• Register
  • TOS
  • Privacy
  • @NeoGAF

DieH@rd
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:18 AM)
DieH@rd's Avatar
I think that this detailed translation of Mark Cerny's interview with japanese press deserves its own thread. It touched creation of PS4, difficulties of letting PS3 BC go, customizations of off-the-shelf PC hardware, and much more. Full kudos goes to gaffer rykomatsu who translated all this. Here it goes:


Part 1:

Focusing on the “positive aspects” and Moving to the x86 Architecture
Cerney states that he started thinking about a “next generation console” in Fall 2007. SCE should have gone into basic R&D regarding next gen technologies soon after PS3’s release and this falls in-line with when Cerney started investigating.

Cerny: I had started discussions regarding the next generation following PS3 in 2007. At that time, I was investigating what should be done for next generation [technologies]. It was at that time, I wondered if we couldn’t use the x86 architecture for the next generation. I used then entirety of Thanksgiving weekend looking into this (lol). For Americans, this holiday is extremely important. But, that’s how I sacrificed (lol) the holidays to think about the future and what possibilities this might bring for our organization.

After that, I went to Phil Harrison since he was at the top of the game development division. I was also introduced to Masayuki Chatani who was SCE’s CTO at that time and was directing the next-gen project. What was surprising was that he said “yes” to me being involved with the next generation console.

By moving to the x86 architecture, this also means losing backwards compatibility with PS3. The basis of Cerney’s vision was to use this x86 architecture. This is a huge tradeoff, but SCE accepted this vision.

Cerny: We struggled with this point. As a matter of fact, this was the major point I thought about during Thanksgiving. What to do with the current CPU and x86…

We decided to focus on the “positive aspects” rising from switching to x86. X86 has instruction sets which are of significant importance for games. Multimedia instruction sets, specifically the existence of SSE 4.1 and 4.2. And of course, the existence of an APU gives us the ability to come close to the results obtained from the SPU.

The decision to move to x86 had an extremely complex set of requirements. Of course there’s issues of backwards compatibility and issues from the vendor’s side as well. But that said, I believe the biggest topic for us was how much affinity the developers would have for this change. In the past 3 years, there have been a large number of refined tools and technologies released for the x86 architecture. If another architecture had been selected, it probably would have been even more problematic. The x86 architecture is well known and development is relatively easy.

Ito: Backwards compatibility, particularly in Japan, is something that is strongly brought frequently, so we thought long and hard about this. Realistically, to support backwards compatibility with PS3, the CELL Broadband Engine would have needed to been part of the new console. Currently, it’s not possible to simulate this via software. If CELL were the only requirement, that wouldn’t have been much of an issue. We would also need to support the supporting hardware indefinitely. We can freely manufacture CELL if the decision is made that it is needed. However, that’s not the case with supporting hardware. There are parts which will become difficult to obtain since 7 years is already considered to be long in the IT industry…

Using this opportunity, we decided to stop going down this path, and as Mark said, to focus our efforts on simplifying developer efforts.

Essentially, SCE’s thinking was that when considering focusing on sustaining and maintaining PS3 (and prior) hardware long-term, they also saw the need to transition to a “more ordinary” platform. It can be interpreted that x86 offered easier development opportunities and also provided for a way to get away from a “proprietary” track, leading to this decision.
Now, SCE hasn’t come to a conclusion regarding the BC problem. It’s said that use of Cloud long-term is part of their vision, but more accurately, SCE is evaluating various content in various forms including sustaining BC.


GPU Customization with use of GPGPU in Mind. Difference in Launch Title Numbers
Use of the x86 architecture also means externally, it becomes difficult to see the difference between PC development. How does Cerney think about how to showcase the difference and value of PS4?

