Support NeoGAF

[onken]

http://garaph.info/linecompare.html

Check either "HTML Table" or "HTML table - more detail".

Thanks, no idea how I missed that!

Dengeki PS sales Jan. 25 - Jan. 31, 2010:

01. [PS3] Resonance of Fate (Sega) - 115,441 / 115,441
02. [PS3] Ar tonelico III: Sekai Shuuen no Hikigane wa Shoujo no Uta ga Hajiku (Namco Bandai) - 89,927 / 89,927
03. [PSP] Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep (Square Enix) - 30,370 / 775,864
04. [PSP] Valkyria Chronicles 2 (Sega) - 22,667 / 113,438
05. [PS3] MAG: Massive Action Game (SCE) - 18,054 / 18,054
06. [PSP] Monster Hunter Portable 2nd G PSP the Best (Capcom) - 16,006 / 124,882
08. [PSP] Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha A's Portable: The Battle of Aces (Namco Bandai) - 14,535 / 95,084
08. [PSP] Shiren the Wanderer 3 Portable (Spike) - 10,195 / 10,195
09. [PSP] 11 Eyes: Cross Over (5pb.) - 8,683 / 8,683
10. [PSP] Dynasty Warriors 6: Empires (Koei) - 7,515 / 19,992

http://dps.dengeki.com/2010/02/05/p11624/

Seems like Dengeki didn't track the 360 version of EoE for some reason, hence the larger than normal difference.

 

[Chris1964]

I think for BbS, we might ultimately have to wait for S-E's next financial results to see what they eventually managed to ship. With the 3 trackers not only having totally varying sales figures, but also varying shipment estimates, it's a total mess. :lol

Ah yes, S-E and the accurate shipment method they have:

''DQIX is the best selling DQ. We shipped 4,2 million copies.''

One month later
''DQIX is the best selling DQ. We shipped 4,15 million copies.''

 

[duckroll]

Ah yes, S-E and the accurate shipment method they have:

''DQIX is the best selling DQ. We shipped 4,2 million copies.''

One month later
''DQIX is the best selling DQ. We shipped 4,15 million copies.''

Hey, at least they correct themselves!

 

[duckroll]

Seems like Dengeki didn't track the 360 version of EoE for some reason, hence the larger than normal difference.

Or maybe you need reading glasses...

 

[cvxfreak]

Obviously Dengeki is counting PSN sales for BbS too.

 

[onken]

Or maybe you need reading glasses...

Check the post I quoted

 

[cvxfreak]

Check the post I quoted

...I'm confused.

 

[Khrno]

Nvm, same game, different name :lol

My apologies.

 

[duckroll]

Check the post I quoted

Learn to read.

Edit: Since more than one person is blind, I will explain. Dengeki PS, as their name suggests, lists only the top10 Playstation family sales for the week tracked by Ascii. The Dengeki overall top10 was already posted above that. If you people bothered to use your eyes and brains to deduce what was going on, I wouldn't have to explain this.

 

[Ryu Hayabusa]

2. End Of Eternity (PS3) - 110,000

I think it's a good start for a new IP

 

[cvxfreak]

Learn to read.

Edit: Since more than one person is blind, I will explain. Dengeki PS, as their name suggests, lists only the top10 Playstation family sales for the week tracked by Ascii. The Dengeki overall top10 was already posted above that. If you people bothered to use your eyes and brains to deduce what was going on, I wouldn't have to explain this.

Hope you aren't referring to me. I'm just shocked onken insisted you go look at the post he quoted. :lol

 

[duckroll]

Hope you aren't referring to me. I'm just shocked onken insisted you go look at the post he quoted. :lol

No I was referring to the guy who posted immediately before my last post! :lol

 

[cvxfreak]

No I was referring to the guy who posted immediately before my last post! :lol

Ah. I actually saw that post. Ah well, the sadness that is F5/Command+R.

I think it's a good start for a new IP

I hope Heavy Rain does well too.

 

[Khrno]

No I was referring to the guy who posted immediately before my last post! :lol

Dude, I very well saw that it was a PS table only, but didn't know that Resonance of Fate and End of Eternity were the same game. So your edit do not apply to me.

 

[Road]

Looks like everyone who really wanted it got it for 360 already. Seems like the PSP might not be the backup console anymore (and possibly why 5pb is going 360-only for its future PC-ports).

The PSP port is selling the same as the 360 version (Famitsu):

[360] 11 Eyes: Cross Over - 10,022 / 11,317
[PSP] 11 Eyes: Cross Over - 10,100 / 10,100

 

[duckroll]

Dude, I very well saw that it was a PS table only, but didn't know that Resonance of Fate and End of Eternity were the same game. So your edit do not apply to me.

Ignorance is only another form of blindness!

 

[Spiegel]

I'll include this next week.

