• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
  • The Politics forum has been nuked. Please do not bring political discussion to the rest of the site, or you will be removed. Thanks.

de Blob as a Representation of Communism

ckeur

Member
Nov 22, 2007
681
0
760
I am writing an essay for a game criticism course I am taking relating how de Blob conveys the idea of communism. Specifically, how does the game represent it, where does it succeed at representing this idea, and where does it fail. Lastly, we need to describe one of these failures or missed opportunities and describe how it could have been accomplished differently or better. I'd like to briefly describe my general direction and points and then would love comments mentioning some ideas I may have missed.

The comparison of de Blob to a communist society seems like a fairly obvious one to make. A single leader uses military might to enact a "War on Colour" by removing all elements of color from a once colorful world. I mention how this "War on Colour" can be seen as similar to the "Great Purge" enacted by Stalin, by which each leader is enacting their personal mission.

A major theme in communism is egalitarianism. This can be seen by the Raydians being turned into Graydians, where the INKT Corporation encases each citizen in a prison-like gray suit, hiding everyone from their uniqueness. They are seen doing monotonous tasks during cutscenes, unlike that which they did before INKT.

A key idea in de Blob is that of revolution, or resistance. Here we have the Colour Underground embarking on a Colour Revolution. I akin this to Tiananmen Square, arguing how the idea of revolution can be seen throughout history in such societies. I think it might be a good point to mention how many such revolutions have been publicized, or pushed I guess, by a key person or a few key people. Such is the case with Che Guerva, which can be linked to de Blob.

This is just the general direction that I am headed. What other connections can be made between the two ideas? Where does the game really fail the most in representing the idea of communism?

Lastly, we need to implement a game prototype that addresses one of these failures. One of the failures that I have noticed is how during gameplay, the army is only focused on you. They only care to try to attack you, ignoring that you have painted much of their town. They never send out Paintbots to suck up the color that you have painted on the town. From a gameplay perspective, this makes sense. I doubt it would be nearly as much fun if some AI character continuously undid the work you put time into. But as I am not critiquing this game for its 'fun-factor', but instead am looking at it by how it conveys a worldly idea, I feel this could potentially be a prototype idea. Basically the same type of game as de Blob, but with more of a military presence, attempting to stop you while at the same time continuously removing the color from the city. Any other ideas of shortcomings in representing communism that could be conveyed with a prototype?

Thanks :)
 

ZealousD

Makes world leading predictions like "The sun will rise tomorrow"
Apr 17, 2007
29,339
2
0
What you're describing is Authoritarianism, not Communism. You're not touching the Socialist aspects of Communism at all.
 

ckeur

Member
Nov 22, 2007
681
0
760
ZealousD said:
What you're describing is Authoritarianism, not Communism. You're not touching the Socialist aspects of Communism at all.

You are right. I've been looking into all the differences between the -isms to try and find what describes the game best. Communism, Authoritarianism, Totalitarianism, Socialism have been some of the ones that I have looked into.

You do bring up a great point, I do need to talk about the socialist aspects of the game. I believe I could argue that how INKT takes control over all major structures (called Landmarks in the game) could represent collective state ownership, as opposed to individual ownership.
 

Dascu

Member
Nov 24, 2006
13,568
0
0
Belgium
twitter.com
ckeur said:
You do bring up a great point, I do need to talk about the socialist aspects of the game. I believe I could argue that how INKT takes control over all major structures (called Landmarks in the game) could represent collective state ownership, as opposed to individual ownership.
Now you're stretching things.
 

pakkit

Banned
Feb 19, 2008
10,913
0
0
Richmond, VA
This is one of those essay ideas that I wish I had thought up of before you. There's interesting material. I'd try to interview some of the developers. They might laugh at you a bit, but I'm sure they'd give some interesting answers as well.

Dascu said:
Now you're stretching things.
You've got to take some liberties (lol) to truly develop the concept. INKT does control all of the major enterprises, including ones we think of as private corporations.
 

ZealousD

Makes world leading predictions like "The sun will rise tomorrow"
Apr 17, 2007
29,339
2
0
I haven't played de Blob, but everything you're describing sounds more like a standard military invasion. There was no revolution by the people here. The INKT weren't ordinary citizens that sparked a revolution of the proletariat. They're not trying to work in the best interests of the color blobs. They're just a bunch of dickholes that invaded and tried to take over their city and impose military rule.
 

ckeur

Member
Nov 22, 2007
681
0
760
pakkit said:
Is there any exposition of how the INKT invaded? I can't remember much, outside of the intro video.

Nope. The intro video pretty much explains it. They are said to be aliens, they arrive on a space ship and just begin to remove color from the world. At the end of the game, Comrade Black retreats to the space ship, which is holding all the sucked up color, and tries to leave the planet to send the color into a black hole. Blob gets on board, eventually fights Comrade Black, and then triggers an explosion on the ship which returns all the color back to the planet of the Raydians.
 

Haruspex

Banned
May 3, 2008
660
0
0
For me the INKT corporation are much more representative of fascism, although I haven't got far enough into the game.