Cerny: Our primary target is to provide a powerful system that developers are familiar with. It goes without saying an x86 CPU has high familiarity. From a power perspective, and providing new possibilities, it will become more important to realize technologies benefiting from a GPU. GPUs increase graphics performance and have been used in that manner traditionally. But, the computing capabilities of GPU will be harnessed in various areas in manners we can’t even begin to think of now.

This essentially means, [PS4] will be a console that not only focuses on CPU performance, but also on GPU performance…essentially a realization of a console using a GPGPU. In fact, at the PS4 press conference, a physics demo using the GPGPU was shown, and PS4 has an added value proposition of having a high performance GPGPU as a core feature set of the platform. For that purpose, the PS3 CPU and GPU has a few proprietary tricks up its sleeve.

Cerny: The GPGPU for us is a feature that is of utmost importance. For that purpose, we’ve customized the existing technologies in many ways.

Just as an example…when the CPU and GPU exchange information in a generic PC, the CPU inputs information, and the GPU needs to read the information and clear the cache, initially. When returning the results, the GPU needs to clear the cache, then return the result to the CPU. We’ve created a cache bypass. The GPU can return the result using this bypass directly. By using this design, we can send data directly from the main memory to the GPU shader core. Essentially, we can bypass the GPU L1 and L2 cache. Of course, this isn’t just for data read, but also for write. Because of this, we have an extremely high bandwidth of 10GB/sec.

Also, we’ve also added a little tag to the L2 cache. We call this the VOLATILE tag. We are able to control data in the cache based on whether the data is marked with VOLATILE or not. If this tag is used, this data can be written directly to the memory. As a result, the entirety of the cache can be used efficiently for graphics processing.

This function allows for harmonization of graphics processing and computing, and allows for efficient function of both. Essentially “Harmony” in Japanese. We’re trying to replicate the SPU Runtime System (SPURS) of the PS3 by heavily customizing the cache and bus. SPURS is designed to virtualize and independently manage SPU resources. For the PS4 hardware, the GPU can also be used in an analogous manner as x86-64 to use resources at various levels. This idea has 8 pipes and each pipe(?) has 8 computation queues. Each queue can execute things such as physics computation middle ware, and other prioprietarily designed workflows. This, while simultaneously handling graphics processing.

This type of functionality isn’t used widely in the launch titles. However, I expect this to be used widely in many games throughout the life of the console and see this becoming an extremely important feature.








Note: I took out most of the commentary....

Part 2

GPU Customization with use of GPGPU in Mind. Difference in Launch Title Numbers (cont’d)
Cerney: In the next few years, we’ll also be supporting a different approach

We have our own shader APIs, but in the future, we’ll provide functions which will allow deeper access to the hardware level and it will be possible to directly control hardware using the shader APIs. As a mid-term target, in addition to common PC APIs such as OpenGL and DirectX, we’ll provide full access to our hardware.

Regarding the CPU, we can use well known hardware, and regarding the GPU, as developers devote time to it, new possibilities which weren’t possible before will open up.

The properties of CPU and GPU are quite difference, so in the current stage, if you were to use an unified architecture such as HSA, it will be difficult to efficiently use the CPU and GPU. However, once the CPU and GPU are able to use the same APIs, development efficiency should increase exponentially. This will be rather huge. Thus, we expect to see this as somewhat of a long-term goal.

Regarding easier development, talking about the action game KNACK

Cerny: I’ve spoken with a lot of developers, but most of the developers are saying that creating a game is considerably easier.

Working on a game myself, I feel that is true. KNACK is still in development, but the PS4, compared to the PS3, really makes game development easy.

This will also lead to the main difference with the PS3 era. The main difference is, we will have many titles for launch. Because game development is easier, there shouldn’t be a barrier as there had been previously. PS3 had the image that it was difficult to develop for. Even the PS2 wasn’t that easy. PS4 has a PC CPU and a GPU that’s been enhanced from a PC so the game lineup should become very rich.

