[Alucard]

I'll tally the votes at the end of each day for the next two.

1st place - 6 points
2nd place - 5 points
3rd place - 4 points
4th place - 3 points
5th place - 2 points
6th place - 1 point

I'll start:

1 - Episode 5
2 - Episode 4
3 - Episode 6
4 - Episode 3
5 - Episode 1
6 - Episode 2



Let's do this.

UPDATES:

After 50 posts:


1. Episode 5: The Empire Strikes Back - 149 points


2. Episode 4: A New Hope - 121 points


3. Episode 6: Return of the Jedi - 113 points


4. Episode 3: Revenge of the Sith - 76 points


5. Episode 1: The Phantom Menace - 55 points


6. Episode 2: Attack of the Clones - 44 points

[sfedai0]

Theres 6?

[KevinCow]

1 - Episode 5 2 - Episode 4 3 - Episode 6 4 - Episode 3 5 - Episode 1 6 - Episode 2

Do we need to go any further with this thread? That's the correct order.

[Arment]

I thought voting threads were outlawed?

Do we need to go any further with this thread? That's the correct order.

I'd switch #5 and #6, that's all.

1 - Episode 5
2 - Episode 4
3 - Episode 6
4 - Episode 3
5 - Episode 2
6 - Episode 1

I can't wait until someone ranks one of the prequels over the originals. My gawd.

[Fudgepuppy]

1. Episode 5
2. Episode 6
3. Episode 4

Can't rank the rest, sorry.

[Nappuccino]

5
4
6
1
3
2


(1 gets extra points for being hilariously awful... where as 2 is dreadfully boring and 3... is occasionally pretty? I guess?)

[JdFoX187]

1. Episode V
2. Episode IV
3. Episode III
4. Episode VI
5. Episode II
6. Episode I

After watching The Phantom Menace 3D re-release recently, I truly realized how bad Jake Lloyd's acting and the god awful plot really were. At least Attack of the Clones does something with its story and moves the plot of the whole saga along, even if there's a whole middle section of nothing but poorly written interaction between Anakin and Padme.

[Htown]

I thought voting threads were outlawed? I'd switch #5 and #6, that's all. 1 - Episode 5 2 - Episode 4 3 - Episode 6 4 - Episode 3 5 - Episode 2 6 - Episode 1

Bingo.

[zomgbbqftw]

I thought the mods had put an end to these ranking threads?

[Marcellus Wallace]

5
4
6
3
1
2

[MattKeil]

1. Episode V
2. Episode IV
3. Episode III
4. Episode VI
5. Episode I
6. Episode II

Actually a bit of coin flip between 3 and 4, since they're both about equally bad, but E3 is prettier eye candy, so it gets the nod.

[madkiller]

Episode V
Episode IV
Episode VI
Episode III
Episode I
Episode II

[lethial]

What the.

[Tieno]

1 - Episode 3
2 - Episode 2
3 - Episode 1
4 - Episode 4
5 - Episode 6
6 - Episode 5

[Stet]

1. Episode V 2. Episode IV 3. Episode III 4. Episode VI 5. Episode I 6. Episode II Actually a bit of coin flip between 3 and 4, since they're both about equally bad, but E3 is prettier eye candy, so it gets the nod.

Who thinks 4 is bad?!

[Lionel Mandrake]

Which one do I shoot?!

[zeitgeist]

1.VI
2.V
3.IV
4.I
5.III
6.II

[sfedai0]

Which is the real countdown?

[Glass Rebel]

1 - Episode 5 2 - Episode 4 3 - Episode 6 4 - Episode 3 5 - Episode 1 6 - Episode 2

Good ranking....


wait, this isn't the results thread?

[Grakl]

I'm scared.

[Dascu]

I'm seeing double here. Four ranking threads!

[Fancy Corndog]

1 - Episode 3 2 - Episode 2 3 - Episode 1 4 - Episode 4 5 - Episode 6 6 - Episode 5

I came here to do this sarcastically, I hope you just beat me to it.

[RatskyWatsky]

1 - Episode 4
2 - Episode 5
3 - Episode 6
4 - Episode 3
5 - Episode 1
6 - Episode 2

[mysticwhip]

3
2
6
5
4
1

the original trilogy could go anyway as I don't really remember them, I think the one where luke is chilling with vader is 6 so I put that ahead of the rest of the OG trilogy.

[OldRosa]

I don't get it.

[mugurumakensei]

5
4
3
2
6
1

[Aaron Strife]

4

5

6

1

3

2

I realize placing Star Wars over Empire Strikes Back is something of an unpopular opinion, but I stand by it.

