• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

One Piece Manga |OT3| Anything You Can Gum I Can Gum Better

NSESN

Member
Honestly I didn't like the way Oda is teasing carrot as a SH. It seemed like he forgot todo it before and is rushing it.
 

Ray Down

Banned
Honestly I didn't like the way Oda is teasing carrot as a SH. It seemed like he forgot todo it before and is rushing it.

Or he's not teasing at all.

It's 2 or so panels guys, lol.

Still doubt its gonna happen, but its at least nice she has something else this arc besides being all happy spunk.
 

Majukun

Member
Honestly I didn't like the way Oda is teasing carrot as a SH. It seemed like he forgot todo it before and is rushing it.

that's the funny thing,he ain't teasing anything
Pedro will be alive, but die before the arc is done due to his lifespan shortening. Just so it's a more "peaceful" death. They'll sail away and we'll see him sitting behind a rock with his eyese closed, he'll say something about the next generation blah blah, then quiety pass away.

i think you are mistaking onepiece for fairy tail
 

LotusHD

Banned
Honestly I didn't like the way Oda is teasing carrot as a SH. It seemed like he forgot todo it before and is rushing it.

Maybe you only dislike it because you got this preconceived notion as to how a potential SH is supposed to be set up to be to be teased to join. Barring the super obvious stuff like a dream, Oda can go about it however he wants, it's been 9 years after all. Not to mention Jinbe is another atypical example. IMO, it's only rushing if you think it's all gonna happen in WCI. (This is not framed in a snarky way btw, just my thoughts)

As for me, I maintained that the bulk of whatever development she's set to get will be in Wano, so this is pretty much icing on the cake for me. Though in hindsight it makes sense. Plant some seeds here and there, then they go to Wano to expand on it, the "it" in this case being what the Minks consider to be the "Dawn" or whatever, maybe properly mourning Pedro's death, etc.


Still doubt its gonna happen, but its at least nice she has something else this arc besides being all happy spunk.

Ooh, is this progress

The cannonballs also being homies made me laugh more than it should have. Poor little guys, what a life.

Lmao same, so unnecessary
 

Ray Down

Banned
Still doubt she get to much focus in Wano considering all the players in that arc.

And not really Lotus, still think she won't join just has a bit more then her to her but still not to much still of the mind with the Grand Fleet.
 

Kave_Man

come in my shame circle
I just feel good at least the making of the cake won't drag on...at least I hope not.

I remember during Dressrosa we all groaned with the 10 minutes or whatever it was for Luffy to get his haki back but that only ate up like 1 chapter.

I could see the same with Sanji and them making it inbetween Luffy fighting or whatever.
 

Ray Down

Banned
I just feel good at least the making of the cake won't drag on...at least I hope not.

I remember during Dressrosa we all groaned with the 10 minutes or whatever it was for Luffy to get his haki back but that only ate up like 1 chapter.

I could see the same with Sanji and them making it inbetween Luffy fighting or whatever.

To be fair we haven't even gotten to the cake making yet and shit can still go down there to extend it.
 

Principate

Saint Titanfall
I like carrot hope she stays. Extra female character and has dynamics that fit right at home within the crew (younger sister relationship with chopper and namo dad a and female idiot to the crew's dynamics. More hand to hand focused female. She fills and adds a lot to the day to day scree shenanigans that makes the strawhats.
 

LotusHD

Banned
I like carrot hope she stays. Extra female character and has dynamics that fit right at home within the crew (younger sister relationship with chopper and namo dad a and female idiot to the crew's dynamics. More hand to hand focused female. She fills and adds a lot to the day to day scree shenanigans that makes the strawhats.

We're all hip, here's to hoping lol
 
Btw who wins Luffy vs Katakuri? My bet is a tie.

I'll say Luffy manages to eke out a win, to show that even though he stands no chance against Big Mom he's going into Wano with some progress. I almost figure that the fight leads to Luffy finding some new application of his devil fruit and Katakuri's "special paramecia" classification amounts to something.

