• Register
  • TOS
  • Privacy
  • @NeoGAF

LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
(11-09-2012, 01:24 PM)
LiquidMetal14's Avatar
Get Jyettis in here!
Waaghals
Member
(11-09-2012, 01:24 PM)
Waaghals's Avatar

Originally Posted by crazygambit

Wait. But doesn't everyone use a modified version of the engine? I don't understand how that ends up in SK having to destroy all the code having to do with UE3.

More importantly, what does this mean for all the other licensees? Could they also be in risk of something like this? If I was licensing the engine or considering licensing it I'd be looking at this very carefully.

You don't understand. Developers are free to modify the engine, but silicon knights terminated their license agreement, and used parts of the engine anyway - without paying Epic.
zon
Member
(11-09-2012, 01:26 PM)
zon's Avatar
Good, it's no less than what they deserve.
patapuf
Member
(11-09-2012, 01:29 PM)
patapuf's Avatar

Originally Posted by crazygambit

Wait. But doesn't everyone use a modified version of the engine? I don't understand how that ends up in SK having to destroy all the code having to do with UE3.

More importantly, what does this mean for all the other licensees? Could they also be in risk of something like this? If I was licensing the engine or considering licensing it I'd be looking at this very carefully.

The key difference is that all the other licensees actually pay for the UE3 license.

SK simply modified it and pretended it was their own - without paying a dime.
Alextended
Banned
(11-09-2012, 01:32 PM)
Alextended's Avatar
...SK didn't buy a license yet sued Epic for not providing support and having the engine in a bad state? Does not compute...

Why didn't Epic sue them sooner, everyone knew that game used their engine and it became quite known (if notorious).

Edit: oh okay, so they did buy a license, then didn't renew it for other projects, but continued to use it. But didn't they still have it back when they made Too Human, why destroy that? If they didn't have it even then, as above.
Last edited by Alextended; 11-09-2012 at 01:35 PM.
Baron_Calamity
Member
(11-09-2012, 01:38 PM)
Baron_Calamity's Avatar
I'm torn. I wanted to get X-men Destiny but I didn't want to pay much beyond $5 for it since it is a terrible game I probably won't play. Do I pay more than my target price of around $5 in order to avoid collectors prices in the future or simply forget about it?
KojiKnight
Member
(11-09-2012, 01:39 PM)
KojiKnight's Avatar
Oh SK... I think you done goofed too hard... I hope you still have some hidden capital somewhere.
Slayven
gimme some o dat God-crafted alabaster greatness
(11-09-2012, 01:43 PM)
Slayven's Avatar
Unsold? Does that mean used games stores might have are not included?
IdreamofHIME
Banned
(11-09-2012, 01:46 PM)
IdreamofHIME's Avatar

Originally Posted by Slayven

Unsold? Does that mean used games stores might have are not included?


The recall will apply to sealed stock only, used games can't be included. How can the publishers refund stores for recalled stock that the publisher never even sold?
Unless they start calling up the kids who traded the games in and demand the credit back :/
Polari
(11-09-2012, 01:46 PM)
Polari's Avatar
Hilarious. I feel sorry for all the SK employees that lost their jobs as result of Denis' ego.
RoboPlato
I'd be in the dick
(11-09-2012, 01:55 PM)
RoboPlato's Avatar
LOL. This lawsuit was never going to end well for SK but this is complete ownage. Holy crap. I still can't believe they went through with it when they could only win a dollar or something.
GotEmRunnin
(11-09-2012, 01:55 PM)
GotEmRunnin's Avatar
I knew DD was close to the edge when he took on GAF defending Too Human. This has to be the last and final blow.
Mileena
Banned
(11-09-2012, 01:58 PM)
Mileena's Avatar
How long till the studio is gone? Good riddance
REMEMBER CITADEL
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:01 PM)
REMEMBER CITADEL's Avatar

Originally Posted by Alextended

...SK didn't buy a license yet sued Epic for not providing support and having the engine in a bad state? Does not compute...

Why didn't Epic sue them sooner, everyone knew that game used their engine and it became quite known (if notorious).

