• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Rumor from Chris Avellone: Avowed has already lost multiple lead devs/designers

CitizenZ

Banned
"Xbox just released the most technically advanced game on console"

Benny Hill What GIF
 

coffinbirth

Member
Dude has been shit talking Obsidian for years and years now.

Grain of salt.

That being said, Obsidian upper management is a giant bag of dicks, so it's possible.
 

R6Rider

Gold Member
How do you define a “fanboy” here? Does criticizing a company mean you are a fanboy for another company? What exactly is the distinction?
Not sure. I was called a fanboy by multiple "Xbox sided" users for calling the 13 minute gameplay reveal of Scorn boring and not very good. One of those users in particular already got triggered in this thread and came to MS rescue.

Really you see it from both sides, but many users try to hide it.
 

tsumake

Member
I don't need to do anything, I'd said what I said the negative nancy is the guy who writes such dumb responses towards me. Seems like I hit the nerve today.

Are you saying that big corps like MS buy smaller devs, set them up to fail, then “intervene” to look like the good guy? That’s crazy talk!
 

MonarchJT

Banned
Expected, in the sense I believe many of the private studios that sold themselves to MS were doing it purely for the cash.
this is one of the behavior that is admitted on this forum and post after post create a false narrative. I report you ... for the stupidity and ignorance and the little respect for software houses.... of your comment
 
Last edited:

Roberts

Member
So what do you do in flight sim?
I will actually try to answer this one seriously, especially because you clearly didn’t want it to be answered.

1) It helped with my irrational fear of flying and as someone who loves traveling to all parts of the world, this is the big one.
2) I crashed into the house I am living in. I also crashed into mount Fiji, that Jesus statue in Rio as well as other famous landmarks.
3) It gave me a chance to visit places I will never get to visit.
4) It taught me the basics of how airplanes work.
5) it left me in awe, reminding me how beautiful this planet is. Of course, I can get the same feeling by watching one of those Attenborough docs, but here I choose my own content.
6) Soon I will be able to get that Top Gun experience and it is going to be glorious.
7) It calms me down better than anything after a long, stressful day at work.
 

MonarchJT

Banned
Either that or it's a sign that MS might have poor studio management. Drew Murray, from the Initiative, is already back with Sony at Insomniac Games
have i to tell you how many from SSM naughty dog and other are still in the initiative ? lol some people have still no idea of how this industry works
 
Last edited:

Black_Stride

do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
Inarguably? No. There are many things that other games are doing that Flight Simulator isn't.

But which games are more technically impressive.
Whether a game has SSS or an RTGI implementation while Flight Sim doesnt isnt whats happening, we are taking the whole game as a technical marvel........which games do you know that are more technically impressive.

And before you comment make sure you know what you are talking about watch the dev logs and update logs for Flight Simulator.
 

Hobbygaming

has been asked to post in 'Grounded' mode.
have i to tell you how many from SSM naughty dog and other are still in the initiative ? lol some people have still no idea of how this industry works
It's all just speculation but it's not out of the realm of possibility that there's some shaky management happening behind the scenes with this studio or others
 
Last edited:

Godot25

Banned
I don't know
Fact is, that Obsidian sometimes had a problems with upper guys and project scope.
But on the other hand Avellone is so bitter towards Obsidian and his relationship with Urquhart is so broken, that it could be only one part of truth...
 

kyoji

Member
this is one of the behavior that is admitted on this forum and post after post create a false narrative. I report you ... for the stupidity and ignorance and the little respect for software houses.... of your comment
Dude i hope u get banned mods need to get rid of people exactly like YOU.
 

Teslerum

Member
It's all just speculation but it's not out of the realm of possibility that there's some shaky management happening behind the scenes with this studio
Leads have changed (Roughly at that) and shaky management is definitely happening.

That said, this has been going on since the studio's inception 17 years ago, so for all we know this could have been still smoother than most Obsidian titles. What matters is how much time and polish the game will receive towards the end with its development, which is presumably going to be better with Microsoft supporting.
 
Last edited:

sobaka770

Banned
That's such an easy bait for console warriors, and for what - a game we know almost nothing about?

