-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Persona 5 |OT3| Ryuji Did Nothing Wr- [DELETED BY ADMIN]
- Thread starter cj_iwakura
- Start date
ClearMetal
Member
I knew they were there, but I stopped using them after the first dungeon. Just not enough value to them to make running around town every week (two weeks? I don't remember the exact restock time) worth it. Especially because the shadows in the lasts stretch of dungeon 1 generally demand more of your SP than these drinks can refund (only 5 SP a pop).
MudoSkills
Volcano High Alumnus (Cum Laude)
Money, compendium, and some items: skill cards, weapons/armour/accessories, special items (social link gifts, Christmas gifts).
Charm does play a big role on how difficult P3's final boss can be, but not because of Mitsuru. As long as you set up her tactics correctly she shouldn't be using Marin Karin, specially not against a boss.
The biggest issue with P3's final boss is how random the last stretch of the battle is. Whether you win, lose or keep stuck in the last form for hours depends entirely on
Night Queen
Yalda
Mr_Antimatter
Member
Best WTF in the game is When you Max/romance
, and romance
Why you ask?
Temperence
devil
Why you ask?
Because then you can call over Temp, whom you are dating, and have her make coffee, then have the good doctor come over to have some 'coffee' upstairs in your room.
When I romanced everyone, I had a similar situation happen often. 1st noticed it when Kawa was making curry for me and the doctor came over. Then it happened with every night girl I had like Ohya and Hifumi. That would be a tough situation to get out of, but none of the ladies said anything. Hope in future games the group acknowledges if you have a girlfriend.
Yeah, I lost most of the times due to charm related incidents. It did involve Marin Karin though. Mainly against my own party members.
OrbOutrider
Neo Member
Recognition of relationships would've been awesome banter material for Mementos. Like dating more than one would lead to Ryuji almost revealing your sexual adventures to everyone.
ClearMetal
Member
Finally started my NG+ playthrough. If there's one thing I like about Persona, it's how it always feels like you're coming home in a sense. (Even if everyone treats you like shit in the beginning of this game.)
Tried to remote play it on my Mac, but kind of disappointed by the obvious drop in image quality. I thought it would be a nice way to bypass the stupid screenshot block, but I'm not so sure anymore now... It seems the Vita has better image quality, though, so I might try that as well.
I went with the Japanese voices again, but I still wonder if I shouldn't pick the English ones instead. The lack of subtitles in animated scenes and when watching movies (either at home or at the theater) is annoying. But since I'm used to everyone's Japanese voices, I fear the English ones will just sound weird. I guess I should decide soon, since switching too far into the game isn't an option for me either.
Edit: Switched to English. The protagonist's voice sounds kind of weird, but Sojiro's is fine. The only thing that's bothering me so far (just introduced myself at school) is how the game switches between full dub and voice grunts. Why leave out a few lines in between scenes? It just sounds cheap. I could've sworn everything in these scenes was voiced in Japanese, as well.
Tried to remote play it on my Mac, but kind of disappointed by the obvious drop in image quality. I thought it would be a nice way to bypass the stupid screenshot block, but I'm not so sure anymore now... It seems the Vita has better image quality, though, so I might try that as well.
I went with the Japanese voices again, but I still wonder if I shouldn't pick the English ones instead. The lack of subtitles in animated scenes and when watching movies (either at home or at the theater) is annoying. But since I'm used to everyone's Japanese voices, I fear the English ones will just sound weird. I guess I should decide soon, since switching too far into the game isn't an option for me either.
Edit: Switched to English. The protagonist's voice sounds kind of weird, but Sojiro's is fine. The only thing that's bothering me so far (just introduced myself at school) is how the game switches between full dub and voice grunts. Why leave out a few lines in between scenes? It just sounds cheap. I could've sworn everything in these scenes was voiced in Japanese, as well.
Finished it,
of course after using characters without harrisan recovery none of the characters are hungry when the attack hits xD. Lvl 42 is doable (I was 43 now) but it is also a bit of luck. In my case,
Yusuke's counterstrike went off removing almost half its health. So a good strategy might be using physical reflects also.
