lightskintwin
Banned
Based on Disney's past and how much they value China as a market, I'm pretty certain all the major characters, if not all of the characters will be ethnically Chinese.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Disney is struggling to cast its live-action Aladdin.
- Thread starter torre_avenue
- Start date
Based on Disney's past and how much they value China as a market, I'm pretty certain all the major characters, if not all of the characters will be ethnically Chinese.
Well that's what happens when the talent pool is kept small and isn't allowed to grow, you start to get slim picking.
Disney just need look harder and maybe be less fussy as only it's Aladdin, everyone knows that the real star of the movie is the Genie, though no offense to Will Smith but he will never top Robin William Genie.
Disney just need look harder and maybe be less fussy as only it's Aladdin, everyone knows that the real star of the movie is the Genie, though no offense to Will Smith but he will never top Robin William Genie.
sixteen-bit
Member
I had no idea he was 34. That's kinda old for Aladdin, right?
one of the funny complaints was that jlo didn't have a big enough ass if you can believe that.
lightskintwin
Banned
Will Smith doesn't need to top Robin William's Genie. He just needs to make the character his own like Robin did in the animated film.
No way. J.Lo's ass was bigger than Selena's. So much so, I remember J.Lo's ass was kinda distracting in the movie. LOL
Edit: On second look, they're about the same size. GOOD CASTING.
Honestly was my first thought
LilWayneSuckz
Member
I was thinking the same thing.
I mean, I kinda want this
Scott was born in London, England. Her mother, Usha Scott (née Joshi), is of Gujarati Indian descent from Uganda, and her father, Christopher Scott, is British
She isn't a bad actress either. I'd be totally fine with her.
Citizen_Insane
Member
Shit i'll do it
Dm me disney
Dm me disney
Don't think the UK ever occupied Russia for an extended period of time while raping their culture and women.
How about Irish then
Finaika
Member
Thisss!
JustSomeone
Member
If only they invested that much effort in casting Genie.
Will Smith? Really? What the fuck
Will Smith? Really? What the fuck
Germany and France did yet no one would complain about Michael Fassbender playing a Russian.
DarkLordMalik
Member
Zayn Malik as Aladdin
Freida Pinto as Jasmine
Freida Pinto as Jasmine
hodayathink
Member
To be fair, this happens for every high profile acting role. Look at the names that got tossed around for years for Captain Marvel. Or the Cable casting threads for Deadpool. All you need to do is vaguely look the part.
The point is they dont actively deny it happening. Even to the face of the survivors.
The Fatal Englishman
Member
I find it hard to believe that unknown actors wouldn't fall over themselves for the chance to be cast as the lead actor in a big-budget Disney movie, regardless of whether they have, historically speaking, had access to 'Hollywood avenues' or not.
The likely source of the problem is the sheer magnitude of the requirements for an actor to play the lead in what amounts to a live-action musical - and a beloved one at that.
Cosmic Bus
pristine morning snow
Utkarsh Ambudkar from Pitch Perfect and Mindy Project checks off every box they want aside from being in his early 30s, but he's got those boyish looks and he's playing a college-age character most of the time anyway.
milanbaros
Member?
I really hope they actually cast people around the right age (late teens/early twenties).
godhandiscen
There are millions of whiny 5-year olds on Earth, and I AM THEIR KING.
Read the article. They are looking beyond Hollywood.
nocturnalis
Member
Back in 2011 when Japan had the terrible earthquake/tsunami, he tweeted about it being revenge for Peal Harbor. Subsequently, he was fired from Geico and just about dropped off the face of the earth.
Sheila Vand who has Iranian ties and starred in A Girl Who Walks Home at Night could play an excellent Jasmine.
She is 32 but could easily play someone in their mid 20's. And Jasmine does not need to be 16 years old. If Emma Watson can play Belle then she can play Jasmine. Not sure if she can sing though, but Audrey Hepburn did not sing in My Fair Lady and nobody bitches about that performance.
She is 32 but could easily play someone in their mid 20's. And Jasmine does not need to be 16 years old. If Emma Watson can play Belle then she can play Jasmine. Not sure if she can sing though, but Audrey Hepburn did not sing in My Fair Lady and nobody bitches about that performance.
