-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
The darker ground texture on XBO hides the lack of AO. There's your answer.
XBOX ONE IS USING LIMITED RGB
Crushing the levels to Limited RGB and "Sharpen More" (one time) for the PS4 picture replicates the XO results!
I hope this makes sense for you guys.
bingo bango. colors match perfectly.
Of course there is a difference favoring the PS4, but I can't help but laugh at people here looking to round up folks to send to reeducation camps on resolution.
On the first or second page there was literally this exchange:
"Huh, Xbox One looks better imo."
"You're wrong."
lol.
Get over it folks, not everyone is gonna be counting pixels.
Also on this page, "stupid people that don't know what to look for ruin it for those of us that do" . Fucking wow. Maybe you ruined it for yourself.
On the first or second page there was literally this exchange:
"Huh, Xbox One looks better imo."
"You're wrong."
lol.
Get over it folks, not everyone is gonna be counting pixels.
Also on this page, "stupid people that don't know what to look for ruin it for those of us that do" . Fucking wow. Maybe you ruined it for yourself.
FinalStageBoss
Banned
Everyone watch the IGN video. Case closed.
Mihael Mello Keehl
Banned
Im watching a walkthrough now and it got to the part where dude
Is it that easy to do that?
cut the other dudes leg
everyday math
Banned
The trucks didn't appear in the XO version at 1:06. Wat?
xn0
Member
I've heard a couple of things about the BF4 capture. It seems that the PS4 was captured in 1080p where as the xbone was captured in its native 720p. Wouldn't this mean that because the PS4 is 1600x900 natively it has to upscale via software/hardware to produce the 1080p resolution for capture? Which could account for the "softening" effect?
That being said the same will be true on the Xbone where its native resolution of 720p will look exactly this way on a 720p native display, however on a 1080p display the image will have to be "upscaled" in order to look correct on a 1080p display.
What i'm trying to say is that if the PS4 is captured at 1080p and not in the games reported 1600x900 native resolution then some upscale processing is going to be on the PS4 images vs. the 720p native capture w/o any upscale processing from the xbone images.
Its late does this make any sense?
That being said the same will be true on the Xbone where its native resolution of 720p will look exactly this way on a 720p native display, however on a 1080p display the image will have to be "upscaled" in order to look correct on a 1080p display.
What i'm trying to say is that if the PS4 is captured at 1080p and not in the games reported 1600x900 native resolution then some upscale processing is going to be on the PS4 images vs. the 720p native capture w/o any upscale processing from the xbone images.
Its late does this make any sense?
thought the same about motion blur.
also,
so he was right!? wtf....
Glad others are noticing the motion blur as well. Was starting to think I was crazy.
Better graphics, higher resolution, and higher average frame rate is largely exaggerated? Huh?
Pristine_Condition
Member
Can I guess?
Um...how 'bout: furiously hitting "refresh" on his browser over at B3D, trying to get pro-XBone talking-points from all the "experts" over there?
Did I win?
Guys hair doesn't pop and isn't black enough. XO version looks better.
Multplayer shows a bigger difference for sure. Xbox is so jaggy, wow.
Dreams-Visions
Member
PS4 version looks better in the details thanks to the higher resolution or AA or whatever. It's pretty obvious whenever you look at buildings or tree limbs or powerlines in the distance. The jaggies on the One version remind me a little too much of a 360/PS3 game for my money.
PS4 version and One version appear to both suffer from some aliasing issues in the Multiplayer when looking at stuff like powerlines...but PS4 ever so slightly less so.
Both look good, but I think the aliasing issues on the One would aggrivate me after awhile because BF is such a wide open kind of game, you're compelled to look into the distance all the time.
Because people are choosing to look at a few pictures posted and not bothering to watch the video of the game in motion.
You just pop in to ruffle feathers(pun intended ) when you don't have a new leak I like it
I thought maybe it was 360 footage or something when I first saw it lol
Pop
Member
Way better than DF. Ps4 is miles ahead of X1. These guys in the video seem to agree with the majority of GAF.
Night Angel
Member
So to recap: PS4 wins according to all articles (versus XB1) in IQ, res, and frame rate. One article has janky settings that make the XB1 version look (worse) "better." The PC and PS4 versions are closer than the PC and XB1 versions, particularly because of the extra sharpening and contrast tinkering.
Verdict: XB1 > PC.
Yep. Where's that this is NeoGAF gif?
Verdict: XB1 > PC.
Yep. Where's that this is NeoGAF gif?
SRTtoZ
Member
Yea its stunning. Most people expected just a resolution difference. What we have here is a much lower resolution, missing clouds, worse shadows (missing shadows), missing details, worse lighting, almost zero AA (cant really tell). This seems to be as significant as some thought, a 40% difference.
Dat XB1 power.
Lookin sharp.
Just watched some more of it. My goodness, the jaggies in the X1 version...
Deadly_headmen
Neo Member
Someone needs to hamper DF. This is ridiculous. What is this Amateur hour?
Yes, I see that. They both look really good, the PS4 just looks that much better.
Way to go IGN. Seriously.
ChiliManiac
Banned
bingo bango. colors match perfectly.
Woah...
Wishmaster92
Member
wtf, there better be a full rgb mode.
Codeblew
Member
XBOX ONE IS USING LIMITED RGB
Crushing the levels to Limited RGB and "Sharpen More" (one time) for the PS4 picture replicates the XO results!
I hope this makes sense for you guys.
post again with original PS4 version also.
re: the color of the PS4 from DF
The game will not look like that on a properly calibrated TV set. (fuck or even a decent TV set period)
Just for the sake of arguement...put both versions of the game on a calibrated ZT60 Plasma...the PS4 will win out no matter what due to superior resolution, aliasing, framerate, effects, etc
The game will not look like that on a properly calibrated TV set. (fuck or even a decent TV set period)
Just for the sake of arguement...put both versions of the game on a calibrated ZT60 Plasma...the PS4 will win out no matter what due to superior resolution, aliasing, framerate, effects, etc
Pristine_Condition
Member
Dat XB1 power.
Well played.
ref
Member
sharpened up the avatar for good measure.
Read DF article and Videogamer article. No comparison pictures/vids necessary. The victor is clear here.
Vire
Member
Gamespot has some 60 FPS PS4 footage mixed in with all the other versions. (No Xbox One footage)
http://www.gamespot.com/reviews/battlefield-4-review/1900-6415517/
http://www.gamespot.com/reviews/battlefield-4-review/1900-6415517/
Maninthemirror
Banned
Game over for BF as a respectable source after this. No way am i trusting their comparison now
Meus Renaissance
Member
I agree
They say they used the full RGB option, but maybe it wasn't fuctional.
Sandy Nipples
Banned
This game is so aptly named for what's going down right now. The footage and analysis will determine a shitload of purchasing decisions.
Dreams-Visions
Member
Real talk tho, XOne is winning the nextGen nappy hair race.
PsihoPerihelion
Member
You mean, right?
(disclaimer: very quick and veeeerrry dirty gimp shop)
The Citizen Kane of replies. Bravo.
Ps4 version is missing a ground texture layer or two in that shot??
Jules Coast
Member
So what's the reason for the X1 screens looking sharper? From my understanding, it's due to the upscaling form 900p to 1080p? Sorry, I'm not too familiar with the details.
Regardless, launch titles are hardly the best to compare. The multiplats for next holiday will be much more interesting to do comparisons on.
Regardless, launch titles are hardly the best to compare. The multiplats for next holiday will be much more interesting to do comparisons on.