Support NeoGAF

[joe_zazen]

 

[DanielsM]

Surprised Days Gone hasn't surpassed Bloodborne yet (btw, both are my games of the cycle).

Now do Days Gone 2 and Bloodborne 2.

 

[Barakov]

Crazy that COD WWII outsold both BLOPS III/IV. Guess people really liked the return to WWII.

 

[joe_zazen]

I’m surprised at no gtsport and Naughty Dog being beat by Guerilla and Santa Monica and Insmniac.

 

[Geki-D]

RDR2? Man, that came out of nowhere. I mean, I knew it sold well but you barely heard about it anymore after like the first 2 months and everyone seemed to agree that the MP was a flop. Yet it's the second best selling of all time on PS4 in the US? Damn.

 

[Birdo]

No love for Gran Turismo in Americaland

 

[kittoo]

Horizon sold more than Uncharted? Damn!

 

[Doom85]

Surprised Days Gone hasn't surpassed Bloodborne yet (btw, both are my games of the cycle).

Now do Days Gone 2 and Bloodborne 2.

Bloodborne's had a few more years since its release to get some buyers here and there especially as the game's price lowered plus the DLC dropping probably brought in a few more people, while Days Gone isn't even a year old. Plus Days Gone is a new IP whereas Bloodborne is a spiritual successor to a popular franchise, Dark Souls, so it generally already had an established audience ready to check it out.

 

[DonF]

Surprising exclusives list. Good for Horizon and new IPs. I hope that Sony keeps delivering that quality and original IPs next gen..

 

[Mista]

Happy to see God of War and Spider-Man. Well deserved!

 

[Micolash]

RDR2? Man, that came out of nowhere. I mean, I knew it sold well but you barely heard about it anymore after like the first 2 months and everyone seemed to agree that the MP was a flop. Yet it's the second best selling of all time on PS4 in the US? Damn.

I would think if it wasn't that would be a pretty big flop all things considered.

 

[ethomaz]

No love for Gran Turismo in Americaland

GT never did well in US except when heavy bundled with every PS2 for a holiday.

Most GT games sold around 1.5-2.0m in US lifetime.

 

[thelastword]

Spiderman and God of War are absolute beasts, do you know how much Infinite warfare and those NBA2k games sell. Spiderman is above both and GOW is higher than 2k.

 

[StreetsofBeige]

Surprised: No FIFA?
Not surprised: GTA and Call of Dutys

Surprised: UC4 4th?......
Not surprised: ...... but other games came out later when there was higher user base to buy them

Surprised: Bloodborne still 5th when PS4 user base wasn't high when it launched
Not surprised: Days Gone 6th. There's around 100 million consoles now

 

[Lionel Richie]

Infamous Second Son is very underrated.

 

[Dane]

Surprised: No FIFA?
Not surprised: GTA and Call of Dutys

Surprised: UC4 4th?......
Not surprised: ...... but other games came out later when there was higher user base to buy them

Surprised: Bloodborne still 5th when PS4 user base wasn't high when it launched
Not surprised: Days Gone 6th. There's around 100 million consoles now

I think soccer is not that popular in US.

 

[MayauMiao]

RDR2? Man, that came out of nowhere. I mean, I knew it sold well but you barely heard about it anymore after like the first 2 months and everyone seemed to agree that the MP was a flop. Yet it's the second best selling of all time on PS4 in the US? Damn.

I think many of us love RDR2 not for the MP but for the SP experience. You can't judge RDR2 just from MP alone.

 

[Wonko_C]

I own not a single one of those games, both lists. Shows how far away from the mainstream I am and into maniac territory.
(No I don't like Souls-style games either, and I know they should be right up my alley as I like challenging games, but I just can't get into them.)

 

[StreetsofBeige]

I think soccer is not that popular in US.

Ah yes. Good point.

 

[C4lukin2]

It is weird to see that.

It is only like 5 great games, then you get into the rest of the library.

But those top 5. Were so great. But yeah it was not as impressive as I thought it would be.

 

[sn0man]

No love for Gran Turismo in Americaland

Man I wish a GT game came out in the US this gen.

 

[joe_zazen]

I think soccer is not that popular in US.

I think i read it is the #1 most played irl outdoor game in the us.

 

[mckmas8808]

RDR2? Man, that came out of nowhere. I mean, I knew it sold well but you barely heard about it anymore after like the first 2 months and everyone seemed to agree that the MP was a flop. Yet it's the second best selling of all time on PS4 in the US? Damn.

That's because after the game came out people created a narrative to try to bring the game down a peg. Truth is many people are still playing the multiplayer of RDR2 now.