 

[onken]

Learn to read.

Edit: Since more than one person is blind, I will explain. Dengeki PS, as their name suggests, lists only the top10 Playstation family sales for the week tracked by Ascii. The Dengeki overall top10 was already posted above that. If you people bothered to use your eyes and brains to deduce what was going on, I wouldn't have to explain this.

Man sorry, long day :lol

 

[Chris1964]

I think it's a good start for a new IP

I had written

(Fake) Famitsu leak Jan 25-31

and from all numbers in this thread you quoted these?

 

[duckroll]

http://img702.mytextgraphics.com/sparklee/2010/02/04/7d3584306d7b121c57ca61ef9a33d133.gif

I'll include this next week.

Omg no! Now -I- am going blind. -_-

 

[Khrno]

Ignorance is only another form of blindness!

Fortunately, I can rectify my mistakes on my own without the need of any e-thugs.

 

[schuelma]

yeah ducky stop being a thugy

 

[onken]

Yeah duckroll, stop pointing out my stupid mistakes.

(I've been at work for 11 hours, leave me alone)

 

[Souldriver]

Man sorry, long day :lol

Don't be sorry, it was a honest mistake that got dragged along for almost half a page because no one simply pointed it out to you.

 

[mello]

Don't be sorry, it was a honest mistake that got dragged along for almost half a page because no one simply pointed it out to you.

An intimidating thread this has become. :/

 

[schuelma]

An intimidating thread this has become. :/

We demand perfection

 

[cvxfreak]

We demand perfection

HOW IRONIC

HAR HAR HAR

 

[Segata Sanshiro]

Don't worry Onken, duckroll makes mistakes, too. Like every time he recommends a game.

 

[ElFly]

Those Dengeki PS numbers fool me every week into thinking Sony has taken over japan.

But I realize my mistake way before hitting "Reply".

 

[Baki]

HOW IRONIC

HAR HAR HAR

OH SNAP!

 

[C-Jo]

If NMH manages to do 20k combined, Suda will be bathing with champagne and sleeping on a pile of ¥10000 bills.

 

[onken]

Don't worry Onken, duckroll makes mistakes, too. Like every time he recommends a game.

Stone cold :lol

 

[starship]

Congrats to starship and Brazil.

Results 	By Units 		By Points 	
1 	51000 	starship 		49,25% 	Brazil 	
2 	61000 	Road 		 	68,63% 	Kurosaki Ichigo 	
3 	81000 	Brazil 		 	70,25% 	ksamedi 	
4 	87000 	Kurosaki Ichigo 	74,46% 	Road 	
5 	91000 	Shadowlink 		86,24% 	C-Jo 	
6 	93000 	schuelma 		98,48% 	Chris1964 	
7 	97000 	ksamedi 		101,73% starship 	
8 	98000 	Durante 		108,72% schuelma 	
9 	101000 	Chris1964 		110,00% Rainier 	
10 	123000 	Takao 		 	121,36% Y2Kev 	
11 	126000 	RPGManiac 		123,46% gundamkyoukai 	
12 	131000 	MemoirsofMimi 	 	139,24% onken 	
13 	139000 	Nirolak 		142,54% Shadowlink 	
14 	141000 	Y2Kev 		 	142,65% ULTROS! 	
15 	143000 	LINK.AGE76 		172,56% Rpgmonkey 	
16 	148000 	gundamkyoukai  		172,97% jj984jj 	
17 	151000 	Rainier 		176,42% Takao 	
18 	153000 	Orgen 		 	179,21% Durante 	
19 	163000 	Aru 		 	180,74% Tailzo 	
20 	186000 	C-Jo 		 	182,46% farscape82 	
21 	186000 	onken 		 	186,42% Redroses 	
22 	196000 	Rpgmonkey 		188,48% mugurumakensei 	
23 	201000 	ULTROS! 		193,45% MemoirsofMimi 	
24 	210000 	baki 		 	193,94% LINK.AGE76 	
25 	212000 	mugurumakensei 	 	199,30% Aru 	
26 	223000 	faridmon 		209,49% KuwabaraTheMan 	
27 	253000 	Tailzo 		 	221,49% RPGManiac 	
28 	256000 	duckroll 		238,53% donny2112 	
29 	273000 	donny2112 		241,46% Nirolak 	
30 	299000 	Redroses 		245,22% Orgen 	
31 	299000 	jj984jj 		257,59% faridmon 	
32 	351000 	KuwabaraTheMan 	 	269,80% baki 	
33 	431000 	farscape82 		312,81% duckroll 	

