Support NeoGAF

[The Real Napsta]

I'm sure many of us have played more than our fair share of games with horses and more often than not they tend to be terrible with regards to their controls. I think it got to the point where it was just something to expect and very few games have really made it a joy to use.

And then Elden Ring came out and made me think about them once again. This game has given me very little reason to complain about it's design. It's quick to get on and off of it. It reacts exactly as I expect it to and I can even be right at the very edge of a cliff facing the drop and immediately turn around without it moving forward and making me fall. I think this latter part is really what tipped me off about how great it really is. It even traverses the landscape quite well and can take a decent fall.

The horse can even help you accomplish wild stuff like this:



Anyone have any actual complaints about the horse that I haven't noticed?

 

[Mossybrew]

Anyone have any actual complaints about the horse that I haven't noticed?

Well let's point out the elephant in the room - there's only one! No other mount skins, customization, etc, seems like a wasted opportunity.

 

[ParaSeoul]

Its alright. No inertia,feels like its missing animations. RDR 2 horses are probably the best we'll ever get.

 

[Mr Hyde]

From really nailed the horse riding. I was a bit worried at first because horse riding has never been fun, at least in the games I've played with them. The Witcher 3, Assassin's Creed, Zelda. It doesn't feel right. But in Elden Ring I'm using the horse regularly. My only complaint is the lack of customization options. I hope From gives us the choice for different skins. Maybe equipping it with more items etc.

 

[Codes 208]

Its just ok, good for traveling but getting stunlocked because the horse can only take a hit or two in a fight makes the combat feel like a gamble that i personally would prefer being on foot for

 

[Bernd Lauert]

Its alright. No inertia,feels like its missing animations. RDR 2 horses are probably the best we'll ever get.

RDR2 horses are the worst. I like the practicality of the ER horse. I don't want to play a horse riding simulation.

 

[ParaSeoul]

I don't want to play a horse riding simulation.

Fair but the thread was about how great the one in elden ring is as a horse mount,its not really up there tbh.

 

[Punished Miku]

It feels like a very arcadey horse. Just simple and easy movement. Its not really trying to emulate real horse movement but just control easily. Its almost the opposite in design philosophy to how the rest of the game controls. It works well and doesn't have massive issues with delayed inputs.

 

[.Pennywise]

Lol it's just ok. It's super arcadey. It doesn't excel in anything.

Are we already at the point where everyone starts sucking every cock on every aspect of the game no matter how simple it is?

 

[Sub_Level]

Nope. We can't talk about it.

 

[Aesius]

My only issue with horseback combat in Elden Ring is that you shouldn't get knocked off of Torrent unless he "dies." It's BS to get knocked off only to find out that he's still alive. I get that the horse shouldn't be able to tank hits until you personally die, but it's too easy to get knocked off.

 

[March Climber]

It has issues as mentioned above, and to add on to those issues it is a nightmare to platform with and the game constantly has moments that ask of you to do so. It's really slippery and especially imprecise which is the opposite of what you need when trying to carefully land on a ledge. Instead at times it will inconsistenly slip off or land facing a completely different direction and I barely even touched the left joystick. Oh and don't dare try to mount while near a ledge either. He tends to move forward a few steps sometimes when calling him out which can also lead to a death. One time I was standing still, called torrent out, and he burst into a full speed gallop instantly throwing me off of a cliff. There were multiple moments where I said "Yea, that's exactly what I wanted to do torrent" in a very sarcastic manner.

It is a good first attempt at a magical horse by From, but it needs improvement if it's going to be used for the next game.

 

[Zeroing]

"How dare you !!! It is not a horse, it is a magical beast. Also it has a name, Torrent" - me if I was a hardcore From Software fan

Lol it's just ok. It's super arcadey. It doesn't excel in anything.

Are we already at the point where everyone starts sucking every cock on every aspect of the game no matter how simple it is?

This !!!

 

[CZY]

Slow-walk is janky af

 

[Simpkin92]

I personally love the horse in Elden Ring and despised the horse in RD2.

