I disagree so, so, sooo much with that premise.
I love video games. I hated and was bored to tears at the same time by Harcore Henry. Your love for one thing has nothing to do with how much you'd like the other.
I feel like everyone who doesn't actually play a lot video games would immediatly make the connection, that gaming fans would have to love it - simply because it represents the stereotype of a video game so well. It has little to no plot, no character growth, no real dialogues, no taste - it's just a 13-year-old screaming "YEAH BRO! ACTION! ISN'T THIS AWESOME?! WOMEN IN SKINNY LEATHER SUITS! WHY? THE FUCK DO IT CARE?! HARDCORE!!!" in my ear for 90 minutes, without any finesse, any skill or sense for action.
Listen, I love action movies. The Raid 2 is one of my favorite movies of all time. Because the action scenes are absolutely incredibly choreographed and shot. The action is Hardcore Henry is none of these things. The shootouts are boring. They work exactly like you would First Person Shootouts expect to work. Henry shoots and someone a few meters away from him falls over. There is nothing interesting happen there. It's always the same perspective and thus, every shootout looks and feels the same. It's cool for the first 90 seconds. Then it's not.
The brawls are way, way worse. Because the first person camera makes it actually impossible for you to notice any kind of choreography. It's just people and hands and bodies flailing at the camera while the camera contionously shakes up and down and left and right and never gives you any time to actually process or understand who is where doing what. It's just motion. I heard comparisons to The Raid in a video a few days ago and that actually hurt my soul a little bit, because every little punch is so incredibly well directed and choreographed. None of that is happening in Hardcore Henry - or if it is, you cannot see it.
Worst of all, the movie betrays its premise over and over again. There are SO many cuts in the middle of fights or to end chase scenes. Henry is running away from a police officer, it feels like the chase is still on and then CUT and he is somewhere else and everything's fine. Henry is fighing a bunch of goons, punches one and CUT then is already in the process of punching another one and CUT is getting punched and CUT stands on his feet again. It actively goes against what the movie was trying to achieve with its perspective.
The plot actually made it worse, since the movie spends quite a bit of time on it and it's so incredibly boring. There is nothing there. Absolutely 100% nothing. There is a bad guy with superpowers. He is bad. Kill that guy. But the movie doesn't play with that stupid premise in a fun way, Crank-style, but treats it like any other movie would treat its plot. Like I should actually feel for the characters. And then there are all of these moments where the filmmakers just try
sooooo fucking hard to be HARDCORE! "Hey man! What would be Hardcore? Maybe, uh, women with swords in leathersuits? HARDCORE!". So Henry is fighting (in a brothel with tits everyhwere of course because thats HARDCORE!) and out of fucking nowhere those two leather-ninjas walk into frame, say two things and then proceed to do absolutely fucking nothing the rest of the film. I'm not kidding you: Someone sitting in front of me literally had this reaction when those women walked into frame:
The movie only ran for 90 minutes but to me it felt like more than 2 hours because it simply repeated itself over and over and over again. The cool scenes you see in the trailer? Those are ALL of the cool scenes. Pretty much EVERYTHING that's not regular punching and shooting is in that one trailer, which I found to look pretty cool. And that's really the impression I came away with: This First-Person-Stuff lends itself pretty well to a 2 minute trailer or even a 5 minute short movie. Turn it into a 90 minute movie however and it turns into an untter borefest. Not a fun, stupid movie. Just a confusing mess.