Edit: oh okay, so they did buy a license, then didn't renew it for other projects, but continued to use it. But didn't they still have it back when they made Too Human, why destroy that? If they didn't have it even then, as above.

I believe the contract was for multiple games (the whole Too Human trilogy and others), and SK opted out of that.
lunchwithyuzo
Banned
(11-09-2012, 02:01 PM)
So X-Men Destiny just retroactively became a Wii exclusive?
DragonSworne
Satoru Iwata and his Trilateral Commission cronies are suppressing the truth about Retro. Wake up, sheeple!
(11-09-2012, 02:02 PM)
DragonSworne's Avatar
Destroying code?

Stupid ass court siding with a big corporation instead of understanding technology.

This mandate proves the court has no clue what it doing or what is going on.
jcm
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:08 PM)
jcm's Avatar
I'm no fan of Dyack, but this is a real bummer. His ego is going to cost a bunch of people their jobs.

Originally Posted by DragonSworne

Destroying code?

Stupid ass court siding with a big corporation instead of understanding technology.

This mandate proves the court has no clue what it doing or what is going on.

What are you talking about?
Cornbread78
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:10 PM)
Cornbread78's Avatar

Originally Posted by Azure Dream

Here's a nice price for US buyers, although there's a chance they might not ship out if they get the notice soon enough.



Already fixed:

Oops! Please correct the errors below to continue.

Currently Too Human is not available for purchase and has been removed from your cart.
Big Papa Husker
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:15 PM)
Big Papa Husker's Avatar
I was going to buy a sealed copy, but realized I never opened the copy I bought on clearance at Best Buy years ago.
Dipswitch
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:25 PM)
Dipswitch's Avatar
This won't effect the development of the rest of the trilogy right guys?
Joni
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:34 PM)
Joni's Avatar

Originally Posted by DragonSworne

Destroying code?

Stupid ass court siding with a big corporation instead of understanding technology.

This mandate proves the court has no clue what it doing or what is going on.

It is siding with a company that has about 150 employees over a company that had 150 employees when it started the lawsuit. Clearly a big company that was bullying a little one.
Stumpokapow
Currently AFK. Please ask another moderator for help or support.
(11-09-2012, 02:36 PM)
Stumpokapow's Avatar

Originally Posted by MTMBStudios

Pro-tip:
DO NOT SUE EPIC GAMES

Pro-tip:
Don't launch a lawsuit against anybody when you don't have a case.
FlyinJ
Douchebag. Yes, me.
(11-09-2012, 02:40 PM)

Originally Posted by REMEMBER CITADEL

I believe the contract was for multiple games (the whole Too Human trilogy and others), and SK opted out of that.

I believe you can license the engine on a year-by-year basis, and if you ship a game there is another cost you pay Epic.

SK paid the initial fee for the engine, decided to not use it, then shipped their game with Unreal code in it without paying Epic for continued usage of their code.
legacyzero
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:42 PM)
legacyzero's Avatar
Have never deleted a demo faster than Too Human.
grumpy
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:42 PM)
grumpy's Avatar

Originally Posted by Stumpokapow

Pro-tip:
If you are a 2nd party developer, never try to leave Nintendo.

Fixed
Messofanego
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:43 PM)
Messofanego's Avatar
Good thing I didn't sell my Too Human copy! A piece of unpolished history, I tells ya!
Dyno
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:46 PM)
Dyno's Avatar
SK used Epic's code on multiple games, all the while thinking they could get away with it. There is no point in firing Dyack because SK is done. The staff has no engine they can use now and they will have to tool up and learn to use a new one.

Not worth the money.
tmarques
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:48 PM)
tmarques's Avatar

Originally Posted by The Mana Legend

All unsold copies of Too Human? Shit, better get the landfill next to ET Atari ready.

Wasn't Microsoft forcing this game down people's throats for a while via bundles? I'd be surprised if there were that many new copies floating around.

I kind of wish I hadn't unsealed mine. Not because I think it will be worth anything in the future, but I kind of miss those 6 hours or so of my life.
tmarques
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:49 PM)
tmarques's Avatar

Originally Posted by Stumpokapow

Pro-tip:
Don't launch a lawsuit against anybody when you don't have a case.

