Reply
Edge #194 Reviews Thread Tools
Roxas
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:39 AM)

Roxas's Avatar
Edge #194 Reviews #1

Cover story is about GTA: Chinatown Wars for the DS. They have a few pages about it inside and pics and it looks pretty decent i suppose.

Previews

- Empire: Total War
- DC Universe Online
- Resistence 2
- Killzone 2
- Far Cry 2
- Fuel
- The Agency
- Champions Online
- Cities XL
- Call of Duty: World at War
- Infamous
- Halo Wars
- Stormrise
- Operation Flashpoint 2
- Silent Hill: Homecoming
- House of the Dead:: Overkill
- Trackmania DS
- Ragnarok Online DS
- Theresia: Dear Emile

(By the way, they are not impressed with how Resistence 2 is looking at the moment.)

Reviews

- Spore [7]
- Star Wars: The Force Unleashed [5]
- Mercenaries 2: World in Flames [6]
- Brothers in Arms: Hells Highway [6]
- Fatal Frame: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse [8]
- Infinite Undiscovery [6]
- Crysis Warhead [8]
- De Blob [8]
- Yakuza 2 [8]
- Viva Pinata; Trouble in Paradise [8]
- Reset Generation [8]
- Pure [7]
- Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 [6]
- Galaga Legions [6]
- Castle Crashers [7]

Features

- Interview with Dan Houser at Rockstar talking about GTA: Chinatown Wars
- Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts feature
- Interviews with Harmonix devs
- The making of Deus Ex Machima (this is a good read)
- A Look at how Canada is becoming one of the most powerful gaming dev centres in the west.
- A Look back at Star Wars; Tie Fighter

Next Month



I'll update this when ive had a more thorough read through.
Rez
(09-24-2008, 09:40 AM)

Rez's Avatar
#2

Hard to resist Yakuza 2 at this point.
Grimmy
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:41 AM)

Grimmy's Avatar
#3

Is that "Next month" Silpheed????
Or so I hope...
clay_ghost
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:41 AM)

clay_ghost's Avatar
#4

Star fox wii/ds?
Burger
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:42 AM)

Burger's Avatar
#5

Originally Posted by Grimmy:
Is that "Next month" Silpheed????
Or so I hope...

Or Brabens Elite ?
maxax
Junior Member
(09-24-2008, 09:42 AM)

maxax's Avatar
#6

I'd like some info about Ragnarok DS if you got the time to write it. :)
Darkflight
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:44 AM)

Darkflight's Avatar
#7

Sounds good, I haven't got round to reading last months yet , I only read on the train to/from work and I keep getting distracted working my way through Seinfeld

Looking forward to reading last month's and then getting into this one, a look back at Tie Fighter, that's gonna be a good read.
EmCeeGramr
gettin' up in yo
ho-ass modal verbs:
dem bitches be AUXILIARY
(09-24-2008, 09:44 AM)

EmCeeGramr's Avatar
#8

EDGE SCORES ARE GRADED ON THE WHOLE SCALE OF 1-10.
5 IS AN AVERAGE PLAYABLE GAME OR AN INTERESTING CONCEPT HAMPERED BY SOME FAULTS.
IF WHATEVER SOFTWARE YOUVE EMOTIONALLY INVESTED YOURSELF INTO DIDNT GET ABOVE AN 8, DONT START BAWLING


Pretty please.
Mr. Pointy
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:45 AM)

Mr. Pointy's Avatar
#9

I guess Edge thought Fatal Frame's controls were workable.
TTP
Have a fun! Enjoy!
(09-24-2008, 09:45 AM)

TTP's Avatar
#10

Originally Posted by Grimmy:
Is that "Next month" Silpheed????
Or so I hope...

wut? Silpheed wasn't wireframe.

Darkman M
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:45 AM)

Darkman M's Avatar
#11

Originally Posted by Rez>You:
Hard to resist Yakuza 2 at this point.


