Support NeoGAF

Chamber · Oct 25, 2013

Speedy Blue Dude said:
Maybe the surprise is Xbox One runs at 900p as well. He's a professional in the gaming industry who posts in a community filled with hardcore gamers in the known, expecting the PS4 to be MUCH, MUCH, better than Xbox One. It wouldn't be a surprise to the community if it was. The only surprise would be basically similar resolution and detail (with Xbox One maybe falling behind in the detail department slightly) or Xbox One being superior (unlikely).

Quick! Someone give me more straws!

Didn't DICE already say they were aiming for the same resolution on both platforms? At this point I'm expecting 900p on both consoles. And then we can have the always fun forced parity discussion.

gaming_noob · Oct 25, 2013

Chamber said:
Did the definition of confirmed change recently?

Yes

DeadManWalking · Oct 25, 2013

This will be interesting.

kikonawa · Oct 25, 2013

what if Xbone looks better then the ps4 version?

filepicker%2FVLhdKYnbSqM3pcdxFyPe_if_you_know_what_i_mean.jpg

Nags · Oct 25, 2013

Single player footage versus MP footage...

This is not how you do a comparison.

theviolenthero · Oct 25, 2013

SP footage will ALWAYS look better than MP footage.
We won't be able to fully say which one looks better until we have SP & MP direct feed footage from BOTH systems.

Raist · Oct 25, 2013

SP vs MP? Heh.

Wouldn't surprise me if BF4's res (regardless of platforms) is lower for MP considering the 64p thing.

CassidyIzABeast · Oct 25, 2013

Unless Jack is one of the lucky few to be oblivious to the spec war that's been going on over the past 5 months there shouldn't be any surprises.

def sim · Oct 25, 2013

This is probably more boring than he says. I'm guessing the PS4 will have the higher resolution and so the better image quality. Assets and effects could be the same.

It's too bad the comparison is between campaign and multiplayer.

tkalamba · Oct 25, 2013

SniperHunter said:
So true..
Mp vs sp how lame. Why no mp footage from xbone ver? Very strange

Could be servers aren't up for the X1 version yet, the PS4 is closer to release technically.

DBT85 · Oct 25, 2013

Surprised would be a) Xbone looks better or b) the difference is large.

Going with B.

IN&OUT · Oct 25, 2013

UNCMark said:
Do us all a favor and grow the fuck up.

Seriously, I feel sorry for some of you just getting pumped and start speculating for the 19847663 time to finally get crushed . it happened in NFSR thread, Ryse, COD, NBA14K and now BF thread. X1 will never ever output a single multiplat that perform better than PS4 NEVER*. Specs are laid down 4 months ago, we have discussed this to death. it's just impossible.

* unless devs intentionally force parity or f**ck up PS4 version

FTF · Oct 25, 2013

Comparing/showing the multiplayer of one to the single player of another makes no sense.

ypo · Oct 25, 2013

They are just trying to lessen the damage by only showing the SP mode for the Xbone. Pretty lame.

Revolutionary · Oct 25, 2013

Surprise, SP footage looks better than MP footage! Oh wait, thats not a surprise at all.

CassidyIzABeast · Oct 25, 2013

SniperHunter said:
So true..
Mp vs sp how lame. Why no mp footage from xbone ver? Very strange

That happens on the Nov. 1st

Shaddy · Oct 25, 2013

Bunta said:
You've got those mixed up.

You're right.

tkalamba · Oct 25, 2013

FTF said:
Comparing/showing the multiplayer of one to the single player of another makes no sense.

He isn't comparing though, he's showing two separate videos

ced · Oct 25, 2013

FTF said:
Comparing/showing the multiplayer of one to the single player of another makes no sense.

It does if there is an agenda.

potam · Oct 25, 2013

#teamps4multipayerlooksbetterthanxb1singleplayer

Snaku · Oct 25, 2013

DBT85 said:
Surprised would be a) Xbone looks better or b) the difference is large.

Going with B.

It's COD, I wouldn't bet on either version being a real looker.

Marvel · Oct 25, 2013

So no XB1 MP footage to compare to the PS4 footage then?

Suspicious.

Fried Food · Oct 25, 2013

I bet the X1 version is going to end up looking better. What a twist.

floatingcoffins · Oct 25, 2013

So, he's showing PS4 multiplayer and single player on the Xbox One and thinks we'll be surprised by the difference?

Ok then.

CassidyIzABeast · Oct 25, 2013

We won't be able to compare but we will know the resolution of the Xbox version since single player is more demanding than multi.

badb0y · Oct 25, 2013

SP vs MP.
If Xbox One doesn't look better that would be pretty bad news.

FTF · Oct 25, 2013

tkalamba said:
He isn't comparing though, he's showing two separate videos

But it's pretty obvious why it's being done this way. Imagine if it was reversed.

BibiMaghoo · Oct 25, 2013

Direct feed 1080p footage...

for a game that DICE confirmed was 720p...

Ok.

VanWinkle · Oct 25, 2013

tkalamba said:
He isn't comparing though, he's showing two separate videos

Then why does his tweet say "And finally I think you guys will be very surprised when you see Xbox One vs PS4 footage"?

DBT85 · Oct 25, 2013

Snaku said:
It's COD, I wouldn't bet on either version being a real looker.

Its BF.

