• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GR: PS5 and Xbox Series are Neck and Neck for 2022 (Up: Nintendo lolz - post #273+)

Who will be crowned UK King of 2022?

  • Nintendo

    Votes: 40 34.2%
  • Microsoft

    Votes: 17 14.5%
  • Sony

    Votes: 60 51.3%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .

FoxMcChief

Gold Member
You jumped in yourself when I was replying to a known biased poster who made a list of games and services Sony released in 2022 that should have helped their sales performance yet he failed to mention that Sony were struggling to produce enough PS5 stock until a few months ago. You posted stock available as of today. I didn't claim there is no stock available today.
Stupid? Shopto are known for selling shit bundles at silly prices. I could find console only deals quite easily.
Also your the one who was claiming that it was a false narrative that PS5’s were in short supply in 2022. You then proceeded to post links to supply as of today as a rebuttle.
I think this is where both sides should have stopped. Both bias, so nothing was going to change anyone’s mind here.
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
Series S counts towards the Xbox sales numbers and that was not supply constrained all year, which is what I think people are arguing.
Series X stopped around mid-year, with PS5 getting plenty of stock shortly after.

But no one buys the series S right? It just sits on shelves.....

Or is that not true?

Not saying you claim this but I just need some Sony peeps to tell me if the series S is a success or not lol.
 
Last edited:

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
It's funny that the thread with the console war title is clipping past 150 posts.

The original thread regarding sales and this information got 3.

https://www.neogaf.com/threads/call...ber-uk-monthly-charts-sales-down-yoy.1647123/

Pretty crazy, mustn't be the news people wanted to see?
It’s all due to a lack of supply for PS5. I don’t think the series s has anything to do with the sales being neck and neck.

I'm so confused right now, there is supply of ps5...its been shown multiple times that since April the ps5 has been pretty much readily available for anyone who wants to buy it.

Is the ps5 flopping or something, I'm getting confused at what the message is here?

Microsoft just can't be succesful so the ps5 is flopping and the series consoles are flopping too? It makes 0 sense to me, becuase the xbox sales are tracking higher than any previous generation xbox. So it's successful right? Ps5 is succesful too. That's damn good.
 

Kagey K

Banned
It's Gamerants thread title.
It was nothing against you, I just was making an observation about how the thread is titled drives engagement, even if both have the same content.

Of course the other thread isn't just about the 20K gap between Xbox, PS and Switch, but also included some software information as well.
 

MilkyJoe

Member
Well you were quick to post that there is stock available today so you should be able to provide the same proof for the rest of the year?

Lol Shopto? The place where they bundle two games and a controller and charge a fortune?
Even the slowest person if stupid enough could buy a PS5 bundle from there.




 
Sony sold every unit they made instantly but couldn't produce nearly enough in the first six months of the year

Microsoft is selling a much weaker console (no shortages) for less than half the price... They basically gave them away for Black Friday

If it wasn't tight, it would be a disaster for Microsoft
 
Last edited:
Here's john Wicks original argument in response to someone being shocked at the closeness of the consoles for HOLIDAY SALES,

????
Sony can't make enough consoles to meet demand. So what difference are those games going to make for Sony genius?

Here's John Wick changing his argument by moving the goal posts to throughout 2022 instead of the holidays, while making numerous posts calling people out for proving his first argument wrong by claiming they don't disprove his new argument,

No lies detected.
So has the PS5 been readily available throughout the whole of 2022? Or are you basing this on the last couple of months?

Now you know why he panicked and mass posted in the thread.

The actual truth is as has been posted here by many users, the PS5 was easier to get during the Holidays. It was not impossible to find* as was originally stated by the above poster.

*In the UK
 
Last edited:

FoxMcChief

Gold Member
Sony sold every unit they made instantly but couldn't produce nearly enough in the first six months of the year

Microsoft is selling a much weaker console (no shortages) for less than half the price... They basically gave them away for Black Friday

If it wasn't tight, it would be a disaster for Microsoft

tenor.gif
 

Helghan

Member
More competition is good for us, hopefully Xbox takes the win which pushed Sony to do better, so Sony can win which pushes Microsoft to do better
 

Mr Moose

Member
But no one buys the series S right? It just sits on shelves.....

Or is that not true?

