NeoGAF

Prime crotch · (05-04-2009, 12:05 PM)

Oh, another ACE, I would like that, with Shin Mazinger Z please.

Originally Posted by Doubledex:

6 Breath of Fire Capcom

If you motherfuckers hadn't bitched about the best sequel ever then it wouldn't be on this list!

Totobeni · (05-04-2009, 12:06 PM)

Originally Posted by Doubledex:

1 Sakura Taisen (aka Sakura Wars) Sega
2 Shenmue Sega
18 Senjou no Valkyria (aka Valkyria Chronicles) Sega
24 Panzer Dragoon Sega
30 Jet Set Radio Sega
37 Eternal Arcadia (aka Skies of Arcadia) Sega
LINK

SEGA fans who read fami in japan kinda redeemed , they are still epic fail for not wanting a new Ristar game tho

ChryZ · (05-04-2009, 12:06 PM)

I approve of Okami in the top3.

54-46! · (05-04-2009, 12:10 PM)

I'm not gonna lie, I was expecting Wii titles, Final Fantasy and other stupid stuff.. but this list is actually pretty decent :)

Chittagong · (05-04-2009, 12:11 PM)

Zelda and Super Mario am dead

Dead Man Typing · (05-04-2009, 12:15 PM)

Originally Posted by Doubledex:

A sequel without Yu Suzuki? :-/

Why, is he busy working on something else? Bring him out of his so-called retirement.

Besides, I'm pretty sure there's a complete design document lying around somewhere for the rest of the Shenmue story, including some gameplay scenarios. Remember Kikizo said that a source told them that the game was finished and ready to be ported to a next gen console. (Hi Adam!!)

LiK · 12:20 PM

Originally Posted by Doubledex:

2 Shenmue Sega
3 Okami Capcom
5 Xenogears Square Enix
8 Ogre Battle Square Enix
14 Chrono Square Enix
15 Z.O.E Konami
18 Senjou no Valkyria (aka Valkyria Chronicles) Sega
19 Justice Gakuen Capcom
21 Subarashiki Kono Sekai (aka The World Ends With You) Square Enix
24 Panzer Dragoon Sega
27 Lost Odyssey Microsoft
30 Jet Set Radio Sega

fuckin yes to all of those.

Callibretto · (05-04-2009, 12:20 PM)

no suikoden? =(

Phoenix Fang · (05-04-2009, 12:22 PM)

Originally Posted by Doubledex:

44 Bullet Witch AQ Interactive

LINK

WTF

Azure J · (05-04-2009, 12:25 PM)

Megaman Legends, Megaman X, The World Ends With You, Mother, Valkria Chronicles, Jet Set Radio, Chrono, & Golden Sun.

So good.

big_z · (05-04-2009, 12:31 PM)

list fails without actraiser!

i would love okami 2 sadly no one buys good games....

Puck · (05-04-2009, 12:33 PM)

I WANT A NEW POKEMON STADIUM ON THE WII AND ON THE DS WHERE YOU CAN FIGHT POKEMON ACROSS PLATFORMS AND BECOME THE ULTIMATE TRAINER. ALSO POKEMON SNAP WOULD BE GREAT.

Doubledex · (05-04-2009, 12:35 PM)

:lol :D

XTERC · (05-04-2009, 12:36 PM)

No Metal Gear or Final Fantasy titles? How was the question worded?

Dapperk · (05-04-2009, 12:39 PM)

Originally Posted by Hunahan:

like I'd be able to play it anyway.

Whatever.

I have no idea wtf we are even talking about here.

wait......what?

Eh. I could go for that I guess.

"Oh! Oh! That game that came out like 2 seconds ago!!!"

Xenosaga blows.

forgot to specify "srpg." whoops.

Did you say whatever to sequels to ZOE and Chrono and Shenmue. You just alienated yourself from 95% of GAF :lol

And Kowloon's Gate rocks, although since 90% of GAF probably doesn't even know what game it is I'll give you some leeway on that one.

Originally Posted by XTERC:

No Metal Gear or Final Fantasy titles? How was the question worded?

Well probably because those series getting a sequel is a given.

Shig · (05-04-2009, 12:41 PM)

Might wanna put "aka Rival Schools/Project Justice" next to Justice Gakuen so more people can say "OMG FUCK YES" in agreement.

OMG FUCK YES, by the way.

Jinfash · (05-04-2009, 12:53 PM)

Ookami? Why, so no one would buy again? >:(

sixteen-bit · (05-04-2009, 12:56 PM)

Gotcha Force!

dreamcastmaster · (05-04-2009, 01:02 PM)

I'd vote for Bullet Witch, it's one of my favorite X360 games, BUT you have to be able to forgive some of the flaws and general lack of polish. I'd love a sequel that fixed the problems of the first.

Nolan. · (05-04-2009, 01:02 PM)

Can't make up my mind if it's good that there isn't 1 FF title there or not but really hope Sega takes note of SHENMUE.

yankee666 · (05-04-2009, 01:03 PM)

Shenmue saga on the PSP please!!!.

HUELEN10 · (05-04-2009, 01:03 PM)

No Super Mario Galaxy?!?!?!?!?!?!??!
No Ace Attorney?!?!?!?!?!?

