• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

DigitalFoundry: RotTR Xbox One X vs PS4 Pro First Look Graphics Comaprison

I really really hope the aliasing is completely gone though because in the DF video we see a bit from the Pro version and after Lara has used that slide thing or however you call it and you see those trees, man there is clearly aliasing there. It was at times terrible on X1 but I'm shocked they didn't fix it completely.
 

BatSu

Member
z6Z6SVH.png
 
I really really hope the aliasing is completely gone though because in the DF video we see a bit from the Pro version and after Lara has used that slide thing or however you call it and you see those trees, man there is clearly aliasing there. It was at times terrible on X1 but I'm shocked they didn't fix it completely.
The aliasing in ROTTR is pretty bad across all platforms and you can only really get rid of it with downsampling. Their AA solution just isn't very good. However, one of the bullet points on the X1X trailer is "improved AA" so they might have implemented something new! (TAA pls)
 
Improved textures look great, and there's definitely a noticeable jump in clarity. Very clean sharp.

Did they even improve the textures at all with the Pro version though? Not even trying to start anything, just curious
 
The aliasing in ROTTR is pretty bad across all platforms and you can only really get rid of it with downsampling. Their AA solution just isn't very good. However, one of the bullet points on the X1X trailer is "improved AA" so they might have implemented something new! (TAA pls)

Yeah that's a shame because it really ruins an otherwise fantastic looking game. Thing is, the aliasing isn't bad everywhere though. The more linear parts is where it actually looks fine I would say.
 
Improved textures look great, and there's definitely a noticeable jump in clarity. Very clean sharp.

Did they even improve the textures at all with the Pro version though? Not even trying to start anything, just curious
No, the Pro doesn't really have extra memory (maybe an extra half gig? I can't recall) vs the X1X's 12GB.
 
I think this is what we are going to see, and more and more, until next PS is released. The XBOX 1 X is awesome.

I hope so man. Comparisons of upcoming games like ACO, Wolfenstein, Evil Within 2,CoD, Battlefront 2 from DF will definitely show us if we can expect differences similar to this. I do hope so, use that power!
 

Colbert

Banned
It's going to be interesting which one of the modes people with 4K TVs will choose. I'm probably going with native 4K, but we will see...

You can switch modes on the fly. It is maybe that people just switch to 60 fps mode in more hectic or shooting scenes and back to enriched when exploring.
 

Navid

Member
Much better texture quality on XB1X, wonder if the lack of depth of field blur is something that they have removed (or not implemented) for this early footage?
 
I'll probably end up sticking with Native 4K because as soon as I have the X I'll put my couch much closer to the screen, that much closer that a 1080p game will look too blurry for my liking. Do we know what resolution it has when high framerate is enabled? 1080p right? Because iirc enriched visuals uses checkerboard 4K,correft?
 

f@luS

More than a member.
It's going to be interesting which one of the modes people with 4K TVs will choose. I'm probably going with native 4K, but we will see...
If the CB is good enough from a high resolution I might go with this one

I virtually see no difference when it's a good 4k cb or native. I tried few games that have both and it's really the same for me at normal viewable distance. (Wipeout for exemple or tlou)
If effects or textures are much better I'll go for Cb
 

RootCause

Member
If the CB is good enough from a high resolution I might go with this one

I virtually see no difference when it's a good 4k cb or native. I tried few games that have both and it's really the same for me at normal viewable distance. (Wipeout for exemple or tlou)
If effects or textures are much better I'll go for Cb
This will be a great game to test it out.
 

Black_Stride

do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
Bring on Quantum Break next please.
Just did another playthrough on OG XB1 and im still impressed by it.
 

wotta

Member
Removed as don't really want to start a fanboy console war. I own PS4 Pro and Xbox One S. Was just joking around more than anything.
 
Holy shit, that difference is even larger than I expected, and I fully expected there to be a not so small visual difference.
 

theWB27

Member
Bringing in exclusives by Naughty Dog to downplay the differences between the same game shown across different consoles. Impressive stuff.
 

wotta

Member
Man, we don't need console war bs in very thread.

Sorry, was just trying to say that I would prefer to see what Xbox One X can do with new games. It's all very well showing off a game no-one will play. The bigger issue is why should I upgrade my Xbox One S to an X when there are no games for MS' new console.
 
Top Bottom