• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Netflix The Witcher Discussion

KingGhidorah

KingGhidorah

Banned
Just finished Episode 3. I'm loving it so far. Episode 3 is so intense!!

I haven't seen the remaining episodes yet, but if there's one episode that will define Season 1, Episode 3 is it!!

I like the acting and the atmosphere better than Disney's Mandalorian. The fight scenes are also better (fight scene in Episode 1, wow!)

I won't binge, I'm gonna savour it throughout Christmas/NY break...........who the fuck am I kidding I prolly gonna finish them all by Sunday
 
Mista

Mista

Banned
Flying back home tomorrow and so stoked to watch it. I don’t like Henry a.k.a Geralt but the lads praised him a lot
 
C4lukin2

C4lukin2

Banned
mekes said:
I’m about to try the first episode. I knew it was coming but didn’t know it would be so soon. Glad to see a positive review here!
Click to expand...

I finished the season.

As someone who has not played the games or read the books, I enjoyed it.

It is a bit of a mess I must admit.

I think the worst special effect monster Is in the first episode, opening scene is bad. It is a terrible start for the whole show. It takes 6 episodes for it to shit.... There are worse monsters as far as effects around episode 6.

But I thought it was fun.

It is messy, and super silly. But there is something.... to it.
 
Mista

Mista

Banned
KingGhidorah said:
Henry perfectly fits as Geralt, his voice, his looks, everything. and I bet ladies don't mind him going shirtless showing his pecs and muscles
Click to expand...
I read that his co-workers said that he slept in Geralt’s uniform to stay in character. That’s dedication

Will judge myself when I start watching
 
mekes

mekes

Member
Stopped after 20 minutes. H.C seems okay as Geralt but I wasn’t enjoying it. I may try again another evening but first impressions were not good.

I am picky with TV shows so I don’t recommend looking to me personally for a gauge on whether you’d enjoy it or not.
 
Last edited:
Malakhov

Malakhov

Banned
mekes said:
Stopped after 20 minutes. H.C seems okay as Geralt but I wasn’t enjoying it. I may try again another evening but first impressions were not good.

I am picky with TV shows so I don’t recommend looking to me personally for a gauge on whether you’d enjoy it or not.
Click to expand...
No shit you stopped after 20 minutes. Man you don't want to waste any time do you? 😂

-How was yesterday?

-Tried to have sex with my wife but I stopped that shit after 2 minutes, it wasn't going anywhere
 
Last edited:
thief183

thief183

Member
So I watched 2 episodes.... at the moment I don't know what to say, The cast is ok I guess, Cavill tries really hard to be Geralt and it works, Ciri is ok, she is not as I figured from the books but I've been spoiled by the videogame.

Honestly I was hoping for something different and less Game of Thrones. The fight scenes are better than expected, they are really good so far.

The forced diversity is just BS and it makes all the lore become more "General Fantasy" than "Poland Fantasy". They could have the people from the south to make some new interesting black character instead of putting black ppl here and there (I mean there is a black elf.....).

For the rest is ok, I'm going to keep watching it.

(The Italian sub is sub par expecially Dendelion)
 
bronk

bronk

Banned
DeepEnigma said:
It definitely gets better from episode 4 on.

It reminds me of an R rated Xena/Hercules. That’s not a bad thing.

Almost done with episode 6. Cavill does a believable Geralt and grows on you fast. His swordsmanship choreography work is well done.
Click to expand...
Whaaaaa Xena/Hercules? I'm gonna fucking love it then.
 
VertigoOA

VertigoOA

Banned
Watching episode 1 now...

ummm he sounds like game Geralt a lot

like a lot!

Lol

edit: episode 2 ... loving this

he really sounds like fukkin geralt .
 
Last edited:
Falcs

Falcs

Banned
Finished episode 3. I'm loving it so far. But it's a bit confusing and hard to follow. The 3 main story archs occur decades apart from each other but the show doesn't tell you this. I'd expect new comers to be quite lost. Hopefully it gets easier to follow once all the main cast are together.
 
Halo is Back

Halo is Back

Member
On eps 5. Story is pretty interesting and Herny freaking nails Geralt. I’m glad to see the personality of the 3rd game come through in his performance.

My main big issue it that there are 3 main stories going on all at different times and I didn’t even freaking know this until someone on YouTube mentioned it. The show dose a poor job of conveying time and makes the story confusing for the half of the season until everything starts to mold together
 
Dark Star

Dark Star

Member
Just finished the season. I thought was pretty well-executed, despite some cheesy/campiness here and there, like the "goat monster" and other lame antagonists sprinkled throughout the story. You'd think with such a big budget they'd be able to make scary looking monsters lol, almost seemed like parody comedy at some points.

