Support NeoGAF

[Natiko]

I attacked you for your Terra vote, not Mazre.

Just to recap it for you Nat. Kalor was the top scum read at the time when Terra started being stupid with Lifeline making him suspicious. You then quickly followed in behind Kalor's vote hoping the two players already under suspicion would take the heat.

It was a very sly and safe vote. Fat4All did the same thing



Sorry for not being an idiot on day 1.

Yes, my mistake. It was the Terra one you piggybacked off Sorian despite that being the literal reason you tried to say my vote was scummy. Lets review shall we - first off both Kalor and SexyFish are tied with three votes each at this point.

There's a couple of players I could put a vote on but I'll go with Terra for now. Other people have posted less and been more vague than him but he has a lot of general mechanical talk or observations. He also threw out a vote and has barely went back to it.

Vote: Terrabyte20xx

Kalor comes in and votes Terra based on Terra being vague and a previous vote. Nothing to do with the strange post that is about to come. This moves Terra to one vote.

Your conviction is commendable.

Heh. We've got time, I'll humor you.

VOTE: Acohrs

The strange post in question as there's little incentive here outside of possibly baiting others. A single vote isn't going to humor lifeline as it won't actually get acorn lynched and this is the person Terra was previously just voting for. This moves acorn to two votes.

So you went from voting for him to voting with him to humor him?

VOTE: Terrabyte20xx

I come in and vote him over the complete 180. This moves Terra to two votes. Tied for third, not even first.

VOTE: Terrabyte20xx

Your movements are irking me a bit here.

As does Fat. This vote puts Terra in a three way tie for first.

Haha, Terrabyte, that's not a good look, especially swinging your vote off two posts.

Easily the scummiest thing I have seen all day. Not voting for you though. Don't want to bandwagon vote but I want you to know if you hadn't gotten some votes already I probably would have thrown one your way.

Lifeline/Terra scum team 2017

Final thoughts before my phone dies and I can't get back on for a couple hours:

Lifeline's weird full guess of every mafia member and telling us to mark his words is weird.

Terrabyte's sudden switch to hammering acohrs with Lifeline is WEIRD.

And it wasn't just us, several others also felt it was scummy.

If you want to think I'm scum then go for it Faddy. History will prove you wrong, but you could at least try and make a valid argument as to why instead of acting like I bandwagoned when I was the first person to point out the erratic nature of Terra's post. I mean your whole point just now was to claim that I manufactured a Terra train by putting him at two votes which there were three others at or above that point already. I guess that doesn't fit your narrative though so you ignore it.

Long Live RetroMG, Magnanimous ruler of Gafia

 

[batsnacks]

Terra (Flame) clearly isn't scum. At first I thought he tied that vote at the very end but knowing that Lifeline was town means that made no sense at all for a scum player to do so unless he was so disillusioned that he didn't mind spitting in the face of teammates that he knew about and then still going through with being replaced. So cool to kind of have a clear even if the method was sketchy.

Terra ragequit his last scum game (minimafia) in pretty much exactly the same way and for the same reasons, and he was their strongest role (roleblocker). This is NAI for him.

If Lifeline vs Terra was town/town though mafia is voting on the stronger case which imo was Lifeline. Also if I'm mafia I 1000% prefer voting out the guy that didn't give up (Lifeline).

Unless I'm mafia Faddy and doing lame stuff like this:

Sorry for not being an idiot on day 1.

 

[Sorian]

Terra ragequit his last scum game (minimafia) in pretty much exactly the same way and for the same reasons, and he was their strongest role (roleblocker). This is NAI for him.

If Lifeline vs Terra was town/town though mafia is voting on the stronger case which imo was Lifeline. Also if I'm mafia I 1000% prefer voting out the guy that didn't give up (Lifeline).

Unless I'm mafia Faddy and doing lame stuff like this:

Isn't that the game I replaced him? I don't remember him having quote the outburst, it seemed like his asking for a replacement was more a private affair.

 

[batsnacks]

I'm gonna be annoying put it out there that fat4all looks like mafia rn and not really explain myself.

Worm is a huge jerk for voting me at EOD and is v lucky I didn't shoot him last night but I think town.

Maybe? Only way to tell is if it happens again, really.

