Meccanical
Member
Final Fantasy XIII-V Lighting Myself on Fire
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Square-Enix Q3/13: ¥5.7b/$61M loss amid console market, praises social/mobile/browser
- Thread starter Blablurn
- Start date
What if the town serves a purpose to the story?
Lufia, for example. You play the game and visit a few towns that are normal and happy. Then you happen upon a town that is completely decimated. Utterly destroyed. You can explore the entire thing if you want, but it's a wasteland. And it's intended to be, to show the power of the enemy you're facing.
Meccanical
Member
He'll probably say something like "a cutscene would have displayed that much better in a shorter amount of time" or something.
Prove me wrong worldrevolution pls
I don't like to judge people by their avatars but DAMN
ambientmystic
Member
Thanks for the reply mate. I had no idea Nojima-san was so instrumental in making FF X such a well directed game. I thought it was the Guch leaving after X that caused it all to go down the toilet.
Meccanical
Member
Gooch became kind of hands off with FF after FFV, besides VII and IX.
lunchwithyuzo
Banned
You do realise that if they decide to remake FFVII, the cost will cripple them right? They basically have to recreate a PS1 Jrpg's massive scale and content while not make it look like ass. Consider all of their output in the current generation couldn't even match FFXII's level of content, you wouldn't see any remake of the Ps1 FF any time soon.
that's the thing. people are always assuming ff7 remake is going to be this instant success that rakes in money. but the only people who want it are the people who played it when it came out. i'd wager to say most gamers these days either weren't alive when ff7 came out, or were too young to play it (3-5).
i honestly believe that it would not make any difference for square. it'd be a success, but it would hardly be a runaway success.
Yup but the gooch games this gen (BD, LO, TLS) were all better than ffxiii
So he being tjere def. Helped raising quality id say.
He is good at merging and acquring. have you give em that. I actually hope nintendo kicks iwata out to get wada yoichi.
RurouniZel
Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
If Square-Enix got to a point where they needed a buy out (FFXIV 2.0 bombs, vXIII bombs, LR: FFXIII bombs, KH bombs etc.), I see one of two scenarios.
1) SE merges with another company like Capcom or Tecmo-Koei
2) Enix divests from Square and Nintendo buys a majority share of Enix. Sony then buys a majority share in Square.
1) SE merges with another company like Capcom or Tecmo-Koei
2) Enix divests from Square and Nintendo buys a majority share of Enix. Sony then buys a majority share in Square.
I...never heard anyone credit RE4 for its pacing. I'm not even sure if its right to compare a survival horror to an RPG, as they both have different goals, audience expectations, and means of meeting those expectations. But the fact that towns help establish pacing doesn't mean that they are the only mechanic to do so. It's a concept that exists in films and novels, and as loosely defined a managing the tone from one point in the story to the next.
An action sequence can be exciting, and a character's speech can be dramatic, but if either of things goes on too long or begin to repeat themselves, they become boring. Final Fantasy XIII has a great battle system, but when killing monsters gets boring after an hour or three, then there's nothing else to do but to shut off the game.
One of the benefits of sandbox games is that the player gets to consume the game at their own pace. The developers have to worry less about doling out just the right amounts of action and exposition without boring the audience, because the player defines the game's pace to match whatever they feel like. In Skyrim they can go out and explore the wilderness. Eventually, exploration gets boring. So by then they decide to start killing some monsters, until fighting gets boring. Then they can go to town and sell things, learn about local lore, read books, and loot houses. Until that gets boring. Then they can get a quest to explore a side temple. By this point they're up for exploring the wilderness again. Repeat. This is how 70-hour games are born.
Some people don't see games as just something to "get through". They see the journey itself as something to be enjoyed. If the entire purpose of a game is to just see it finished, why bother having gameplay? Just give us an auto-play button then.
My main point remains the same, FFXIII lacked towns, and it's story, pacing, and world-building suffered for it. I enjoyed FFXIII, but not as much as past FF games, and I find it fun to compare them and figure out why. It makes it easier to articulate what made them enjoyable. It wasn't huge monsters or crazy weapons, but more subtler things, such as a ragtag cast of characters that exist not for their own sake, but to act as avenues of information for larger story concepts.
I agree
A FF7 remake is not going to reach FF7 numbers and is going to be hated by fans unless made absolutely perfect.
How about Goldenrod City?
2 is even more unlikely than a nintendo or sony buyout.
I dont think capcom or tecmo koei management would like to merge with SE seing how Wada yoichi won over control despite Enix was the company buying squaresoft
Great! I can use him with my Tabatasaurus Rex.
It's like you never played any game with a quest before ever. A town is a place for a player to go restock, get clues about upcoming dungeons and sidequests, and the odd piece of information about the story. But they can also be used as good story-telling points, like in FF2, when the Empire wipes them out.
