Andrex
ὁ αἴσχιστος παῖς εἶ
(11-25-2011, 04:45 AM)

Andrex's Avatar
#51

[spoiler]Spoiler text.[/spoiler]
Incendiary
Member
(11-25-2011, 04:59 AM)

Incendiary's Avatar
#52

Originally Posted by Zzoram: View Post
I remember I was skeptical of Angel when it first started. Then it got SO GOOD by the end of Season 1, and just keep on rising.

Season 4 had a few iffy parts in the middle but that's the only weakness the show has.
I haven't watched Angel yet, but I feel like I should. Part of it is because I know if I start watching it, that's a week+ of my life I won't do anything else.
Phoenician_Viking
Please listen.
(11-25-2011, 05:03 AM)

Phoenician_Viking's Avatar
#53

My favorite season is 5 of Buffy. Itīs a brilliant show.
When Buffy tells the council that she has the power and they need her, i got goose bumps. Itīs one of my favorite scenes of any series ever.
hamchan
Member
(11-25-2011, 05:06 AM)

hamchan's Avatar
#54

Originally Posted by SolidSnakex: View Post
Potential Slayers
Fuck all of them! There's only two people awesome enough to be slayers damn it!

Also Season 4 is so damn bad. Riley as a love interest is boring and rubbish, especially coming after Angel. Then the big bad is some Frankenstein's monster thingy, horrible stuff. You can tell Joss Whedon's writing suffered in season 4 because he had to handle two shows at once.
Medalion
Banned
(11-25-2011, 05:09 AM)

Medalion's Avatar
#55

Never forget

http://images.wikia.com/buffy/images/b/bf/Adam01.jpg

Don't click that link if you haven't made it past season 4, spoiler I guess
Andrex
ὁ αἴσχιστος παῖς εἶ
(11-25-2011, 05:11 AM)

Andrex's Avatar
#56

Originally Posted by hamchan: View Post
Fuck all of them! There's only two people awesome enough to be slayers damn it!

Also Season 4 is so damn bad. Riley as a love interest is boring and rubbish, especially coming after Angel. Then the big bad is some Frankenstein's monster thingy, horrible stuff. You can tell Joss Whedon's writing suffered in season 4 because he had to handle two shows at once.
Completely and utterly agreed. Season 4 was a colossal trainwreck.
brianjones
Member
(11-25-2011, 05:13 AM)

brianjones's Avatar
#57

Originally Posted by Medalion: View Post
Never forget

http://images.wikia.com/buffy/images/b/bf/Adam01.jpg

Don't click that link if you haven't made it past season 4, spoiler I guess
Lol

yeah he was pretty lame
SolidSnakex
Member
(11-25-2011, 05:19 AM)

SolidSnakex's Avatar
#58

Originally Posted by djsandman: View Post
Don't read the comic.
Yeah, i've heard that they continued the show in comics. I just really don't pay attention to them.

Originally Posted by hamchan: View Post
Fuck all of them! There's only two people awesome enough to be slayers damn it!

Also Season 4 is so damn bad. Riley as a love interest is boring and rubbish, especially coming after Angel. Then the big bad is some Frankenstein's monster thingy, horrible stuff. You can tell Joss Whedon's writing suffered in season 4 because he had to handle two shows at once.
I still don't see how they went from Angel as a love interest to Riley. Riley was beyond dull. Hush was in Season 4, so it wasn't all bad.
TheVampire
Member
(11-25-2011, 05:47 AM)

TheVampire's Avatar
#59

Originally Posted by Andrex: View Post
Completely and utterly agreed. Season 4 was a colossal trainwreck.
I thought season 4 was ok.

It was interesting to find out that the government was studying vampires and demons and had that huge underground base.

And then the humor that came with them inplanting that chip in Spikes brain so the only way he could satisfy his violent nature was to kill other vampires and demons thus becoming an ally lol
animlboogy
Member
(11-25-2011, 05:58 AM)

animlboogy's Avatar
#60

Buffy is probably the better show over Angel overall, given that it just sort of sags instead of hitting the sordid lows Angel does early on, but Angel season 5 is one of the most gleeful, amazing, well-written, retarded (in a good way) things ever. One of the best seasons of television, period. It comes off like the best year-long run on a genre comic book ever put together. Just fun, emotional, awesome. If you don't "click" with Angel, just hit Wikipedia for the bits you'll need to watch this one season.
Raistlin
Post Count: 9999
(11-25-2011, 06:03 AM)

Raistlin's Avatar
#61

Originally Posted by SolidSnakex: View Post
Yeah, i've heard that they continued the show in comics. I just really don't pay attention to them.