I guess the INKT corporation could easily be substituted for the totalitarian state under Stalin, but Stalinist Russia was a million miles from Marx, Socialism, and the 1917 revolution as you can get.

I guess you're interpretation of de Blob will come down to how you perceive 'Communism'- is it an inherently authoritarian, homogenous society exemplfied by Stalinst Russia and other countries that emulated the model of 'socialism in one country'- because this is what most historians and politicians would love you to believe.

Or is 'communism' something more akin to what we witnessed during 1917- the masses of ordinary working people taking economic and social control and in doing so a flowering of culture and progressive values like the legalisation of homosexuality, abortion on demand, divorce on demand of either partner and an internationalist mindset against racism, sexism and homophobia. Of course all this was crushed by the impact of the First World War, the 'Wars of Intervention' which saw an invasion by over a dozen imperial armies, the counter-revolution and perhaps most importanly the failure of the revolution to spread throughout Europe, allowing Stalin and his idea of 'socialism in one country' to take hold.
 

ZealousD

Makes world leading predictions like "The sun will rise tomorrow"
Apr 17, 2007
29,339
2
0
ckeur said:
Nope. The intro video pretty much explains it. They are said to be aliens, they arrive on a space ship and just begin to remove color from the world.

Then that definitely isn't Communism. That's just an invading military force. Communism requires some sort of proletariat revolution, or at the very least needs to be formed by the people living in the country.
 

GaimeGuy

Volunteer Deputy Campaign Director, Obama for America '16
Jun 18, 2004
49,321
0
1,710
ZealousD said:
Then that definitely isn't Communism. That's just an invading military force. Communism requires some sort of proletariat revolution, or at the very least needs to be formed by the people living in the country.
.
 

cooljeanius

Member
Dec 7, 2008
7,511
0
750
GWU
www.facebook.com
I always thought that Blob and the color revolutionaries were the communists, because they were leading a revolution of the proletarian Graydians against the bourgeois INKT. Also, some of the challenges where you had to paint stuff red could be seen as communist innuendos, e.g. "Better red than dead" being a reversal of the saying "Better dead than red."
 

biggyfries

Member
Sep 2, 2006
1,489
0
1,125
ckeur said:
Nope. The intro video pretty much explains it. They are said to be aliens, they arrive on a space ship and just begin to remove color from the world. At the end of the game, Comrade Black retreats to the space ship, which is holding all the sucked up color, and tries to leave the planet to send the color into a black hole. Blob gets on board, eventually fights Comrade Black, and then triggers an explosion on the ship which returns all the color back to the planet of the Raydians.

Well, i guess i can stop playing now. thanks.
 

ckeur

Member
Nov 22, 2007
681
0
760
biggyfries said:
Well, i guess i can stop playing now. thanks.

Sorry, I assumed that a thread which is solely about the overall story would be assumed to have spoilers. Obviously too late, but it's been spoilered now.
 

Cygnus X-1

Member
Mar 7, 2007
4,626
40
1,320
Sigh.

Actually, before saying such things, you should read "das Kapital", von Karl Marx.
 

Chipopo

Banned
Jun 7, 2004
2,918
0
0
Based on the degree of comprehension you've displayedfor your topic, I suggest you take a dump, shmear it all over your teachers face, and hope for the best.
 

Zoc

Member
Aug 13, 2007
2,675
0
0
Communism is a specific system of government in which private property is abolished and "the people" share everything. In practice, this idea of sharing has never really happened. Instead, the invariably undemocratic Communist government has controlled everything.

Totalitarian government is a general term for any government that seeks total control over the economy and people's lives. It isn't really an "-ism" because it isn't a political philosophy. Totalitarian governments can be Communist, Fascist, Nazi, royalist, left-wing, right-wing, anything at all.

Authoritarian government is another general term that means any government in which all the power is concentrated in one place. Imagine the President, Congress, the Senate, and the Supreme Court were all one person. That government would be authoritarian, even if people and businesses were mostly free.

Anyway, I think of the above, "totalitarian" best fits De Blob's story, but an even better fit would be "colonialism." In Canada, for example, European invaders came in with advanced technology, stamped out local societies, and in the end, tried to erase Native peoples' culture completely. They stole children from the families, punished them for speaking their native languages and indoctrinated them in Christianity. Just the same as De Blob, only in real life there was no effective resistance.
 
Aug 9, 2008
2,505
0
0
I think this thread is all about tag fishing. :lol

OP just wants a communist De Blob tag.

That said though, far-fetched but good argument.
 

Proven

Member
Jan 19, 2007
7,241
0
0
One thing I like while reading through this topic, and GAF in general, are how the responses give insight to where everyone comes from. I've traveled a lot when I was younger, but still lead a relatively closed off life. I read these answers and see exactly the same structure that Americans, even friends of mine, would answer, except little differences that show the person's nationality or culture.

Despite having so many multi-cultural and immigrant friends that I hang out with on a consistent basis, I don't get to talk much about the way they see life. I should get on that.