The most important difference is, it won’t take as much technical training, so developers can focus more on the game-play aspects. That’s ideal isn’t it? As a result, [gamers] should a world with a richer gaming experience.
Regarding 4KTV, he is a little passive

Cerny: hm…(lol). Personally, I’m very interested in 4K

We’re still in the initial stages of supporting 4Kx2K in games. Our focus is to provide for a solid FullHD experience. We can secure the display buffer for Game and OS separately, and can provide for independent scaling of both as well. (Regarding 4K) We can provide an extremely smooth user interface.

If we consider purely memory bandwidth, with 4K, securing 2 displays worth of display buffer requires 10GB/sec. That just for simply displaying.
This is our simple answer for why we’re focusing on just the FullHD experience.

PS4 will read CDs, but will not play back audio CD music.

Realizing Energy Efficiency and Smoothness using a Second Custom Chip with Embedded CPU
Cerny: The second custom chip is essentially the Southbridge. However, this also has an embedded CPU. This will always be powered, and even when the PS4 is powered off, it is monitoring all IO systems. The embedded CPU and Southbridge manages download processes and all HDD access. Of course, even with the power off.

Ito: The second custom chip also takes into consideration environmental problems. For background downloading, if the main CPU needs to be started every time, energy consumption increases significantly, so we run this with the second chip. Particularly in Europe, there are strict energy consumption regulations, so handling consumption in this manner is also one of our goals.

Cerny: There’s also network bandwidth considerations. Background downloading allows for smooth downloading of large files even when bandwidth is limited.

More importantly, this helps reduce the time required until a game can be played. Simultaneously, this also allows for decreased initial downloads. Only the first few GB are downloaded during the initial play session and while the game is being played, the remaining portions will be downloaded. Of course, even with the power off, the remaining download will continue. So, the primary goal is to decrease the amount of download time before initial play.

Cerney: The data is logically divided into a few chunks, and uploaded [to the server by the dev?] with a specially annotated script. Further, based on how the script is written, additional customization is possible. For example, downloading of single player portion or multiplayer portion first…Related to this…system memory has increased by 16x since PS3, but the BD drive transfer speed has only increased a few fold. Because of this, using a similar technique, it’s possible to copy just the important parts from the BD to the HDD and start the game. By doing this, it’s possible to load directly more smoothly from the faster HDD. Of course, it’s possible to stream the data from a ginormous BD and play a game as well.










Note:Commentary removed again...getting late so sorry for typos
Part 3 (last one)


Built-In Video Encoder for Video Sharing and Vita Remote-Play
Cerny: The PS4 has a dedicated encoder for video sharing and such. There are a few dedicated encoder and decoder functions which are available and use the APU minimally. This is also used for playback of compressed in-game audio in MP3 and audio chat.

When the system is fully on, the x86 CPU core controls the video sharing system. However the Southbridge has features to assist with network traffic control.

Cerny: While investigating the initial hardware design, we had been thinking about what aspects will become important in the future. All hardware components have been prepared with enveloping the gamer with a realizing a wonderful user experience.

Our team thought deeply of the concept of “computer entertainment”. People from other Sony groups participated and we investigated this from many different angles. Since we are the “game” people, we have UI specialists, and Richard Marcks(sp?) (father of SCE’s Natural UI design)was involved as well. This multi-facetted team spent a few weeks discussing how amazing of a user-experience we could realize.

So, how does this affect games?

Ito: For example, even without a PS4, this time, we can use the PlayStation App to see game details (content?). Even without a PS4, you would be able to experience “man, this game looks fun” or “this game might be pretty good”. And with this, it is our hopes that the allure of the PS4 will be evident.
Of course, if a gamer shares images on Facebook, you can see this from Facebook without the PlayStation App.

Regarding Vita Remote-Play

Cerney: Vita Remote Play is special.
Smartphones and Tablets are used to see game information regarding the PS4 in various places, experienced in various places. In addition to this, this type of content can be seen on the PC as well using a web platform.

