Final Fantasy XV should be #1, because I can't think of a single game that comes out this year that would be more disappointing if it sucks.
I can't imagine Quantum Break sucking, Remedy are a solid developer after all. It might be short though due to what I imagine are few project changes over it's life time due to the past few years of Microsoft/Xbox drama.
Honestly I think people who have very high expectations for FFXV, especially on GAF can be counted in one hand, figuratively speaking. And without high expectations, I don't think FFXV is going to disappoint much. I myself am still looking forward to the game, but I expect it to be just an okay game with some excellent aspects like graphics and music, better than FFXIII series overall, but that's about it.
Almost everyone is expecting the worse out of Battleborn. The only hype I see for it are from Borderlands fans. It might as well be #1 for "Top Ten Games in 2016 That Turned Out Good."
I think this list would've been better named Top 10 Games in 2016 we're very skeptical of delivering or Top 10 Games in 2016 we have major reservations about.but not any game can be one of the TOP TEN games that might suck