Yusuke's counterstrike went off removing almost half its health. So a good strategy might be using physical reflects also.
Does anyone use party member
Haru
She seems really weak. She is the same level as the rest of the team and has good armor but she constantly dies. A lot.
StarCreator
Member
She does insane amounts of multi target gun damage (especially if you get all her Persona passive abilities), so yes. I used her more than I thought I would; she's especially effective for just literally blowing away regular encounters.
ShadowSoldier89
Member
Shes the 3rd strongest party member in raw power. Ryuji > Ann > Haru. One Shot Kill stacked with Cripple and Snipe does consistently high damage. The only reason she cant beat Ryuji and Ann is because she doesn't get Charge(concentrate in Ann's case). Cripple and Snipe also make her grenade launcher excellent for killing generic encounters. Amrita shower adds some versatility alongside hitting weaknesses with her Psi skills.
ClearMetal
Member
So last night I sent the calling card for the first dungeon. As I watched the scene where Kamoshida finds out, I noticed the way the calling cards were arranged:
At first I thought they were randomly posted, but as I looked at them, I thought they might resemble katakana. So I tried to decipher them. The first part, not completely visible in the picture, says:
力モ
The second part (which was a lot harder to read) says:
シダ
The first part is translated as 'pimp' by Google Translate, which is sort of appropriate for that asshole I guess. So I thought it might be a taunt or something. Turns out, it just spells out his name. 力 = Ka; モ= mo; シ = shi; ダ = da. Google interpreted the first kana as kanji, hence the mistranslation.
Oh well, still a nice detail and something I completely missed the first time around.
At first I thought they were randomly posted, but as I looked at them, I thought they might resemble katakana. So I tried to decipher them. The first part, not completely visible in the picture, says:
力モ
The second part (which was a lot harder to read) says:
シダ
The first part is translated as 'pimp' by Google Translate, which is sort of appropriate for that asshole I guess. So I thought it might be a taunt or something. Turns out, it just spells out his name. 力 = Ka; モ= mo; シ = shi; ダ = da. Google interpreted the first kana as kanji, hence the mistranslation.
Oh well, still a nice detail and something I completely missed the first time around.
UpDownLeftRight
Banned
Is it worth pushing through the final dungeon if I'm not really feeling it anymore? I kinda wanna know how it ends but I'm really not sure I have another dungeon in me. I expect this one to be big too and have seen what's waiting at the end which is also a deterrent.
I've heard the ending is disappointing so not sure if I've seen the best of it yet or not.
Have I had the twist that people talk about already?
ClearMetal
Member
Depends... could you post what exactly have you seen at the end? (Between spoiler tags of course.) I have to ask, because the entire ending of the game is spoiler galore. I'm afraid I will say too much if I don't know exactly where you are with the ending.
UpDownLeftRight
Banned
Right now I'm just at the start of
Shida's dungeon. Seen the whole thing with the police station etc.
StarCreator
Member
That palace is pretty divisive, it seems - I liked it a lot but many in the previous threads found it tedious. I would say you're quite far enough into the game that you should push for the ending, but I can't make that decision for you if you really aren't feeling it.
ClearMetal
Member
I think that from that point in the game to the absolute ending took me about 15 - 20 hours. That includes time spent on grinding, persona fusion and going through daily life as slowly as possible because I didn't want it to end. So you could shave a few hours of if you rush through the less important parts.
Spoilers about the gameplay of this dungeon in the next part:
The dungeon you're in is possibly the larges in the game and contains a few puzzle segments which you probably won't enjoy (they contain a lot of running back and forth through rooms and corridors, flipping switches and the like).
You could always watch a playthrough on YouTube, but this doesn't pack the same punch as the genuine experience. If you haven't done it yet, it might be worth it to put the game aside for a week or two to recharge your battery. I personally feel it's a shame to throw in the towel here, since you're relatively close to ending it.
cj_iwakura
Member
I really enjoyed it, mostly because they nailed the design and layers of the locale.