PS4 has video encoding hardware, and this is used with Video [Miracast?-type] feature. Vita’s control inputs are sent to the PS3, and using these functionalities, with minimal overhead and no pain, it becomes possible to remotely play PS4 games. Atleast, this is what we’re aiming for, and compared to the PS3 era, we’re aiming for a significantly wider support of remote play. Of course, this function applies to games using Dualshock. Games that use the camera (such as PS Move and PS4 location recognition) cannot utilize remoteplay.
Leaving that aside, Vita’s remote play was developed to provide as close to perfect PS4 gameplay within a household as possible. This requires connection to a Wifi network and should be used in a low latency environment. The thinking here is also that even if someone else is using the TV, you can continue playing PS4 games.

Use of Real Names for Gaming without Walls, Use of a BSD base for a Rich OS Layer
Cerny: We’re investigating using the network to switch control between players. Just keep in mind, this doesn’t mean these types of features will all be present on Day 1. Please understand that we’re preparing and investigating these as features supportable on the platform.
Either which way, use of social interactions to stimulate gameplay should become a huge weapon in our arsenal.

Just my image of things but…think of it like being in a living room. When you’re playing a game with your friends, there’s no physical wall to prevent interaction. It’s kind of like having hundreds of friends gaming with you nearby, but this feeling while you’re sitting at the end of a network. We want to act as the facilitators to enable this; to enable the feeling of actually meeting and enjoying gaming with your real world friends around the world. Over the course of a few years, we’ll support all the features required to support and achieve this goal.
For this purpose, PS4’s OS layer is very rich compared to PS3 or Vita

Cerney: The OS is based on BSD. I believe this is the first game console using this architecture.
From the OS side, the PS4 will allow use of many multiple features simultaneously. Our goal is something like the following:

Send a video of the game you’re playing, and return to the game immediately to continue playing. Then, watch a game play video from your friend, then switch to video chat with that friend right away. If you see interesting DLC that your friend has, move to the store, then be able to ask your friend if it’s the right one.
In this manner, we envision it to be possible to come-and-go between and use many features. Even for multi-player games, you would be able to move the game to the background without quitting, and go through a similar routine.


The facilitation by the OS will allow for a rich set of actions.

Regarding the “real name” policy

Cerny: The concept of aliases for online games is the current paradigm. For example, in a multiplayer deathmatch, it’s better to have an alias, right? However, when coop aspects or communications leveraging social interactions are brought into the game, it’s better not to have an alias. For example, let’s say you gift an item you earn in a game to a friend. That type of interaction should evoke a completely different feeling than when you’re playing the game.

Of course, we respect the desire to use an alias for game play as well. We support that type of gaming too. Having a deathmatch using aliases is possible on the PS4 as well. But at the same time, we want to support aspects which increase the fun of gaming with real world friends. For example, wouldn’t it be wonderful to meet a college friend you haven’t seen in ages?

Cheers :)
Last edited by DieH@rd; 07-17-2013 at 11:43 AM.
Psycho_Mantis
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:19 AM)
Psycho_Mantis's Avatar
I am so glad Cerny is finally getting the recognition he deserves.
IonicSnake
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:20 AM)
IonicSnake's Avatar
Thanks for the translation, really interesting read.
stryke
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:20 AM)
stryke's Avatar

Originally Posted by DieH@rd

Full kudos goes to gaffer rykomatsu who translated all this.

Agreed. Good to read a more in depth, coherent passage on the design philosophies behind the PS4.

Thanks rykomatsu.
maverick40
Junior Member
(03-30-2013, 11:21 AM)
maverick40's Avatar
Thank you for this thread, cerny is a fascinating man
Canis lupus
Junior Member
(03-30-2013, 11:27 AM)
Canis lupus's Avatar
OS is based on BSD, what to think of it?
RyoonZ
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:27 AM)
RyoonZ's Avatar
Thanks for the translation rykomatsu!