 

[TintoConCasera]

Yeah, this goat+horse thing is very good for a game like this. It moves perfectly and the double jump makes exploring the overworld a breeze.

It would have been cool to be able to customize it, like I dunno, maybe adding some armor or something so he doesn't die so quickly.

 

[TexMex]

Yes and thank you for the thread. Looking at the front page I’m not sure where else we could have discussed!

 

[jaysius]

Do we need an ENTIRE thread for every single aspect of this game?

You’re not that important use the OT ffs.

 

[Robb]

I haven’t played it but it looks really great - fluid, quick and useful.

I’m hoping BotW2 takes some pointers because the horse riding in BotW did not feel great imo. I very very rarely chose to ride a horse in that game which feels strange to say about a Zelda game.

 

[Graciaus]

Its fun to use but breaks the combat. Unless you are in a small space it's easy mode to just do circles around them.

 

[The Real Napsta]

"How dare you !!! It is not a horse, it is a magical beast. Also it has a name, Torrent" - me if I was a hardcore From Software fan

This legit made me lol

Thanks for that.

 

[stranno]

Its alright. No inertia,feels like its missing animations. RDR 2 horses are probably the best we'll ever get.

Agro has been the best horse ever designed in a videogame since 2005.

 

[Captain Toad]

Its alright. No inertia,feels like its missing animations. RDR 2 horses are probably the best we'll ever get.

RDR2 horses are a nightmare. Fucking stop running directly into a tree you dumb stupid bitch-ass horse.

 

[zeorhymer]

Only thing the horse is good for is going over rot/poison ground. Totally sick of those levels.

 

[BossLackey]

For traversal? It's fantastic

For combat? It's pure and utter trash in the later game because Torrent doesn't get any kind of upgrade and just gets instantly killed by anything later on. Then you're on the ground for five whole seconds just hoping you're lucky to not get killed.

 

[NinjaBoiX]

Its alright. No inertia,feels like its missing animations. RDR 2 horses are probably the best we'll ever get.

Yeah, it does control well, in terms of doing what you want it to do in a fairly responsive manner. But it’s incredibly rudimentary in almost every other aspect, its not “impressive” as much as it is functional.

It’s basically just a graphical asset that spawns underneath you to modify your moveset, it’s far from a technical accomplishment.

 

[ethomaz]

Alright.

Some things Elden Ring's weapons are too heavy for their INT build.
Other do love the Elden Ring's horses.

I mean are these topics not covered by the OT?

https://www.neogaf.com/threads/elden-ring-ot-one-ring-to-rule-them-all.1631116/page-36#post-265709544

 

[ethomaz]

From really nailed the horse riding. I was a bit worried at first because horse riding has never been fun, at least in the games I've played with them. The Witcher 3, Assassin's Creed, Zelda. It doesn't feel right. But in Elden Ring I'm using the horse regularly. My only complaint is the lack of customization options. I hope From gives us the choice for different skins. Maybe equipping it with more items etc.

I'm not even sure to what tell you.

Horses are fun to control since well decades ago... did you tried Shadow of Colossus? Or Zelda Ocarine of Time? Or Uncharted 3? Red Dead Redemption 2? TLOU2? Or maybe more recently Breath Of The Wild, Metal Gear Solid V or Ghost Of Tsushima?

 

[Bartski]

My only complaint with the horse is the same one as with the animation with every other character in the game - its last-gen inverse kinematics system was clearly not designed to work on such a variety of terrain and elevation. (Edit: the game was initially way less vertical in early prototypes). So while it's super responsive and very "game'y" unrealistic, which here is obviously a GOOD thing, it's all jittery and a source of all kinds of bad collision and jank on screen. So while it feels great on the stick, it can look pretty bad at times. One doesn't contradict the other IMO, we're just not there yet. I hope we'll see that improvement in Elden Ring 2.

 

[SafeOrAlone]

I really appreciate that I don't have to get off my horse to summon people or interact with messages, as well as the fact that it controls easily. It's pretty frustration-proof.

