I love my Xbox One and I was never really disappointed with it. With that said, I had way more fun with OG and 360. The difference for me though is having a family now.
OG had so many great titles, 1st and 3rd party. Halo 1 and 2, Outrun 2, Shenmue 2, Splinter Cell series, Grabbed by the Ghoulies, Conker Live and Reloaded, Panzer Dragoon Orta, Fable, Ninja Gaiden, Brute Force, Riddick, PGR 2. So many hours of pure fun.
360 had many great titles too. Mass Effect, Gears of War 1 and 2, Halo 3 and Reach, Ninja Gaiden 2, PGR 3, Viva Pinata, Kameo, Fable 2, Braid, Halo Wars, Shadow Complex. Again hours and hours of fun. My total playtime in Halo 3 is 3 complete months!
And then Xbox One: Halo MCC and 5, Forza 7, Peggle 2, PUBG.
Of course those are not the only titles I've played, but exclusive wise I understand the complaints. Where are those franchises like PGR and Fable (I know rumors say a reboot is comming). The crazy thing is that I absolutely love all my time with Xbox One. My wife luckely don't hate games and likes to watch me play. She also love the One.
We even liked the Kinect 2.0, because it was handy to be able to control with your voice when holding a baby. I loved that it could 'scan' my face for ingame uses. Who doesn't wanna put his face on the hero or sporter? I was hoping for that being 'the future', but I was wrong.
I love the Xbox brand, but also buy other consoles. Is this generation the most disappointing? Depends on what you look at. But IP and exclusives wise I have to say "yes".
I'll buy the bext Xbox for sure and I'm hoping that MS is very busy to make sure they have a lot to offer with cool new games.
You listed God of War as being "God of War(derivative of numerous other game series and sequel to best selling PS franchise)", basically ignoring all the massive changes they made to the game. After 5 big selling entries they completely changed the camera and gameplay and MANY fans are not happy with it, it's like the next entry of Bayonetta playing like Dark Souls.
Is that not a risk?
Can you see MS doing that with Gears of War?
Also, what X1 game similar to Gravity Rush or The Last Guardian or Dreams or Until Dawn/Detroit?
Man I would love reboots of titles like Halo and Gears with a new perspective, but fans ars gonna go crazy.