They are dead to me....

Jinfash · (05-04-2009, 01:04 PM)

Originally Posted by Laguna:

Here the list with number of votes

1. Sakura Taisen (aka Sakura Wars) 267 votes
2. Shenmue 249 votes
3. Okami 204 votes
4. Gotchaforce 189 votes
5. Xenogears 185 votes
6. Breath of Fire 180 votes
7. Rockman Dash (aka Mega Man Legends) 176 votes
8. Ogre Battle 174 votes
9. Chikyuu Boueigun (aka Earth Defence Force) 162 votes
10. Kowloon’s Gate 151 votes
11. Shinobido 141 votes
12. Demon’s Souls 123 votes
13. Rockman X (aka Mega Man X) 110 votes
14. Chrono 107 votes
15. Z.O.E 94 votes
16. Mother 92 votes
17. Romancing SaGa 90 votes
18. Senjou no Valkyria (aka Valkyria Chronicles) 87 votes
19. Justice Gakuen 82 votes
20. Medarot 81 votes
21. Subarashiki Kono Sekai (aka The World Ends With You) 79 votes
22. Shadow Hearts 77 votes
23. Ore no Shikabane o Koete Yuke 75 votes
24. Panzer Dragoon 72 votes
25. Baten Kaitos 69 votes
26. Infinite Undiscovery 65 votes
27. Lost Odyssey 65 votes
28. Wild Arms 64 votes
29. OZ 60 votes
30. Jet Set Radio 59 votes
31. Dewprism 58 votes
32. Ougon no Taiyou (aka Golden Sun) 57 votes
33. Another Century’s Episode 56 votes
33. Estopolis Denki (aka Lufia) 56 votes
33. Fire Pro Wrestling Spike 56 votes
36. Biohazard Outbreak 55 votes
37. Eternal Arcadia (aka Skies of Arcadia) 54 votes
38. Shirokishi Monogatari: Inishie no Kodou (aka White Knight Chronicles) 51 votes
39. Panzer Front 50 votes
40. Seiken Densetsu 48 votes
41. Front Mission 46 votes
42. Grandia 43 votes
43. Arc The Lad 42 votes
44. Bullet Witch 41 votes
45. Racing Lagoon 39 votes
46. Drag-On Dragoon 37 votes
47. Panekit 36 votes
48. Metal Wolf Chaos 33 votes
49. Tokimeki Memorial 33 votes
50. Famicom Tantei Kurabu 30 votes

ugh, I knew that list would hardly represent anything. These people could basically be the only ones who went out and bought the prequels.

Brandon F · (05-04-2009, 01:06 PM)

All 12 people that bought Okami in Japan voted it #3? How big was this population sample?

Edit: NM, just saw the votes list. Makes sense now.

Haunted · (05-04-2009, 01:06 PM)

Originally Posted by XTERC:

No Metal Gear or Final Fantasy titles? How was the question worded?

Quite clearly aimed at games where no sequels are expected/announced (hence the lack of Zelda/MGS/FF/MH/DQ(!) etc.).

vandalvideo · (05-04-2009, 01:06 PM)

Why was Shadow Hearts so far down the list?

sixteen-bit · (05-04-2009, 01:09 PM)

Originally Posted by vandalvideo:

Why was Shadow Hearts so far down the list?

Maybe they played Lost Odyssey

vandalvideo · (05-04-2009, 01:10 PM)

Originally Posted by _dementia:

Maybe they played Lost Odyssey

Lost Odyssey didn't have that same occult vibe to it though. :(

Wii Will Rock U · (05-04-2009, 01:10 PM)

Seeing Chrono Trigger, Mega Man Legends and Okami on there warms my heart. I'd love to see sequels.

crowphoenix · (05-04-2009, 01:11 PM)

Originally Posted by Laguna:

Here the list with number of votes

31. Dewprism 58 votes

I thought I was alone in wanting a sequel for this game.

Dabanton · (05-04-2009, 01:12 PM)

Originally Posted by Nolan.:

Can't make up my mind if it's good that there isn't 1 FF title there or not but really hope Sega takes note of SHENMUE.

With 249 votes i'm sure they will...:P

But seriously I can understand why they will never do it though ironically a game like Shenmue would do extremely well nowadays even playing it now it's still well ahead of other so called 'open world games' in terms of characterisation and exploration it's still tops.

Sigh...:(

borghe · (05-04-2009, 01:12 PM)

no zack & wiki? wtf?

vandalvideo · (05-04-2009, 01:13 PM)

Originally Posted by Dabanton:

With 249 votes i'm sure they will...:P

But seriously I can understand why they will never do it though ironically a game like Shenmue would do extremely well nowadays even playing it now it's still well ahead of other so called 'open world games' in terms of characterisation and exploration it's still tops.