UpDownLeftRight
Banned
Yeah you're probably right, does feel like a waste to end it so close to the finish line, especially when it's basically just coasting after. Think I will just take a break and come back to finish it. I've been really powering through it and I do find the Persona series a little text heavy after a while despite appreciating the lengths it goes to on that front too. Might just be a series where I need to do it in parts rather than one long run.
Shadow Ranger
Member
On the final palace/last days now. So bloody glad. The game is so overly drawn out it's unbelievable. It had a solid beginning, and so far a decent end, but the middle...the middle is just not very good. And it's a lot of middle! I'd love to stick around for fusing more Persona, but the game long since outstayed its welcome for me, so as soon as the end credits finish rolling, I'm done!
kraspkibble
Permabanned.
i'm about 30 hours in so far and just went into the 3rd palace for the first time.
i'm still really enjoying it if anything it's got more interesting since i met Akechi and i'm really wanting to know what's going on with Sae + Makato. I think Akechi + Makato will end up joining the team or at least Makato. Not sure what to think of Sae really. Also I'm still wanting to find out the deal with Morgana....I quite like him except when he's telling me I can't do stuff and to go sleep lol. I don't think he really is a human and he must be connected to the metaverse place somehow. Probably put there by Igor or those twins.
The only thing I've been spoiled with is that
i'm still really enjoying it if anything it's got more interesting since i met Akechi and i'm really wanting to know what's going on with Sae + Makato. I think Akechi + Makato will end up joining the team or at least Makato. Not sure what to think of Sae really. Also I'm still wanting to find out the deal with Morgana....I quite like him except when he's telling me I can't do stuff and to go sleep lol. I don't think he really is a human and he must be connected to the metaverse place somehow. Probably put there by Igor or those twins.
The only thing I've been spoiled with is that
the Igor this early on is an imposter which is why his voice is different.
ClearMetal
Member
Well, they are on the game's cover. So... ;p
I'm currently at the start of the second arc (5/6). Just officially formed the Phantom Thieves. Went with the name 'Shitennou', the romanized name of the Four Heavenly Kings. I wanted a name from mythology and this sounded cool. They protect the nation against evil and there are four of you (Joker, Ryuji, Morgana, Ann) at this point, so it's somewhat fitting.
Spoiler for September and onward:
Calling yourselves the Four Heavenly Kings when you're only three high school students and a cat is also cocky as fuck, which ties in nicely with the Thieves' popularity eventually going to their heads.
Makoto was also properly introduced just now. I actually didn't know she was voiced by Cherami Leigh in the English dub. I wanted to romance someone else this time, but I don't know if I can anymore. I wonder if she will go full
At the end of October now.
Game is still a blast.
Suddenly I have no idea where this game is heading. Who is the traitor?
Is there a traitor? Adechi seems to be a good bet. But two defectives being the bad guy in a row seems a bit much. I can see Makato exposing them because she is afraid Sae might die. The weird white flashes are strange though. Was MC drugged to forget things? How rich is Haru? Will MC finally find something to put on his shelves? So.Many.Questions
Is there a traitor? Adechi seems to be a good bet. But two defectives being the bad guy in a row seems a bit much. I can see Makato exposing them because she is afraid Sae might die. The weird white flashes are strange though. Was MC drugged to forget things? How rich is Haru? Will MC finally find something to put on his shelves? So.Many.Questions
Game is still a blast.
Why do you hate him? I don't even get why you state that "the developer wants you to hate him".
I really believe he is one of the better written characters and along with makoto and futaba he is one of my favourites.
Yeah, fuck the guy who had an abusive dad and a shitty school life who fucked everything up for himself and the people around him. Also fuck him for having very realistic anger issues because I definitely remember being calm and perfect in highschool.
Now if you'll excuse me, i'll go hug my Makoto daki. the canon waifu ^_^
ShadowSoldier89
Member
yea Ryuji is a great character with a lot of details to shape the picture of who he is.
Its Yusuke thats shit.
Its Yusuke thats shit.