Ninja Scooter
Member
And play basketball.
CaviarMeths
Member
They should go super meta and cast an Asian, since it's theorized that the character was Chinese in the original story.
Jesus, what is with this guy and making jokes about horrible tragedies without even a time buffer. His 9/11 joke right after it happened got him in trouble too.
Jesus, what is with this guy and making jokes about horrible tragedies without even a time buffer. His 9/11 joke right after it happened got him in trouble too.
Markitron
Is currently staging a hunger strike outside Gearbox HQ while trying to hate them to death
Don't care who they cast, as long as Nolan North dubs him in the Blu-ray extra features. He was so convincing in PoP 2008. Also he won't need to sing, as Peter Andre can fill in for all the songs.
I think Will Smith is a good choice. The Genie and that parrot are the two characters that do not demand a Middle Eastern origin.
Will Smith is no Robin Williams but who is?
He can sing, rap, improvise. Seems like a good choice to me. I would love it if they got Gilbert Godfrey back but his past indiscretions may make that impossible.
Will Smith is no Robin Williams but who is?
He can sing, rap, improvise. Seems like a good choice to me. I would love it if they got Gilbert Godfrey back but his past indiscretions may make that impossible.
Yo, dude looks great
If the end credits isn't a new hot rap of Big Willie there will be hell to pay.
hodayathink
Member
I wonder if we can go a full 30 posts without someone suggesting that at 30+ year old play a teenager.
Contrary to popular belief, acting isn't something you're just born able to do. You train at it, you practice it, and you get better. Part of that training and getting better involves learning from the roles you take (and the people you meet during them) and carrying that into your next job. If the film industry had done a better job of creating minority parts, then more of these "unknown actors" would have the experience to show they are able to handle a part of this magnitude, or to learn from people that would help them be able to handle it, instead of Disney having to choose someone and hope they can pull it off. Not to mention that maybe more minorities get into acting in the first place, widening the pool you get to search from.
Contrary to popular belief, acting isn't something you're just born able to do. You train at it, you practice it, and you get better. Part of that training and getting better involves learning from the roles you take (and the people you meet during them) and carrying that into your next job. If the film industry had done a better job of creating minority parts, then more of these "unknown actors" would have the experience to show they are able to handle a part of this magnitude, or to learn from people that would help them be able to handle it, instead of Disney having to choose someone and hope they can pull it off. Not to mention that maybe more minorities get into acting in the first place, widening the pool you get to search from.
Chuck Norris
Banned
No one is on that level but he should be CGI anyway. Surely there is a voice actor out there with far more range than Will Smith
AgentOtaku
Member
Really? Rami Malik (some makeup to make him look younger) for Aladdin and Priyanka Chopra for Jasmine. See if there's chemistry between them.
lol, she's my age (34) and looks it
womfalcs3
Banned
A bit of make-up and they both can be made to look in their 20s. And I don't want to see a live action love story between two teenagers; times have changes. I don't want to see a father trying to marry off his daughter at 18.
I am sure there is someone out there, but with his range and starpower? It is going to be a CGI character obviously. Billy Crystal is probably the best emulation of Robin Williams you could find, but he is 15 years past his prime.
Sure there are more inspired choices then Will Smith, but I cannot think of someone offhand who would fit the bill better and has that level of star power. Maybe Jim Carrey. Actually definetly Jim Carrey.
NorthAndSouth
Member
Genuinely don't understand why they NEED to find an actor who is also an accomplished singer. Unless someone has been trained for the stage, they're just going to create downgraded versions of previous classics a la Beauty and the Beast and then ask the actors to lipsync to said downgraded version, which shall then be extensively edited anyways.
Just cast a good actor please who fits the role. The singing can be handled by actual professionals.
Just cast a good actor please who fits the role. The singing can be handled by actual professionals.
Razgriz-Specter
Member
Honestly i'd probably consider classic Genie in full CG and use William's replacement actor.
Yeah people will compare it like crazy and such but they will do that to literally anything that gets put out there as Genie.
I agree with this. As great as it is to have the actual actor singing, we have the technology to lip sync those scenes. I would prefer a great actor playing the character, and a great singer doing the songs.
Jamie Foxx would be a better fit for Genie.