Originally Posted by Cerny

This will also lead to the main difference with the PS3 era. The main difference is, we will have many titles for launch. Because game development is easier, there shouldn’t be a barrier as there had been previously. PS3 had the image that it was difficult to develop for. Even the PS2 wasn’t that easy. PS4 has a PC CPU and a GPU that’s been enhanced from a PC so the game lineup should become very rich.

Can't wait for E3!!!
Corto
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:36 AM)
Corto's Avatar
Great read. Thanks for all the work translating Rykomatsu!

Originally Posted by Canis lupus

OS is based on BSD, what to think of it?

It's nice. It's a strong mature (decades of development) kernel that enables multitasking and proprietary customization (ie. Apple OS X is BSD based also)
Last edited by Corto; 03-30-2013 at 11:44 AM.
Risette
A Good Citizen
(03-30-2013, 11:43 AM)
Risette's Avatar

Originally Posted by Canis lupus

OS is based on BSD, what to think of it?

Good.
Konosuke
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:46 AM)
I hope that Mark Cerny can become the Adrian Newey of Console gaming. The network stuff really exciting.
JJD
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:48 AM)
JJD's Avatar
Wow!!!

Thanks for the great work rykomatsu and DieH@rd! You guys rock!
Man
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:52 AM)
Man's Avatar

Originally Posted by Canis lupus

OS is based on BSD, what to think of it?


'...but one day... I got in.'
The PS4 has the utmost elegant hardware architecture powering the ever classical computer kernel that's the basis for all OS teachings.
DieH@rd
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:53 AM)
DieH@rd's Avatar
I was really surprised when Cerny said that secondary OS chip is located in the Southbridge. That's very interesting.
BrokenEchelon
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:54 AM)
BrokenEchelon's Avatar
21st Century Cerny > 21st century Carmack

And yeah, many thanks for the translation effort.
ricen-beans
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:55 AM)
ricen-beans's Avatar
Great work guys!

So considering PS4 will have x86 architecture which is more aligned to PC development, how easy would it be to "transfer" some current PC games to ps4?

Witcher 2
Bioshock infinite
Tomb Raider

These are just examples of games that look great on PC now, better than current console counterparts, and I'd imagine would run on "max settings" on PS4.

Or am I completely off base?....
BrokenEchelon
Member
(03-30-2013, 11:57 AM)
BrokenEchelon's Avatar

Originally Posted by ricen-beans

Great work guys!

So considering PS4 will have x86 architecture which is more aligned to PC development, how easy would it be to "transfer" some current PC games to ps4?

Witcher 2
Bioshock infinite
Tomb Raider

These are just examples of games that look great on PC now, better than current console counterparts, and I'd imagine would run on "max settings" on PS4.

Or am I completely off base?....

It shouldn't be very difficult at all, but probably wouldn't make a lot of business sense for most titles if they're just reselling them with the proverbial graphics settings on "high".
planetsmasherx1
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:02 PM)
planetsmasherx1's Avatar
The most ridiculous thing in this interview is the following, but by no means in any way a dealbreaker.

"PS4 will read CDs, but will not play back audio CD music."

So no custom soundtracks?
ricen-beans
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:02 PM)
ricen-beans's Avatar

Originally Posted by BrokenEchelon

It shouldn't be very difficult at all, but probably wouldn't make a lot of business sense for most titles if they're just reselling them with the proverbial graphics settings on "high".

I see. I was thinking of it almost as a replacement for backwards compatability. It'd be nice to still play games coming out for PS3 in an "upgraded" fashion on PS4.
Thorgal
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:07 PM)
Thorgal's Avatar

This will also lead to the main difference with the PS3 era. The main difference is, we will have many titles for launch. Because game development is easier, there shouldn’t be a barrier as there had been previously. PS3 had the image that it was difficult to develop for. Even the PS2 wasn’t that easy. PS4 has a PC CPU and a GPU that’s been enhanced from a PC so the game lineup should become very rich.

