So much wrong with this article.
"Check out screenshots from the Gamer that stole Halo 4." - what evidence is there to support this outrageous claim? Other than him playing Halo 4 online, there is none. For all you know, a game store employee stole a copy and put it on the shelf, where this person bought it from. Does it make him a thief because he was completely unaware?
Let's not forget Microsoft reversing bans in the past for being wrong. But let's point and laugh at Microsoft for once again, having their flagship, baby, leader of Xbox, out in the wild with minimal security. Then again, you can expect the worst from cheap labour.