|
Member
(05-19-2012, 04:45 PM)
|
#9951
They've mostly forgotten this, but Abed is a much better athlete than former star quarterback Troy.
Last edited by beat; 05-19-2012 at 05:52 PM.
Reason: stupid touchscreen phone keyboard
|
|
|
|
Banned
(05-19-2012, 04:48 PM)
|
#9952
yeah, but Jeff is the only one that religiously lives at the gym and maintains his diet, since he's a narcissist. Better athlete or not, Jeff is likely twice as strong as Abed, and I'd still put him a good deal over Troy.
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 04:59 PM)
|
#9953
Aside from the obvious parodies in Community of Hughes' works, there's a fairly consistent undercurrent of his influence throughout the show. At least, from what I can see anyway. |
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 05:07 PM)
|
#9954
Wait, I'm suppose to be thankful that they're going to throw us a bone "of a shortened season 4". As a fan, no. I totally understand the business and financial side on why this thing is under performing and they need change, but you can also see that this is creative suicide. There are plenty of notable mediums that have hit the same snag (think Jurassic Park 3, or something like Resident Evil 5). Fans SHOULD be skeptical of change, and when it's as clear on why the change is happening, we know damn well to expect the worst.
|
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 05:09 PM)
|
#9955
How I really wish this would end: Harmon would bite the bullet, say that he would still be a staff writer, be in the room pitching ideas, and leave the managing to someone else.
It's your baby, Harmon. Even if you don't have the final say, you still should help it. And guess what? You sucked at managing and dealing with things like music clearance. |
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 05:11 PM)
|
#9956
If forced to choose, I'd take season 1 simply because there wasn't some weird need to make someone "dark". Chevy was actually pretty good in season 1. In 2 he got on my nerves with all the dark, angry shit. In season 3 they clearly didn't know what to do with him, or simply refused to try. In season 3 Abed obviously goes dark and it affects everything. I enjoy a lot of the wackier episodes, but season 1 is the most cohesive and consistent season to me. As someone else said - it had bullies, it had classes, it had love interests (I miss Professor hottie), it had a lot of Duncan. In other words, it was more relatable and believable. I do miss that aspect of it. Rather than a consistent narrative this season, it felt like a series of cool science experiments. Gets kinda tiring after awhile when what you really want is to see these people grow and evolve.
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 05:11 PM)
|
#9957
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 05:20 PM)
|
#9958
Oh, definitely. It was used more of a crutch then and that's eased back over the series, but I think there's still a little bit of it there. Or maybe it's that both Community and Breakfast Club/16 Candles etc. both serve as brilliant studies of the human psyche and happen to cover the same themes. Pretty sure everyone sees a little bit of themselves in each main Community character, just as they do with *most* John Hughes films (particularly Breakfast Club and Ferris Beuller's Day Off).
|
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 05:55 PM)
|
#9960
Not really. He's a great creative but a horrible boss of a multi-million company (the Community production). He's a micromanager, he's late on delivering, he's always over budget (sometimes wildly so)... And that's why we love him. Because those are the decisions that help make Community what it is. But it doesn't mean he's good at the running part of showrunning.
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 05:58 PM)
|
#9961
|
|
wears the band's shirts to the band's concerts
can't comprehend the origin of terms (05-19-2012, 06:04 PM)
|
#9962
If he can't even get along with people when he has complete creative control, what are the odds he'll get along with them when he doesn't have any control?
Has demoting the boss and turning him into another grunt ever worked out in other shows? Because it sounds like a bad idea for almost any workplace. |
|
Banned
(05-19-2012, 06:07 PM)
|
#9963
|
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 06:12 PM)
|
#9964
An interesting take from NPR:
http://justtv.wordpress.com/2012/05/...thor-function/
Quote:
|
|
wears the band's shirts to the band's concerts
can't comprehend the origin of terms (05-19-2012, 06:17 PM)
|
#9965
Or he'll flip the fuck out when the dude that now has his job starts vetoing his ideas.