I don't have an Xbox and have no interest in Gamepass or other MS stuff but if they want to start releasing good games outside of Halo (although the verdict is still out there on Infinite), Forza and Gears - I say let them at least show something before piling on. I know nothing about Avowed, or Hellblade 2 or new Fable. I don't even know anything about Starfield! This whole new age of marketing shows us so little of actual gameplay, even some of Sony demos while much more in-depth usually omit the UI, progression systems etc..

I'm much more concerned about speculation and hype based on nothing but studio name and another shoddy CG trailer that is released way early than Avellone comments. Maybe those leads were shuffled for the benefit of the final product cause Deadfire wasn't it (although it seems Grounded has a niche).
 
Last edited:

Godot25

Banned
It's all just speculation but it's not out of the realm of possibility that there's some shaky management happening behind the scenes with this studio or others
Jesus
Murray lost his brother. And he was design director at The Initiative with plenty of responsibilities.
So he quit and took lesser role at Insomniac (Principal Designer) so he can get his life back on track. It's pretty much obvious when you were reading his twitter at the time of his departure.

His departure was for sure sudden, because he was in dev diary in december and left studio in January

But nope. Some people need to have tinfoil hats.
 

azertydu91

Hard to Kill
It's all just speculation but it's not out of the realm of possibility that there's some shaky management happening behind the scenes with this studio or others
Yes it is a possibility and it is also a possibility that it impact the game positively since we've seen nothing on the game.
Like if a shake up was announced a 343 a few years ago it would've been badly perceived, now in hindsight maybe it should've happened(considering their solo reveal).So let's wait until we see more to know if it is a bad thing or not.
 

MonarchJT

Banned
It's all just speculation but it's not out of the realm of possibility that there's some shaky management happening behind the scenes with this studio or others
sure is not out of the realm of possibility that there is shaky management anywhere in the world ... if we want to be honest.
 

Bernkastel

Ask me about my fanboy energy!
It's all just speculation but it's not out of the realm of possibility that there's some shaky management happening behind the scenes with this studio
Speculation without anything to back it up. Avellone is just reposting that rpgcodex theory about Carrie Patel somehow replacing Chris Parker in Avowed. It has nothing to do with anyone leaving Obsidian
Now what do their LinkedIn tell about who is replacing who?
Anyone whose willing to do the LinkedIn homework
I didn't find anything about anyone in senior position leaving Obsidian.
 

kyoji

Member
That's such an easy bait for console warriors, and for what - a game we know almost nothing about?

I don't have an Xbox and have no interest in Gamepass or other MS stuff but if they want to start releasing good games outside of Halo (although the verdict is still out there on Infinite), Forza and Gears - I say let them at least show something before piling on. I know nothing about Avowed, or Hellblade 2 or new Fable. I don't even know anything about Starfield! This whole new age of marketing shows us so little of actual gameplay, even some of Sony demos while much more in-depth usually omit the UI, progression systems etc..

I'm much more concerned about speculation and hype based on nothing but studio name and another shoddy CG trailer that is released way early than Avellone comments. Maybe those leads were shuffled for the benefit of the final product cause Deadfire wasn't it (although it seems Grounded has a niche).
💯
 

Leyasu

Banned
Neogaf. “Fucking clowns on Ree cancel/condemn everyone on nothing but unproven rumours “

Neogaf. “Oh Microsoft you fucked up and badly managed this. It’s all your fault for buying the studios. We are very concerned by this unproven rumour”

Same people as usual
 

Bernkastel

Ask me about my fanboy energy!
I am not surprised by this. Let's be honest the owners got a lot of money, got replaced, now everyone may feel down. They quit or are removed, the environment gets worse. New management tries to keep things afloat, but the mindset is set now.
Do tell me which senior Obsidian dev quit or was removed?
 

The_Mike

I cry about SonyGaf from my chair in Redmond, WA
We don’t know is MS is involved or not. Why are you in such a rush to absolve them, and blame Obsidian.
I guess we just blame Microsoft over literally anything here, but when there's other involved we have to see who to blame
Besides Microsoft.

