Amy Hennig: God Bless Sony for Supporting AAA Single Player; I Don’t Fault EA for Project Ragtag

May 23, 2018
554
708
250
#8
Well my opinion is Amy is spot on, single player games - even when they sell well - do not generate the money of multiplayers with plenty of microtransations, therefore you are possibly putting in more work for less reward. If you believe your only reward is the money you make. If you are more in line with the artist's thinking, your reward is to make a truly celebrated work of art. However, with this being a business, money talks so therefore you see less and less true AAA single player experiences. Sony puts their money where their mouth is, and takes bets on the single player.

Not one to rest on their ass though, Yoshida came out and said while he is happy with the company's SP success, he wishes they had more success on the multiplayer side. Since that is coming from the horse's mouth, I expect at least one division of one of their studios to be cooking something up in the multiplayer area. We already know TLoU2 will have multiplayer, and perhaps the return of Killzone (Not made by GG, who we can assume are concentrating on HZD2) or some such.
 
Dec 15, 2011
1,477
2,067
430
#10
As a fan of single-player games, this pleases me.

Related:
Shortly after the release of God of War 2018, GamesIndustry.biz had an editorial on why they believe AAA, big-budget single-player games is an increasingly difficult model to sustain in today's climate. I found it interesting reading:
GamesIndustry.biz said:
That very logic means Sony is presently operating on a level that's simply out of reach to most third parties. It's great news for Sony and its studios; but for those wishing that the commercial logic of single-player games will find a healthy balance, Sony's blockbusters are a false hope.
 
Last edited:
Sep 28, 2014
2,017
192
325
#11
It has been sad to watch the decline of the single player experience over the past decade or so. Luckily I believe Sony and Nintendo will never forget the importance of quality first party titles driving system sales so I don't think we ever have to worry about single player games going away completely, but they will probably become more scarce unless something drastically changes within the industry
 
May 24, 2005
38,422
1,457
1,320
#12
As a fan of single-player games, this pleases me.

Related:
Shortly after the release of God of War 2018, GamesIndustry.biz had an editorial on why they believe AAA, big-budget single-player games is an increasingly difficult model to sustain in today's climate. I found it interesting reading:
This is a good article, but I think he's not giving enough credit to the many 3rd party games that get put out from publishers that have a similar mindset to Sony. Rockstar with Red Dead 3, Bethesda with many of its games (FallOut4, DOOM, etc), CD Project RED with the Witcher 3 and Cyperpunk 2077 and so on. EA and Activision could do this too but they've chosen to go with shared worlds where your single player game is also a shared world/multiplayer game to generate profit.

I'd say Ubisoft has taken a cool approach to this gen by constantly sticking to their games and adding content which is cool. But the industry is fine with the way it is. We have to adjust to the fact that 80% of games will not be single player only or single player "FIRST" games anymore. Those companies above will still make them and Nintendo will too and that's good enough.
 
Aug 30, 2014
6,192
306
385
#14
As a fan of single-player games, this pleases me.

Related:
Shortly after the release of God of War 2018, GamesIndustry.biz had an editorial on why they believe AAA, big-budget single-player games is an increasingly difficult model to sustain in today's climate. I found it interesting reading:

Sony exclusives keep me firmly entrenched in their ecosystem. I'm still hoping they do another handheld because while I still have a massive Vita back log I want new games too. I picked up a new 2 DS to play some smt games and desperately miss my Vita every time I play them, Form and Function wise.
 
Last edited:

Killer751

Loves Nintendo. Owns Nintendog rescue shelter.
Jul 5, 2018
228
118
270
#16
"Sony supports single player!"

Yeah, single player movies.

As much as I don't like Nintendo, at least they try to give a little bit of variety in their offerings.
 
Likes: The_Mike
Feb 22, 2015
812
129
255
#18
Last edited:
#20
I do love single player games, sure I play online but sometimes you just want to play through a really solid story like Uncharted 4 or God of War (PS4) The Last of Us Part II will kick some ass as well. I feel like this is maybe why my PS4 gets more play time than my Xbox One, although I tend to use my Xbox One more for RTS type games.

I definitely agree Amy Hennig should be heading up a studio for Sony vs waiting for companies like EA to finally make good choices.
 
Mar 3, 2014
4,898
779
350
#22
As someone who prefers single player games , any dev that continues to put single player games at the forefront should be praised. The problem for me is that I personally have no interest in much of Sony's in-house single player games.
 