Not saying you claim this but I just need some Sony peeps to tell me if the series S is a success or not lol.
Would love numbers and split % for all of them, sadly this info isn't given. I'd imagine Series S accounts for at least half, if not more, especially for the first half of the year.
 
Pretty crazy, mustn't be the news people wanted to see?


I'm so confused right now, there is supply of ps5...its been shown multiple times that since April the ps5 has been pretty much readily available for anyone who wants to buy it.

Is the ps5 flopping or something, I'm getting confused at what the message is here?

Microsoft just can't be succesful so the ps5 is flopping and the series consoles are flopping too? It makes 0 sense to me, becuase the xbox sales are tracking higher than any previous generation xbox. So it's successful right? Ps5 is succesful too. That's damn good.

Xbox series consoles are more readily available in the UK than PS5 which is the main reason for the neck and neck sales.

All consoles should be readily available next year so I think we will get a clearer picture then.

Also we don't have the actually data on Series X sales compared to Series S sales, I think people need to stop jumping to conclusions and at least wait for real data. Look how many articles has been released saying Xbox outsold PS5 this year knowing the PS5 has had crap supply throughout the year, its all click bait.
 
Last edited:

MacReady13

Member
I mean seriously, who cares? Microsoft clearly aren't in the game to sell the most consoles. They've stated where they want to be in the game and who their main competitors are, and it isn't Sony!
 
Maybe he’s blown away because he’s read one of your posts where you claimed that barely anyone wants the Series S?

Nice try but I never actually said that. I've always said that Series S has regularly been underperforming relative to the purpose/intent of its design and release into the market at the time it was made available. It was meant to help bring in the mainstream and casual gamers who normally wait until the middle of the gen with price cuts to buy a new console, and get them to jump in early on.

Given that market intent, and considering where combined S/X sales are at, it's not doing that much in that goal department relative to what the typical person would expect. Series may be tracking ahead of XBO and 360, but not at the numbers you'd expect when one system was already placed at a mainstream, entry-level price point at launch and needed regular deals from the second half of this year to start moving more volume.

That is not the same thing as saying or even insinuating "barely anyone wants the Series S", so you must have me confused with someone else.

Ps5 has been in stock so much better this year. You have been able to buy them every time I've looked this year. Sure not every retailer has had them in 100 percent of the time but if you Google search you can find them in some place.

Supply was still massively lower than initial targets for the first half of the year. Supply only really started improving around some point in the start of Q3 (FY 2022 Q2 for Sony); here in America is when I noticed the supply was starting to finally improve around June/July period.

But basically, what you are saying is the series S is a genius little beast from MS because its allowed them to consistantly have stock and provide an option to buyers looking to purchase. ( even though no one buys them and they are just sat on shelves collecting dust, isn't that right Gaf?)

It depends on how you look at it. Sales for the S in the early half of the year weren't particularly strong; the months where Series won NPDs were due to Series X supply, not S, and we started seeing pricing deals, free game deals etc. for Series S around late July, which was...very weird, timing-wise. They may have improved sales from September onward, but at the expense of heavy subsidizations; if you knew where to look you could've picked up a Series S for $190 around the Black Friday period, and I saw several people talk about gift card stacking on top of that getting price down to $100.

Whether you see that as good or bad depends on how you look at it. Me? Well, for the person buying the system that's obviously a great deal. For a show of strength of Series S's value on the market, it's a bit of a bad sign because in order to move any serious volume, they seemingly need to time steep price cuts and deals around big holiday seasons and pushing the system into bargain bin pricing territory, which isn't that far removed from liquidation pricing. For a system that's only two years old, and considering the production costs on the system, it's a bit of a bad look.

Some people will try saying that the aggressively low pricing is a move to get more GamePass subs, but IMO that brings up a whole host of other potential problems that could be argue as examples of predatory pricing, which in itself could be viewed as an anti-competitive practice, but I'm not here to get into that topic.

The only thing i dont get about your comment is, what happens if people want sony exclusives....why would they pick up a series S? Somethings got to be inticing them?

???

Man unlucky, did you check all the usual spots? I picked up a ps5 yesterday from game with no game. Disk version in the middle of December with absolutely no issues for my father in law.

Edit: just checked and its still in stock


I don't know how this narrative that you can't buy a ps5 still exists. They've even said they've got to a point where stocks so readily available they can ship more for Japan.