No reason to cheap and probably the best game Ive purchased this month.
Mr. Pointy
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:46 AM)

Mr. Pointy's Avatar
#12

Originally Posted by Burger:
Or Brabens Elite ?
Looks like Elite to me. Could be a feature of Braben's new game.
nny
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:47 AM)

nny's Avatar
#13

wow, so many "8"s. Go Yakuza 2!
Kabouter
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:47 AM)

Kabouter's Avatar
#14

Quote:
- Brothers in Arms: Hells Highway [6]
Seems low, shame, was kinda looking forward to this. Can anyone post what they said was good/bad about it?
Rez
(09-24-2008, 09:47 AM)

Rez's Avatar
#15

Is it possible for an Aussie to get a subscription to Edge? I've been meaning to get one for a while but I'm not sure if it's possible. :(
Dizzan
MINI Member
(09-24-2008, 09:48 AM)

Dizzan's Avatar
#16

Heavy rain next month?
Mdk7
Member until he fucks up again
(09-24-2008, 09:48 AM)

Mdk7's Avatar
#17

Galaga Legions deserved much more than 6 IMHO...it's brilliant.
navii
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:48 AM)

navii's Avatar
#18

Castle Crashers got an appropriate score imo. :P
Roxas
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:49 AM)

Roxas's Avatar
#19

Originally Posted by maxax:
I'd like some info about Ragnarok DS if you got the time to write it. :)

Sure. There's not a lot of info (only half a page) but it does say you can have up to 4 players join forces in over 50 randomly generated dungeons. There'll be a lot of solo stuff too. Makes use of the stylus when attacking and moving (think Zelda: PH). Lots of character customization. They say finally that the game will cost a whopping 6090 Yen in Japan, which is around £32. Way above the usual rate.
Tenbatsu
(09-24-2008, 09:51 AM)

Tenbatsu's Avatar
#20

Quote:
Fatal Frame: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse [8]
Where's the NA release?
maxax
Junior Member
(09-24-2008, 09:52 AM)

maxax's Avatar
#21

Originally Posted by Roxas:
Sure. There's not a lot of info (only half a page) but it does say you can have up to 4 players join forces in over 50 randomly generated dungeons. There'll be a lot of solo stuff too. Makes use of the stylus when attacking and moving (think Zelda: PH). Lots of character customization. They say finally that the game will cost a whopping 6090 Yen in Japan, which is around £32. Way above the usual rate.
Thanks!
It's the only MMO I ever fell in love with, a good DS "port" would be awesome.
Any info on the release date?
TheHeretic
freaky fetish expert
(09-24-2008, 09:53 AM)

TheHeretic's Avatar
#22

Originally Posted by EmCeeGramr:
EDGE SCORES ARE GRADED ON THE WHOLE SCALE OF 1-10.
5 IS AN AVERAGE PLAYABLE GAME OR AN INTERESTING CONCEPT HAMPERED BY SOME FAULTS.
IF WHATEVER SOFTWARE YOUVE EMOTIONALLY INVESTED YOURSELF INTO DIDNT GET ABOVE AN 8, DONT START BAWLING


Pretty please.

You say that, but every single score there is 5 or above. Edge use more of the scale than most, but they don't use it all.
Kagari
Zero Shift Combat
(09-24-2008, 09:53 AM)

Kagari's Avatar
#23

Yakuza 2 /bow.
Chû Totoro
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:53 AM)

Chû Totoro's Avatar
#24

Originally Posted by Roxas:
By the way, they are not impressed with how Resistence 2 is looking at the moment.
:o
I'm a little bit confused here. Everyone claims that it's one of the best looking game they ever seen and Edge is saying "yeah it's ok".

Maybe it's the atmosphere that lacks of originality ?
Dizzan
MINI Member
(09-24-2008, 09:54 AM)

Dizzan's Avatar
#25

Originally Posted by Roxas:

(By the way, they are not impressed with how Resistence 2 is looking at the moment.)


Old build.

