CLOSED
March 2015 poll: voting and results
Rules:
- List a minimum of five and maximum of ten of your top superhero movies.
- This poll covers superhero movies released before January 1, 2017. That means The Lego Batman Movie and The Logan Old Man Movie are not eligible this time around.
- Number lists in order from #1 to #10. 10 points go to your #1 choice, 9 points to #2, etc. Lists without numbering won't count.
- Feel free to supplement rankings with thoughts on your choices, honorable mentions, etc. as long as your movie titles and rankings stand out (bolding/underlining).
- Make only one list. You may edit your list until voting ends (will leave this open for a week or two, depending on when new entries dry up).
Reminder: not all movies based on comic books are superhero movies (Monkeybone), and not all superhero movies are necessarily based on comic books (Condorman).
Be nice and respectful of other people's lists. After voting finishes I'll create a new thread to share and discuss the results.
Some resources:
Superhero movies, ranked (io9)
The 100 Best Superhero Movies of All Time (Paste)
List of all superhero movies
Regarding that last link, generally movies with a 'C' (non-superhero comic) would be ineligible here. However, that site's classifications aren't sacrosanct and opinions on whether some movies fit in the superhero genre will vary. My view is the results should/will ultimately reflect NeoGAF's consensus. That includes scenarios in which half of you think something like Mr. Magoo is a superhero movie.
March 2015 poll: voting and results
Rules:
- List a minimum of five and maximum of ten of your top superhero movies.
- This poll covers superhero movies released before January 1, 2017. That means The Lego Batman Movie and The Logan Old Man Movie are not eligible this time around.
- Number lists in order from #1 to #10. 10 points go to your #1 choice, 9 points to #2, etc. Lists without numbering won't count.
- Feel free to supplement rankings with thoughts on your choices, honorable mentions, etc. as long as your movie titles and rankings stand out (bolding/underlining).
- Make only one list. You may edit your list until voting ends (will leave this open for a week or two, depending on when new entries dry up).
Reminder: not all movies based on comic books are superhero movies (Monkeybone), and not all superhero movies are necessarily based on comic books (Condorman).
Be nice and respectful of other people's lists. After voting finishes I'll create a new thread to share and discuss the results.
Some resources:
Superhero movies, ranked (io9)
The 100 Best Superhero Movies of All Time (Paste)
List of all superhero movies
Regarding that last link, generally movies with a 'C' (non-superhero comic) would be ineligible here. However, that site's classifications aren't sacrosanct and opinions on whether some movies fit in the superhero genre will vary. My view is the results should/will ultimately reflect NeoGAF's consensus. That includes scenarios in which half of you think something like Mr. Magoo is a superhero movie.