01/25-01/31 	Sales 	duckr 	Memoi 	Duran 	Aru 	ksame 	Brazi 	donny 	farid 	mugur 	Tailz 	Raini 	baki 	RPGMa 	gunda 	Orgen 	farsc 	Redro 	Takao 	LINK. 	Nirol 	Shado 	Y2Kev 	Rpgmo 	ULTRO 	C-Jo 	Road 	jj984 	Kuro 	onken 	Kuwab 	Chris 	schue 	stars
NDS DQVI 	906000 	1000000 950000 	900000 	850000 	950000 	950000 	800000 	850000 	825000 	750000 	975000 	976000 	950000 	825000 	880000 	1250000 1150000 870000 	875000 	920000 	920000 	970000 	1000000 1000000 1050000 900000 	1100000 937000 	1000000 1150000 950000 	875000 	910000
PS3 EOE 	118000 	190000 	150000 	160000 	170000 	100000 	140000 	0 	210000 	185000 	150000 	165000 	193000 	125000 	150000 	170000 	135000 	130000 	160000 	160000 	170000 	145000 	150000 	170000 	200000 	120000 	140000 	175000 	153000 	160000 	165000 	140000 	125000 	120000
360 EOE 	27000 	80000 	65000 	60000 	60000 	30000 	30000 	0 	60000 	45000 	50000 	35000 	75000 	75000 	45000 	70000 	45000 	66000 	60000 	55000 	70000 	50000 	40000 	50000 	40000 	35000 	33000 	45000 	31000 	40000 	55000 	40000 	40000 	45000
PS3 ATIII 	82000 	45000 	65000 	65000 	60000 	50000 	70000 	60000 	40000 	36000 	40000 	55000 	65000 	55000 	65000 	50000 	30000 	86000 	70000 	40000 	52000 	55000 	50000 	55000 	70000 	50000 	55000 	52000 	65000 	45000 	50000 	60000 	40000 	55000

Difference 	0 	256000 	131000 	98000 	163000 	97000 	81000 	273000 	223000 	212000 	253000 	151000 	210000 	126000 	148000 	153000 	431000 	299000 	123000 	143000 	139000 	91000 	141000 	196000 	201000 	186000 	61000 	299000 	87000 	186000 	351000 	101000 	93000 	51000
Difference (%) 	0,00% 	312,81% 193,45% 179,21% 199,30% 70,25% 	49,25% 	238,53% 257,59% 188,48% 180,74% 110,00% 269,80% 221,49% 123,46% 245,22% 182,46% 186,42% 176,42% 193,94% 241,46% 142,54% 121,36% 172,56% 142,65% 86,24% 	74,46% 	172,97% 68,63% 	139,24% 209,49% 98,48% 	108,72% 101,73%

NDS DQVI 	0 	94000 	44000 	-6000 	-56000 	44000 	44000 	-106000 -56000 	-81000 	-156000 69000 	70000 	44000 	-81000 	-26000 	344000 	244000 	-36000 	-31000 	14000 	14000 	64000 	94000 	94000 	144000 	-6000 	194000 	31000 	94000 	244000 	44000 	-31000 	4000
PS3 EOE 	0 	72000 	32000 	42000 	52000 	-18000 	22000 	-118000 92000 	67000 	32000 	47000 	75000 	7000 	32000 	52000 	17000 	12000 	42000 	42000 	52000 	27000 	32000 	52000 	82000 	2000 	22000 	57000 	35000 	42000 	47000 	22000 	7000 	2000
360 EOE 	0 	53000 	38000 	33000 	33000 	3000 	3000 	-27000 	33000 	18000 	23000 	8000 	48000 	48000 	18000 	43000 	18000 	39000 	33000 	28000 	43000 	23000 	13000 	23000 	13000 	8000 	6000 	18000 	4000 	13000 	28000 	13000 	13000 	18000
PS3 ATIII 	0 	-37000 	-17000 	-17000 	-22000 	-32000 	-12000 	-22000 	-42000 	-46000 	-42000 	-27000 	-17000 	-27000 	-17000 	-32000 	-52000 	4000 	-12000 	-42000 	-30000 	-27000 	-32000 	-27000 	-12000 	-32000 	-27000 	-30000 	-17000 	-37000 	-32000 	-22000 	-42000 	-27000

No one got anything right.

Past Predictions Results:
12/07-12/13 Predictions Results
11/30-12/06 Predictions Results
11/23-11/29 Predictions Results

Thanks.
Ar tonelico 3 did a lot better than what I thought.

 

[icecream]

The PSP port is selling the same as the 360 version (Famitsu)

Yes, (although I was referring to dengeki numbers), but that's the point: PSP ports of these games usually outsell the 360 version 2-3x (see: Clannad). The fact that they're moving so closely with each other shows that the majority that wanted it had already gotten it for the 360 instead of waiting for the PSP port. The PSP numbers being so similar means that the only people that got it were people who only play on portables or didn't own a 360 (a minority of a minority, so to speak).