I still don't see how they went from Angel as a love interest to Riley. Riley was beyond dull. Hush was in Season 4, so it wasn't all bad.
It was a really weird season. As a whole, it was pretty crap ... but a number of eps if taken in a vacuum were quite excellent. Beyond Hush, Who Are You? and Restless come to mind.
Andrex
ὁ αἴσχιστος παῖς εἶ
(11-25-2011, 05:44 PM)

Andrex's Avatar
#62

Originally Posted by animlboogy: View Post
Buffy is probably the better show over Angel overall, given that it just sort of sags instead of hitting the sordid lows Angel does early on, but Angel season 5 is one of the most gleeful, amazing, well-written, retarded (in a good way) things ever. One of the best seasons of television, period. It comes off like the best year-long run on a genre comic book ever put together. Just fun, emotional, awesome. If you don't "click" with Angel, just hit Wikipedia for the bits you'll need to watch this one season.
Puppet Angel, lol. So good.
Metalmurphy
(11-25-2011, 05:45 PM)

Metalmurphy's Avatar
#63

I also thought this show had TERRIBLE acting, but for some reason, I just kept watching.


Also, Sarah Michelle Gellar's best years so...




UGH!!
Last edited by Metalmurphy; 11-25-2011 at 05:47 PM.
-Pyromaniac-
(11-25-2011, 05:46 PM)

-Pyromaniac-'s Avatar
#64

Originally Posted by Beam: View Post
My favorite season is 5 of Buffy. Itīs a brilliant show.
When Buffy tells the council that she has the power and they need her, i got goose bumps. Itīs one of my favorite scenes of any series ever.
Similar moment but I love when Buffy tells Giles to fuck off and she's done with him after he tries to trick her and get Spike killed.
ivysaur12
"Who said you should help?"
(11-25-2011, 05:55 PM)

ivysaur12's Avatar
#65

Season 4 of Buffy is so bad. So very, very bad.

Season three and the ending of season two were the best things ever. And season five was almost up there with 3 and 2.

I'd rank them:

3 > 2 > 5 > 1 > 6 > 7 > 4

Kennedy > Riley
rkn
Member
(11-25-2011, 05:58 PM)

rkn's Avatar
#66

Originally Posted by ivysaur12: View Post
Season 4 of Buffy is so bad. So very, very bad.

Season three and the ending of season two were the best things ever. And season five was almost up there with 3 and 2.

I'd rank them:

3 > 2 > 5 > 1 > 6 > 7 > 4

Kennedy > Riley
Hey now, season 4 as a whole is sorta terrible, but there are gems in there, Something Blue, Hush, the Faith 2 parter, hell I even like the opener, plus Restless, some great stuff when taken individually.
-Pyromaniac-
(11-25-2011, 06:01 PM)

-Pyromaniac-'s Avatar
#67

Originally Posted by rkn: View Post
Hey now, season 4 as a whole is sorta terrible, but there are gems in there, Something Blue, Hush, the Faith 2 parter, hell I even like the opener, plus Restless, some great stuff when taken individually.
goes back to what I said on the first page, even when buffy has dips in season quality, it's still pretty damn good.
SlipperySlope
Member
(11-25-2011, 06:13 PM)

SlipperySlope's Avatar
#68

SMG was fucking hot in season 1.