So in this post and another post later in the thread you're throwing up screenshots of PS5 systems being available to discount the narrative that PS5s aren't hard to find but...the post I made that you quoted didn't say anything about PS5s being impossible to find. I never even claimed something of the sort.

My statement simply said, it's not surprising that two systems with generally lesser demand than PS5 are in close distance sales-wise to it considering one of those two, Series S, had heavy price cuts and promo deals for the past couple of months (maybe even more than that in some European countries), and where Series S supply over the course of the entire year was much better than PS5's. One big Sony 1P exclusive coming in the 11th month wasn't going to suddenly push PS5 sales far and ahead of whatever combination Series X & S had managed over the year, considering the UK is traditionally one of Xbox's strongest markets.

I said demand for the S and X is lower than PS5s, and that's true. That's particularly true if we're talking about innate natural demand. There's also demand that can form out of a need or where a preferred product may not be available, but a customer is still in the market for something, then they'll limit their options to runner-ups and that will be a purchase based on a different type of demand. For a market like the UK I'd say if PS5 natural demand is a 100%, Series X natural demand is probably around an 85% - 90% and Series S natural demand is closer to a 60%.

So if a system like Series S is the only one regularly available over the course of a year, starts getting more and more aggressive pricing deals/promos/cuts/offers as the year goes on, and generally benefits from more people from last gen looking to jump into current-gen even with a second or third-choice console, then Series S demand may increase some in those instances, say to 75% - 80% and that can start to make up some differences especially if a system like PS5 is heavily supply-limited for at least half of the year.
 

John Wick

Member
[/URL]

[/URL]

:pla-882619520147%7ccrid:587991330707%7cnw:u%7crnd:12821460141031819723%7cdvc:c%7cadp:%7cmt:%7cloc:9045999&utm_source=Google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=16586469281&utm_term=1259465&utm_content=shopping&utm_custom1=137424042631&utm_custom2=534-693-8244&GPDP=true&gclid=CjwKCAiAs8acBhA1EiwAgRFdwzgthAJb5Pe_3kDO-1L9AXg-6e7MuVfy7CK1oFMIbH62AqVSH8sTrxoCrNQQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds[/URL]

[/URL]
Blimey you were quick there SleepyJoe........... Have you got anything to add that hasn't already been stated since.page one?
 

John Wick

Member
Here's john Wicks original argument in response to someone being shocked at the closeness of the consoles for HOLIDAY SALES,



Here's John Wick changing his argument by moving the goal posts to throughout 2022 instead of the holidays, while making numerous posts calling people out for proving his first argument wrong by claiming they don't disprove his new argument,



Now you know why he panicked and mass posted in the thread.

The actual truth is as has been posted here by many users, the PS5 was easier to get during the Holidays. It was not impossible to find* as was originally stated by the above poster.

*In the UK
Here's Eddie making a fool of himself again. Was GT7 and HFW released in the holidays??? I'll let you work that one out genius.
So how does Holiday availability affect March and April Eddie???
No PS5 was severely in short supply in March and April compared to SERIES consoles.
 

Ozriel

M$FT
It depends on how you look at it. Sales for the S in the early half of the year weren't particularly strong; the months where Series won NPDs were due to Series X supply, not S, and we started seeing pricing deals, free game deals etc. for Series S around late July, which was...very weird, timing-wise. They may have improved sales from September onward, but at the expense of heavy subsidizations; if you knew where to look you could've picked up a Series S for $190 around the Black Friday period, and I saw several people talk about gift card stacking on top of that getting price down to $100.

You have no source for your claims that Series S sales weren’t pretty good. No source for your claims that only XSX supply drove Xbox Series elevated NPD performance.

The vast majority of Series S deals around Black Friday were at the $250 price point for the Holiday edition, a 17% discount from launch price 2 years after launch…certainly not the ‘steep discounts’ you’re claiming.

Any deal with gift card stacking would apply to everything sold in store and not isolated to the Series S, so It just seems like warz BS to try to paint a picture of $100 deals.

It's January already!? Ahh.

You realize what this says about your comprehension skills? quite the self-own.

Series s is 250 and some deals at under 200 in uk. And recently have being given away like crazy.

20% discount for a holiday promotion is ‘giving away’ now?
 
Here's Eddie making a fool of himself again. Was GT7 and HFW released in the holidays??? I'll let you work that one out genius.
So how does Holiday availability affect March and April Eddie???
No PS5 was severely in short supply in March and April compared to SERIES consoles.