LOAD THOSE MEGATON BOMBS!!!



MY BODY IS READY !!!!
Last edited by Thorgal; 03-30-2013 at 12:12 PM.
Respawn
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:09 PM)
Respawn's Avatar
Such a lovely technical read. Thank you for the translation.
Man
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:11 PM)
Man's Avatar
If Killzone SF, Driveclub, inFamous SS, BF4 and Watch_Dogs are all launch titles like rumored than that's already the best release lineup ever deviced. I'm buying all of these.
Respawn
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:11 PM)
Respawn's Avatar

Originally Posted by planetsmasherx1

The most ridiculous thing in this interview is the following, but by no means in any way a dealbreaker.



So no custom soundtracks?

Reading not playing. So you should be able to rip.
BrokenEchelon
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:14 PM)
BrokenEchelon's Avatar

Originally Posted by ricen-beans

I see. I was thinking of it almost as a replacement for backwards compatability. It'd be nice to still play games coming out for PS3 in an "upgraded" fashion on PS4.

I'm sure we'll see some sort of "HD" collections pop up for next-gen at some point down the line.
gofreak
GAF's Bob Woodward
(03-30-2013, 12:18 PM)
gofreak's Avatar

Originally Posted by Respawn

Reading not playing. So you should be able to rip.

Not to mention there's many other sources of music for custom bgm. I mean, obviously vita doesn't play CDs, but does allow custom bgm.
Tricky I Shadow
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:20 PM)
Tricky I Shadow's Avatar
Nothing on Shenmue III! ;_;
Usobuko
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:20 PM)
Usobuko's Avatar

Originally Posted by Man

If Killzone SF, Driveclub, inFamous SS, BF4 and Watch_Dogs are all launch titles like rumored than that's already the best release lineup ever deviced. I'm buying all of these.

Knack? That's one of the few title I'm remotely interested in. While I am not the biggest fan, I think Naughty Dog/Sony Santa Monica will have a game ready at launch or during the launch window. Also, I doubt Sony is going to just offer these since they would also have to appeal to the home crowd in Japan as well. Just another FF and possibly Knack would not be sufficient, but that is something we all have to see in future.
Perkel
Banned
(03-30-2013, 12:25 PM)

Originally Posted by Usobuko

Knack? That's one of the few title I'm remotely interested in. While I am not the biggest fan, I think Naughty Dog/Sony Santa Monica will have a game ready at launch or during the launch window. Also, I doubt Sony is going to just offer these since they would also have to appeal to the home crowd in Japan as well. Just another FF and possibly Knack would not be sufficient, but that is something we all have to see in future.


Knack is definitely on my list. Halfway this generation i stopped playing action games like FPS and started to play more non mainstream genres.
wapplew
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:36 PM)
wapplew's Avatar

Originally Posted by Usobuko

Knack? That's one of the few title I'm remotely interested in. While I am not the biggest fan, I think Naughty Dog/Sony Santa Monica will have a game ready at launch or during the launch window. Also, I doubt Sony is going to just offer these since they would also have to appeal to the home crowd in Japan as well. Just another FF and possibly Knack would not be sufficient, but that is something we all have to see in future.

Ya, Knack is interesting . I hope dev devote on gameplay detail next gen. Bring on some fresh game play experiences. We've got enough cinematic set piece visual feast this gen, i hope next gen won't repeat it all over.
One thing I like about nintendo is how much they pay attention to those little game play details. They don't have to waste alot of time on story, writing, facial expression, mo-cap, emotion stuff. Please focus on bringing fun and entertaining game play next gen.
immortal-joe
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:43 PM)
immortal-joe's Avatar
Devil's advocate mode:


(snip)

We have our own shader APIs, but in the future, we’ll provide functions which will allow deeper access to the hardware level and it will be possible to directly control hardware using the shader APIs. As a mid-term target, in addition to common PC APIs such as OpenGL and DirectX, we’ll provide full access to our hardware.