Sigh...:(

There is a new Shenmue game coming, and its an MMO. Booyah. :lol

INDIGO_CYCLOPS · (05-04-2009, 01:16 PM)

I'm impressed and so happy for Demon's Souls - among a list of great classics it's #12 and this is FAAANTASTIC :frankwest:

Nolan. · (05-04-2009, 01:18 PM)

Originally Posted by Dabanton:

With 249 votes i'm sure they will...:P

But seriously I can understand why they will never do it though ironically a game like Shenmue would do extremely well nowadays even playing it now it's still well ahead of other so called 'open world games' in terms of characterisation and exploration it's still tops.

Sigh...:(

Iv'e always thought that. Plus on this generation hardware it could look so awesome. Now this makes me all nostalgic and a bit sad just thinking about it.

cw_sasuke · (05-04-2009, 01:20 PM)

SheMue should be a no-brainer i mean they already got their next-gen engine for yakuza kenzan/3.

omg rite · (05-04-2009, 01:20 PM)

Hear that Capcom? Mega Man X9 with SNES graphcis. Get on it.

Also, Shenmue sucks. Sorry.

oneHeero · (05-04-2009, 01:24 PM)

Originally Posted by Doubledex:

Yeah, that high and still... nobody bought it @japan! So... wtf?

YOU HAVE TO BUY THE GAME FIRST, GUYS! THEN, YOU WILL GET A SEQUEL!

Exactly why I dont understand why these 2 are voted for.

26. Infinite Undiscovery 65 votes
27. Lost Odyssey 65 votes

Didnt they bomb in JP?

Haunted · (05-04-2009, 01:24 PM)

Originally Posted by omg rite:

Also, Shenmue sucks. Sorry.

nomg wrong

Originally Posted by oneHeero:

Exactly why I dont understand why these 2 are voted for.

26. Infinite Undiscovery 65 votes
27. Lost Odyssey 65 votes

Didnt they bomb in JP?

I'm pretty sure the sixty-five people who voted for sequels have bought the respective first games.

INDIGO_CYCLOPS · (05-04-2009, 01:26 PM)

Originally Posted by omg rite:

Hear that Capcom? Mega Man X9 with SNES graphcis. Get on it.

Also, Shenmue sucks. Sorry.

Originally Posted by Haunted:

nomg wrong
.

...

max-pain · (05-04-2009, 01:28 PM)

267 votes?:lol
Is this a joke?:lol

Gomu Gomu · (05-04-2009, 01:34 PM)

I'm interested to see the results of a similar poll from GAF. someone, do it.

h3ro · (05-04-2009, 01:36 PM)

26 Infinite Undiscovery Square Enix
27 Lost Odyssey Microsoft

Seriously? Seriously?

They want a sequel to IU before they want one to LO? Ugh.

Dabanton · (05-04-2009, 01:39 PM)

Originally Posted by vandalvideo:

There is a new Shenmue game coming, and its an MMO. Booyah. :lol

I know about the MMO. From the sounds of it, it's in name only.

I want a single player end to the story.

eXistor · (05-04-2009, 01:39 PM)

Originally Posted by Doubledex:

12 Demon’s Souls SCEJ

Nice. Also yes to a sequel please.

Dark FaZe · (05-04-2009, 01:40 PM)

Shenmue Sega
Rockman X (aka Mega Man X) Capcom
Chrono Square Enix
Z.O.E Konami
Biohazard Outbreak Capcom

YESSSS.

Shenmue 3 is a must. Wouldn't mind a Shenmue 1/2 remake with some new mechanics and graphics to lead people into S3.

HD Megaman X with 2D handdrawn sprites ftw.

Chrono 3? Probably the most obvious shit ever. Square is embarrassing for not pursuing this.

I'd rather see Kojima work on a new project than go back to Z.O.E but a ZOE3 could be EPIC.

Biohazard Outbreak? YESSSSS. Best of both worlds capcom. RE can go back to singleplayer mastery and Outbreak can be the cooperative and competitive version of the series.

omg rite · (05-04-2009, 01:40 PM)

Originally Posted by Haunted:

nomg wrong.

Nah, Shenmue was the definition of mediocre. I think EGM put it best when they gave it like a 6.0 and said it's a good "door knocking sim".

So insanely boring.

I heard Shenmue 2 was better at least.

Haunted · (05-04-2009, 01:41 PM)

Originally Posted by h3ro:

26 Infinite Undiscovery Square Enix
27 Lost Odyssey Microsoft

Seriously? Seriously?

They want a sequel to IU before they want one to LO? Ugh.

Both got 65 votes. Same amount, Famitsu probably just ordered them alphabetically.

vandalvideo · (05-04-2009, 01:43 PM)

Originally Posted by h3ro:

26 Infinite Undiscovery Square Enix
27 Lost Odyssey Microsoft

Seriously? Seriously?

They want a sequel to IU before they want one to LO? Ugh.

IU was actually an amazingly good game. The problem with the game was that Square didn't give enough funds to Tri-ace to pay for good VO talent. In the end, willfull suspension was ruined. I played the entire game muted listening to a OST and enjoyed the experience ten times more. The voice acting realyl ruins an otherwise great JRPG.

thaOwner · (05-04-2009, 01:43 PM)

Originally Posted by yankee666:

Shenmue saga on the PSP please!!!.

Having never played a Shenmue game and planning to get the new PSP, I'd pick this up day one if it became a reality.