Um... that's all I have to add to this thread.
sixteen-bit
Member
(11-25-2011, 06:33 PM)

sixteen-bit's Avatar
#69

I recall seeing the first episode when a student brought it in to art class in middle school. Not my cup of tea.
Stitch
Member
(11-25-2011, 06:35 PM)

Stitch's Avatar
#70

Originally Posted by MetalAlien: View Post
Never liked the show, loved the original movie though.
the first 2 or maybe 3 seasons are alright but yeah, the movie is fun :D
anaron
Member
(11-25-2011, 07:31 PM)

anaron's Avatar
#71

What season 4 lacks in structure, it more than makes up for in its strong character interaction and brilliant standalones. The cast chemistry and cinematography of the show are also at a peak, making even the worst episodes enjoyable on some level.
Andrex
ὁ αἴσχιστος παῖς εἶ
(11-25-2011, 07:37 PM)

Andrex's Avatar
#72

Originally Posted by _dementia: View Post
I recall seeing the first episode when a student brought it in to art class in middle school. Not my cup of tea.
The first season in general completely betrays the expectations of what the series becomes. Start with the middle of season two and you'll see what I mean.
anaron
Member
(11-25-2011, 07:46 PM)

anaron's Avatar
#73

Season two hasn't aged particularly well (buffy and angel's romance especially) but starting with "what's my line" or "Surprise" is, I suppose, the most relative way to bridge someone onto the show from an early point in the series.
Orcastar
Member
(11-25-2011, 07:47 PM)

Orcastar's Avatar
#74

One of my all time favourite TV shows. Should really rewatch the whole series at some point.
Gonky
Junior Member
(11-25-2011, 07:49 PM)

Gonky's Avatar
#75

I FUCKING LOVE BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER
Raistlin
Post Count: 9999
(11-25-2011, 09:44 PM)

Raistlin's Avatar
#76

We should do a full-on Buffy / Angel in order gaf watching ... anyone up for it?
TheVampire
Member
(11-25-2011, 09:54 PM)

TheVampire's Avatar
#77

Buffy/Angel did some really good crossover episodes too.
<+)O Robido O(+>
(11-25-2011, 09:55 PM)

<+)O Robido O(+>'s Avatar
#78

My 1st ep of Buffy was "The Body." I was inconsolable by the end of "The Gift."
Medalion
Banned
(11-25-2011, 09:59 PM)

Medalion's Avatar
#79

I can barely stand to watch through season 1 after the levels of greatness the show hit, yet I was there when it was all going down. The dangers of a new struggling show trying to find its feet.
moojito
Member
(11-25-2011, 10:02 PM)

moojito's Avatar
#80

Originally Posted by TheVampire: View Post
Buffy/Angel did some really good crossover episodes too.
No kidding. That one that showed Angel way back in ye olde China or somewhere from two different perspectives blew me away. The way they used the exact same scene and it having two completely different meanings. So awesome.
anaron
Member
(11-25-2011, 10:24 PM)

anaron's Avatar
#81

Originally Posted by Raistlin: View Post
We should do a full-on Buffy / Angel in order gaf watching ... anyone up for it?
Do eeeeet
Captain_Spanky
Member
(11-25-2011, 10:27 PM)

Captain_Spanky's Avatar
#82

Originally Posted by Raistlin: View Post

There never really were any 'very special episodes' on Buffy. The show quite consistently dealt with serious situations in a very realistic manner ... and it was nearly always handled with grace. Stuff like sex, drugs, sexuality, loss, death, etc. never felt forced. It was never an after school special. Instead such things were fully integrated into the plot and only done because it really made sense to the characters and plot circumstances.

Except for 4 episodes. Season 4's "Beer Bad" and the god awful (season 6 spoiler) magic addiction storyline. But then I couldn't stand seasons 6 or 7, such a shift away from I'd been enjoying. And I only watched the show 2 years ago in a big run on DVD.
Mr. Sandman
Member
(11-25-2011, 10:33 PM)

Mr. Sandman's Avatar
#83

So I've started my re-watch of the series last night. I have the DVDs for Buffy and Angel is on Amazon Prime's video service so I'll be watching both. I made it through the first four episodes and those actually hold up pretty decently. Yeah, they are dated but not as bad as you'd think for something from 1996.
Medalion
Banned
(11-25-2011, 10:45 PM)

Medalion's Avatar
#84

I guess I'm the weird one who actually really enjoyed season 6 and the dark storyline involving Willow

Dark Willow ftw
ivysaur12
"Who said you should help?"
(11-25-2011, 10:51 PM)

ivysaur12's Avatar
#85

Originally Posted by Medalion: View Post
I guess I'm the weird one who actually really enjoyed season 6 and the dark storyline involving Willow

Dark Willow ftw
I respect the sixth season, especially now that I'm in my twenties and understand what Joss was trying to say about that time period of ones life and its general ambivalence. That being said, a lot of it fell flat for numerous reasons.

