MetalliCabombination
Member
My memory is a little sketchy about the exact specs but the game ran really well on my 390x at launch.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Digital Foundry: Quantum Break Xbox One X vs Xbox One: First Look
- Thread starter dancrane212
- Start date
No to get anywhere near 60fps at 1080p you need a 1080gtx
Every other gpu you need to either turn down graphics or run at around 30fps locked with ultra settings
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Looked great, this is probably one of the few games I would get an XB1 or XBX for if a good deal emerges.
Honestly, it's not as good as Alan Wake.
Thats debatable I think. Alan Wakes core mechanics were never as engaging to me and you spent too much time running through areas that looked identical to one another. QB felt more like a Max Payne sequel in many ways. I can understand why people didnt like it, though, but I had a great time with it.
I'm a HUGE Alan Wake fan, but this is how I felt about the combat (as opposed to exploration) between the games.
PsihoPerihelion
Member
The game is constructing a higher res based on a 1440p buffer. It won't look like a 1440p game just like the original one doesn't look like a 720p game.
Karspankey
Banned
A vast majority of games updated for Pro were also made by one, maybe two, people. Also, the update is not being made by MS at all. They don't own the dev or have any say in what they work on. A guy is reportedly making the patch as a sort of passion project. If true, this patch probably wouldn't have existed at all.
Snake29
RSI Employee of the Year
That means that the game is poorly optimized for the pc.
GinoFelino
Member
So it's miles from True 4K and has obvious and glaring performance issues but this is still somehow evidence of One X being super amazing.
Righto
Ah, so basically like what the PS4 Pro has been doing for a year
Righto
Ah, so basically like what the PS4 Pro has been doing for a year
It was never gonna be full 4K with the tech it uses.
Jessie.Bristol
Member
Definitely doing a second run through this game on the Xbox One X in the 2160p mode. Hope they tighten up the minor frame rate and screen tearing issues before launch.
Collateral22
Member
Does the X support input from 1440p displays for a game like this?
GinoFelino
Member
Well, yes, obviously people in their right mind knew this and expected this
Head.spawn
Junior Member
When you start the morning trolling up Xbox threads they all start to look the same perhaps. lol
Incoming? Maybe?
D'ultimate
Member
You know this how?
PsihoPerihelion
Member
From what I remember, it's not quite a similar implementation. There also seems to be a lot more artifacting on Remedy's technique, specially on heavy movement. To be honest, I'm all for reconstruction techniques, but QB's solution doesn't feel as robust as Checkerboard or Temporal Injection does now.
Dictator93
Member
I thought the base combat in this game was much better than alan wake, but found myself coimpletely bored with the story, the television show, and also the fact that there were so many "read my emails" kind of side story elements. The game should have had waaaaaay more combat.
I was also hella confused at the game's completely lack of real reloading animations. After max payne 2, or basically, since the game is highly detailed cinematic TPS game... I would at least expect realistic gun behaviour and magazines and what not to actually work.
Comparing final X1X settings with PC ones should be rather eye opening, but I imagine, things like SSR or AO will generally just look that much better at higher res even though they may align with lower settings on the PC version.
The DX12 win 10 store version was horribly optimized on NV, 20% less power usage than any other game on my system in that version while running framerate uncapped (DX12 is supposed to increase power utilisation in uncapped scenarios btw!). But the DX11 version apparently fixes that as it relies in the superior NV driver for so much. On the higher settings the game is "unoptimised", but if you settle for medium or lower (basically x1 settings), the game's graphics tend to scale much more "linearly" with GPU grunt.
I was also hella confused at the game's completely lack of real reloading animations. After max payne 2, or basically, since the game is highly detailed cinematic TPS game... I would at least expect realistic gun behaviour and magazines and what not to actually work.
Comparing final X1X settings with PC ones should be rather eye opening, but I imagine, things like SSR or AO will generally just look that much better at higher res even though they may align with lower settings on the PC version.
The DX12 win 10 store version was horribly optimized on NV, 20% less power usage than any other game on my system in that version while running framerate uncapped (DX12 is supposed to increase power utilisation in uncapped scenarios btw!). But the DX11 version apparently fixes that as it relies in the superior NV driver for so much. On the higher settings the game is "unoptimised", but if you settle for medium or lower (basically x1 settings), the game's graphics tend to scale much more "linearly" with GPU grunt.
LukasTaves
Member
It means the game is demanding not that the port is a mess.
Probably not
Posting in Neogaf is free.
LukasTaves
Member
Yes, because it's a game xbone originally ran in 720p.
Pro has been doing 1440p for some games ps4 ran at 1080p.
Bitch Pudding
Member
It looks really good for a demandig game like QB.
But.
It's not what they promised, isn't it? This is the disappointing part, not the game itself.
But.
It's not what they promised, isn't it? This is the disappointing part, not the game itself.
Reckheim
Member
no no, xboxone is stronger than the GTX1080ti, don't you know.
"Making"
N21
Member
This game wasn't made by a MS first party.
Plus, there's like on a handful over games that can match or outshine QB in the graphics department.
KainXVIII
Member
QB has too little gameplay moments, maybe even less than Uncharted 3 (and too many bloated and boring cutscenes, especially live-action)
Bits N Pieces
Member
From the first paragraph of the article you linked:
- any game we're making
- that we're launching in the Scorpio time frame
Does the above apply to Quantum Break? Also, try not to be too disappointed. I'm still going to have a blast playing through the game again with all these new bells and whistles and I'm sure many other people are as well
Bitch Pudding
Member
Damn, totally my fault, I really should read MS' well constructed PR statements more careful.
Head.spawn
Junior Member
It was in the first paragraph of that page you linked and the first part of the actual quote from MS.
Damn, you always have to read the fine print in MS' PR statements...
Well, I remember stories saying it would get 4K like this:
https://www.windowscentral.com/quantum-break-will-get-4k-treatment-xbox-one-x
4K has been passed around such as the quote from the article:
In this particular case you just need to be able to read, no catches about it
Damn, my fault, you always have to read the fine print in MS' PR statements...
Think its more you yeah.
Journey
Banned
Was this needed after seeing plenty of other AAA games hitting native 4k?
Hold up! what happened to your repeated "Native >> checkerboard rendering" posts that you was doing a few days ago? in this video he clearly says that it doesn't look 4K like checkerboard rendering does.
LukasTaves
Member
On xbonex footage reflections seems at higher resolution as well.
When you start the morning trolling up Xbox threads they all start to look the same perhaps. lol
Incoming? Maybe?
This would be great because there is a lot of people with monitors in between 1080P & 4K & they shouldn't have to drop down to 1080P just because the resolution of the monitor isn't 4K.
But that's what I'm talking about. You don't need a GTX 1080 to run QB at 1440p/30fps (or 1400p, whatever the XB1X version is).
Karspankey
Banned
Mark Cerny said that most devs putting out patches for already released games only needed and were assigning a person to a patch since it doesnt take much time to make one (he estimated that one person can get a patch done in two weeks).
ResidentDante
Member
What a pathetic fanboy trolling attempt full of utter factual bullshit. Effort 1/10
Hold Up! lmao
Native is better than checkerboard. If a system can run QB at native 4k compared to checkerboard 4k then its better.
When did i every say a game not running in native 4k isn't good? Please show me