-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Penny Arcade on Obvious Kickstarter Scams
- Thread starter GhostWriter24
- Start date
Trancetronic
Member
You can online with your friends
Fusion Pizza
Member
Well that about sums up how I feel about quite a few game projects on there.
B_Rik_Schitthaus
Banned
I like PA but when they are wrong, they are really fucking wrong.
GhostWriter24
Member
Examples? I'm not saying they haven't been, it's just 2AM and having trouble thinking of those rare occasions. maybe one I can think of was the shitting on Nintendo DS comics.
Yes... Kickstarter is one of the best things happen to old school gaming koncepts (Wasteland etc etc).
Of course... we will see if these intresting games will be done.
GhostWriter24
Member
Easy pal, if you're not a fan nobody told you to click the thread that said "Penny Arcade".
ItAintEasyBeinCheesy
it's 4th of July in my asshole
I read it in a dodgy Russian accent "Hkello, I'm Jhohn Vidgeogame."
he's right though, it's not funny at all. when did gaf become "click on this thread only if you're a fan of ______!" ?
B_Rik_Schitthaus
Banned
It's like they looked at some thread titles and extrapolated what people were complaining about from there.
Maybe, but cake baking Krogans still made me laugh. Mission accomplished.
It's like they looked at some thread titles and extrapolated what people were complaining about from there.
Fusion Pizza
Member
about kickstarter?
Oh shit they finished the new Wasteland? I was under the impression that it wasn't even close to being started, but who knows I don't live in the future.
I think PA hit the nail right on the head, KS is ridiculous. What's wrong with having game COMPANIES that are well established for making GOOD GAMES ALREADY make games? It's only been working well for the past FOREVER
Wouldn't be the first time.
GhostWriter24
Member
Stop it, you're making too much sense.
Dog Problems
Banned
Yeah, those companies are really pumping out the point-and-click adventures and isometric RPG's.
MightyHedgehog
Member
The problem is that there aren't enough good COMPANIES making GOOD GAMES ALREADY. The past isn't FOREVER, it's the past, man.
it's working so well right now. we're pretty much drowning in awesome games, right? (????)
Yeah those games are selling well also here's this new ace of base album dude i saw the sign!!
Debatable. Good games are opinion based, but the stuff on KS can't really hold a candle to a huge team of people working on a game.
you're very much missing the point.
You would hope not, since their live-in bro-mances Kris Straub and Scott Kurtz used Kickstarter to get their web-show off the ground not 1 year ago.
Kickstarter allows people to fund a a project that they have interest in. There doesn't seem to be any harm in that, but admittedly I don't know much about it.
I guess I just don't see the need to take an adversarial stance on this when it doesn't require you to donate to them. Just my two cents.
I guess I just don't see the need to take an adversarial stance on this when it doesn't require you to donate to them. Just my two cents.
Then please, oh mighty kickstarter sage, enlighten me, please
Kickstarter is still a crock of shit IMO. Maybe I'm "missing the point" but I don't see ANY point in giving someone money unless they give me a product in return. But hey, I work for the money I have.
My point really is that it's just the newest thing that caters to people who have more money than sense. Pet rock? Snuggies? They might as well make Kickstarter ads AS SEEN ON TV!! It's basically the same shit, you're just "donating" 19.95 instead.
Dog Problems
Banned
But you do get a game in return. They're not asking you to buy it once it's finished and put out.
corporate cheerleader
Member
If you want to hate on KS, fine. At least don't be a prick about it.
When companies are PIECES OF SHIT which don't want to try anything DIFFERENT.
quickly? the point is that games that "successful game companies" would NEVER EVER FUND are getting funding from people who care about them. that is it. how is that bad?
ps. i dont care about money because my mom gives me all of mine.
To be fair, it sounds like they're shitting on shitty Kickstarters, not the site as a whole, but we'll see what the news post says when it appears.
Indeed: I'm *sure* they had Your World in mind when doing this one.
Because money.
Gosh, that was easy.
How is saying i work for a living being a prick? i'm sorry if you don't have a job, but ESPECIALLY with the way the economy is i just find it absolutely retarded when people are just willing to throw money away when the reality is you don't know if you're getting ANYTHING or not, it's all on good faith.