(snip)

PS4 has video encoding hardware, and this is used with Video [Miracast?-type] feature. Vita’s control inputs are sent to the PS3, and using these functionalities, with minimal overhead and no pain, it becomes possible to remotely play PS4 games. Atleast, this is what we’re aiming for, and compared to the PS3 era, we’re aiming for a significantly wider support of remote play.

(snip)

We’re investigating using the network to switch control between players. Just keep in mind, this doesn’t mean these types of features will all be present on Day 1. Please understand that we’re preparing and investigating these as features supportable on the platform.

(snip)

Just my image of things but…think of it like being in a living room. When you’re playing a game with your friends, there’s no physical wall to prevent interaction. It’s kind of like having hundreds of friends gaming with you nearby, but this feeling while you’re sitting at the end of a network. We want to act as the facilitators to enable this; to enable the feeling of actually meeting and enjoying gaming with your real world friends around the world. Over the course of a few years, we’ll support all the features required to support and achieve this goal.


This sort of language right here is what scares me. Please don't under-deliver, please!

Also, him not even bringing up Gaikai when asked about BC certainly does not convey any confidence about their "dream" to ultimately use it as an all around BC solution, as mentioned in the reveal event.
grimshawish
Banned
(03-30-2013, 12:46 PM)
If the online features are not like Sony suggested I will be damn well let down.
gofreak
GAF's Bob Woodward
(03-30-2013, 12:48 PM)
gofreak's Avatar
There's two consumer facing features being talked about there. I think Vita remote play will be there day one (although whether it'll be in ALL games or MOST games or SOME games I think is a bit wishy-washy). I think 'taking over another player's session remotely' won't be, will be a later feature. That was fairly clear anyway from David Perry's talk in the Feb reveal.
Auto_aim1
MeisaMcCaffrey
(03-30-2013, 12:51 PM)
Auto_aim1's Avatar
So if I'm reading this right, they are trying to replicate the SPU Runtime System of the PS3 on PS4, so that custom tasks can be executed faster without affecting the graphics processing. Or does that mean something else?
Guymelef
Member
(03-30-2013, 12:52 PM)
Guymelef's Avatar

Originally Posted by planetsmasherx1

The most ridiculous thing in this interview is the following, but by no means in any way a dealbreaker.



So no custom soundtracks?

Do you know about MP3?
JJD
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:00 PM)
JJD's Avatar
Could some one explain the advantages of BSD based PS4 OS?
Metalmurphy
Banned
(03-30-2013, 01:00 PM)
Metalmurphy's Avatar

Originally Posted by immortal-joe

Devil's advocate mode:

This sort of language right here is what scares me. Please don't under-deliver, please!

Also, him not even bringing up Gaikai when asked about BC certainly does not convey any confidence about their "dream" to ultimately use it as an all around BC solution, as mentioned in the reveal event.

He did mention, but he called it just cloud gaming.
Man
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:05 PM)
Man's Avatar

Originally Posted by JJD

Could some one explain the advantages of BSD based PS4 OS?

Very low memory footprint.
Tried and tested for the last 3.5 decades.
Basically all OS teachings use BSD Unix as its base (Apple OS X, Linux are based on it).
dragonbane
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:28 PM)
dragonbane's Avatar

Originally Posted by Cerny

This type of functionality isn’t used widely in the launch titles. However, I expect this to be used widely in many games throughout the life of the console and see this becoming an extremely important feature.

I hope all the people who said that we have already seen everything the PS4 can do graphics wise are prepared to eat crow.
DieH@rd
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:30 PM)
DieH@rd's Avatar
They aim to prolong the life of PS4 by delaying the deployment of lowlevel APIs. Interesting tactics.
JJD
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:33 PM)
JJD's Avatar

Originally Posted by Man

Very low memory footprint.
Tried and tested for the last 3.5 decades.
Basically all OS teachings use BSD Unix as its base (Apple OS X, Linux are based on it).