 

[Mr Hyde]

Horses are fun to control since well decades ago... did you tried Shadow of Colossus? Or Zelda Ocarine of Time? Or Uncharted 3? Red Dead Redemption 2? TLOU2? Or maybe more recently Breath Of The Wild, Metal Gear Solid V or Ghost Of Tsushima?

I've played every game except RDR 2 and MGS 5, and yes, all of the horse riding sucked ass in those games. Shadow of the Colossus is probably the worst offender on that list. How you can call the horse riding enjoyable on that game is beyond me.

 

[Xeaker]

Darksiders 2 had already that kind of horse lol

 

[Danjin44]

Its just ok, good for traveling but getting stunlocked because the horse can only take a hit or two in a fight makes the combat feel like a gamble that i personally would prefer being on foot for

I would say its good against dragons but for every other boss, you better off on foot.

 

[ethomaz]

I've played every game except RDR 2 and MGS 5, and yes, all of the horse riding sucked ass in those games. Shadow of the Colossus is probably the worst offender on that list. How you can call the horse riding enjoyable on that game is beyond me.

Shadow of Colossus is probably the most realist horse unless it is really really well trained but that should be boring even in games.

BTW you don’t control Agro… she is independent… what you control is the man riding her that makes things even more fantastic.

 

[John Bilbo]

Yeah I like it.

But why no $10 horse armor though?

 

[Decontamination Silo]

Its alright. No inertia,feels like its missing animations. RDR 2 horses are probably the best we'll ever get.

#filtered

The mount in Elden Scrolls is truly the GHOAT

 

[Bartski]

Its just ok, good for traveling but getting stunlocked because the horse can only take a hit or two in a fight makes the combat feel like a gamble that i personally would prefer being on foot for

IMO is super OP as soon as you get a feel of the dash iframes and L2 and R2 weapon charge timing. It actually makes most situations easier to handle than on foot, it just takes a while to get into. I really haven't figured it out till very late game but once I did I started clearing out enemy camps on it, those big gold armored knights all over Lyendell are helpless against it.

 

[Ogbert]

It’s brilliant.

Low key the best thing about the game.

 

[DeceptiveAlarm]

The mount is awesome OP. The only game I've played with a equally cool mount system is probably guild wars 2. And that is only because there is more than one kind.

 

[Ghost of Caelid]

Well let's point out the elephant in the room - there's only one! No other mount skins, customization, etc, seems like a wasted opportunity.

Good, sometimes too many options becomes more annoyance than anything.

 

[-tetsuo-]

Its fine I guess. Not that much different than most other games I play with horses. Not enough for me to notice anyway.

 

[nemiroff]

It's kinda embarrassing but It took me about ten hours to realize I could dismount simply by pressing down on the stick..

 

[Antwix]

Well let's point out the elephant in the room - there's only one! No other mount skins, customization, etc, seems like a wasted opportunity.

Actually would've been cool if you could sacrifice/convert an armor set you already have to convert it into horse armor or something.


Anyways, I actually kinda dislike the horse combat. One of the very few things I dislike about the game. It just feels tedious to keep doing drive-byes then circle around....and keep doing it over and over.

 

[01011001]

Its alright. No inertia,feels like its missing animations. RDR 2 horses are probably the best we'll ever get.

if you want them to be realistic (aka. controlling like shit) then yeah

 

[Antwix]

It's kinda embarrassing but It took me about ten hours to realize I could dismount simply by pressing down on the stick..

Wait.... how were you getting off the horse without pressing L3 ?

 

[The Real Napsta]

Wait.... how were you getting off the horse without pressing L3 ?

Probably using the Spectral Seed Whistle

 

[MiguelItUp]

What the horse does, it does absurdly well. I wasn't expecting platforming with the horse to be as good as it is whatsoever.

 

[Boneless]

The horse is top notch.

 

[Yoboman]

It doesn't even have pooping animation

 

[Beer Baelly]

Not clicking on that vid