Support NeoGAF

[ethomaz]

WINNERS

Spoiler

5. Red Dead Redemption 2 (92,391)
4. The Last of Us (147,826)
3. Zelda Breath of the Wild (157,065)
2. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (230,978)
1. Grand Theft Auto 5 (295,651)

Thanks S siekro1983 for sharing the video.

 

[killatopak]

Good list.

 

[AV]

An AI could have come up with that list, they genuinely needn't have even had a poll.

 

[siekro1983]

Here are the winners you might want to add to your OP. I trust this list way more then metracritc which gave Mario odyssey a 97. As a open world game GTAV is much then zelda or witcher 3.



5. Red Dead Redemption 2 (92,391)

4. The Last of Us (147,826)

3. Zelda Breath of the Wild (157,065)

2. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (230,978)

1. Grand Theft Auto 5 (295,651)

 

[ethomaz]

Here are the winners you might want to add to your OP



5. Red Dead Redemption 2 (92,391)

4. The Last of Us (147,826)

3. Zelda Breath of the Wild (157,065)

2. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (230,978)

1. Grand Theft Auto 5 (295,651)

I added the winners in spoiler when created the OP.

 

[ethomaz]

Good list.

The poll was probably done before Death Stranding

 

[HelpYouFall]

No Dark Souls cause this world is full of casul scrubs who never made it past the two Gargoyles.

 

[siekro1983]

No Dark Souls cause this world is full of casul scrubs

it's kinda of sad, because Bloodborne and sekiro are perfect games besides not being 60fps on consoles. causals love there open worlds.

 

[HelpYouFall]

it's kinda of sad, because Bloodborne and sekiro are perfect games besides not being 60fps on consoles.

 

[Aion002]

it's kinda of sad, because Bloodborne and sekiro are perfect games besides not being 60fps on consoles. causals love there open worlds.

All we can do is hope that the Ps5 will give them the boost they need.

 

[MasterDerico]

I disagree with all 5 listed.
People need to go deep on games, leave the surface.

Of course the majority who voted are casuals, so the top 5 is mainstream games.

 

[Dane]

I disagree with all 5 listed.
People need to go deep on games, leave the surface.

Of course the majority who voted are casuals, so the top 5 is mainstream games.

The chad casual gamer vs the virgin hardcore gamer.

 

[ethomaz]

I disagree with all 5 listed.
People need to go deep on games, leave the surface.

Of course the majority who voted are casuals, so the top 5 is mainstream games.

All the games are pretty deep.

 

[Daymos]

Ok ok.. I'll give witcher 3 another try!

 

[ethomaz]

Ok ok.. I'll give witcher 3 another try!

It won’t work if your issue is the same as mine

 

[GamerEDM]

only game missing from list is call of duty modern warfare. Great list!


/s

 

[PhilipDoesMatter]

Bloodborne is the definitive experience of the decade. These casuals ...

 

[Arachnid]

Bloodborne should be up there, and there are a few I'd switch around, but good (if obvious) list.

 

[Heimdall_Xtreme]

FAIL of list If they dont incluided Gravity Rush 1 and 2

 

[Ingeniero]

Good list.
GTA V was cool and very appealing to casual gamers, so no surprise it won.

 

[GymWolf]

All the games are pretty deep.

I mean, combat in almost all of the games in that list is subpar, and i'm being gentle.
Gta5 and rdr2 have shit aim and cover system and input lag (less on pc obviously) and you are almost forced to use the shitty autoaim becaude the game is balanced with that in mind, zelda melee combat is the most basic shit ever, combat in witcher 3 is mediocre at best and even if you have signs and potions and stuff, even at the hardest difficulty powered-up queen is almost all you need to fuck people up...and tlou at the end is a realistic tps without a huge deep combat...

They are not exactly the pinnacle of GAMEPLAY in VIDEOGAMES.

They are lucky because some other aspect are great in these games, gameplay tho? Nah...

P.s. and i love 3 games out 5 in that list, not really an hater of mainstream games.

 

[MasterDerico]

ethomaz

Deep in games search. Try and find other games that is not in the surface.

And yes, those games are deep...like a puddle!

 

[MasterDerico]

The chad casual gamer vs the virgin hardcore gamer.

So gratuitous man, no personal offense please, here is not gamefaqs...

 

[Deleted member 774430]

Pretty much what i thought, it's an accurate top 5 if you look at reviews, sales, gamers reception.

 

[SimonGosejohann]

The Last of Us is a joke. rest ist ok. exchange last of us with mario odyssey.

 

[Fake]

No Bloodborne? I'm offended. At least Witcher 3 and TLOUS is there.

 

[manfestival]

I totally respect that list. I havent played breath of the wild but I know how much people love it. I would find it hard to counter GTA 5 being the game of the decade. It isnt my personal favorite but I can certainly give the nod to it.