Not to mention the PSP version specifically released after the anime had just finished, so it also had the benefit of the popularity of the series and the wider interest, which also would contribute to the higher number of sales.

 

[BlazingDarkness]

So any guesses for first week God Eater sales? Didn't the demo get loads of downloads? Was the demo good?

 

[djtiesto]

Is that considered good sales for Resonance of Fate PS3?

 

[mello]

Yes, (although I was referring to dengeki numbers), but that's the point: PSP ports of these games usually outsell the 360 version 2-3x (see: Clannad). The fact that they're moving so closely with each other shows that the majority that wanted it had already gotten it for the 360 instead of waiting for the PSP port. The PSP numbers being so similar means that the only people that got it were people who only play on portables or didn't own a 360 (a minority of a minority, so to speak).

Not to mention the PSP version specifically released after the anime had just finished, so it also had the benefit of the popularity of the series and the wider interest, which also would contribute to the higher number of sales.

Or it could be that it's just a port, and like most ports with little distinction sales rarely move further than the original because those who were initially interested would have taken the steps to purchase it in the first place, other than retain the wishful thought of a port. There are examples were PSP ports of 360 games have gone on to sell better, but there aren't that many cases in that regard to suddenly suggest the PSP might not be the backup console anymore, not that I ever thought it was.

 

[icecream]

There are examples where PSP ports of 360 games have gone on to sell better, but there aren't that many cases in that regard to suddenly suggest the PSP might not be the backup console anymore, not that I ever thought it was.

Which is why I suggested the possibility. This is the first example of the PSP port not handily outperforming the 360 port, and this is despite a stronger demographic/media mix. Whether that will become the trend or not obviously remains to be seen, and is why I said it'll be interesting to see how No Fate! does, because it will be the first simultaneous platform release.

And the PSP is definitely the de facto backup console of choice for ADV developers. Whether it's first a PS2 game or a 360 game, if it doesn't sell or wants more sales, you'll hear about a PSP port after, never before.

 

[jj984jj]

Is that considered good sales for Resonance of Fate PS3?

It's not bomba, but most were expecting more I think.

 

[gerg]

Apparently Sandlot spent three years developing Reginleiv for the Wii - they started working on the title even before the Wii was released.

 

[Aru]

Goooo Ar

Spoiler

u

Tonelico 3 ! And please be as good as AT1 at least, I didn't get to play AT2

Disappointing sales for EoE.

I can't stop laughing at Last Rebellion though :lol

 

[charlequin]

I'm not happy

vs.

FIGHT!

if psp go drops below 1000 we need to start popping out the hilarious pre-360 bill gates xbox solid if not spectacular images.

..."if"?

 

[schuelma]

PSP 47,875
Wii 42,309
DSi LL 34,863
PS3 34,431
DSi 24,783
DS Lite 6,811
Xbox 360 4,089
PS2 2,182
PSP go 1,645

 

[Nirolak]

It seems we're at the point where Dragon Quest pretty much doesn't effect DS sales anymore, though I think that was expected.

It also seems Onken practically hit the nail on the head this time in regards to the PS3.

 

[schuelma]

It also seems Onken practically hit the nail on the head this time in regards to the PS3.

Yup. I definitely got that one wrong..shock!

Its amazing to see how long Wii can maintain decent sales when they literally have nothing coming up that can sell more than 75K LTD.

 

[Nirolak]

Yup. I definitely got that one wrong..shock!

Its amazing to see how long Wii can maintain decent sales when they literally have nothing coming up that can sell more than 75K LTD.

Yeah it is still holding really well.

Also, it seems that retailers ordered quite a few copies of God Eater, especially if the stack on the left is indicative of how high all the stacks used to be:

Also its marketing seems to be hitting all the classy notes:

Thanks to whoever took these.

 

[faridmon]

my prediction improved a bit, but still, its down right terrible (damn you Otakus for ruining it)


mine for next week:

Reginleiv - 12k
Mad World - 6k
DB2 DS - 24k

i think i am going to flop like those games............... again.

 

[MattyGrovesOrMe]

Is Madworld getting any kind of publicity or marketing in Japan? Generally, how has Platinum been received there?

 

[ULTROS!]

My prediction for this week:

Star Ocean: The Last Hope International ~ 150k :lol
God Eater: 240k

 

[thestopsign]

my prediction improved a bit, but still, its down right terrible (damn you Otakus for ruining it)


mine for next week:

Reginleiv - 12k
Mad World - 6k
DB2 DS - 24k

i think i am going to flop like those games............... again.

You are going to do god awful with those predictions. Undershot all of them besides Mad World (maybe).

Reginleiv: 30k
MadWorld: 9k
Dragonball 2 DS: 70k

God Eater: 310k
Star Ocean 4 PS3: 90k