Support NeoGAF

Mik2121 · May 17, 2010

Mods - please edit the title and delete the "(retarded)" part. Some people might get offended by it and it wasn't my intention

. Anyway, I hope the mods understand the reason why I made this thread (if not, just check out the RDR OT).

Please, post all that shit here and leave the Official Thread alone

And taken from the FFXIII thread:

Rules:
1) Do not go out of your way to antagonist people. I don't want to see people playing the fanboy card or insulting people, or trying bait/troll using "ammo" provided by differences in versions.

2) Keep it factual. Making exaggerated claims to fan the fires of dramatica is also not factual. If you want to compare the games, let's look at direct feed screenshots, direct feed video, and make factual comparisons to determine which is the best purchase for people who have a choice.

3) NO SPOILERS. Do not discuss anything story related. Do not use this thread to discuss any story spoilers or gameplay elements not revealed before hand. I don't want to see people using this thread as a springboard to troll the game, or to talk about import impressions. I don't want people asking questions about the game from importers either. There are other RDR threads for that.

4) If you take this: http://i44.tinypic.com/24y20yt.gif seriously, you are doing it wrong.

red-dead-redemption-announced-20090204060630438_640w.jpg

Go!

NEOPARADIGM · May 17, 2010

lol

Well done.

Metalmurphy · May 17, 2010

How could you have made this thread without this fabulous gif

:lol

OnPoint · May 17, 2010

The manager at my local Gamestop would have you believe the PS3 version looks inferior because they don't have enough experience developing for Blu-ray yet. Since it's a new technology.

But seriously, is there a big difference between these two versions?

noisome07 · May 17, 2010

sd tubes

Cant0na · May 17, 2010

SUB HD

/tears

UFRA · May 17, 2010

Thanks, Mik.

That's right assholes, keep this garbage here and get the hell out of our good thread! :lol

Mik2121 · May 17, 2010

Metalmurphy said:
How could you have made this thread without this fabulous gif

http://i44.tinypic.com/24y20yt.gif[IMG]

:lol[/QUOTE]
Check the edited OP, I added it just a minute ago :lol

Anyway, this will be my last post in this thread. Hope you guys have fun here.

FrankT · May 17, 2010

Metalmurphy said:
How could you have made this thread without this fabulous gif

:lol

Epic.

Mad_Ban · May 17, 2010

PS3 has clearer skies confirmed.

wizword · May 17, 2010

There is no need for this topic.

noisome07 · May 17, 2010

Mad_Ban said:
PS3 has clearer skies confirmed.

didn't you hear? ps3 version takes place on the moon.

dreamer3kx · May 17, 2010

I will put a end to this thread, they both look......the same, o shit.

Spy · May 17, 2010

wizword said:
There is no need for this topic.

Have you seen the official Red Dead Redemption thread?!

SamuraiX- · May 17, 2010

wizword said:
There is no need for this topic.

I really beg to differ.

Many thanks, TC.

Majima Everywhere System · May 17, 2010

Actually, this could be interesting. Maybe it will help someone pick a version, or maybe some people can scratch their console warz itch.

Zeliard · May 17, 2010

wizword said:
There is no need for this topic.

There is. It keeps the shit out of the real thread.

szaromir · May 17, 2010

PS3 version runs sexier.

Absinthe · May 17, 2010

Mad_Ban said:
PS3 has clearer skies confirmed.

Yep, much better blacks

chubigans · May 17, 2010

Was this topic bish-approved? Huh? WAS IT???

Pooya · May 17, 2010

pharmboy044 · May 17, 2010

Why the hell does that horse only have 3 legs? That's unpossible!

Dennis · May 17, 2010

Zeliard said:
There is. It keeps the shit out of the real thread.

This IS the real thread.

V_Ben · May 17, 2010

yeah. keep that stuff in here. cheers!

DMeisterJ · May 17, 2010

I actually like the fact that the PS3 version runs at a lower resolution and framerate. More cinematic and such.

Kazuma Kiryu · May 17, 2010

Metalmurphy said:
How could you have made this thread without this fabulous gif

:lol

:lol :lol :lol

trudderham · May 17, 2010

ShallNoiseUpon · May 17, 2010

Thank the gods for this thread.

Mad_Ban · May 17, 2010

DMeisterJ said:
I actually like the fact that the PS3 version runs at a lower resolution and framerate. More cinematic and such.

It has a sort of subtle beauty.

Camper182 · May 17, 2010

in the xbox version marston has a higher resolution (1080p ) because he is bigger in the comparison gif

on ps3 it is sub hd

Majine · May 17, 2010

I heard there are no Wifi hotspots in the PS3 RDR world.

Cant0na · May 17, 2010

Low resolution and low framerate means the ps3 version looks more warm and unique. like a true western

360 versions is generic as well bro, looks like gta: the western

Dead Prince · May 17, 2010

i am offended by the word "retarded" in the thread title. i demand the mod send mik2121 to my room.

Esteban · May 17, 2010

Both versions are identical, but the 360 version is definitely more identical.

/insert random retarded comparison gif between a SD tube and a 1080p perfect stream.

scoobs · May 17, 2010

Mad_Ban said:
It has a sort of subtle beauty.

i see what you did there

I'd like to add that the 360 version looks more 360 than the ps3 version. Definitely 360 the 360 version guys

StuBurns · May 17, 2010

So all I care about is if the PS3 version isn't completely fucked, and if there is any screen tear, help me GAF.

Mad_Ban · May 17, 2010

If this gets bish sanctioned then I hope some people remember the graveyard of the GT vs Forza thread.

The Lamonster · May 17, 2010

Interesting how there has been no actual discussion on the real differences in the two versions...

dreamer3kx · May 17, 2010

trudderham said:

WTF, are you mad? :lol :lol

Slappy967 · May 17, 2010

So just a shot in the dark here but I am going to guess I should be buying this on the 360 then :lol

Really want this game but alas it will have to wait since my gaming is soon to encompass only SMG2 and UFC Undisputed 10.

belvedere · May 17, 2010

The Lamonster said:
Interesting how there has been no actual discussion on the real differences in the two versions...

Well that's because no actual differences have been accurately noted. Making this even more ridiculous.

:lol

TheSeks · May 17, 2010

chubigans said:
Was this topic bish-approved? Huh? WAS IT???

And will this run for five months like the Forza 3 vs GT5 thread?

jett · May 17, 2010

StuBurns said:
So all I care about is if the PS3 version isn't completely fucked, and if there is any screen tear, help me GAF.

I don't see screen tearing in the multiplayer.it review video.

LiquidMetal14 · May 17, 2010

More trash PS3 shots please!

Thank God for this thread

Deleted member 30609 · May 17, 2010

what is it about rockstar games that attract this kind of bullshit.

nico · May 17, 2010

sarah palin is offended by your thread title

wayward archer · May 17, 2010

Keyser Soze · May 17, 2010

Wait, what is with the crazy comparison image...

Who made it, why does it exist in this world, why?

trudderham · May 17, 2010

dreamer3kx said:
WTF, are you mad? :lol :lol

LOL, no - but I thought the image was photoshop worthy :lol

evil ways · May 17, 2010

TheSeks said:
And will this run for five months like the Forza 3 vs GT5 thread?

No, it will go on for eons.

Support NeoGAF

Red Dead Redemption - 360 & PS3 comparison (Bish-approved!)

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

y'all should be ashamed

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Neo Member

Junior Butler

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.

D-Member

hide your water-based mammals

Deleted member 30609

Unconfirmed Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Similar threads