you know. of course different opinions are valid. you just have to express your opinion in a fair way. for example saying "this is talking simulator lol. i go here npc talk i go there npc talking wtf is this jhahahahahahajalkjfsl" is not the same as saying "i have no problem with games with a lot of dialogue. i just didn't find cyberpunk interesting"
because the problem here is not that the game is a "conversation simulator" the problem is you didn't like the conversations. the witcher 3 was a conversation simulator too and you liked it.
kinda suspect some of these people haven't really fucked with the witcher 3 like they are saying though. witcher 3 has undeniable acclaim so some peeps are lying and saying "well the witcher 3 was good though!" when they either didn't play it, or have like 30 hrs in it.
because too many of these complaints are pretty much within the design philosophy of the witcher 3.
so either these people were able to see the witcher 3 for what it was because it didn't have guns, cars, and a first person view.
or, *whispers* some of these people didn't really play the witcher 3 and didn't understand what this game was going to prioritize.