(Unless you're Apple)
Lupin the Third
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:49 PM)
Lupin the Third's Avatar

Originally Posted by jcm

I'm no fan of Dyack, but this is a real bummer. His ego is going to cost a bunch of people their jobs.

If by "a bunch" you mean like 4?

SK consists of "less than 5 people," including Dyack himself. This tidbit was posted within the last month here on GAF. Dyack's ego probably cost plenty of people their jobs long before this happened (see: internal X-Men Destiny/ED2 resources debacle).
Kazuma Kiryu
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:49 PM)
Kazuma Kiryu's Avatar
it's a bummer for all the employees, and i really loved some of their work (LoK, eternal darkness, twin snakes was okay too) but they've been a shadow of that for so long i can't say i will be truly disappointed. just get rid of dyack since the guy's an idiot and start a new studio with the rest of the folks, i'll be interested to see if they still have what it takes. hope everyone over there eventually manages to go to bigger things.
edit: holy, 4 people? wow, didn't know that.
Shining Sunshine
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:50 PM)
Shining Sunshine's Avatar

Originally Posted by Lupin the Wolf

If by "a bunch" you mean like 4?

SK consists of "less than 5 people," including Dyack himself. This tidbit was posted within the last month here on GAF.

He already costed a lot of people jobs over the past few years.
Cheerilee
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:50 PM)
Cheerilee's Avatar

Originally Posted by Stumpokapow

Pro-tip:
Don't launch a lawsuit against anybody when you don't have a case.

Whatever happened to "the customer is always right"? I'm pretty sure that used to be legally binding. Just like "possession is nine tenths of the law."

Like... if I go to McDonalds and I buy a cheeseburger, and I don't like it, then I can go back to McDonalds and demand my money back. If they don't give it to me, I can sue them. Also, I shouldn't have to hand over my half-eaten cheeseburger, I can take that cheeseburger home and "fix it" by adding more mustard, and then it's fine. Why should I give my half-eaten cheeseburger back to McDonalds? It won't do them any good. They'll just throw it in the trash. And I can use it as a base to make my new totally-original not-McDonalds cheeseburger.

Originally Posted by Dyno

SK used Epic's code on multiple games, all the while thinking they could get away with it. There is no point in firing Dyack because SK is done. The staff has no engine they can use now and they will have to tool up and learn to use a new one.

Not worth the money.

There is no staff left at SK. It's just Dyack.

http://kotaku.com/5955223/what-went-...-x+men-destiny
Oneself
Fired from EB Games
thanks to this thread!
(11-09-2012, 02:50 PM)
Oneself's Avatar
Massive Damage.
Lupin the Third
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:51 PM)
Lupin the Third's Avatar

Originally Posted by Shining Sunshine

He already costed a lot of people jobs over the past few years.

Gah, you got in before the edit.
jcm
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:52 PM)
jcm's Avatar

Originally Posted by Lupin the Wolf

If by "a bunch" you mean like 4?

SK consists of "less than 5 people," including Dyack himself. This tidbit was posted within the last month here on GAF. Dyack's ego probably cost plenty of people their jobs long before this happened (see: internal X-Men Destiny/ED2 resources debacle).

Ah, I didn't realize that. I guess I should have used the past tense. I think the death of independent console developers is a damned shame. And the environment is tough enough without trying to survive self-inflicted wounds from egomaniacs.
demigod
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:54 PM)
lol, serves them right. Trying to sue for money and end up screwing themselves.
tkscz
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:56 PM)
tkscz's Avatar
Ok, past the GameCube age and besides Too Human and X-men destiny, what else did SK even make? I mean it, I don't know anything else they made and Too Human wasn't even worth while.
Gadirok
Member
(11-09-2012, 02:56 PM)
Gadirok's Avatar

Originally Posted by Riposte

Canada should pay Epic now, it is only fair.

You kidding me? I'm going to be pretty pissed off if this comes out of taxpayers money. They gave off enough to Silicon Knights in the first place. The only reason they continued to exist on the map.

