• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Best TV Detective (series, mini-series, movie, et al)

Happosai

Happosai

Hold onto your panties
I nominate Columbo played by the late/great Peter Falk.
The series started from a late-60's movie and became a regular running series during most of the 70's. It fizzled out after the 7th season and was given a mini-series reboot in the late-80's which aired it's final episode (with a much older Peter Falk) in the early 2000's. Tact, humour, and an old Peugnot...that was Columbo.

What was your favourite TV detective series...etc?

 
Meowzers

Meowzers

Member
A Touch of Frost. A UK TV detective show back in the early 90's to late 00's. Always kept you on your toes like a ballet, and had good humour too.
 
teezzy

teezzy

Banned
Duckman!

mev-10483030.jpg
 
Last edited:
Happosai

Happosai

Hold onto your panties
pauljeremiah said:
Frist season of True Detective and Zodiac.

Also speaking of Columbo, as most people know Peter Falk had a fake eye but did Columbo have one? Or is that fake eye playing a real eye in the series?
Click to expand...
Columbo (the character) is never mentioned in any episode to have a fake eye (although, Peter Falk did have a glass eye). His first name is never revealed in the series either and the lack-of became a sort of running gag.
 
pauljeremiah

pauljeremiah

Gold Member
Happosai said:
Columbo (the character) is never mentioned in any episode to have a fake eye (although, Peter Falk did have a glass eye). His first name is never revealed in the series either and the lack-of became a sort of running gag.
Click to expand...

so you're saying that the fake eye was playing the part of a real eye in the series?
 
NeoIkaruGAF

NeoIkaruGAF

Gold Member
Cumberbatch’s Sherlock is fantastic and my pick for best recent detective (well, kinda, since the character is one of the oldest in the genre, lol).

But in the heart of an Italian born in the 80s it’s hard to top Columbo. That series was constantly on air in Italy until the end of the 90s, and the character is unforgettable.
 
Mistershine.

Mistershine.

Banned
In general list form:
Colombo
White collar
Magnum
Miami vice, series not film
Sherlock
Bergerac
Jonathan creek
Dirk gently
Twin peaks
Luther

Not sure if they count:
Person of interest
Lethal weapon TV series
X files
 
-Arcadia-

-Arcadia-

Banned
Cumberbatch Sherlock would be mentioned again and again in this thread, if Moffat hadn't utterly, thoroughly Moffated (tm) every season after 2. Right now, I get the feeling most people just want to forget all of the nonsense.

I don't understand why people do business with this man, without having an editor breathing down his neck. The slightest hint of success and creative freedom, and he flies off the rails.

I need to rewatch 1&2 and rediscover that love, though. What a show, while it lasted.
 
nikolino840

nikolino840

Member
Happosai said:
I nominate Columbo played by the late/great Peter Falk.
The series started from a late-60's movie and became a regular running series during most of the 70's. It fizzled out after the 7th season and was given a mini-series reboot in the late-80's which aired it's final episode (with a much older Peter Falk) in the early 2000's. Tact, humour, and an old Peugnot...that was Columbo.

What was your favourite TV detective series...etc?

Click to expand...

Is the only TV shows that we saw the murderer in the beginning of the episode?
 
DKehoe

DKehoe

Member
-Arcadia- said:
Cumberbatch Sherlock would be mentioned again and again in this thread, if Moffat hadn't utterly, thoroughly Moffated (tm) every season after 2. Right now, I get the feeling most people just want to forget all of the nonsense.

I don't understand why people do business with this man, without having an editor breathing down his neck. The slightest hint of success and creative freedom, and he flies off the rails.

I need to rewatch 1&2 and rediscover that love, though. What a show, while it lasted.
Click to expand...

It’s crazy how that show flew off the rails after season 2. Those first two seasons are excellent though.

Spoilers for the show:

There’s something kind of appropriate about how Sherlock “dies” and then the show keeps going. It’s like how Doyle killed off Holmes and then had to bring him back because of his popularity.

After that you’ve just got weird shit like Watson’s wife being revealed to secretly be some sort of special forces assassin and that there was a secret Holmes sibling all along. Considering how rabid the fans of that show are there’s something funny about it turning into something that’s like fan fiction.
 
-Arcadia-

-Arcadia-

Banned
DKehoe said:
It’s crazy how that show flew off the rails after season 2. Those first two seasons are excellent though.

Spoilers for the show:

There’s something kind of appropriate about how Sherlock “dies” and then the show keeps going. It’s like how Doyle killed off Holmes and then had to bring him back because of his popularity.

After that you’ve just got weird shit like Watson’s wife being revealed to secretly be some sort of special forces assassin and that there was a secret Holmes sibling all along. Considering how rabid the fans of that show are there’s something funny about it turning into something that’s like fan fiction.
Click to expand...

I don't know if you've ever watched the creator's run on Doctor Who, but the exact same happened there. Even the recent Dracula had an interesting first episode, and by the third, was an absolute mess.

Sherlock, and the stuff you mentioned, might be the worst example, though. Its amazing that somebody even committed this to paper, let alone decided to film it. And that multiple others agreed, and thought it was fine.
 
DKehoe

DKehoe

Member
-Arcadia- said:
I don't know if you've ever watched the creator's run on Doctor Who, but the exact same happened there. Even the recent Dracula had an interesting first episode, and by the third, was an absolute mess.

Sherlock, and the stuff you mentioned, might be the worst example, though. Its amazing that somebody even committed this to paper, let alone decided to film it. And that multiple others agreed, and thought it was fine.
Click to expand...

I think Doctor Who is a great example of how he’s a great ideas guy who needs someone reigning him in or filtering him. His episodes on Doctor Who before he took over as show runner are right up there among the very best the show has ever produced. But take the restrictions off so that he now has complete control of the show and it becomes directionless after a while.

The stuff I mentioned from Sherlock is something where I feel like I’m remembering it totally wrong and must be imagining it or mixing it up with some other show. It just feels so tonally disconnected from those first two seasons.
 
xrnzaaas

xrnzaaas

Member
Breakage said:
Castle

It's easy to watch.
Click to expand...
Castle was good for the first few seasons. I really hated episodes about Beckett's past and big crisises in the city and how the writers didn't want Castle and Beckett to be together. Heck, original plans of removing Beckett from the show's final season were like the ultimate insult to the fans of the show.
 
Last edited:
B

Breakage

Member
xrnzaaas said:
Castle was good for the first few seasons. I really hated episodes about Beckett's past and big crisises in the city and how the writers didn't want Castle and Beckett to be together. Heck, original plans of removing Beckett from the show's final season were like the ultimate insult to the fans of the show.
Click to expand...
I haven't watched it consistently, but I enjoyed what I saw. I heard there were difficulties between Nathan Fillion and Stana Katic.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Robocop: Rogue City | Review Thread
Analysis Review 3 4 5 6 7
320
20K
VinnyMac replied
Interview with Shuji Utsumi (SEGA Co-COO) by Japanese media outlet Seizo-Trend
Business Game Dev
1
1K
Unknown? replied
The "I survived development hell" club (7 years+) of games.
2
62
7K
Ozriel replied
On Uncharted 2's 10th anniversary, its developers look back on the making of a perfect sequel
2
73
6K
Sosokrates replied
  • Poll
John Carpenter Appreciation Thread/Favourite Film?
26
2K
LegendOfKage replied
Top Bottom