Demoting a manager rarely works out because that person is generally resentful of the new management and frequently tries to undermine it. |
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 06:25 PM)
|
#9967
Smash is doing it now. It happens. Supervising producer is also the second most powerful person in the room, especially if the EPs aren't there. It happens. Whether Dan could deal is another story.
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 06:29 PM)
|
#9968
|
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 06:33 PM)
|
#9969
In an ideal world, it would be better if Harmon wasn't managing anyone and was just writing, or running the room. And this: @DamonLindelof: Not my business, but despite my love and support for COMMUNITY, it needs to be said that there IS a behavioral line that cannot be crossed.
Last edited by ivysaur12; 05-19-2012 at 06:35 PM.
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 06:39 PM)
|
#9970
I do wonder how Harmon would have reacted to them essentially asking him to co-run things, with him handling creative and somebody else doing the monetary vetoing and whatever ("No, you can't spend the entire music budget for the year on the Halloween episode.") It doesn't sound from his post like he'd have been a fan of anybody being able to tell him no, but hurt feelings must be a part of that.
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 06:48 PM)
|
#9972
I'm late to the party here.
I heard last night, and was fully pissed. Didn't come to this thread though. Because I was pissed. Just 12 hours has given me enough time to make a less vitriol-filled opinion on the ordeal, I think. There's no way to think this is okay. This has happened with TV shows before all the time. Some shows are designed to have a replaceable showrunner. Community is factually not one of them. It has been, since day one, auteur television. The vision of Dan Harmon. Artistically, this shift (in addition to losing so much of the writing staff) is undeniably bad for the show that we know as Community and will bring changes. That, of course, is just the art side of it. Commerce factors in of course. Community has low ratings. Dan has been something of a problem at times. So we know Sony Pictures had a lot of pressure on them. Does that mean the decision to fire Harmon makes business sense? No. Not at fucking all. The concepts of cultural cache and niche marketing are important here. The only reason Community survived as long as it did was the devoted and unmoving fanbase. They provided NBC and Sony with something they supposedly wanted: a cult hit. Cult hits have values. Their critical status can reflect better on a network's other shows. Tangential products can sell well. They can be part of lending an image to a network as a whole. That's impossibly important in today's network system. Can make or break a channel. Dan Harmon was difficult to deal with. He turned in episodes late. Went slightly over budget. Fought notes. But Sony and NBC knew what they were getting into and needed it. They can't be CBS and FX. They're falling and failing in the middle. Dan Harmon and Community were giving them what they wanted: a cult show with ravenous fans and lofty critical praise. In return, they fired the progenitor of all the greatness. Yes, they renewed the show. But that only showcases their continuing bumbling viewpoint. Renewing the show and firing Dan Harmon is evidence that they STILL want the show to be a mass audience hit. They don't understand what the show is or has been. Maybe it'll miraculously evolve into a hit. Maybe it'll even stay funny. But, conclusively, Community's regime change is evidence of a misunderstanding network and studio. The kind of network and studio that I don't see living in their current form for much longer.
Also, it's dickish to outright call him a drunk who loves drama. There's no doubt he's volatile. He talks about being volatile all the time. But a lot of that comes from passion. Finally, Dan wasn't the only person to not act in a professional manner. Sony fired Dan via a press release on a Friday evening. That's a really fucking dirty move. Through a showrunner change, it's important for the network and studio to make it seem slightly smooth to the audience. What Sony did was not only the complete opposite of professional and respectable, it was bad for business.
But while Dan is a terrible manager, he gave something more to the show. Him being there made it auteur, "quality" TV. The kind that they supposedly love to create. And the cult worship that created could have boosted the show to a better syndication number, I think.
Hell, this is detached from reality, but: imagine if Dan Harmon got to come to AMC after the end of Breaking Bad and Mad Men, with the network at its most worried, and imbue it with both its return to high quality and its first successful comedy. Would be amazing.
1) An asshole-ish superior tone. Nobody likes you when you do that. You don't look cool for denigrating others by talking about them holding...napkins? What the fuck even are your insults? Is this post just the result of a stroke? Can you function in society? 2) Several misunderstandings about how television works on the business end. For one, you're equating your personal experience with Pan Am and Alcatraz to the change on Community. Which is stupid. Neither of the former had critical accolades or a solid fanbase. Their cancelation made perfect business sense. As I've said in this post, getting rid of Harmon does not make a lot of business sense for the type of show that Community is. 3) A lack of care about the artistic side of the show. Good for you if you don't care about the actual quality of the show. People here do. Firing Dan and losing so many writers undeniably alters the show. It's logical to care about that.