Today's 'reveal' looks awesome and it's only going to get better in the last few weeks of polish.

and it's Resistance btw :P
Kagari
Zero Shift Combat
(09-24-2008, 09:54 AM)

Kagari's Avatar
#26

Originally Posted by Chû Totoro:
:o
I'm a little bit confused here. Everyone claims that it's one of the best looking game they ever seen and Edge is saying "yeah it's ok".

Maybe it's the atmosphere that lacks of originality ?

Didn't Edge give Halo 3 a 10 though?
Roxas
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:54 AM)

Roxas's Avatar
#27

Originally Posted by maxax:
Thanks!
It's the only MMO I ever fell in love with, a good DS "port" would be awesome.
Any info on the release date?

Dec. 18th in Japan. TBA everywhere else.
Chû Totoro
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:58 AM)

Chû Totoro's Avatar
#28

Originally Posted by Kagari:
Didn't Edge give Halo 3 a 10 though?
Well it seems that my "originality" point doesn't stand anymore.
Maybe the Heavy Rain demo is the reason they are less impressed.

Anyway it's not really a big deal for me since I'm not into FPS but it's just that it's different from everything I've heard so far on this game.
haowan
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:58 AM)

haowan's Avatar
#29

there's no ship like this in any Elite game
Roxas
Member
(09-24-2008, 09:59 AM)

Roxas's Avatar
#30

About R2, they are going by what they saw at Leipzig. Bad AI, bad animation, too grim (too many browns and grey), level design remains "undisguised" , movement through the city feels constricted, motion and aiming lacks the control of Killzone 2. They do say thats hands-off demonstrations looked better though, but it is a pretty negative preview on the whole.
Rez
(09-24-2008, 10:07 AM)

Rez's Avatar
#31

Originally Posted by Roxas:
About R2, they are going by what they saw at Leipzig. Bad AI, bad animation, too grim (too many browns and grey), level design remains "undisguised" , movement through the city feels constricted, motion and aiming lacks the control of Killzone 2. They do say thats hands-off demonstrations looked better though, but it is a pretty negative preview on the whole.
That's the impression I've been getting from the footage too. I don't get the hype. But then I haven't played Resistance so obviously I'm lacking experience with the driving factor behind why people are hyped for this game. To be fair though, if the Insomniac marketing team were doing a really good job I wouldn't need that experience to be hyped in the first place.

But hey I'm all for more good games so I really hope R2 turns out great.
SpokkX
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:08 AM)
#32

The wireframe model got me thinking of Elite
haowan
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:09 AM)

haowan's Avatar
#33

it's not Elite.
Gagaman
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:10 AM)

Gagaman's Avatar
#34

Darn, De Blob even got an 8 from Edge, that's a good sign.
SpokkX
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:12 AM)
#35

Originally Posted by Rez>You:
That's the impression I've been getting from the footage too. I don't get the hype. But then I haven't played Resistance so obviously I'm lacking experience with the driving factor behind why people are hyped for this game. To be fair though, if the Insomniac marketing team were doing a really good job I wouldn't need that experience to be hyped in the first place.

But hey I'm all for more good games so I really hope R2 turns out great.

I am sure there are large enemies and large battles... but it seems to be scaled up last gen stuff. No amazing physics, animation or AI at work. It seems.. drab
Hammer24
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:13 AM)

Hammer24's Avatar
#36

Originally Posted by SpokkX:
The wireframe model got me thinking of Elite

Came here to say this. Nextgen Elite?
RandomVince
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:13 AM)
#37

Originally Posted by TheHeretic:
You say that, but every single score there is 5 or above. Edge use more of the scale than most, but they don't use it all.

That's because they dont review every game released each month. It's known as Selection bias.
Uncle
Dave's other lieutenant
(09-24-2008, 10:13 AM)

Uncle's Avatar
#38

What did they say about Banjo?
Station42
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:14 AM)

Station42's Avatar
#39

what's reset generation anyway
Kafel
(09-24-2008, 10:17 AM)

Kafel's Avatar
#40

Roxas, can you please tell us what it is about :
Quote:
Interviews with Harmonix devs
?