As much as i wish it were the other way around, good faith isn't worth shit nowadays, guys.
i think they are making fun of the kickstarters that literally are like that John Videogames one. Giantbomb was talking about one a week or two ago on the podcast, it was basically like "yeah it will be a perfect mmorpg with lasers and hawks and donate now to recieve a mount with 20% extra speed even though we havent even started designing the game yet".
even with the stuff like wasteland you have no guarantee they won't just never release the game, or it will be a pile of crap.
even with the stuff like wasteland you have no guarantee they won't just never release the game, or it will be a pile of crap.
HadesGigas
Member
Wow. It's just amazing when someones angry rant exposes that they have no idea what they're ranting about...
what are you talking about? you too busy with your bootstraps to answer my question? (which was.. in case you weren't paying attention) games that would NEVER EVER GET funding from big successful publishers are getting money and attention from people who care about those games. what is wrong with that?
Dog Problems
Banned
Well, I won't argue with you there. It does come down to faith. But I personally have faith that Double Fine can deliver a pretty good adventure game.
There's definitely plenty of other Kickstarter projects that I have no faith in.
http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/120873716/your-world ?
To the above posters, yes I'm aware if goals aren't met no money is taken, but still what's keeping me from "making a game" and then taking the money and running? That's all I'm saying. Not ALL Kickstarter PROJECTS are shit, but the way the website is set up for NOW is shady to me.
michaelius
Banned
It's working so good people are willing to drop 100$ for a promise of getting good RPG and not dumbed mass market shooter with some stats and dialogues
B_Rik_Schitthaus
Banned
Is this a joke post? I'll act like you mean this and blow it apart anyway.
''Oh shit they finished the new Wasteland? I was under the impression that it wasn't even close to being started, but who knows I don't live in the future.''
Do you say this in every thread about a new game announcement?
Even the new Smash Bros was announced before a single idea was on paper.
''I think PA hit the nail right on the head, KS is ridiculous. What's wrong with having game COMPANIES that are well established for making GOOD GAMES ALREADY make games?''
How does KS stop this from happening? KS isn't replacing this, it's allowing for a middle tier between no budget games (the Newgrounds type) and big budget.
''It's only been working well for the past FOREVER''
If you only like game where you drive realistic cars or shoot people.
Also the use of 'FOREVER' is funny, since a lot of the games funded would have been made under the Publishers just a decade ago, but now the budgets have increased to a point they don't want to release a game that requires thought to enjoy, everything they put out is idiot friendly. Leaving a lot of genres and more unique voices in the industry locked out.
Sir_Crocodile
Member
Yup you are.
Every kickstarter I've funded I'm getting the finished product in return for.
maybe you should have read before rant
incredible
I really hope this is about shitty Kickstarters and not good guys like Brian Fargo or the Double Fine guys.
And Coal you should really stop posting in Kickstarter threads. You have no idea what you are talking about. How many times do people have to explain to you how Kickstarter works and how many great successful projects have already come out of it.
And Coal you should really stop posting in Kickstarter threads. You have no idea what you are talking about. How many times do people have to explain to you how Kickstarter works and how many great successful projects have already come out of it.
Dog Problems
Banned
It really comes down to the people behind the project. Double Fine, for example, are pretty big and well known. Something like that would hurt them so bad that it'd ruin them, more than likely.
About what? That shitty Kickstarters are shit?
Because if you're implying that they're throwing the whole website under the bus, I'll redirect you to the last two months of posts by Tycho which have been copious with Kickstarter project pimping.
wait, wait... i enlightened you, you called me the great kickstarter sage, and all i get is a "to the above posters" lame response? maaaan. you should start a kickstarter to raise funds in order to not look like a jerk. hire somebody to type for you or something.
Maybe video game production costs has escalated to the INSANE and CREATIVITY isn't being sought any more because the FINANCIAL RISK in it is too high, and because all the risk is resting on one COMPANY or a PUBLISHER very few CREATIVE, GOOD GAMES are being made, as more focus is given to sure fire profit generating games - Kickstater allows the risk to be SHARED by a crowd of passionate people who want to see the project made.
CrunchinJelly
formerly cjelly
Sounds about right.