Quote:
|
|
wears the band's shirts to the band's concerts
can't comprehend the origin of terms (05-19-2012, 06:48 PM)
|
#9973
I think that replacing Harmon had something to with the show's creative direction as well, and simply making him head writer wouldn't fix that.
I liked S3 a lot but it even seemed a little too out there for me towards the end, when people were actually being killed and murdered. |
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 06:53 PM)
|
#9975
Dan deserves whatever this was. Because obviously we don't know jack and or shit about it all.
If he's being a huge chode as a showrunner and producer he couldn't have expected this to end well. You don't get the opportunity to create and run your own television show and then not play the game a bit. You're just setting yourself up and the show to end horribly. |
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 06:54 PM)
|
#9976
There was a way for Sony to do this that could have appeased everyone. This was not one of those ways.
At the same time, I don't fault Sony for wanting him out of the managerial role. Cause god, he sucked at that. But to replace him without a phone call, or try to keep him on in some capacity? Fuck that.
Last edited by ivysaur12; 05-19-2012 at 06:57 PM.
|
|
wears the band's shirts to the band's concerts
can't comprehend the origin of terms (05-19-2012, 06:58 PM)
|
#9977
Same with Sony firing Harmon. They just want to wrap up syndication deals without the headaches of a volatile showrunner. |
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 07:04 PM)
|
#9979
Also keep talking about "playing the game" but won't talk about how Harmon DID play the game to a degree. The issue is that the game is changing.
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 07:28 PM)
|
#9983
Then Sony should have given him a co-showrunner. Who's going to run the show and accept Dan as a mere staff writer pitching anything as weird and wonderful as a 16-bit videogame? Who's going to let a mere staff writer tell the editor what to do? Even little stuff like the "Leonard likes this post" joke from the Ken Burns/pillow fort war ep were thought up by Harmon in the editing process. All of that goes away by demoting Harmon even in the scenario where he stays on the day to day writing.
|
|
will fuck homely black hookers in the name of progress and tolerance
(05-19-2012, 07:32 PM)
|
#9984
|
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 07:36 PM)
|
#9985
They all have contracts. |
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 07:55 PM)
|
#9989
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 07:56 PM)
|
#9990
Can't say I didn't see this coming. Harmon always sounded like a time bomb, but this is still a big loss in talent.
That's not to say S4 is going to be bad though. No choice but to wait and see, especially with S3 wrapping up nicely and in full circle.
But season 3 just ended Community Season 4 OT Cruel Cruel Cruel |
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 08:07 PM)
|
#9993
|
|
Member
(05-19-2012, 08:12 PM)
|
#9995
Yes, but I don't get why that's so much of an issue now. Getting to a syndication-able 84 eps means Sony makes back their investment and then some. This move hurts Sony on the back end by making the show slightly less attractive to syndicators and the s4 DVD box set much less attractive to fans.
My point here is that keeping an eye on costs is important, but if it leads you to forget about the other end, about revenue, then you've royally screwed up, and it's not because you were trying to 'be responsible'. |
|
"Who said you should help?"
(05-19-2012, 08:14 PM)
|
#9997
Cable channels don't really care if Harmon is on the show or now. They care about 1) ratings 2) how many episodes they can show. Can they show Community at 3am to plug some holes in their schedule? Yes? There's around 90-100 episodes they can show? Dope. DVD sales are icing on the cake, not really a huge revenue stream for TV. |
|
The Autumn Wind
(05-19-2012, 08:26 PM)
|
#9999
To bring this conversation back to the stuff in front of the cameras: did I miss some visual clues or something that is making everyone jump to the conclusion that Britta is moving in with Troy? It seemed to me she was just helping Troy move his stuff into the extra bedroom now that the Dreamatorium has been taken down, while Abed stays in the living room.
|