What am I supposed to do, search Chocolina's pockets for the items I once lifted from bookshelves and pots?
Meccanical
Member
Some fans of current SE would find any reason to skease on Chocolina so while you may not want to, pretty sure some other people I have seen would.
>_>
lunchwithyuzo
Banned
Oh god no. I'd rather Nintendo went down in flames with Iwata than become what Wada's frankensteined SE into.
I dunno, I don't play Pokémon. :[
I'm an expert
Formerly worldrevolution. The only reason I am nice to anyone else is to avoid being banned.
What can I say, I like change. I like SE doin different shit. I like their output. /happyfan
Sucks if you aren't.
Sucks if you aren't.
Meccanical
Member
"I don't have any preference because SE are wonderful gods. All my body and soul are belong to them. May they whisk my worldly flesh to the cleansing fires and bathe my soul in the holy light of Toriyama Kami-sama. May Lightning be praised!"
I'm an expert
Formerly worldrevolution. The only reason I am nice to anyone else is to avoid being banned.
You have a million rpgs with towns and fetch quests and walls to spam x on to find a potion. Does it really piss you off that much they didn't use the same formula again for 13 lol?
I might be a fanboy for certain things but SE is not one of them lol. I just don't need the same shit for my entire life. Why Zelda and Mario and all Nintendo ips suck now.
Wow... I don't even... LOL. So all Zelda and Mario games have been the same eh?
I'm an expert
Formerly worldrevolution. The only reason I am nice to anyone else is to avoid being banned.
Not to go off topic, but their recent outings, you bet. That's my opinion, not a fact. Deal.
So you didn't play Galaxy or Galaxy 2, then.
I'm an expert
Formerly worldrevolution. The only reason I am nice to anyone else is to avoid being banned.
I did. Same collectathon but this time with bite sized linear levels with no chance to go off the rails. Just like 13! Lol
Boss Man
Member
Personally I think it's just easier to sell shit, linear games for $0.99.
I'm an expert
Formerly worldrevolution. The only reason I am nice to anyone else is to avoid being banned.
What did I say that was factually wrong? You choose something from a list to collect, and they put you in a predetermined playpen to go get it. The opposite of 64 or Sunshine. Well not as extreme as opposite, but def more limiting. In the end, minus the gravity, the same game. Let's see the next new leap. Or you want star/8 red/100 forever now?
Ether_Snake
å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®
An expensive new console with more expensive games will solve everything!
Now the whole industry can pull off a Sony!
Now the whole industry can pull off a Sony!
so after complaining about towns you are now complaining about how limiting is is to not have hub areas, uh...
I'm an expert
Formerly worldrevolution. The only reason I am nice to anyone else is to avoid being banned.
Er I was talkin about the actual level selection/design being limited, compared to the earlier entries allowing the player to explore most of each stage. I got nutin against hubs, but this is 4 hub Marios now. Change isn't allowed?
12 FFs with towns, 1 isn't allowed? Lol.
You mean sucks for SE. Because the Final Fantasy brand has been in a slow, inexorable decline and they don't know how to stop it. Only make it lose relevance faster.
I'm an expert
Formerly worldrevolution. The only reason I am nice to anyone else is to avoid being banned.
Haha it's gaf gaming side, I'm used to it. I never "lose" arguments because I only state my opinions and never attack others'.
Shrug, if I get games I like I'm happy. There's good SE games with and without the FF brand this gen.
Lady Bird
Matsuno's Goebbels
There's no problem with RPGs lacking towns and so, as long as they compensate with different pacing mechanics. But FFXIII does not compensate with different mechanics. Important systems were downright stripped for the sake of a story-telling ideal, the designers were completely clueless about the side effects their changes would create, and in the end, ironically, even the story-telling ended up suffering with this because it lost mechanics that were rich at improving immersion, forcing the clueless designers to throw all the side-details into boring recaps.
Novels are not that necessary for story-telling. Wikipedia's recaps of said novels are basically what the books would say, just condensed.
Well, everything you said was wrong, but more to the point, it's ignorant as can be. We're talking MARIO here. The series with the most variety of all video games ever. Do you want an FPS Mario? THERE IS one. Educational? THERE IS ONE. RPG? GOT THAT. ANY KIND OF SPORT? YEAH WE HAVE ALL OF THEM. RACING? YUP. Platforming? YOU BETCHA.
And here you are, bitching because the formula is somehow stale. Mario is all-encompassing. But let's pretend that somehow, your inevitably bitchy response "But I'm only talking about platformers!" is in any way valid. Understand, first, that I'm entertaining that more for when Jaxword comes along to argue with me than I am pretending anything you say is in any way valid.
