Originally Posted by Soka
Rumor is that the Cards shut down Shelby Miller to keep him healthy as a potential trade prospect, possibly for some shortstop out of Texas. Maybe Jurickson Profar? Not sure how fair that trade would be straight up, I don't know much about Profar.
Because secretly holding him out of postseason action without any type of acknowledgement would boost his trade value? If they came out and said they were Strasburging him, that may be a possibility. Doing it this way would just lead to speculation of injury and lower his trade value.
Not that we haven't done stupid stuff to lower the trade value of our players before *coughcoughColbyRasmuscough* but I'm willing to pin most of that on TLR opening his mouth to the media.
Originally Posted by nemss
If the Cards did do this, then they flat out deserved to lose. Why have someone on the roster that you're not planning on using at all?
If he's traded, then my guess is its something else that lead to the trade.
As Soka said, it ultimately matters little in the end. A healthy, effective Miller would've been significant. But assuming he really wasn't fit to pitch and you wanted to replace him on the roster, the best option to replace him would've been a third LHP out of the bullpen in Freeman/Lyons. Certainly would've helped with Ortiz but we lost because we couldn't get a big hit from the bottom of the lineup.
Our options for adding another bat were Rob fucking Johnson and Adron Chambers. If Taveras hadn't gotten injured, I'd be more upset of wasting the last two roster spots on mop-up guys who were non-factors.