That is great! Specially the bolded.

Thanks for clearing that friend!
Valnen
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:34 PM)
Valnen's Avatar

Originally Posted by DieH@rd

They aim to prolong the life of PS4 by delaying the deployment of lowlevel APIs. Interesting tactics.

Not liking that, they should be providing full access from the start.

And hopefully by full HD experience he means most/all games at 1920x1080 and nothing less.
Quasar
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:34 PM)
Quasar's Avatar
I wonder what components they were referring to regarding BC. The RSX? or some other chips?
Quasar
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:35 PM)
Quasar's Avatar

Originally Posted by DieH@rd

They aim to prolong the life of PS4 by delaying the deployment of lowlevel APIs. Interesting tactics.

What I wonder about is the allowing of low level access. Won't that lead to BC issues again next time?
JB1981
I am full of shit.
Rich, smooth, creamy shit.
(03-30-2013, 01:39 PM)
The GPGPU stuff sounds interesting
HollovVpo1nt
Banned
(03-30-2013, 01:41 PM)
HollovVpo1nt's Avatar
Mark Cerney reminds me of Xfactor's chicken factory guy, slimmed down

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rm9jBH7ufRU
HolyBaikal
Japanese Culture Expert
(03-30-2013, 01:52 PM)
HolyBaikal's Avatar
I really, really dislike a lack of backwards compatibility. And I think it stopped a lot of hype for systems like the PlayStation 3. People were extremely disheartened by a lack of ecosystem between various Sony hardware. And it will get even more extreme with this generation.

On the other hand, I think, for once, it was worth it. Moving to x86 is worth sacrificing x86. I hope we can ditch Power architecture, with the Wii U being the last console using it. I know that Power architecture has done some amazing things like the Blue Gene supercomputer and is doing amazing things in moving towards a world where whole brain emulation is possible.

But it is still pretty obscure architecture. And perhaps even IBM support for it will significantly wane. I cannot imagine too many more blue gene projects or feasible uses for carrying on the Power torch. We don't have MOS microprocessors anymore, and I don't have a much more hopeful outlook for Power. Today the microprocessor industry is overwhelmingly about x86 and ARM. In fact that would make ARM the only thing really carrying on the RISC torch strongly right now.

In multiple fields, x86 is just the best bet. And it would be best if libraries of software for Power architecture were all brought to x86. So I wholly, totally support this move.
Last edited by HolyBaikal; 03-30-2013 at 01:54 PM.
Perkel
Banned
(03-30-2013, 01:53 PM)

Originally Posted by DieH@rd

They aim to prolong the life of PS4 by delaying the deployment of lowlevel APIs. Interesting tactics.

That is not what he said. He said that they just want to have API in place day1 and from there they will go down even deeper to metal.

PS3 on other had terrible API at start.
Kun Aguero
Member
(03-30-2013, 01:56 PM)
Kun Aguero's Avatar
Thanks OP, that was a very informative read.
Ivan
Member
(03-30-2013, 02:01 PM)
Ivan's Avatar
DieH@rd always delivers. And thanx rykomatsu for translation, too. Great read.
HolyBaikal
Japanese Culture Expert
(03-30-2013, 02:02 PM)
HolyBaikal's Avatar

Originally Posted by pizzaroll

Good.

Isn't that normal, though?

If I'm not mistaken, weren't the operating system of both the PlayStation 3 and PS Vita BSD based?
SniperHunter
Member
(03-30-2013, 02:03 PM)
SniperHunter's Avatar

Originally Posted by JB1981

The GPGPU stuff sounds interesting

indeed it also means, the second wave of titles will blow the launch games away :D

Thread Tools