Aksys is partially to blame by creating this situation in the first place, pulling the watches from the games and now, apparently several months later, shipping the damaged ones anyway...
From what I can see they essentially forced Amazon to come up with a solution to a situation not conducive to how their system works thanks to the creation of the situation by Aksys themselves
Even then Aksys is not completely responsible.
They're not manufacturing the watches themselves. They're ordering some outside company to do them.
It's a total bummer that the fault was not detected any sooner but the actual manufacturer for the watches is really to blame for fucking up a whole bunch of watches in the first place.
I'm relatively sure that Aksys won't work with that specific company together again.
Pretty sure some people got fired because of that, too because these faulty watches mean a whole lotta money lost.
Now this is just how I see it, mainly because I did that kind of work before, so I'm speaking out of some experience with this.
It's just unfair to bash Aksys and only Aksys for this situation when they are only partially to blame, and even then it's really only the smallest amount they are to blame for, mainly because of their not exactly outstanding communication with the people who pre-ordered the game and the watch.
EDIT: Oh, and no, I don't think they forced Amazon to come up with a solution. Amazon emailed everyone beforehand that the watch will be shipped as soon as they get their batches.
Gamestop apparently shipped them without any problems at all, if people in this thread are to be trusted. They didn't do some shit like offering the watch for $600 bucks and sending out codes to reduce that price to $0.
Amazon created this shit. Instead of using their data banks to look who ordered what and simply assign those buyers a new $0-order that has only the watch they instead had to pull this ridiculous stunt for whatever reason. It's ridiculous and unprofessional for a big guy like Amazon to do something like this.
I can't see Aksys having any fault in how Amazon operates.