I think about starting again every now and then, but my wife tells me she doesn't like the idea of it. She also freaks out whenever I tell her that I want to go get my ears pierced too though. Guys aren't "supposed" to do either of those things apparently. So I just let it drop.
I know it's easy to say for me as I'm not in your position, but: are you trying to look like how someone else wants you to look or do you go with what you like best? I read that you used some sorts of make up for an extended time before, so I assume you have a personal interest in doing so. Then go for it (again) if that's what you like; if that's what think will suit you or make you represent yourself in a way you desire.
The whole 'not being supposed to' is just as essentialist and harmful as the 'you should'-standard when it comes to applying make-up. Of course, you can choose not to do make-up anymore if you want to please your wife - and that's all fine if that's your choice - but I read your situation as one in which you are being rather limited if you 'conform' (i.e. leave out that which you desire to do; the use of make-up).
Also, the irony of your nick, hehe.