|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:26 AM)
|
#1801
Man, this entire topic just stinks. There's no way of picking a side without ending up being reductionist.
Speaking as a UK FGC member, I don't understand the US culture. But I think that all this silly drama which stemmed from the actions of one person needs to really be looked at in perspective, and the US FGC needs to act as one over this issue. This is 100% drama and it's getting the way of men throwing hadokens at each other. There is a very important difference between allowing people to speak their minds and what Aris did. The fact that this has now erupted into a massive drama over streaming and what can be said is silly.
Last edited by Huw_Dawson; 03-02-2012 at 01:28 AM.
|
|
|
|
XisBannedTier
(03-02-2012, 01:31 AM)
|
#1804
Last edited by QisTopTier; 03-02-2012 at 01:33 AM.
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:32 AM)
|
#1805
"I survived CrossAssault" is becoming a noteworthy accomplishment, it seems.
I like what Jared said. There should be more talk like this (not necessarily in terms of agreement, but tone) and less tit for tat bullshit.
And speaking of that Daigo/Wong parry, that's what got me into this whole thing, cheesy and cliche as that may be. I had seen competitive gaming here and there, but nothing like *that*. The energy in that room was palpable even in a shitty internet vid (before youtube even, iirc!).
Last edited by macuser1of5; 03-02-2012 at 01:36 AM.
|
|
Junior Member
(03-02-2012, 01:33 AM)
|
#1806
Neato getting banned just reinforces my generally low opinion of the type of gaf. Half of this thread is complaining about taking sexual harassment too seriously and overly punishing people for it. Neato calls them on their hypocrisy and they prove his point.
|
|
(ノ`Д´)ノ彡┻━┻
(03-02-2012, 01:34 AM)
|
#1807
Did you not read what duckroll just posted?
|
|
Banned
(03-02-2012, 01:35 AM)
|
#1808
It's amazing the lengths a person will go to dehumanize someone else just to further their crusade. Actually, about a week ago, I heard marn talking some shit on a stream. he was being his usual dumb, belligerent self. Then he got a call from some girl who was crying to him about how she needed to be picked up 6 hours away or something. Not sure what the deal was...he didn't want to go at first because apparently she stole stuff from him. But then he decided he couldn't just let her hang if she was really in trouble and left the stream to go pick her up. The other guys on the stream were commenting about how he was so friendly and all that stuff despite being kind of a rough guy. So, you know, chill out before running off on someone just cause you witness some of their weaker moments. |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:39 AM)
|
#1810
If there are genuinely problematic commentators that can't be trusted to cross the line into legit sexism, I think it's fair to not allow them to commentate. But there's the ability to indicate that your stream is for 18+ people on Twitch for a reason. I like how people are blunt and honest in the US scene. It's less manufactured than many other esports. People also need to consider that the western FGC community is probably the most racially diverse community in gaming, so the fact that there's now a massive argument over sexism, which is just another form of bigotry, is actually really interesting, and it suggests an obvious solution in just treating female and male players equally, rather than encouraging or discouraging female players. It's not actually the end of the world if not many women are involved. Do you see football players ripping their hair out over worries that not as many women play football competetively as men? The fact that we make such a big deal over players like Sherry and Super Yan because they're a novelty is, I would argue, a bad thing. Treat everyone around you as a human being and you will be in a community of human beings. Treat everyone around you as men and women and you end up in a community of tensions.
Last edited by Huw_Dawson; 03-02-2012 at 01:43 AM.
|
|
Why so low?
(03-02-2012, 01:40 AM)
|
#1811
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:40 AM)
|
#1812
It's good (and encouraged) to have discussions and bring forth your opinion in this forum. He was not banned for doing that. Please do read his other posts and see what is the difference between his posts and the rest. |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:41 AM)
|
#1813
Well, SRK actually did something. His first article about this was pure talk but this one is a good start.