But the human costume design choices were usually pretty good. The casting choices were great (especially Anya Chalotra's Yennefer, and obviously Henry Cavill ... what a hunk). The last couple episodes kind of drag a bit, but the ending is perfection. I really enjoyed it, despite it's many flaws, but I REALLY hope they don't cancel it. Looking forward to season 2! I hope the main focus will be on Geralt's back-story, and less on the annoying, singing bard sidekick.
 
Last edited:
Great Hair

Great Hair

Banned
Overall disappointing.
He´s most of the time in the background waiting for others to finish their speech. We don´t see a real Witcher, nor do we see how they get made. At times this looked like a fetch quest Tv Show and the main quest gets ignored for 5 to 6 episodes (young girl).

He takes a nap for 2 episodes? and is when the show goes downhill starting at epi 5 or 6 with the utter boring mage-war-fight-fog-fireballs-Zzzzz. Nothing ya want to rewatch a second time.

Season 2 better be all about the WITCHER and ... less about nobodies, no one cares, who show up for 1x episode.

6/10
 
mekes

mekes

Member
Malakhov said:
No shit you stopped after 20 minutes. Man you don't want to waste any time do you? 😂

-How was yesterday?

-Tried to have sex with my wife but I stopped that shit after 2 minutes, it wasn't going anywhere
Click to expand...

I was going to give you the burning fire emoji but it was too far along the list to reach :messenger_tears_of_joy:

I’ll give the show another go soon. Will post back if I die trying...
 
PuppetMaster

PuppetMaster

Member
Binge watched the whole season.

I didn't like the first episode. But it got far better after ep2 when they introduced Yennifer and some other good characters.

Yennifer is the star of this show. Not Geralt. He was good but not good enough to keep me watching or carry the show on his own. But the actresses playing Yen killed it.

The weakest main character is Ciri. Really need to be improved for the next season. Or swapped for another actress.
 
Last edited:
Javthusiast

Javthusiast

Banned
ArtisticDistinctGodwit-size_restricted.gif
 
VertigoOA

VertigoOA

Banned
I don’t mind any of the characters. I can’t say I dislike anything really.

some of you disliked the man goat dialogue!? Was hilarious

Geralt: “Did your mom fuck a goat?”

:messenger_tears_of_joy:

I think I love this show.

That bard is Dandelion right? I didn’t catch a name but it had to...

The butcher if Blaviken fight in episode 1 was awesome. Fucking incredible sword fight.
 
Last edited:
Javthusiast

Javthusiast

Banned
VanEs said:
Oh Henry, you little scamp :messenger_tears_of_joy:

The show is pretty enjoyable. I have my qualms with it, most of it stemming from the usual books to tv/movie adaptation pitfalls. Some slight wokeness crept in but nothing too bad fortunately.
Henry Cavill is great as the witcher Geralt and Anya Chalotra has won me over playing Yennefer. She's also a total babe.
Click to expand...

Agree, and now that they set things up and have feedback etc. it can only get better in upcoming season 2.

I just hope they don't get discouraged by some reeeing journalists and remove the nudity. I actually am surprised by how much there was considering I thought the showrunner was a total sjw.
 
Last edited:
Whitecrow

Whitecrow

Banned
I'm fkn loving the show. I dont have idea about the games or books, but I dint the show amazing, even if there are a lot of things that are confusing me...
 
VanEs

VanEs

Member
BibleBLACKED said:
Agree, and now that they set things up and have feedback etc. it can only get better in upcoming season 2.
Click to expand...

Not having to incorporate three books (consisting of short stories and a main arc) into one season should definitely help. I expect it to be a lot more focused.

BibleBLACKED said:
I just hope they don't get discouraged by some reeeing journalists and remove the nudity. I actually am surprised by how much there was considering I thought the showrunner was a total sjw.
Click to expand...

Dunno if she's a sjw, but if she is at least she's not a sex negative one that's for sure :messenger_winking:
 
Croatoan

Croatoan

They/Them A-10 Warthog
DeepEnigma said:
Jodie Foster in that gif? She was 17 at the time of the interview, and that was her facial expression when she was asked if there are any men in her life.

Don't project your own thoughts into a joking meme conversation. That is for you to deal with, not us.
Click to expand...
I was talking about the ciri girl and cavill not Jodie Foster...