ClearMetal
Member
Nothing wrong with either Ryuji or Yusuke. Although I wish the latter would've gotten a skill like Apt Pupil. Something to help him during the end-game, when Ryuji gets Charge and God's Hand. It doesn't help that his ultimate persona is cool as hell, while Ryuji's looks pretty bad.
I hope they do something about this in Crimson. They could give Makoto a heavy multi-target physical attack while there at it. Her strength is almost as high as her magic stat, but she gets Flash Bomb (medium damage, chance at dizzy) at level 31 and that's about it. Kind of a waste.
As for the real shitlord in this game, it has to be Akechi. I wanted an option to punch him in the face on live television during that trip to the studios.
Edit:
Oh wow. Just met Ohya in the English dub. Didn't really see it before but with that voice it's like Chie and Yukiko performed a fusion dance and she's the result.
I hope they do something about this in Crimson. They could give Makoto a heavy multi-target physical attack while there at it. Her strength is almost as high as her magic stat, but she gets Flash Bomb (medium damage, chance at dizzy) at level 31 and that's about it. Kind of a waste.
As for the real shitlord in this game, it has to be Akechi. I wanted an option to punch him in the face on live television during that trip to the studios.
Edit:
Oh wow. Just met Ohya in the English dub. Didn't really see it before but with that voice it's like Chie and Yukiko performed a fusion dance and she's the result.
KuwabaraTheMan
Banned
Ryuji is one of the most interesting party members in any Persona game ever, and he's also really likable. His confidant story in particular is above pretty much all the other party members, and his scenes in the story are all really good. Yeah, he tends to get over excited and shout out stuff in random scenes, but his whole character arc really resonated with me. His relationship with the main character feels really real to me, and just about everything about him, from his anger issues, to his attitude, to all of the ways he's screwed up in life and desperately wants to change things feels really genuine.
The developer definitely doesn't want you to hate Ryuji.
Shadow Ranger
Member
Good god! I finally finished the game after 98 hours (and I started day 1. Life, yo).
I thought I was on the last palace in my previous post...I was. Sort of. But holy crap did it drag on and on and on! Only to then throw more crap at the player after it. Never ending, and not in a good way.
Thoughts...
+
Slick style
Soundtrack is mostly great, minus the awful Engrish lyrics
Solid beginning
Persona fusion and related mechanics (not the SLs as I personally always find them shallow) are still fun and interesting
I liked the characters for the most part. Morgana is superior to shitty Teddy in every way (he was the worst thing about P4).
-
Overly long, overstays its welcome. A worse case of Okami's drawn out story, basically.
Middle of the game is a drag and post
drag down what was seemingly a brighter approach to the end (again, drawn out).
Engrich lyrics. The voice is good, the Engrish is not.
So many missed subtitles/bad localisation - in the grand scheme of things it's minor, but it spoils the general production of the game.
I really hope Persona 6 changes things up. Move away from high school,
as a boss is played out in everything (then again I suppose it's an SMT thing), change up the SLs - I know people love them, and I do think they were better than P4, partly because the characters are better, but I generally find the interaction uninteresting with no real substance. Open the world up a bit more, stop stopping us from doing things. If I want to stay awake and lose focus, let me. If I want to bunk school, let me. I don't need Morgana telling what I can and can't do every five seconds. Or cut to those parts automatically, as it's just a pointless action the player has to do, no matter how minimal, I gain no value and no enjoyment from it, just irritation - it's comparable to forced walking scenes for me. Pointless interaction.
Overall, I did like it more than P4 but given how never ending this felt, I don't think I could ever play it again, and the less than 40% score of the end trophy says enough - people barely finish 35 hour rpgs, not surprised people would be turned off a 80+ hour one just for a first-time play through, especially when, for me, a large part of it is dull and forgettable.
Onwards to other games!
I thought I was on the last palace in my previous post...I was. Sort of. But holy crap did it drag on and on and on! Only to then throw more crap at the player after it. Never ending, and not in a good way.
Thoughts...
+
Slick style
Soundtrack is mostly great, minus the awful Engrish lyrics
Solid beginning
Persona fusion and related mechanics (not the SLs as I personally always find them shallow) are still fun and interesting
I liked the characters for the most part. Morgana is superior to shitty Teddy in every way (he was the worst thing about P4).