Taking away the sponsorship from tournaments that do not impose a a minimum code of behavior is good. e: and punishing commentators and participants too. Yeah, evo seeding points are next to meaningless, but it's that or banning marn. Marn should learn a lesson here. |
|
Junior Member
(03-02-2012, 01:43 AM)
|
#1814
Wanting to maintain your community doesn't give you a free pass to use sexist comments and insults and say misogynistic shit. The FGC would be much classier if the guy saying shit like "what's your bra size" is banned. |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:45 AM)
|
#1815
Are you thinking that we are happy that he got banned for having a different opinion that some of the posters in this thread? I mean, really? Do you not... see why he got banned? If anything, I agree to some extent with what he said, but... really? |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:45 AM)
|
#1816
|
|
mashadar's neko-mimi slave
(03-02-2012, 01:47 AM)
|
#1817
If there is an official organization known as the FGC, and they organize all the major tournaments and events internationally, then I believe many people would indeed be in favor of having a sanction against Aris for the crap he said. He would probably also take the ban and reflect on what a terrible douche he was for ruining the mood of the contest for his own team. But there isn't. So all people can do right now is make it known to him that they are displeased with him, and do not agree with him. |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:47 AM)
|
#1818
SRK did (relative) good here. Leading by example, although I'll miss Marn's antics on WNF.
Telling the other venues that they're not going to tolerate the negligence that let the Cross Assault event occur in the first place is a pretty firm foot forward. The punishment is also broad/severe enough to satisfy people who may not understand the whole picture(tldr PR). Hopefully this doesn't have to happen again... I'd still like to have my salty, blowup-flavored pie and eat it too. |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:47 AM)
|
#1819
That slight edit would involve calling someone a fucking cretin, though. Neato was not the only guy saying that what the FGC did was not okay, either. A lot of people have taken that side of the argument. I'd even say most people who've participated in this thread have gone that way. It's only since inkblot's post that we got a bunch of new people from the 'the FGC will suck now' camp.
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:47 AM)
|
#1820
From my experience, before the strict rules were in place, the chat was garbage. Afterwards, the chat is readable and intelligent, and there's rarely a need for slow-mode. Charity begins at home, reducing idiocy starts with banhammer. Remove the people who are causing the actual problems, but the SRK post makes me seriously worried that there's going to be an overreaction that goes from just banning people to banning topics, opinions and anything that's not been vetted by a streaming staff that wants a totally santatized product.
Last edited by Huw_Dawson; 03-02-2012 at 01:54 AM.
|
|
mashadar's neko-mimi slave
(03-02-2012, 01:49 AM)
|
#1821
Just so I don't misunderstand, can you state for the record that you are saying that you have a low opinion of GAF because you disagree with the moderation of this thread? I want to be clear here before I do anything.
|
|
XisBannedTier
(03-02-2012, 01:52 AM)
|
#1822
The whole girls league thing at evo was dumb as well. Just hearing about that event pissed me off. If girls want to play games and not be treated as something different THEN FINE DO THAT don't sign up for some dumbass shit like that. Girls don't play worse than guys there is nothing there that causes them to do so. Giving girls special treatment as well is stupid as hell and is sexist just as bad as acting all shocked they are there in the first place. I think he was just calling out how hateful your first post in the thread was, then again when you just hear news emotions can be a little high. It was a little over the top though. Moderation in the thread has been fine for people on both sides of the fence and has been keeping the discussion as sane as possible.
Last edited by QisTopTier; 03-02-2012 at 01:57 AM.
|
|
Why so low?
(03-02-2012, 01:52 AM)
|
#1823
|
|
Twitch CM
(03-02-2012, 01:53 AM)
|
#1824
Besides, I think I've said enough ;) For the foreseeable future I'll be focused on the games themselves and doing what I usually do in the background to try and ensure growth and reward players. It's up to others to run with the message -- hopefully in a positive way. |
|
Junior Member
(03-02-2012, 01:56 AM)
|
#1826
I'm not defending Neato's specific language, just saying it seems ironic that a lot of people in this thread have complained that people are taking misogynist insults and sexual harassment too seriously, saying "it's just joking around" and they don't want people to be harshly punished for it, but harsh punishment comes down on Neato for his insults.