Not sure what you are getting your panties in a twist about?
 
PaddyOCanager

PaddyOCanager

Member
I really liked it. Plenty of flaws I can nitpick but for a first season it did the job for me. Henry Cavill did great imo - I was really rooting for him going into this and I think he pretty much nailed it. Looking forward to Season 2.
 
Teletraan1

Teletraan1

Banned
Was never a fan of Cavill as superman but I really enjoyed him in this role. Pretty solid first season, hope there isn't too long of a wait for season 2.
 
P

Pidull

Member
Best job Cavill has ever done acting, as far as I'm concerned. Voice and delivery are almost always perfect.

Really well done minus providing viewers with a timeline. I would have preferred they started the show with Geralt's unintentional surprise claim.
 
Last edited:
Hozzicus

Hozzicus

Neo Member
Overall I enjoyed it and i'm happy that season 2 has already been green lighted. Some of the Geralt scenes gave me flashbacks to Hercules: The Legendary Journeys. As far as casting goes, I'm fine with most of the liberties they took except for Triss which I think was a huge miscast.
 
GreyHorace

GreyHorace

Member
Welp. Just finished it. Last two episodes were okay even though they thoroughly changed the plot of the last two short stories. Really felt they should have gone the episodic route and let us follow Geralt's adventures rather than rushing us into the novel saga. Some thoughts:

- Not a fan of Geralt being present during the fall of Cintra. The writers completely missed the point in the books about Geralt refusing to take Ciri and fulfill the Law of Surprise. He didn't want to get involved in the war and it was only mere chance (or destiny) that he and Ciri found each other once more.

- Having them meet at the ending for the first time completely robbed us of one of the most heartwarming scenes in the book. Geralt first met Ciri in Brokilon forest and refused to take her then, which he feels guilty for because he thought she died at Cintra. So his surprise to find out she's alive on the farm was one of the few happy moments in his life. The show's version doesn't have this emotional weight and feels flat. It also makes Ciri's journey to Brokilon completely pointless.

- The battle of Sodden Hill was alright to see. Obviously the showrunners did what they can with the limited budget that they had. Still, nice to see a prominent background event in the books given some screentime here.

- Geralt meeting his mother. One of the few scenes that's actually loyal to the books. Well acted by Henry Cavill, especially when he recounts what he endured to become a Witcher.

So, overall I thought the show was alright. But it did suffer in terms of plot and characterization whenever the showrunners deviated from Andrzej Sapkowski's text and added stuff that they pulled out of their own ass. A lot of the scenes and memorable characters that made the stories special are missing here. Henry Cavill was great as Geralt but I think Anya Chalotra really stole the show as Yennefer.

Hopefully in season 2 they stay truer to the stories, but I'm not holding my breath. I give the series overall a 6/10.
 
Last edited:
Keihart

Keihart

Member
Wached the first episode, that was pretty great. My only complain it's the Nilfgardian armors, they look like garbage.
Geralt is on point.
 
Wunray

Wunray

Member
I really liked the show, the whole three different time line thing was confusing but I caught on eventually. Truth be told I wish there was more monster hunting. Everyone played their roles quite well, especially yenifer she was the stand out in my opinion cause I expected Henry to be a good geralt. I'd give this show an 8.5. Btw that sword wielding mage seems kinda op when you think about it.
 
Hozzicus

Hozzicus

Neo Member
Keihart said:
My only complain it's the Nilfgardian armors, they look like garbage.
Click to expand...

Absolutely agree! Its just so strange looking given the context. I've only ever played the video games so I'm not sure how its described in the books but I think it would have made more sense in the world if they kept the original black plate mail.
 
Kev Kev

Kev Kev

Member
should i watch this?

i never played witcher, although i own witcher 3. it looks good but im just wondering if i should play through the game first then come back and watch the series or if it doesnt matter.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Blue Eye Samurai (new Netflix anime) is incredible.
2 3 4
188
15K
SirTerry-T replied
LTTP : The Walking dead (all seasons/spoilers)
Spoilers
19
1K
Badlucktroll replied
"Netflix Has Created A Self-Fulfilling Cancelation Loop With Its New Shows"
2 3
112
6K
Fake replied
What can Ghost of Tsushima learn from Red Dead, The Witcher, and Spider-Man 2?
47
2K
Gojiira replied
.....why did nobody notice The Witcher 3 - PS5 port was a glitchy mess?
2
51
4K
Xtib81 replied
Top Bottom