Expected, in the sense I believe many of the private studios that sold themselves to MS were doing it purely for the cash.
aM7jEr4p_700w_0.jpg


Can't we get neogaf back instead of Sonygaf please.
 
Last edited:

Teslerum

Member
Speculation without anything to back it up. Avellone is just reposting that rpgcodex theory about Carrie Patel somehow replacing Chris Parker in Avowed. It has nothing to do with anyone leaving Obsidian
Now what do their LinkedIn tell about who is replacing who?

I didn't find anything about anyone in senior position leaving Obsidian.
Jorge Salgado (who was Lead Area Designer), others included.

Also what's your point with that Linkedin? Chris Parker has written Game Director on it for years and never updated and Carrie Patel has Game Director in 2019 because she was that for the OW DLC. And she is a Game Director CURRENTLY.



She's not on OW2, because that's Brandon Adler, she's not on Sawyer's Game. So, where please is she Game Director? Avowed. This isn't really a stretch.
 
Last edited:

GHG

Gold Member
Neogaf. “Fucking clowns on Ree cancel/condemn everyone on nothing but unproven rumours “

Neogaf. “Oh Microsoft you fucked up and badly managed this. It’s all your fault for buying the studios. We are very concerned by this unproven rumour”

Same people as usual

Interesting that you've taken offense to the condemnation of Microsoft in this thread rather than the various sustained attempts of character assassination on Chris Avellone throughout.
 

Bernkastel

Ask me about my fanboy energy!
Jorge Salgado (who was Lead Area Designer), others included.

Also what's your point with that Linkedin? Chris Parker has written Game Director on it for years and never updated and Carrie Patel has Game Director in 2019 because she was that for the OW DLC. And she is a Game Director CURRENTLY.



She's not on OW2, because that's Brandon Adler, she's not on Sawyer's Game. So, where please is she Game Director? Avowed. This isn't really a stretch.

By senior position I meant "leads" that Avellone was talking about.
They keep losing leads on that project
Also this whole Chris Parker-Carrie Patel thing is too much of a speculation to draw doom and gloom conclusions. This definitely does not look like being done by Microsoft either.
 
Last edited:

Teslerum

Member
By senior position I meant "leads" that Avellone was talking about.

Also this whole Chris Parker-Carrie Patel thing is too much of a speculation to draw doom and gloom conclusions.
I'm not drawing any conclusions. Especially because its part of Obsidian's history. Avellone is being disingenuous there considering he's been part of the same thing (Alpha Protocol). And compared to Alpha Protocol this has the advantage of being backed by Microsoft instead of the toxic relationship they had with SEGA towards the end.

For the actual game we don't know how it will turn out, for the problems yeah that might as well be.
 

Akhawi

Banned
obsidian hasn't made a good game since new vegas

Agreed.

Oh, except for South Park: The Stick of Truth

...and Tyranny

...and Pillars of Eternity

...and Pillars of Eternity II

...and The Outer Worlds

...and Grounded


But yeah, apart from them they totally haven't made a single good game since New Vegas.
 

supernova8

Banned
These things happen when you just go out and buy tons of studios....

Goals, culture and other things all need to be aligned to make sure the company doesn't fall apart.

Just look at Blizzard, it took longer but the bigger company slowly destroyed the culture of the smaller one.... there is always a dominant.
They can't even be bothered to sort out Halo. They are not going to give a flying fuck about Avowed or Obsidian.
 

ripeavocado

Banned
The source is believable, Obsidian has been known for mismanagement for years and it’s an overrated company, a shadow of its former self.

With game development becoming more and more broken it would’t be a news.
Most studios these days struggle to release games.
 

Black_Stride

do not tempt fate do not contrain Wonder Woman's thighs do not do not
Exactly

The last two are not good
The Outerworlds and Grounded are not good games?

Is this one of those if a game doesnt score 90/100 and/or isnt made by Sony then its not a good game things?
Cuz if its that sure okay.
Else get the fuck outta here saying The Outer Worlds and Grounded are not good games.
Miss me with that shit straight up miss me!
 
Top Bottom