What remains now is to see how Sanji ties into all this.
 
Didn't realize before that Perospero's name is literally just "pero pero" with an s in the middle.

Okay just finished the chapter. RIP Pedro, but what a way to go! Some good art this week. Carrot's growing on me for sure.

Would be cool if Perospero gets like a morphing candy arm.
 
Oda still so good.
I love how Luffy internally tells us that he's going to stay on Whole Cake and doesn't make it dramatic like
"I gotta go guys! i'll cya later *smile wink*"
they find out after they coupe de burst.

and the stare down between Dogtooth and Loufy.
i love One Piece

EDIT: i guess technically he does say it out loud but no one cries and makes a big scene about it
 
Can Dogtooth not predict stuff anymore or wbat?

I mean he probably can to some extent, but I imagine that ability is far less useful in general in a one on one fight between CoO users since the predictions aren't ironclad and both sides have that ability to some extent. Even if he can see a bit farther it's not useful if the enemy changes their moves based on those predictions as well
 

Daingurse

Member
Btw who wins Luffy vs Katakuri? My bet is a tie.

I don't think Luffy is going to be able to press Katakuri enough to force this to a tie. I think this is going to be an endurance test for Luffy, with him just trying to hold-out as long as he can. This starchy Muad'Dib-lite should be way too much for Luffy to handle right now.
 

Kave_Man

come in my shame circle
Btw who wins Luffy vs Katakuri? My bet is a tie.

Luffy will win this since he's gone so long not winning a one on one fight.

He had help with Doflamingo and Cracker. He'll take down Katakuri to once again establish him as a top player for both readers and people in the One Piece world.
 

Euphony

Banned
I expect Luffy to barely win just like when he fought Lucci. He's war ready and wants a bounty increase.

I wonder if there's a possibility of a new form of Gear 4 because of this fight. We know Bound Man and Tank Man, although that might be a joke/situational one, but it'd be cool to see a new form. Luffy is most likely exhausted from all the fights he's been in this arc so it's going to be a close one.
 

caliph95

Member
Luffy will win this since he's gone so long not winning a one on one fight.

He had help with Doflamingo and Cracker. He'll take down Katakuri to once again establish him as a top player for both readers and people in the One Piece world.
If had trouble against cracker he would have more against Katakuri

But that's getting to power level debates since Cracker ability allows him to outlast his opponents while Katakuri have to fight him head on

So it's possible
 
Holy shit, what a chapter. I haven't seen Luffy this badass since stopping Doflamingo's foot.
Wonder if the anime will Jozu Peros' arm.
Is Pedro definitely dead? I'm now arriving at a solid maybe.
Does Katakuri have a Glasgow Smile? I haven't noticed those scars before.
 
I'm not on my computer so I'll make this brief.

Earlier chapter than usual, but this was great, y'all.
Perospero didn't make it out in ....."one piece." lol
Carrot went into full rage mode, but these opponents are too far out of her league.
Luffy was in pure form this week. I don't expect this fight to last long. Probably five chapters max, mostly off-screened.
 

Man God

Non-Canon Member
Luffy will win this since he's gone so long not winning a one on one fight.

He had help with Doflamingo and Cracker. He'll take down Katakuri to once again establish him as a top player for both readers and people in the One Piece world.
Sanji already softened him up.
 

NSESN

Member
My reasoning for why it would be a tie is that we need to gauge how powerfull Luffy is but I still think Katakuri will come back as opponent after wano. Maybe we will have him fighting Sanji when Luffy challenges BM.
 

Veelk

Banned
I'm willing to bet that Luffy will beat Katakuri, since this apparently this is being treated as the climactic fight of the arc, but if he does, that's gonna be a bit strange since Luffy wasn't able to beat Cracker without Nami's help, and that only after 8 hours (or however long it was).

