Originally Posted by A Huge Battleship
Well, the day after tomorrow then.
I'm very glad I played The Witch's House after Mad Father and Ib, because I prefer saving the best for last when possible, and it was easily the most frightening, the most affecting and the overall most enjoyable of the trio. I knew I was in for a treat when I stepped on a smear of blood in the first room and was promptly made paper thin, but even so, I wouldn't have predicted just how much I'd end up enjoying it.
I think the main reason I preferred it to the other two was because it kept me strongly on edge practically from start to finish. The sudden and shocking deaths in the early rooms instilled a fear in me that the house nurtured throughout the game, making me feel like the 'Game Over' screen was never more than a few seconds away regardless of where I was. It also had my favourite endgame; the final chase section made for an excellent climax, with my brain desperately trying to recall the way out and the house doing what it could to impede my escape.
The scariest moment for me was probably when I picked up the wristwatch underneath the desk in the dark passageway (I was fairly certain it was a bad idea, but I wanted to try everything out), went into the item menu to examine it and saw Viola's HOLY SHIT character portrait. I was already on edge from walking around in that passageway but then I just totally lost it.
I got the normal ending the first time around (not that my mind had much say in the matter), but I remembered reading here that the ending was supposedly very upsetting so I figured I'd missed something. Then I went back and got the true ending.
Yeah.
I said in my previous post that I usually preferred warped endings, but... no, even I couldn't enjoy that. The twist had my jaw hanging open, and watching 'Viola' call out to her father only to be rewarded with a hole in her skull almost had me in tears. Unusual reaction for me considering I'd barely invested 90 minutes into the game, but I think it's testament to the impact it had on my mentality.
I know it's only February, but I suspect this will be one of my favourite games I play this year. Overall rating: 5 grinning skulls out of 5.
I really enjoyed Witch's House as well. It definitely out of the recent RPG Maker horror games put me on edge the most and managed to scare me the most (pretty good atmosphere, you never feel safe), and has a good assortment of puzzle/survival adventure gameplay, interesting setting, and of course, unexpected but fun death scenes.
And of course, the rather well done and surprisingly impacting twist in the true ending. I almost shed a tear the first time too, they did a great job at foreshadowing it but not making it obvious so its surprising.
There is a third ending, but its just an expansion of the true ending with a bit more explained. To get that ending, beat the game without saving or talking to the cat once.