[Sobriquet]

1 - Episode 5
2 - Episode 4
3 - Episode 6
4 - Episode 3
5 - Episode 1
6 - Episode 2

Same as OP.

[beef3483]

1. 6
2. 3
3. 5
4. 4
5. 1
6. 2

[VGChampion]

4
5
6
1
2
3

And actually, I'd probably rather watch Episode 1 again before watching the original trilogy. I just know in the long run I would rate the original > new.

[Reuenthal]

Star Wars
Empire Strikes Back
Return of the Jedi

I realize placing Star Wars over Empire Strikes Back is something of an unpopular opinion, but I stand by it.

And I agree with you.

[DarkKyo]

Everyone is going to mostly agree(with the exception of trolls) so there isn't going to be much of a debate here. Won't even be much of a thread.

[King of the Potato People]

Episodes

1 - V
2 - IV
3 - VI

Ok now it gets hard distinguishing between the levels of shit. Brown is brown.

So...

4 - I, well it doesn’t have Hayden Christensen so there’s that.
5 - III, it broke my heart.
6 - II, mainly because of: “I don’t like sand”

[beef3483]

1. 6
2. 3
3. 5
4. 4
5. 1
6. 2

[The Technomancer]

5
4
2
6
3
1

1 is terrible. So terrible. So utterly terrible.

[impact]

1. Episode V 2. Episode IV 3. Episode III 4. Episode VI 5. Episode I 6. Episode II Actually a bit of coin flip between 3 and 4, since they're both about equally bad, but E3 is prettier eye candy, so it gets the nod.

....


what?

[CrocMother]

Everyone is going to mostly agree(with the exception of trolls) so there isn't going to be much of a debate here. Won't even be much of a thread.

Yeah, what we really should be doing is ranking sci-fi trilogies.

Then we can really get this circle jerk going

[8bit]

5

4

About half of 6

KOTOR

The good Clone Wars cartoon

X Wing vs. Tie Fighter

KOTOR2

Rebel Assault

Caravan of Courage

Being raped by a tramp that sounds a bit like David Prowse

Star Wars Kinect

1

2

3

[Pezking]

5
6
4
1
3
2

[Mordeccai]

5 4 About half of 6 KOTOR The good Clone Wars cartoon X Wing vs. Tie Fighter KOTOR2 Rebel Assault Caravan of Courage Being raped by a tramp that sounds a bit like David Prowse Star Wars Kinect 1 2 3

I like this dude. Listen to this post.

[Kettch]

4
5
6

And ehhhhhh...

1
3
2

[Scott32020]

1 - Episode 4
2 - Episode 5
3 - Episode 6
4 - Episode 3
5 - Episode 1
6 - Episode 2

Not that sure about Episodes 1 and 2, really only seen them recently in little segments on FX/Spike TV/etc.

[mclem]

5 4 About half of 6 KOTOR The good Clone Wars cartoon X Wing vs. Tie Fighter KOTOR2 Rebel Assault Caravan of Courage Being raped by a tramp that sounds a bit like David Prowse Star Wars Kinect 1 2 3

Where's the other half of 6 end up? And, for that matter, the Star Wars Holiday Special? And the Mark Hamill/Luke Skywalker episode of The Muppet Show?

[SpoonyBard]

1 - Episode 5
2 - Episode 4
3 - Episode 6
4 - Episode 1
5 - Episode 3
6 - Episode 2

I'm not sure if 3 is less bad than 2, but Episode 1 is clearly the best of the new ones. There's at least some nice foreshadowing going on there, and Qui-Gon Jinn is pretty likeable.

[Wes]

I can't decide which thread is more ultimate.

[blame space]

Which one do I shoot?!

both of them

[Tucah]

1. V
2. IV
3. VI
4. III
5. I
6. II

Yeah, unnecessary thread, you're not going to find all that much variation in the order.

[kswiston]

I am not the biggest fan of the Star Wars Franchise, but I would say:

1)Empire Strikes Back
2) A New Hope
3) Return of the Jedi
4) Revenge of the Sith
5) Attack of the Clones
6) The Phantom Menace

[Scuba Steve]

1. EP 5
2. EP 4
3. EP 6
4. EP 5
5. EP 4
6. EP 6

[The Technomancer]

1 - Episode 5 2 - Episode 4 3 - Episode 6 4 - Episode 1 5 - Episode 3 6 - Episode 2 I'm not sure if 3 is less bad than 2, but Episode 1 is clearly the best of the new ones. There's at least some nice foreshadowing going on there, and Qui-Gon Jinn is pretty likeable.

Episode 1 is ruined for me by the kid playing Anakin. He drags that entire movie down.