I really think that the switch from the WB to UPN was one of the driving forces behind the creative decline. At that point, the WB had a much more knowledgable set of executives and had crafted a niche that worked. Even when the numbers weren't there for their attempt to expand out of the younger demographics (Pepper Daniels, Jack & Bobby), the shows were creatively vibrant.

It was only towards the end of its life on UPN (ironically, when Dawn Ostroff took over), did it ever feel like UPN could guide a series outside of African-American targeted sitcoms.
Andrex
ὁ αἴσχιστος παῖς εἶ
(11-25-2011, 10:59 PM)

Andrex's Avatar
#86

Originally Posted by Medalion: View Post
I guess I'm the weird one who actually really enjoyed season 6 and the dark storyline involving Willow

Dark Willow ftw
s6 was rough overall but I really thought it was still a gem. The over-arching plots were handled well, and the whole thing kind of seemed like what logically must happen following the events of the s5 finale.

It also gets a lot of hate for being "dark" but like everything in the series I thought it was handled very well.

Plus, Once More With Feeling.
Last edited by Andrex; 11-25-2011 at 11:02 PM.
Grisby
Member
(11-25-2011, 11:08 PM)

Grisby's Avatar
#87

The movie is sooooo good.

Oh.

You mean the TV show? Yeah, that's a good one too. I only watched the first few seasons before it seemed like shit got weird (Willow being a crazy witch, etc.) The opening guitar riff is still one of the best show opening themes ever.
Andrex
ὁ αἴσχιστος παῖς εἶ
(11-25-2011, 11:11 PM)

Andrex's Avatar
#88

Originally Posted by Grisby: View Post
The movie is sooooo good.

Oh.

You mean the TV show? Yeah, that's a good one too. I only watched the first few seasons before it seemed like shit got weird (Willow being a crazy witch, etc.) The opening guitar riff is still one of the best show opening themes ever.
Yeah, Angel's opening is pretty lame in comparison.
ivysaur12
"Who said you should help?"
(11-25-2011, 11:14 PM)

ivysaur12's Avatar
#89

Originally Posted by Andrex: View Post
Yeah, Angel's opening is pretty lame in comparison.
All of Joss' shows have openings that perfectly fit the themes of their respective series. Something I've always admired, especially when we're moving towards a world where most openings on broadcast TV will be nothing more than a flash of the title.
Hansel
Member
(11-25-2011, 11:17 PM)

Hansel's Avatar
#90

Originally Posted by Big One: View Post
Buffy: 2>5>3>7>6>1>4
Angel: 5>3>2>1>4
Buffy: 3>2>6>1>5>7>4

You're 100% right with Angel though

Edit: Also, best show of all time. You're going to have so much fun, OP.
Grisby
Member
(11-25-2011, 11:18 PM)

Grisby's Avatar
#91

Originally Posted by Andrex: View Post
Yeah, Angel's opening is pretty lame in comparison.
Never did watch Angel. Went and looked up the theme and it ain't bad. But yeah, Buffy's is way better.
Vinci
Danish
(11-25-2011, 11:19 PM)

Vinci's Avatar
#92

I prefer Buffy significantly over Angel. Angel's S4 made Buffy's S4 feel like eating a half-gallon of awesome Vienna Mocha ice cream. Even if Angel had been fantastic throughout, which it wasn't, S4 would have sunk it into playing second fiddle to its parent show. It was that bad.

Season rankings wise: 5>3>2>7>6>1>4

Buffy S4 hits the low point due almost entirely because of Riley Finn, the most worthless and uninteresting person imaginable for a show so rife with great characters. Even Hush, the Faith double-dip, and Restless couldn't make up for his sheer suck.

S6 gets points for having one of the best episodes ever, Once More With Feeling, and therefore edges out S1.

I agree with an earlier poster that the Top 3 are pretty much a given, with their placement varying depending on the individual person.

As for the best episodes ever: The Body (S5), Once With More Feeling(S6), and The Gift (S5).

At any rate, anyone making their way through the series is in for a treat - just fast-forward through S4 for the most part and try to ignore it ever happened.
Medalion
Banned
(11-25-2011, 11:20 PM)

Medalion's Avatar
#93

Buffy is more action oriented and youthful, thus the pop-punk intro

Angel is more melancholic, darker, a lil more grown-up, story and character driven, like the Angel character is supposed to be.