Look at this smart comment in a sea of people asking about curses

 

[Sorian]

I'm gonna be annoying put it out there that fat4all looks like mafia rn and not really explain myself.

Worm is a huge jerk for voting me at EOD and is v lucky I didn't shoot him last night but I think town.


Look at this smart comment in a sea of people asking about curses

?

Also, I just take the curse non sense at face value. The only person whos ever lied about it is Blarg.

 

[Flame_AC]

I'm gonna be annoying put it out there that fat4all looks like mafia rn and not really explain myself.

Worm is a huge jerk for voting me at EOD and is v lucky I didn't shoot him last night but I think town.


Look at this smart comment in a sea of people asking about curses

Oh no. We had a good run everybody. Whatcha mean by bolded. I dont care about you saying someone looks like mafia, put a vote out.

 

[batsnacks]

Isn't that the game I replaced him? I don't remember him having quote the outburst, it seemed like his asking for a replacement was more a private affair.

yeah same one. I think he still did the announce-it-to-the-thread-apologize thing. also it was day 1.

 

[batsnacks]

Oh no. We had a good run everybody. Whatcha mean by bolded. I dont care about you saying someone looks like mafia, put a vote out.

ok

VOTE: Flame_AC

 

[Flame_AC]

ok

VOTE: Flame_AC

Better than nothing I guess (though so much for that feeling). What do you mean by what Sorian and I bolded?

 

[SexyFish]

I'm gonna be annoying put it out there that fat4all looks like mafia rn and not really explain myself.

Worm is a huge jerk for voting me at EOD and is v lucky I didn't shoot him last night but I think town.


Look at this smart comment in a sea of people asking about curses

I could hop on a Worm train if I knew what you're hinting at pal.

 

[batsnacks]

I could hop on a Worm train if I knew what you're hinting at pal.

I said I think he's town why would you do that lol

I'm not claiming any of the kills the previous night, I'm just saying that worm is 1) a jerk and 2) lucky I didn't shoot him.

 

[SexyFish]

My reading comprehension failed me. No work train indeed.

 

[batsnacks]

My reading comprehension failed me. No work train indeed.

yeah but you think he's mafia right? why lol

 

[Dr. Worm]

Worm is a huge jerk for voting me at EOD and is v lucky I didn't shoot him last night but I think town.

Aww, coulda woulda shoulda.

What's the matter, snacksy-baby? Is a little heat so much for you that you need to bust out a fake claim to scare me off? I know you wanna kill me.

 

[Verelios]

I said I think he's town why would you do that lol

I'm not claiming any of the kills the previous night, I'm just saying that worm is 1) a jerk and 2) lucky I didn't shoot him.

You do realize how this sounds after last night's 2NK though right? Unless that was the point.

 

[Penguin]

Oh it's a New Day!

Yes, it is!

I can finally enter the Asylum

Though as a distinguished gentlemen like myself, I belong in Blackgate!

 

[batsnacks]

SexyFish and fat4all are looking for easy lunches, possibly because their easy lunch (Kalor) got shot (I didn't shoot Kalor or splinter

but I thought about shooting worm on principle. I'm not faking this.)

MickD would be an easy pick for one of the two spots depending on how they act today, indeed.

and SexyFish is happy to lynch worm even though he doesn't think worm is mafia.

UNVOTE
VOTE: SexyFish

 

[Flame_AC]

Phew. I thought Penguin was around for Day 1 and was about to freak out about how I somehow missed an entire person.

 

[Ourobolus]

chocolate pudding

 

[SexyFish]

SexyFish and fat4all are looking for easy lunches, possibly because their easy lunch (Kalor) got shot (I didn't shoot Kalor or splinter

but I thought about shooting worm on principle. I'm not faking this.)



and SexyFish is happy to lynch worm even though he doesn't think worm is mafia.

UNVOTE
VOTE: SexyFish

I had a feeling about Worm since his vote for me, although it seems to have fell through since Kalor died.

Throwing a vote to hopefully get more insight to get this person actually talking and some of their reads.

VOTE: MickD

What are your thoughts/opinions, MickD? Anything less alcohol fueled?

 

[Dr. Worm]

chocolate pudding

An easy lunch, to be sure, but not the healthiest.