UNCMark · Oct 25, 2013

IN&OUT said:
Seriously, I feel sorry for some of you just getting pumped and start speculating for the 19847663 time to finally get crushed . it happened in NFSR thread, Ryse, COD, NBA14K and now BF thread. X1 will never ever output a single multiplat that perform better than PS4 NEVER*. Specs are laid down 4 months ago, we have discussed this to death. it's just impossible.

* unless devs intentionally force parity or f**ck up PS4 version

You're what's wrong with most gaming forums. Hopefully you're not going to be a part of this one for long. Just pathetic.

Pennywise · Oct 25, 2013

Fried Food said:
I bet the X1 version is going to end up looking better. What a twist.

borghe · Oct 25, 2013

SniperHunter said:
So true..
Mp vs sp how lame. Why no mp footage from xbone ver? Very strange

I think we've already figured this out

MP PS4 vs. SP XBONE will look very comparable. People will be surprised because they will probably look very similar.

Thus, SP PS4 vs. SP XBONE and one (PS4) definitely looks better than the other one (XBONE)

This shit needs to end. MS needs to stop dancing around the subject, man up that their games will be slightly lower IQ, and move on. NES, Genesis, PS2, Wii... all successful systems that weren't the biggest and best IQ of the gen. Get over it already and just show us games without this BS manipulation.

Snaku · Oct 25, 2013

DBT85 said:
Its BF.

This is what I get for posting at work aha.

tkalamba · Oct 25, 2013

VanWinkle said:
Then why does his tweet say "And finally I think you guys will be very surprised when you see Xbox One vs PS4 footage"?

Sorry, missed that part. I was under the impression he isn't so much doing a side by side comparison but showing different streams.

IN&OUT · Oct 25, 2013

Snaku said:
It's COD, I wouldn't bet on either version being a real looker.

You mean BF

DBT85 · Oct 25, 2013

Snaku said:
This is what I get for posting at work aha.

lol.

R3TRODYCE · Oct 25, 2013

IN&OUT said:
Hahaha, look at those xbox fans grasping the straws lol

The MEGATON would be if PS4 multiplayer looked better than X1 Singleplayer

Whoa, it's definitely that time of the year folks.

rekathon · Oct 25, 2013

MysteryM said:
Wouldn't it be amazing if the xbox one version turned out to be better? Given the talk that BF4 on PS4 is 1080p elsewhere its not going to happen but it would just be fun to see the response on the GAF.

That would be the most entertaining thread I ever seen if that happens. Neogaf servers will go down. Lol

Cow Goes Moo · Oct 25, 2013

Why would they compare the single player against a multiplayer

UNCMark · Oct 25, 2013

They've not been hiding the Xbox One version. It's playable on the Xbox tour. Does anyone know what resolution the demo is running at?

New002 · Oct 25, 2013

Chamber said:
Did the definition of confirmed change recently?

Seems like it.

I'm definitely curious to see how this all develops, but I do agree with UNCMark that it would be disigenous to compare the single player footage on one system to the multiplayer footage of another.

Raist · Oct 25, 2013

BibiMaghoo said:
Direct feed 1080p footage...

for a game that DICE confirmed was 720p...

Ok.

Direct feed doesn't get more than what the console outputs. Which can very well be 1080p while the game is 720p native. Nothing misleading here.

IAmRandom31 · Oct 25, 2013

Hmmm .. wonder if the stronger system will have the better looking game?

The suspense, man it is killing me! lol

MThanded · Oct 25, 2013

I have several hours of PS4 multiplayer and the full single player campaign on Xbox One recorded.

what is this? Honestly.

Why would you have multiplayer for one console and single player for another.

miDnIghtEr20C · Oct 25, 2013

IN&OUT said:
Hahaha, look at those xbox fans grasping the straws lol

The MEGATON would be if PS4 multiplayer looked better than X1 Singleplayer

Talk about grasping for straws.

x-Lundz-x · Oct 25, 2013

DBT85 said:
Surprised would be a) Xbone looks better or b) the difference is large.

Going with B.

Same.

Krakn3Dfx · Oct 25, 2013

FTF said:
Comparing/showing the multiplayer of one to the single player of another makes no sense.

Given what we know in this situation, it makes total sense actually. DICE wants to sell a boatload of copies on both systems, if they show the XB1 version being noticeably worse than the PS4 version in the same area of gameplay, it's not good for DICE XB1 sales, and it's not good for EA's partnership with MS.

In less than a month all will be revealed.

IN&OUT · Oct 25, 2013

UNCMark said:
You're what's wrong with most gaming forums. Hopefully you're not going to be a part of this one for long. Just pathetic.

just take my advice and keep away from comparisons threads, or start emphasizing how much you like TV and services starting now.

sportz103 · Oct 25, 2013

Killzone: SF Singleplayer: 1080p 30fps
Killzone: SF Multiplayer: 1080p 60fps
Therefore, games in MP mode should look twice as good (60/30=2)

Therefore the PS4 MP footage needs to look TWICE as good as the XB1 SP footage in order for PS4 to show it has the better-looking port. If the margin is smaller than that, XB1 wins.

It's just simple math guys.

Support NeoGAF

Battlefield 4 PS4/XB1 footage on 10/29 [Up3: Comparisons coming in at midnight EDT]

love on your sleeve

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Neo Member

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

could never

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Loves the Greater Toronto Area

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016

Banned

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Similar threads