is just unacceptable in this day and age to have such a huge studio produce something with so many bugs and problems.
It hurts because this was one of my top game in the last 5 years I was looking forward to. I can only hope they ME remaster is done so I can relive the good old days in glorious high def and with all the DLC.
Going after gangs, solving mysteries and helping people around the Citadel (Mass Effect) and Taris (KOTOR) were some of my favorite moments in Bioware games. When they first announced Mass Effect 4 and hinted that they'd abandon the lone hero/savior of the galaxy trope I was hoping they'd go in this direction...
Oh well, at least we have Cyberpunk 2077.
There is a good chance that she probably will. It is not being universally panned with reviews in the 3-5 range or anything.