-
Overly long, overstays its welcome. A worse case of Okami's drawn out story, basically.
Middle of the game is a drag and post
Shido's Palace
Engrich lyrics. The voice is good, the Engrish is not.
So many missed subtitles/bad localisation - in the grand scheme of things it's minor, but it spoils the general production of the game.
I really hope Persona 6 changes things up. Move away from high school,
God
Overall, I did like it more than P4 but given how never ending this felt, I don't think I could ever play it again, and the less than 40% score of the end trophy says enough - people barely finish 35 hour rpgs, not surprised people would be turned off a 80+ hour one just for a first-time play through, especially when, for me, a large part of it is dull and forgettable.
Onwards to other games!
This game has felt like a ball and chain for a few months now , I feel like I can't move on to other games until I'm done with it but it feels like I still have 15-20 hours left despite being 89 hours deep.
Certainly my real life shenanigans lately haven't helped - from the beginning of June up until last Friday I worked 55-65 hours per week and just didn't feel like gaming during the 2 hours a night plus Sunday that I did have. Last week I finally had a chance to play this some more , finished up a section of dungeon and it just let me go right into the next chunk without a save point so I kept going and an hour later , with that section nearly done I ended up getting banked by a regular enemy encounter. So basically my 2 hour play session was a complete waste of time. Kind of soured me on going back but it feels insane to give up on this now.
There's so much I really do like about this game and on the whole it's a great JRPG but at this point I'm left wishing it was a lot shorter ... like 50-60 hours tops. Give people more incentive to replay it too.
Certainly my real life shenanigans lately haven't helped - from the beginning of June up until last Friday I worked 55-65 hours per week and just didn't feel like gaming during the 2 hours a night plus Sunday that I did have. Last week I finally had a chance to play this some more , finished up a section of dungeon and it just let me go right into the next chunk without a save point so I kept going and an hour later , with that section nearly done I ended up getting banked by a regular enemy encounter. So basically my 2 hour play session was a complete waste of time. Kind of soured me on going back but it feels insane to give up on this now.
There's so much I really do like about this game and on the whole it's a great JRPG but at this point I'm left wishing it was a lot shorter ... like 50-60 hours tops. Give people more incentive to replay it too.
StarCreator
Member
Playing P4 again afterward (my second attempt at it, which has stalled out just like the first) it strikes me that P4 takes control away in favor of plot dumps just as often as P5 does. The only thing P5 does different is give the illusion of control when this happens - likely for mechanical reasons, because this allows for more save opportunities and they can't deny the player access to the cardboard box of DLC holding.
ClearMetal
Member
True, it was just as bad in P4. It also seems worse in P5 because it happens so many days in succession. There's the beginning of the game, of course, but that can be justified by saying the game needs to set up the story and everything. But then, when you think the game has finally opened up, the Madarame arc comes around and you're suddenly 'grounded' for a week, almost two weeks in a row because of plot advancement and 4 days of exams.
I get the set-up of two time slots a day and one activity taking up an entire slot for gameplay reasons, even if you can ride the train to every district in Tokyo without a minute going by. But these 'go to bed early' instanced break my willing suspension of disbelief for some reason. I can't wrap my mind around the notion that an activity like watching TV, reading a book or studying somehow impedes your ability to go to bed early. If I'm home at 7 and want to go to bed at 9, I still have enough time to grab a bite, watch TV and take a quick shower, for example. So instead of immediately sending you to bed, I wish they had put in some activities in or around Leblanc that you can do for fun without offering a reward (or just a small one, like only 1 social stat point instead of the usual 2-3).
cj_iwakura
Member
Imagine my surprise when I heard someone with a Life Will Change ringtone at work.
And I couldn't figure out who.
And I couldn't figure out who.
Via Purifico
Banned
I've resumed my playthrough. I smell a rat already and I am glad Ryuji was called out finally.
StarCreator
Member
I heard the message chime when I went to the theater to see No Game No Life Zero, but that's about it.