Now Luffy is alone and he should theoretically be on a stricter time schedule since he needs to get out and escape with his lame cook before Big Mom decides to eat them along with the cake (though it's mitigated by the fact that they're stuck in mirror world).

I think it's lame that this is the final boss fight tho. Assuming that Luffy does win (and I am assuming that for now), Big Mom is going to be have another 2 of her top 4 taken out and without having the chance to fight anymore. And I know I've said this multiple times, but I still feel that Big Mom got robbed. In general, but especially as a villain. She should be the final boss while the strawhats desperately try to escape, not her number 2. Seeing her just be this ineffectual rampaging idiot whose going to be neutralized by a pastry that shitty cook and his lame waifu crap out is just disappointing, however strong she is.
 

Veelk

Banned
Were people this mad when Zoro didn't end up beating Hawkeye Mihawk by the end of Baretie?

Dunno, but for clarification purposes, I'm not saying Luffy should beat Big Mom. I'm saying she should be the most present and immediate threat as the climax of the arc, not her lieutenant. The final fight should be long to her as Luffy and the rest try to escape, not Katakuri.
 
Uhhhh, the whole reason everyone is scrambling to lead BM away is because she's the biggest threat on the island in this state.
That's why Perospero lied to her so her rage was focused on the SHs instead of her own family and subordinates.
 

LotusHD

Banned
So if we ever get a decent OP fighting game, I definitely would like for the Mirror World to be a stage lol

Can Dogtooth not predict stuff anymore or wbat?

He can, but it's not uncommon for people with that ability to be able to see into the future, and yet still be unable to stop certain events from happening. We've already seen this several times this arc, Luffy grabbing Katakuri is simply another example of this happening.

If had trouble against cracker he would have more against Katakuri

But that's getting to power level debates since Cracker ability allows him to outlast his opponents while Katakuri have to fight him head on

So it's possible

There ya go. Unlike Cracker, it's going to be a much more straightforward fight, so we'll see how it goes.

I really don't know why people think Katakuri is completely out of Luffy's league, especially from what we've seen from him so far. Frankly, I think Katakuri has been holding back a lot in favor of trapping his opponents. Now that he aims to kill Luffy, let's see what he can really do.

Holy shit, what a chapter. I haven't seen Luffy this badass since stopping Doflamingo's foot.
Wonder if the anime will Jozu Peros' arm.
Is Pedro definitely dead? I'm now arriving at a solid maybe.
Does Katakuri have a Glasgow Smile? I haven't noticed those scars before.

Pedro is dead.

I'm willing to bet that Luffy will beat Katakuri, since this apparently this is being treated as the climactic fight of the arc, but if he does, that's gonna be a bit strange since Luffy wasn't able to beat Cracker without Nami's help, and that only after 8 hours (or however long it was).

Well Luffy straight up can't beat her, so we gotta settle for Katakuri, the "Magellan" of the arc. I think Oda rather not give Luffy a legitimate fight against Big Mom, as he's made it clear that he can't win, making it slightly pointless for him to bother with that, as that would also spoil the fun of seeing her abilities while sane. I believe that Oda feels that it's best to have her in this crazed state that is a threat to everyone, because if she were sane this time, then well... Luffy and co. probably would've been dead by now. This way Big Mom remains an ever-present threat until she's fed, but we still get a cool battle against someone. That said, I dunno what his plans are for her, if he's planning some future Elbaf fight, or maybe she'll fight a Yonkou, or something different entirely.

And I don't think this fight is that strange. Cracker has a DF ability that makes it very easy to outlast his opponents, creating soldiers that can tank anything that isn't Gear 4, making up for his fragile body. I guess you could criticize the seemingly weird length of the fight, but meh. Anyways, Katakuri doesn't have such an ability, so the battle is naturally going to be a lot more straightforward and shorter.
 

LotusHD

Banned
That's the reason why I think it will be a tie. BM needs a top fighter when the round 2 happens after Wano.

MUp14Qp.png


Smoothie foreshadowing ;D
 
Top Bottom