I was never really fond of either but I hope SK just goes bankrupt and the developers raise another studio.
Cheerilee
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:01 PM)
Cheerilee's Avatar

Originally Posted by Gadirok

You kidding me? I'm going to be pretty pissed off if this comes out of taxpayers money. They gave off enough to Silicon Knights in the first place. The only reason they continued to exist on the map.

I was never really fond of either but I hope SK just goes bankrupt and the developers raise another studio.

http://www.vg247.com/2012/03/31/sili...g-grant-money/

“We announced a conditional funding agreement with Silicon Knights on July 14, 2011. Because the company has not yet met the conditions of the agreement, no funding has been provided."

Dyack responded to the government’s statement, stating he was confused over such an accusation, as the development firm felt it had “met all the conditions for the grant.”

Treemonkeys
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:07 PM)
Treemonkeys's Avatar
You guys think existing copies will continue to be recognized by XBL with achievements and such? Does the game have multiplayer? I always was a little intrigued by the demo but never purchased due to all the negative word of mouth about they game, after this however I'm going to go look for a used copy.
mbmonk
Banned
(11-09-2012, 03:08 PM)
mbmonk's Avatar
So who has/gets the right to IP Too Human? MS? Epic? *I am assuming this will bankrupt the dev studio*.
KojiKnight
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:11 PM)
KojiKnight's Avatar

Originally Posted by Treemonkeys

You guys think existing copies will continue to be recognized by XBL with achievements and such? Does the game have multiplayer? I always was a little intrigued by the demo but never purchased due to all the negative word of mouth about they game, after this however I'm going to go look for a used copy.

I think under the agreement those copies will soon cease to exist (XBLA versions) and they'll get refunded at SK's expense.
Lazy Man's Wallpaper
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:16 PM)
Lazy Man's Wallpaper's Avatar
I had a copy of Too Human a few years back, never played it and sold it on eBay. It weirdly sold for like double what I thought it would. Granted, that only meant a return of about $6, but still.
tsab
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:17 PM)
tsab's Avatar
Hm, they must be developing Eternal Darkness 2 with Cryengine 3






















jk OR AM I?
Brazil
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:17 PM)
Brazil's Avatar

Originally Posted by mbmonk

So who has/gets the right to IP Too Human? MS? Epic? *I am assuming this will bankrupt the dev studio*.

The forgotten attic storage room.
DAKing240
Junior Member
(11-09-2012, 03:24 PM)
Too Human is still being sold on Xbox.com. I wonder how fast they pull it:

http://marketplace.xbox.com/en-US/Pr...5-d8024d5307de
Xenon
Here's your chocolate,
can we **** now?
(11-09-2012, 03:24 PM)
Xenon's Avatar

Originally Posted by Waaghals

You don't understand. Developers are free to modify the engine, but silicon knights terminated their license agreement, and used parts of the engine anyway - without paying Epic.

There was also the fact that removed Epic's copyright information from the code and did not credit Epic via a little splash screen at the start of the game which were probably clearly defined in the contract they signed.

I think morally SK had a very valid issue. Being a game-developer and licensing a game engine is a huge conflict of interest. It basically puts them in direct competition with their customers. The fact that they released their first game without the same issues most of the other developers had shows that SK had a valid case. Had Denis stuck with the U3 or actually created their own engine he may have had a leg to stand on. But like everything else he has done, while he may have a point, he goes about acting on it in completely the wrong way.


The sad thing is had SK not sued Epic, I don't think they would have pursued any legal action against Silicon Knights. Now their hand is almost forced to make an example out of them.
tmarques
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:25 PM)
tmarques's Avatar
So how long until Dyack hits Kickstarter?
Zaraki_Kenpachi
Member
(11-09-2012, 03:28 PM)
Zaraki_Kenpachi's Avatar
Are any of those games even good? I've only heard of too human.

Edit: Most don't even exist yet, that's why I never heard of them.
Last edited by Zaraki_Kenpachi; 11-09-2012 at 03:32 PM.

Thread Tools