She became a regular in my party after a while. Her gun skills let her wipe enemy groups very easily. I ran her + Ryuji + Makoto most of the time, and I think they worked well together. Anything that wasn't resistant to physical got wrecked between
Haru
Ryuji is one of my favorite characters in the game, and my favorite iteration of the "first friend you make" trope in Persona games. I think the game did a really good job of showing him as a well-meaning hothead who is surprisingly mature if he's calm, but a dumbass when he isn't. Though he manages to make an ass of himself a lot, it's well counterbalanced by the times when he sobers up and actually talks seriously.
I absolutely don't think he's supposed to be hated.
Via Purifico
Banned
If he wasn't meant to be hated they did a bad job at it. When
All I could think about was how it was a long time coming and others in the group should have called him out on it earlier. He also placed the group at risk many times with his stupid outbursts.
Morgana called him out for his self centered nature
All I could think about was how it was a long time coming and others in the group should have called him out on it earlier. He also placed the group at risk many times with his stupid outbursts.
Ugh... so after nearly 6 hours of playtime I've polished off Palace
, it was actually pretty well designed but much like this game on the whole - it overstayed it's welcome especially towards the end.
The calling card bit was pretty neat though so I'm looking forward to wrapping this one up possibly as early as tomorrow and then
7
Seriously , whose idea was it to have players fight the 5th miniboss (which was just an absolute slog I might add) and then without any warning or break subject players to not 1 but 3 additional bosses. I ended up having to use all my healing beads as well as a soma to get through that debacle, none of it was overly difficult just draining.
The calling card bit was pretty neat though so I'm looking forward to wrapping this one up possibly as early as tomorrow and then
I'll have the entire month of december free to get as many social links done as possible , I've been saving my romance for makoto but it being locked to 5 charm is making that difficult, not even sure if it's still possible at this point to be honest but I'll try.
I'm 95 hours into this game right now and based on some skimming I've done about what's left I figure I still have 10-15 hours to go ... I like this game I really do but ... geeze , it could have been a healthy well paced 60 hour game with minimal changes.
ClearMetal
Member
Currently at 6/12 (absolutely love these two days, btw. Hotpot scene is great) and damn, Ryuji's definitely getting louder. I feel he was loud in the Japanese dub, but at a more steady level. In the English dub, he started out pretty normal, but now he seems to be shouting the majority of his voiced lines.
Damn good voice acting, though. Max Mittelman nailed it.
Damn good voice acting, though. Max Mittelman nailed it.
StarCreator
Member
For what it's worth,
that caught me by surprise, too. I don't remember if I used a Soma for it, but if it was, it was the only point in the entire game I felt I needed one, and I was playing on Hard difficulty. Admittedly, I used the Flu+Death trick a couple times so even Akechi had his endgame skills before he left the party.
. Strength confidant max rank is fun,
Dave1988
Member
So, DeepSilver released the Mega Costume Bundle for EU players this week and it contains the Christmas Costumes Set. Only problem is, they haven't released the standalone version of the costume, which should be free. So, if European P5 players want the outfits, they have to pay through the nose for them. Kind of fucked up, no?
Mathrin
Member
Lame, only just found this topic. Completed it last month after 115 hours. Dont think I have played a game quite like it. The style, the pace everything was so good for me.
Got really attached to
story, and found myself really pulling for them in every additional relationship event with Sojiro.
Im sure its been said before but the VA for Akechi deserves any and all praise he gets for
.
Totally up for a restructured or slightly improved version ala P4G. Not that I needed an excuse to go straight back and new game + it!
Got really attached to
Futabas
Im sure its been said before but the VA for Akechi deserves any and all praise he gets for
his quite frankly stellar performance on the boat. His turn towards madness - especially while fighting him was just so good. Raw is probably the best word I have for it
Totally up for a restructured or slightly improved version ala P4G. Not that I needed an excuse to go straight back and new game + it!
Are you counting game overs, and reloading the game? (In my case, I got around 80 hours on the clock, but I did some resetting near the end to help max out confidants.)