 

[Zippedpinhead]

SexyFish and fat4all are looking for easy lunches, possibly because their easy lunch (Kalor) got shot (I didn't shoot Kalor or splinter

but I thought about shooting worm on principle. I'm not faking this.)



and SexyFish is happy to lynch worm even though he doesn't think worm is mafia.

UNVOTE
VOTE: SexyFish

Why I vote before re-voting? Doesn't voting replace it?

Anyway, interesting conclusion... but doesn't it require fat4all being on the same team as Sexyfish?

 

[Sorian]

To add my hat to the current affairs while I have a second at work. I know I was on Worm yesterday but I don't think he is scum anymore. Assuming I'm right that Splinter was the mafia kill, scum wouldn't remind everyone about Splinter softiny yesterday, easier to just let it sit at the bottom instead of trudging things up.

I'm still weirded out by bats phrasing but people on mafia universe used to do the same thing of threatening a shot when they had no actual killing ability so whatever, I know bats has other community experience.

 

[Flame_AC]

Penguin, once you catch up could you give some general thoughts on the most standout players in your opinion?

Also, I think SexyFish's vote is a very safe play and am not a fan of it. We very well might end up making MickD our secondary lynch, though I'm still not too into that idea, but I'd prefer you not just placing your vote there and keeping it for the day.

 

[SexyFish]

Penguin, once you catch up could you give some general thoughts on the most standout players in your opinion?

Also, I think SexyFish's vote is a very safe play and am not a fan of it. We very well might end up making MickD our secondary lynch, though I'm still not too into that idea, but I'd prefer you not just placing your vote there and keeping it for the day.

If he doesn't make a response in half a day I'll probably just move on to a different angle. No need to dwell on him if he repeats his actions from day 1 again.

 

[Sorian]

Penguin, once you catch up could you give some general thoughts on the most standout players in your opinion?

Also, I think SexyFish's vote is a very safe play and am not a fan of it. We very well might end up making MickD our secondary lynch, though I'm still not too into that idea, but I'd prefer you not just placing your vote there and keeping it for the day.

Weird that you read SexyFish as putting that vote down with no intention to move it. He clarified anyway but it clearly reads as a prod vote.

-----

Been debating how I feel about Bats. I still stand by what I said yesterday about him very much trying to guide the game but if I accept that Splinter was a scum kill then Bats seems like an odd scum team member considering Splinter was the first to knock me for wanting to vote Bats.

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

DAY 2 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

AbsolutBro (1)
Sorian 892

Faddy (1)
Flame_AC 937

MickD (1)
SexyFish 970

Natiko (1)
Faddy 918

SexyFish (1)
batsnacks 967

Flame_AC (0): batsnacks 958 967

No active vote for Day 2: AbsolutBro, acohrs, Dr. Worm, Fat4all, Fireblend, Lone_Prodigy, Mazre, MickD, Natiko, Nudull, Penguin, Royal_Flush, StarSketch, Timeaisis, Verelios, Zippedpinhead

Day 2 Postcount: AbsolutBro 5, acohrs 0, batsnacks 7, Dr. Worm 8, Faddy 7, Fat4all 15, Fireblend 0, Flame_AC 12, Lone_Prodigy 0, Mazre 3, MickD 0, Natiko 12, Nudull 3, Penguin 1, Royal_Flush 0, SexyFish 6, Sorian 14, StarSketch 1, Timeaisis 0, Verelios 7, Zippedpinhead 3


Day 2 ends:

Automated vote tally here

 

[Sorian]

I know it's the middle of the night but I though I'd have something to read through during my lunch break :|

Nudull, you posted earlier. I forgot you existed in this game, why is that?

 

[Royal_Flush]

Catching up, so natiko you have to post that line every time or you die? Got it.

I'm thinking Kalor was the scum kill honestly. He was right in the mix with votes, but also voted for both players. Sure he came in third, but so did batsnacks and natiko.

normally I would say that scum was hiding in the last half hour vote fest, but those people are all dead and cursed now except Sorian, Dr worm, star sketch and terra/flame.

That's a very weak post with basically only general statements, like you only want to seem to contribute.

In reading through the thread, AbsolutBro has seemingly flown under the radar, at least on Day 1. However, every time they posted I agreed with them, which I found really weird. For that reason I'll lean town as they made some of the same observations/thoughts that I had in looking at Day 1.