Now, as I was saying Looking at JUST the platformers. You have literally shot yourself into a goddamn corner on this one. Sure, you can say Mario Galaxy is about collecting coins and stars and shizz, but then, you can also say ANY Final Fantasy is about collecting swords, fighting monsters and saving the world. Boiling a game down to its end goal is perhaps the most asinine form of appraisal of all time.
But beyond that, there's the hilariously incorrect claim that Mario Galaxy is 1)bite-sized levels and 2)somehow smaller than Mario Sunshine. Which is stunning, because Sunshine really DOES include "bite-sized" levels in terms of the levels without the FLUDD. What makes these levels noteworthy isn't length though, but difficulty. A platformer isn't about bloating the goddamn game with huge open worlds. It's about delivering a neat, tidy, platform jumping experience, which Mario Galaxy does.
Nevermind the fact that there are a plethora of courses between Galaxy 1 and 2 that are deviations from jumping in "gravity" as you so pin-headedly describe it, but about surfing around, flying on some bird thing, or rolling around on a giant marble. Forget all that for a moment and consider the fact that Galaxy delivers variety even as a platformer. There are huge differences between levels like Bowser's Castle and Purple Coins on Luigi. The Gusty Garden Galaxy isn't the same as The Perfect Run.
You know where this all shrivels up and dies and hopefully your posts with it, though? The fact that 13 wasn't meant to not have towns. They didn't CHOOSE to not include towns. They just fucked up so much during production that nobody bothered to make them. This is a game that HAD NO DISTINCT AGREEMENT UPON ITS FORM UNTIL AFTER THE DEMO CAME OUT. MERE MONTHS BEFORE THE GAME ACTUALLY LAUNCHED.
XIII is a horrible waste of potential and a foulup only overshadowed by XIV's magnificent crash shortly afterward.
Nothing about how crappy XIII is is some manner of styllistic suck. They didn't CHOOSE not to have towns, or back tracking, or a coherent plot, or the ability to turn left or right, or anything to that effect. They just plain screwed up.
Lady Bird
Matsuno's Goebbels
They even wanted for FFXIII to have western-like elements, but it was not possible because when they thought of it, it was too late in development to implement them. No matter how some might try to twist it, FFXIII's development was terrible, both due to company management and to the clueless game's direction.
I still remember one of the very first interviews for the game, where Kitase has said that FFXIII would revolutionize the progression structure of the genre, but it would still have "towns where you can buy stuff" (it was even supposed to have a political rank system that would change the dialogues of the NPCs, and Lightning's rank would be determined by the colors of her shoulder's armor).
Or when they were "considering" the idea of using the summon's vehicles outside of combat for traveling. Lol.
I still remember one of the very first interviews for the game, where Kitase has said that FFXIII would revolutionize the progression structure of the genre, but it would still have "towns where you can buy stuff" (it was even supposed to have a political rank system that would change the dialogues of the NPCs, and Lightning's rank would be determined by the colors of her shoulder's armor).
Or when they were "considering" the idea of using the summon's vehicles outside of combat for traveling. Lol.
Do you eat shit?
D
Deleted member 20920
Unconfirmed Member
I don't think SE can just split into Square and Enix separately. They're one single entity.
I don't think FFXIV bombing will kill them. It's the next set of games that will determine their future fate. They still have lots of cash I think.
They probably cut out loads of stuff after the development nightmare. I suspect much of the plot was removed from the point where the party goes to Gran Pulse. That felt like a mid game point and then we ended up with "We can do it!" repetitions for the second half instead of anything meaningful. For a game that was supposed to focus on story, the story felt really half baked and incomplete.
I feel Oerba is where the plot goes wrong. I mean, there are a lot of problems before that, but at that point it's painfully obvious. Because Hope is all "HEY WE SHOULD GO TO OERBA THAT IS WHERE ANSWERS."
And instead we get nothing but the villain saying "HEY WE NEED TO END THE GAME NOW BECAUSE REASON"
In an SNES RPG, that'd've been time for a second or third world map. In a PSX RPG that moment would've been a switching of discs. Instead it's a straight shot to a final dungeon, and it feels jarring, even with the rest of the game.
Blood Diamonds
Banned
Dear Square-Enix,
Fuck You.
P.S- TWEWY 2
Fuck You.
P.S- TWEWY 2
You said that Galaxy was the opposite of earlier 3D Marios, then two sentences later, you say it's the same?
Make up your mind!
They've been delusional for a very, very long time.
The only things that cripple them in the moment are their gigantic MMO turd that already cost them a fortune and is guaranteed to bomb when it finally sees the light of the day and on top if that the alienating of their fanbase with that piece of shit FF 13 and it´s successors.
When everything is said and done this generation they will not only have lost tremendous amounts of money, but also the last bit of benevolence from their old fans.