 

[Heimdall_Xtreme]

GTA V for me at least the main cast have a horrible personality... How can I say it?... Odiosos? Heavy blood?... When you dont like the personality of the characters.

 

[cabbage5k2]

So gratuitous man, no personal offense please, here is not gamefaqs...

... have you not read the threads posted here in the last week or so? This place can almost be more autistic than gamefaqs sometimes, and that's bloody saying something.

 

[StormCell]

Cry cry cry. Complain complain complain.

Just because your favorite game isn't most people's cup of tea. Do y'all ever get tired of dogging someone else's favorite game?

It's about fun. GTA is fun. BotW is fun. Bloodbourne is not fun for everyone. There are lots of games that aren't fun for everyone, but apparently anyone can jump into GTA and BotW and have fun!

 

[DonF]

Mmm I understand...its been a cinematic decade. It makes me kinda sad. I still enjoy more arcadey games, but the thing that gets the best reviews now is the cinematic presentation so I cant blame devs for going for that market.

I agree with the list, but I'm not happy.

 

[Flintty]

A fair list, I’m glad BotW is on there.

Sad that Xbox let me down but it’s a true reflection of their output.
I need to give Witcher a go on Gamepass!

Maybe one day I’ll borrow a Playstation and give that zombie game a go.

 

[DunDunDunpachi]

IGN fans really like open-world games.

 

[Diddy X]

I don't agree with the list so I'm angry.

 

[JokerMM]

No Dark Souls cause this world is full of casul scrubs who never made it past the two Gargoyles.

THIS

fucking casuals

 

[Bumblebeetuna]

A fair list, I’m glad BotW is on there.

Sad that Xbox let me down but it’s a true reflection of their output.
I need to give Witcher a go on Gamepass!

Maybe one day I’ll borrow a Playstation and give that zombie game a go.

If you mean LoU, just watch it on YT. Gameplay wise it’s pretty meh. Or maybe you mean Days Gone.

 

[Great Hair]

Zelda Best of the Worst is a joke. rest ist ok. exchange Zelda BOTW with Skyrim of 2009 aka Fallout 3.

 

[Birdo]

Not a bad list.

I'm SOOOO glad BOTW wasn't number 1.

 

[Werewolf Jones]

Show me someone who has played the first Witcher game. I'll wait.

Only GTA V and BotW deserve it.

 

[Bathtub Fart]

No Dark Souls cause this world is full of casul scrubs who never made it past the two Gargoyles.

That's generous. Most probably didn't even make it there.

 

[Flintty]

If you mean LoU, just watch it on YT. Gameplay wise it’s pretty meh. Or maybe you mean Days Gone.

Yeah I meant The Last of Us

 

[anthraticus]

No Dark Souls cause this world is full of casul scrubs who never made it past the two Gargoyles.

Guess you missed the part that said it's an IGN poll ?

 

[siekro1983]

Guess you missed the part that said it's an IGN poll ?

Each one of those games is critically acclaimed and loved by most gamers. Each one of the has sold over 15 million. Games that challenge the player to get better just dont have the same appeal.

 

[brap]

Awful list. I feel like I've also seen the same list a million times.

 

[waltyftmus Prime]

No Bloodborne, Fuck ignorance.

 

[Vawn]

I have two issues with the Top 5:

1. There should be From Software games on the list.
2. There should not be non-From Software games on the list.

 

[siekro1983]

I have two issues with the Top 5:

1. There should be From Software games on the list.
2. There should not be non-From Software games on the list.

Fromsoftware easily makes the best games, but from a average gamer perspective they are very hard to get into. I bought dark souls on ps3 played for 30 minutes, and said this game looks like shit and was janky, and kept getting killed, never played the game again. Then I tried bloodborne got clerk beast and got owned I like was wtf I have start over the level and have no blood vials didnt play again for a year then I kept on hearing how great it is, and went back to it and fell in love with fromsoft after but a new player getting into there games it's not easy because god damn was it hard.

 

[HelpYouFall]

Guess you missed the part that said it's an IGN poll ?

Found the DEX guy

 

[Vawn]

Fromsoftware easily makes the best games, but from a average gamer perspective they are very hard to get into. I bought dark souls on ps3 played for 30 minutes, and said this game looks like shit and was janky, and kept getting killed, never played the game again. Then I tried bloodborne got clerk beast and got owned I like was wtf I have start over the level and have no blood vials didnt play again for a year then I kept on hearing how great it is, and went back to it and fell in love with fromsoft after but a new player getting into there games it's not easy because god damn was it hard.

Judging by your name, they're hard to spell too.

 

[Stiflers Mom]

but apparently anyone can jump into GTA and BotW and have fun!

Fuck, what's wrong with me?