Interesting how you left out GOW.

The poster was surprised that they would be neck and neck at all, those games should have helped Sony have a strong holiday season (PS5 was ahead before it) and now things are even closer now then they were before.

You keep shouting short supply but the only thing that really brought these consoles this close together was the holidays. It doesn't make sense to blame the current gaps on "march and april" that doesn't make sense. This is also your 4th post in a row in a single chain and you are freaking out over nothing.

The winner is decided by December as Chris posts, you're acting like Sony has already lost when his tweet doesn't even say that. In fact, Sony is still ahead right now looking at the tweets and the article, it's just closer so why are you getting all panicky about this?
 
Last edited:

John Wick

Member
I know. Just some clearly not seeing logic. So why fight that battle. After all, there is only one PS5 sku. Must mean there’s only one Switch sku too.
The Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra has many different SKU's due to Ram and Storage sizes. Do you think people think they are 3-4 different phones?
The PS5 and DE are the same console minus disc drive. The Series consoles are two separate distinct consoles. Clearly you've seen the logic now let Samsung and other phone manufacturers know they are selling completely different phones.
 

John Wick

Member
Interesting how you left out GOW.

The poster was surprised that they would be neck and neck at all, those games should have helped Sony have a strong holiday season (PS5 was ahead before it) and now things are even closer now then they were before.

You keep shouting short supply but the only thing that really brought these consoles this close together was the holidays. It doesn't make sense to blame the current gaps on "march and april" that doesn't make sense. This is also your 4th post in a row in a single chain and you are freaking out over nothing.

The winner is decided by December as Chris posts, you're acting like Sony has already lost when his tweet doesn't even say that. In fact, Sony is still ahead right now looking at the tweets and the article, it's just closer so why are you getting all panicky about this?
Why am I gonna include GOW when it released in November?
Sony would have sold more consoles when those games released if they had more to sell. Its not rocket science Eddie.
I haven't mentioned anything about a winner or Sony losing. I was just replying to DenchDekard who put out a dishonest take. After that it was all fun.....
 

yazenov

Member
Not that strange. PS5's are still in limited supply and fairly hard to find in the UK, without resorting to paying over the odds for bundled packages.

Xbox series consoles are readily available and have been for months. Plus, there have been deep discounts for Series S for Black Friday so it makes sense that Xbox will have a strong Holiday period.

While they may be close like you mentioned due to the PS5 supply issues and the deep discounts for the Xbox series S, their software splits doesn't really match their userbase numbers.

"57% of sales came on PlayStation formats (42% on PS5), with nearly 33% on the Xbox platforms and nearly 11% on PC"

Call of Duty Modern Warefare 2 sales splits including digital are overwhelmingly in favor of PS.

People are buying more 3rd party games on the PS platforms in addition to Sony's 1st party games.


Must be the Gamepass effect.
 
Last edited:
Why am I gonna include GOW when it released in November?

Because the user you quoted didn't say anything about April and March, and listed GOW?

Again, he was referring to the context of this article which was about the holidays. You brought up "throughout 2022" after the fact.
 

John Wick

Member
Because the user you quoted didn't say anything about April and March, and listed GOW?

Again, he was referring to the context of this article which was about the holidays. You brought up "throughout 2022" after the fact.
No that was one of the games he listed and he listed two more which released in March and April. Those games have a big impact on launch window. Those titles could have hade a big impact on moving PS5 units if more were available.
No he wasn't because why would he bring those games up or the newly released PS plus tiers service?
 

Woopah

Member
It's one console. Series S and X have different specs and huge price difference therefor two different consoles. Your opinion is the only thing that is asinine.
S and X are two models of the same console. Just like PS4 and PS4 Pro or 3DS and new 3DS.
It all kinda depends on whether the neck-and-neck determination is based on units sold or revenue generated. Because objectively the lowest priced item should always enjoy an advantage to volume sales due to mass-market accessibility, especially during holidays where the benefits towards impulse/gift buying are the strongest.
It's unit based. Price can be an advantage, but it's also one that Sony could use if they wanted to.
 
No that was one of the games he listed and he listed two more which released in March and April.

Your backtracking, he included GOW war, he didn't mention april and march so you had no reason to exclude it.

You also ignored the context and the point to the rest of his post.

Again this is all pointless because you're acting like the PS5 has lost the year when it's early December and there's still weeks left, and the PS5 is from the article and the tweets still ahead.