Or maybe it is because he barely said anything noteworthy D1, let alone something controversial. D2 seems to be off to a better start. Do you agree with Faddy being the Scum kill? That sounds like a very contrived logic to me.

 

[acohrs]

Agree with others that Splinter was probably NK'd by scum and Kalor was probably done in by a SK or town vigilante. Forgot about Splinter's semi role-claim, but would that really be important in a role madness game? -Thinking face-

@Flame_AC, what do you think of your predecessor's total meltdown and accusations that he's done it before?

 

[acohrs]

@Natiko, curiosity is getting the better of me. Do you just have to end each post in that line or can you also not say derogatory stuff towards Retro in a post like Retro is a big, dumb stinkyhead?

 

[Sorian]

Agree with others that Splinter was probably NK'd by scum and Kalor was probably done in by a SK or town vigilante. Forgot about Splinter's semi role-claim, but would that really be important in a role madness game? -Thinking face-

@Flame_AC, what do you think of your predecessor's total meltdown and accusations that he's done it before?

Splinter isn't exactly a weak player so any little reason could have pushed it over. Calling attention to a role still get the sub conscious rolling.

 

[batsnacks]

Dr Worm are u ok with me town reading you? That was a really weird thing you did yesterday when you said "hey Lifeline I'll vote who you vote" and then you wound up voting Lifeline.

I said that if Lifeline/terra was town/town mafia is probably voting Lifeline cause he was the stronger case. If terra was mafia then duh that's even more reason to vote Lifeline so there's probably scum on that wagon.

this is the worst vote for Lifeline:

Reading through these posts, I feel like I'm trying to grab wet spaghetti by hand. Soggy, slippery, and if we try and grab it too quickly we are all likely to get burned.

Here is my vote, it's not perfect but it's mine.

vote: lifeline

I don't understand his gameplay. I've been trying to make sense of it for a day and still don't see it. I feel like he might be a scum player trying to hard.

I still think Fat4all looks like mafia there are a lot of similarities with how he played vampire

 

[batsnacks]

Timeaisis doesn't look like mafia voting Lifeline his case was good/original he pretty much got the ball rolling

I'm not mafia lol I pushed Lifeline hardest

Idk why royalflush and starsketch voted Lifeline they might have given reasons but I don't remember them

I'm saying dr worm is town even though his vote was weird

Splinter was town

Natiko votes for "no tie"

Sorian was all over the place. It'll be a bad look for him if flame is scum.

so yeah zipped looks the worst on that wagon

 

[Sorian]

Did I miss why you are town reading Worm? I know you posted earlier but I don't remember what the topic was.

I also wasn't all over the place. Lifeline was always 100% my choice. I moved the vote to even to force fence sitters to actually vote and then kept getting caught preventing a tie in the last few minutes.

 

[batsnacks]

Reading through these posts, I feel like I'm trying to grab wet spaghetti by hand. Soggy, slippery, and if we try and grab it too quickly we are all likely to get burned.

Here is my vote, it's not perfect but it's mine.

vote: lifeline

I don't understand his gameplay. I've been trying to make sense of it for a day and still don't see it. I feel like he might be a scum player trying to hard.

 

[acohrs]

.

 

[Dr. Worm]

Dr Worm are u ok with me town reading you? That was a really weird thing you did yesterday when you said "hey Lifeline I'll vote who you vote" and then you wound up voting Lifeline.

sure, man, whatever makes you happy

I wasn't too thrilled about any of the trains that were rolling, so I wanted to see if I could get Lifeline to help me start another. Lifeline was my #1 of the wagons that were going, but I expected him to be lynched easily - I was surprised Terrabyte had as much of a following as he did.

I still think Fat4all looks like mafia there are a lot of similarities with how he played vampire

FWIW, his rationale for voting Terrabyte seems the most developed, and he put a lot of time into defending it

seems odd for mafia to do that when it's probably better for them to get town unanimous on Lifeline

 

[Dr. Worm]

Idk why royalflush and starsketch voted Lifeline they might have given reasons but I don't remember them

Here's what I get for Royal_Flush:

Sorry, I thought it was obvious from my earlier posts. Terra still is dangerously close to being lynched and my second favorite lynch candidate is vote leader so I swing over to create additional buffer.