So yes the themes fit the shows very well.
brianjones
Member
(11-25-2011, 11:20 PM)

brianjones's Avatar
#94

Originally Posted by Raistlin: View Post
We should do a full-on Buffy / Angel in order gaf watching ... anyone up for it?
i think id be up for that.. it's been a while
dave is ok
aztek is ok
(11-25-2011, 11:21 PM)

dave is ok's Avatar
#95

Originally Posted by Medalion: View Post
Never forget

http://images.wikia.com/buffy/images/b/bf/Adam01.jpg

Don't click that link if you haven't made it past season 4, spoiler I guess
Why on earth did he have a floppy disk slot
Medalion
Banned
(11-25-2011, 11:24 PM)

Medalion's Avatar
#96

Originally Posted by dave is ok: View Post
Why on earth did he have a floppy disk slot
This was back in the early 1999-2000 when we still had those drives but were slowly being phased out... I guess outfitting him with a CD-ROM or DVD-ROM, damn those load times
Raistlin
Post Count: 9999
(11-25-2011, 11:27 PM)

Raistlin's Avatar
#97

Originally Posted by anaron: View Post
Do eeeeet
Originally Posted by brianjones: View Post
i think id be up for that.. it's been a while
I'll give it a shot in a few weeks :)

I'll start by polling people on what sort of timeline makes sense (# of eps a week) ... and once we're rolling, keep the OP updated at the top with times/dates, etc.





Originally Posted by Captain_Spanky: View Post
Except for 4 episodes. Season 4's "Beer Bad" and the god awful (season 6 spoiler) magic addiction storyline. But then I couldn't stand seasons 6 or 7, such a shift away from I'd been enjoying. And I only watched the show 2 years ago in a big run on DVD.
I suppose, maybe? I don't know ... guess we'll have to rewatch :p

For Beer Bad I guess I do vaguely recall it feeling a little preachy, but in general what stands out is how goofy the episode was in general. Joss certainly never had a problem with being goofy (it's arguably one of the strengths of his writing), but it almost seemed a bit much. I suppose there's nothing wrong with doing it every once in a while though. Either way, it had some eminently quotable material. I remember quite regularly hearing 'BEER ... GOOD' in a caveman voice at parties back in the day :D


As far as the other eps in question, I'm generally don't agree. For me a 'very special episode' has some key traits. It's forced via some combination of the tenor being out of character for the show, the characters being out of character, things being overly explained ... and many times, it's a very topical subject matter.

With that happened to Willow, I don't really see it following any of that. If anything, in many ways it defined her character. For all the good things about her, a continual issue was her addiction to power. It's not like the issue just went away after the eps in question, it was a continual struggle for her character. And what made it interesting is they didn't just show the bad side of things ... the also showed the aftermath. It wasn't just her turning dark ... she later struggled with the fear of using powerful magic, and that set up some important conflicts.

Was the analogy to drugs pretty obvious? Sure. Were the eps in question handled as deftly as they could have been? Probably not, but overall things played out pretty realistically, continued to be an important aspect of her character, and impacted situations later on.
Medalion
Banned
(11-25-2011, 11:29 PM)

Medalion's Avatar
#98

It was some of the best acting I saw from Alyson instead of playing the usual shy geek girl
JerkShep
Member
(11-25-2011, 11:33 PM)

JerkShep's Avatar
#99

Buffy Season 2 and 3 are amazing.
But "Not Fade Away" (Angel series finale) >>> "Chosen"

"Let's go to work"
Last edited by JerkShep; 11-25-2011 at 11:36 PM.
Raistlin
Post Count: 9999
(11-25-2011, 11:34 PM)

Raistlin's Avatar
#100

Originally Posted by djsandman: View Post
So I've started my re-watch of the series last night. I have the DVDs for Buffy and Angel is on Amazon Prime's video service so I'll be watching both. I made it through the first four episodes and those actually hold up pretty decently. Yeah, they are dated but not as bad as you'd think for something from 1996.
If you want ... I'm going to start an official Buffy / Angel series watch. So if you want to discuss each ep you might want to slow down :p