What multiple users were trying to point out to you, is that PS5 stock had improved and was not impossible or incredibly hard to find. The user you quoted, or the people who are quoting you posting pictures and links to available stock were not talking about march and april.
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
Do you think any other kinds of media devices have fans that argue over sales....

"...well you only sold your LG OLEDS this year because you did a black Friday sale!"

Waaaa waaaa like its a negative lol
 
Last edited:

Stuart360

Member
jesus guys, is it so hard for some of you to just accept both consoles are doing well?.
I mean there are numerous Sony guys in here basically insinuating that PS5 is doing badly, and thats why Xbox is so close. I mean they would rather suggest its that rather than admit that Xbox is doing well lol.

Grow up guys ffs.

Also last week i went into Leeds to buy a new controller and SSD, and Curry's and GAME both had PS5 and XSX on store shelves, and CEX had both PS5 and XSX available second hand.
 
I'd like to know the breakdown of S vs X

Hardcore gamers that hang around forums these days are myopic on these things with the whole holding back the generation narrative (which makes no sense so long as we're supporting 8th gen still), I'm guessing the Series S is doing serious heavy lifting in saving Xbox this generation, both in terms of the smaller die making for greater availability and selling to people who just wanted a 9th gen console and it was what they could get, in emerging markets, and as a secondary console to a PS5, which at half the cost more people might consider vs doubling up with an SX.

It's funny that Sony fans have been slating the series s for ages calling it pointless and a terrible deal and now it's "doing all the heavy lifting".

Maybe MS was right in making this console.
 
Series S was being given away with things like phone contracts for the past couple of years (it's how I got mine) so it's hardly surprising, they'll be giving them away with boxes of cereal next.
It would be interesting to see the breakdown of Series X vs PS5 only.

"Giving them away" lol. This has appeared numerous times in this thread lol. At first I thought people were joking but it's coming up that much that people seem serious.

I can bet you you overpaid monthly on a crappy phone which covered the cost of the series s.

Where can I get these mythical free series s? It's funny cus I remember when need first hit of the series s and people were mocking it.... And now suddenly it's a huge seller that's carrying the Xbox brand.

So I'm confused.... Was the series s a terrible idea for ms or not?
 
Last edited:

ANIMAL1975

Member
We are in December now.
Yes December the 10th, about time to get November sales, that's what everyone expecting _ it's the black Friday month!
So burying the information that should be the first topic/announcement, on a long dissertation about who's going to win the year 2022 in sales, just feels like a big spin to me.
 
Do you think any other kinds of media devices have fans that argue over sales....

"...well you only sold your LG OLEDS this year because you did a black Friday sale!"

Waaaa waaaa like its a negative lol

Even on TVs it would be absurd to compare the sales of a $2K TV vs a $800 one....

It's just stupid. And in this analogy the $2K TV is actually even more expensive because it's supply constrained
 

John Wick

Member
Your backtracking, he included GOW war, he didn't mention april and march so you had no reason to exclude it.

You also ignored the context and the point to the rest of his post.

Again this is all pointless because you're acting like the PS5 has lost the year when it's early December and there's still weeks left, and the PS5 is from the article and the tweets still ahead.

What multiple users were trying to point out to you, is that PS5 stock had improved and was not impossible or incredibly hard to find. The user you quoted, or the people who are quoting you posting pictures and links to available stock were not talking about march and april.
He mentioned three first party games which are system sellers. The first two didn't have that much of an impact because they released when the PS5 was in short supply. Therefor Sony could have sold more consoles in those months if not for supply.

I'm not acting anything. I'm confident enough that PS5 will outsell the Series consoles when all is said and done.

Over the last few months PS5 stock has improved hence why it has won NPD a few times. But PS5 sales have been hampered by short supply during the first half of the year. Remember Series consoles outselling PS5 in Japan for a week or two. Now why do you think that was?
 
Until you can go in and buy a PS5 anytime you want these stats are meaningless. Series S has been easy to find for most of the year and that counts towards this, Series X is still more challenging but easier to find than a PS5.
 

twilo99

Member
Until you can go in and buy a PS5 anytime you want these stats are meaningless. Series S has been easy to find for most of the year and that counts towards this, Series X is still more challenging but easier to find than a PS5.

No one wants a series s so it really doesn't count
 
Top Bottom