Because he is my eternal blindspot. There are quite some other options I'd also take over Terra. Lifeline and bats come to mind.

Mazre pretty much is random chance at this point. But the last couple of games I lost as Town (minus DR3 where Nantiko did a great job) were because the random chance people stayed random chance people and never got lynched.

Oth I'd also be on-board for lifeline or bats, though I'd prefer lifeline. The main reason I want to keep him around is that I like the craziness he brings in

Voting Terra is a mistake. His plays seem like something Town-Terra would make.

not really reasoning, but well-documented indication

also, here's Royal_Flush on Zippedpinhead:

What is this metaphor even supposed to mean? And what are "these" posts? And why are you apologizing in advance for your vote? Do you know something we dont?

didn't see StarSketch give much in terms of justification, though

 

[batsnacks]

Yeah I love RF callout on zipped I was just about to post that

 

[batsnacks]

But I hate his read on me

 

[Penguin]

Now how many heroes are we talking here? I feel like Natiko and Faddy are fighting a bit too much... that may be trying to play us. Go after each other, but make sure the other is safe or get one voted off so we won't look at them again.

 

[Zippedpinhead]

Pasta pot infomercial fails! Hilarious! What a joker!

Anyways I didn't like his gameplay and got tired of his trying to make kalor work as a lynch target (which I rightfullly disagreed with). I came back periodically throughout the end of the day, saw the vote was close and didn't change.

And royal, I guess that's general statements, but I honestly thought it's a pretty town forward one. I don't think scum was involved with jockeying the vote last day phase. And the metaphor is pretty straight forward. We don't have a lot to go on day one so we try to infer what we want out of everyone else's posts. But ultimately we get burned and lynch a potentially good role.

 

[Natiko]

@Natiko, curiosity is getting the better of me. Do you just have to end each post in that line or can you also not say derogatory stuff towards Retro in a post like Retro is a big, dumb stinkyhead?

Well, I technically wasn't told not to. At the same time the way it's written I don't know if I particularly want to test it out lol

Long Live RetroMG, Magnanimous ruler of Gafia

 

[acohrs]

@Natiko - row row fight the powahs

@SexyFish - your attempt to start a wagon on Worm was pretty scummy, rn you look pretty scummy but without the fun, jokes or GIFs, it's making me really sad

Vote: SexyFish

I want more jokes and townplay dammit!

 

[Timeaisis]

OK, almost all caught up...couple things

- I don't see how Flame is confirmed town at this point. Yes, Terra's play last night definitely isn't something mafia would "do", necessarily, but if he knew he was going to be repalced anyway.
- Did batsnacks just admit he was vig?

Yeah lynch the guy who was trying to change the thread away from a pair of town trains. If I were scum why would I even bother.

This post rubs me the wrong way. I didn't have a good feeling on Faddy yesterday, and I continue not to today.

So, for now.

VOTE: Faddy

 

[SexyFish]

@Natiko - row row fight the powahs

@SexyFish - your attempt to start a wagon on Worm was pretty scummy, rn you look pretty scummy but without the fun, jokes or GIFs, it's making me really sad

Vote: SexyFish

I want more jokes and townplay dammit!

So if I get this straight, the more goofs and gaffs I make the less likely it is I die?

I can see how I seem scummy going after Worm. Still feel off about him but I don't think it works in this situation.

I think MickD will probably should be our secondary lynch if he doesn't try anything.

No reason to go after Flame/Terra I think, he doesn't seem like the guy who would almost fuck his team over by voting himself, but who knows?

We need more from StarSketch and Nudull right now importantly. Also, what's the consequence of not hitting 10 minimum? Or did Nudull have a good excuse?

 

[acohrs]

So if I get this straight, the more goofs and gaffs I make the less likely it is I die?

I can see how I seem scummy going after Worm. Still feel off about him but I don't think it works in this situation.

I think MickD will probably should be our secondary lynch if he doesn't try anything.

No reason to go after Flame/Terra I think, he doesn't seem like the guy who would almost fuck his team over by voting himself, but who knows?

We need more from StarSketch and Nudull right now importantly. Also, what's the consequence of not hitting 10 minimum? Or did Nudull have a good excuse?

Yes, now...

 

[SexyFish]

Yes, now...

 

[acohrs]

.