Rock Band 2 ? (it would then hint at a near release in Europe)
RandomVince
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:17 AM)
#41

Oh, and to the OP if you could find out what they say about Stormrise I'd appreciate it.
EmCeeGramr
gettin' up in yo
ho-ass modal verbs:
dem bitches be AUXILIARY
(09-24-2008, 10:23 AM)

EmCeeGramr's Avatar
#42

Originally Posted by TheHeretic:
You say that, but every single score there is 5 or above. Edge use more of the scale than most, but they don't use it all.

Most games are derivative and playable or conceptual and lacking. This month was lucky enough to not have complete shit. Ive read plenty of reviews in edge that were almost entirely positive but there would be a 6 or 5 by the score. It was because theyd be reviewing some tetris wannabe on the ds for example that was competent enough. It was a solid 5. The text in edge reviews is what matters.
Its the only respectable mature gaming mag Ive ever read, and when some forumite's favorite flavor of the month is given a six they decry Edge as worthless. I was hoping we could avoid that this month.
haowan
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:23 AM)

haowan's Avatar
#43

Originally Posted by Hammer24:
Came here to say this. Nextgen Elite?

How many times - it's not Elite. There isn't a ship in any Elite game that looks like that.

it. is. not. Elite.

Braben has recently said that they're working on Elite 4 though, I believe.
herod
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:27 AM)

herod's Avatar
#44

Yes, I imagine Elite 4 will have no AA at all.

That's right, it's coming out for the GBA.
TheHeretic
freaky fetish expert
(09-24-2008, 10:28 AM)

TheHeretic's Avatar
#45

Originally Posted by EmCeeGramr:
Most games are derivative and playable or conceptual and lacking. This month was lucky enough to not have complete shit. Ive read plenty of reviews in edge that were almost entirely positive but there would be a 6 or 5 by the score. It was because theyd be reviewing some tetris wannabe on the ds for example that was competent enough. It was a solid 5. The text in edge reviews is what matters.
Its the only respectable mature gaming mag Ive ever read, and when some forumite's favorite flavor of the month is given a six they decry Edge as worthless. I was hoping we could avoid that this month.

Why does a derivative, playable game have to be a 5 or more? If a game isn't worth buying it should be a 1. Edge are still stuck in the "report card" system of reviewing that IGN fester in tirelessly.

Originally Posted by RandomVince:
That's because they dont review every game released each month. It's known as Selection bias.

Then their scoring system should reflect that. They are still only using half a scale.
nelsonroyale
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:29 AM)

nelsonroyale's Avatar
#46

r2 impressions in general have been mixed...until this latest reveal when they have been pretty damn positive...

also, Edge are generally more critical, but they are certainly not the gold standard people make them out to be...they aim for high brow, but alot of the writing comes off as verbose and the reviews often seem fault-finding to me, based on their own subjective likes/dislikes...ie pretty similar to any other reviews

also, pretty sure that is for wipeout...if they havent reviewed it yet
Burger
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:30 AM)

Burger's Avatar
#47

Originally Posted by haowan:
How many times - it's not Elite. There isn't a ship in any Elite game that looks like that.

it. is. not. Elite.

Braben has recently said that they're working on Elite 4 though, I believe.

Oh man what if it WAS Elite?!?

You'd be all like... shit.
Porkepik
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:31 AM)

Porkepik's Avatar
#48

Well maybe it is not elite but I really thought it was, any nextgen Elite would be day one purchase for me, I played countless hours on ELite 1,2 and 3 (even if the last one was a bug fest at release)
herod
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:32 AM)

herod's Avatar
#49

here you go guys: http://www.neilwallis.com/elitejava/yardbbc.htm, knock yourselves out.
haowan
Member
(09-24-2008, 10:32 AM)

haowan's Avatar
#50

Originally Posted by Burger:
Oh man what if it WAS Elite?!?

You'd be all like... shit.

I'd be all like... "The magic was probably lost along with Bell". And also "Edge seem to know fuck all about Elite ships".
Reply




Message Boards and Forums Directory