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:56 AM)
|
#1827
But to be clear. It is not the same as how you treat them when in a conversation. |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:57 AM)
|
#1828
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:57 AM)
|
#1829
Women largely feel unwelcome in many insular, male dominated communities (I should know! :P), and I feel that it's pretty important to show women that the environment is a welcoming one. You don't have to treat us in any sort of dramatically special way, because we generally don't want to feel singled out, but many of us do want to feel like our wishes can be respected, without a furor in response, when we choose not to comply with the more "masculine tropes" (for lack of a better phrase). |
|
Why so low?
(03-02-2012, 01:58 AM)
|
#1830
"Just so I don't misunderstand, can you state for the record that you are saying that you have a low opinion of GAF because you disagree with the moderation of this thread? I want to be clear here before I do anything." The king demands that you explain yourself before he beheads you. |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 01:58 AM)
|
#1831
Once it got into the gaming press, it became not just about Aris and what he had done but the community to which he belonged. Many comments on the blogs wondered whether or not this was endemic to the scene (as Aris seemingly suggested) and many people emphatically stated that he was an isolated case and did not represent them. Marn, thanks to his making light of an issue that the community as a whole has been shamed by, undermined literally everyone trying to make the case that Aris is an isolated case. He embarassed Level|Up and cost them both EVO points and SRK sponsorship, thus making sure that every person who now streams is going to have to think about the possible consequences for themselves or their organization, especially if they are supported by SRK Illuminati or other organization likely to pull funding because of bad behavior. |
|
XisBannedTier
(03-02-2012, 01:59 AM)
|
#1832
The subject as a whole right now is way past the how to talk to girls nicely part.
Last edited by QisTopTier; 03-02-2012 at 02:03 AM.
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 02:00 AM)
|
#1833
What should manz consider, if anything? Is there a general list of things people should consider? |
|
Junior Member
(03-02-2012, 02:00 AM)
|
#1834
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 02:01 AM)
|
#1836
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 02:05 AM)
|
#1838
I honestly don't know what to think about the woman's tourrny. On one hand I like, because there is this historical weight and while most guys played games as little kids, a lot of girls started a lot later; but on the other hand, I feel they should slowly carve they way in and that's why it is so fricking important that they feel welcomed, so they have a chance to do that fair and square.
|
|
Junior Member
(03-02-2012, 02:06 AM)
|
#1839
|
|
mashadar's neko-mimi slave
(03-02-2012, 02:06 AM)
|
#1840
But I think the bigger question here is, why didn't Capcom sanction him for the actions and comments he made while on a show organized by Capcom, which Capcom has now come out to say they disagree with and find unacceptable? |
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 02:07 AM)
|
#1841
Especially since inkblot/EVO was able to quite effectively sanction WNF/Marn/ETR.
|
|
Why so low?
(03-02-2012, 02:07 AM)
|
#1842
|
|
XisBannedTier
(03-02-2012, 02:10 AM)
|
#1845
The situation is dumb ass hell, and I'm really not trying to play blame the victim here, but I think things went on further because she acted like things were okay. Let alone almost asking one of the contestants how big their dick is to back up her statement about her boyfriend. Capcom was probably like OH HEY LOLZ THEY ARE ALL GETTING ALONG AGAIN :D No there is still no excuse for why he was still on the show after it. I'm guessing they just didn't want to stop it. Toss in all this internet publicity she is getting now about it, making things even worse for her. You think someone that was sexually harassed or raped or any of that subject mater wants the world to know and see that type of stuff about it, or see the break down of it. Shit really sucks for her. Well some people are open about it, but she really really doesnt seem the type.
Last edited by QisTopTier; 03-02-2012 at 02:16 AM.
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 02:11 AM)
|
#1846
That was really bad on Capcom's part, and I find it sad that an amateur (or semi-pro, to be more nice) production got on it on the next day. Both times there was an article that called them out on it, but only Level-Up Live apologized in matter of hours. :-/
|
|
Member
(03-02-2012, 02:18 AM)
|
#1849
He did the crime now he has to do the time, but some think that he shouldn't immediately be ostracized from the community and given a second chance in due time. |