Aug 18, 2016
3,417
635
360
35
Michigan
www.geeksundergrace.com
#23
Well my opinion is Amy is spot on, single player games - even when they sell well - do not generate the money of multiplayers with plenty of microtransations, therefore you are possibly putting in more work for less reward. If you believe your only reward is the money you make. If you are more in line with the artist's thinking, your reward is to make a truly celebrated work of art. However, with this being a business, money talks so therefore you see less and less true AAA single player experiences. Sony puts their money where their mouth is, and takes bets on the single player.

Not one to rest on their *** though, Yoshida came out and said while he is happy with the company's SP success, he wishes they had more success on the multiplayer side. Since that is coming from the horse's mouth, I expect at least one division of one of their studios to be cooking something up in the multiplayer area. We already know TLoU2 will have multiplayer, and perhaps the return of Killzone (Not made by GG, who we can assume are concentrating on HZD2) or some such.
This is why I buy Sony and Nintendo consoles: the emphasis on AAA experiences that are not contingent upon multiplayer participation.

I have never purchased an Xbox, which is weak in the SP area.
 
Aug 22, 2014
221
260
300
#24
"Sony supports single player!"

Yeah, single player movies.

As much as I don't like Nintendo, at least they try to give a little bit of variety in their offerings.
yeah as long as you like all your characters coming from either the Super Mario universe or the Zelda universe there are a ton of great single player options with Nintendo.
 

Danjin44

The nicest person on this forum
Mar 22, 2017
4,409
2,775
355
#25
What I like about Sony is that they give me both quality western single player games and Japanese single player games and Nintendo also has fantastic first party and third party Japanese single player games. As long as this two keep giving me quality single player games then I'm happy.
 
May 24, 2005
38,422
1,457
1,320
#26
What I like about Sony is that they give me both quality western single player games and Japanese single player games and Nintendo also has fantastic first party and third party Japanese single player games. As long as this two keep giving me quality single player games then I'm happy.
They have all the incentive to keep giving those types of games too.
 
Jul 8, 2018
132
107
160
#29
An Amy Hennig penned Star Wars game would have been incredible and undoubtedly would have sold well. Such a waste of her talent to let it get cancelled. I heard she's gone indie. Is there any updated to anything she's working on?
 

Fbh

Member
Dec 6, 2013
9,515
1,080
545
#30
I’ll quit gaming if SP dies.
I'd probably still play some online games with friends every now and then

But yeah, If the day comes that good SP are dead gaming will go from being a hobby to more of a time waster when im bored and there's literally nothing better to do
 
Last edited:
Jun 13, 2014
3,786
664
345
USA
#31
The industry needs to figure out the financials of SP eventually. You can't have a massive aspect of gaming just fade like that.

Also, someone really needs to hire her. The fact that she's not holding grudges really says a lot.
 
Sep 25, 2012
1,950
660
440
#32
Weird she mentions Destiny clones. I wish that were an actual thing as I'm fairly fed up with Destiny, and not that optimistic about Anthem with the combat looking like trash. Only clone I've found was a iOS game called Shadowgun but even that isn't that great. I mean it's OK for phone but meh. The best part about that game is that they literally have an in-game casino so there's no doubt about whether you're gambling your money on MTX.
 
Last edited:
Nov 28, 2014
311
45
275
#37
But most SP games nowadays are open world and they are exactly what you are describing.
We hardly get linear SP games anymore.
Precisely why I buy few games these days. I'm opting for more games in the vein of Life is Strange and Until Dawn at present.

hmm its interessting how cd project red did manage to make an open world with very INTERESSTING quests instead of those basic fetch me quests you find in almost every other open world game..
Exactly. You sir....you get it. Not many devs can achieve this.
 
Dec 3, 2013
15,435
7,483
555
#40
PLEASE COME BACK HOME TO SONY! I'd make her a creative lead of a studio right now.
I actually took a survey that Square/Enix sent out last week. Was actually a pretty long and detailed one. One part had, "which series would you like for us to revive" (in so many words), and I put Legacy of Kain.

I also made mention to contract Amy Hennig again to revive it, etc., now that she is Indy.

I would be there day zero if that ever happened!

I’ll quit gaming if SP dies.
Same here.

Thankfully a lot of well done indie titles are out there for consumption as well.
 
Last edited:
Likes: mckmas8808