-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Ps5 vs XSX call of duty
- Thread starter geordiemp
- Start date
Agnostic2020
Member
Ps5 performing a bit better again.
Becoming a trend i guess.
Like for like comparison:
Also xsx has 1 second drops that are bad but for 1 second like this one :
Becoming a trend i guess.
Like for like comparison:
Also xsx has 1 second drops that are bad but for 1 second like this one :
Last edited:
Kupfer
Member
Didn't watch but thumbnail says 1080p@120fps ...
Agnostic2020
Member
At 120 fps mode they r both 1080p
Schmick
Member
1080p. Its says in the YouTube video title.
Neko Mimi Mode
Member
Drops on both versions, killcams for XsX and gameplay for PS5. Looks to be about even overall.
Which is weird because the XsX game is online but the PS5 is a private match against bots.
Which is weird because the XsX game is online but the PS5 is a private match against bots.
Rossco EZ
Member
thanks, i’m guessing for war zone to be 120 as well that drops to 1080?
Schmick
Member
Comments like this are getting boring and don't help the discussion unless of course your intention is to fuel the war.
OmegaSpear
Member
Why is the XSX performing worse?
Yoboman
Member
Sorry, mum
The XSX gets the largest frame drops over the PS5 when they respawn or just start playing. It seems the SSD / IO really provides an advantage there to prevent loading being an issue whilst playing. Other than that, the frame drops are fairly equivalent with drops into the 105’s/ 110’s on both the XSX and PS5. For actual gameplay then, they’re achieving more or less the same.
Schmick
Member
I'd argue that it isn't really, frames were dropping after player death. I still think it's far too early to judge a consoles performance.
geordiemp
Member
It never will be alignhed its multiplayer at 1080p120, so the dips will never be aligned, just need to look at teh stability and the amount of frame rate dip.
Ps5 performs better here but only just, both are great in gameplay
Last edited:
Physiognomonics
Member
Yes it actually goes down to 82fps on XSX here. Some kind of bottleneck we already saw in DMC5 high fps mode.It's not a good comparison at all but overall they perform about the same with slight drops to ~110FPS in gameplay. Othere than this kill cam spot on XSX:
Neko Mimi Mode
Member
At the very least the video should show both online, or both against bots. Instead we've got XsX online and PS5 against bots.
And yes, both versions are roughly equal here. Though we all know you wouldn't have posted the thread if you genuinely believed that was the case.
Last edited by a moderator:
BabyYoda
Banned
Every comparison I've seen has been a tiny bit in Series X's favour, not sure what videos you've been watching...not bad considering developers have had the PS5 debut kits for a while longer and Microsoft's new development software will take a while longer to get to grips with!Ps5 performing a bit better again.
Becoming a trend i guess.
Expect Series X to pull ahead eventually, if not, you might be left a tad disappointed.
Yeah I see the bigger drops on Xbox
BlueXImpulse
Banned
Only complaint is I wish they completely synced the footage on each side, if possible.
geordiemp
Member
Only possible in campaign, this is multiplayer
sendit
Member
Doubt this has anything to do with it. I’m sure the majority of, if not all the assets have already been loaded in to RAM.
Last edited:
Armorian
Banned
So far XSX performs slighty worse mostly. We are talking about console that was supposed to be AT LEAST (when PS5 is "overclocked", not standard 9TF
) 20% more powerful so even if there is slight win in DMC in some modes it's completly not matching paper specs of the consoles.
Armorian
Banned
Yeah you reminded me of this... Devs has less CPU memory and with lower speed than on PS5...
In PS4 SKU due to how BC works.
Last edited:
Agnostic2020
Member
Ps5 performs better in assasim creed valhalla at higher resolution
And ps5 outperforms xsx in dmc5 se in high frame mode
So no you are wrong . We will Keep waiting maybe it will change?
Night and day tone change from few backs though when xsx was gonna crush ps5
geordiemp
Member
It does not matter for the gameplay during death of course in COD..
But the low dips does show how each hardware power and architectural design deals with different work loads at 120 FPS and ps5 is just more nimble.
Last edited:
Monkeygourmet
Banned
Radical_3d
Member
Ah... the flipping table...
The SX is still a great value. MS has a lot of internal studios now and I love Halo. Game Pass is an insane value and is the only next gen console where BC is so good you can play Black at 4K. If that isn’t a win I don’t know why we have video games in the first place. It’s just not the most powerful console ever forever ever.
Last edited:
Physiognomonics
Member
Not if they constantly stream the assets during gameplay like they do in Demon's souls. Those consoles have only 13GB available.
geordiemp
Member
Both XSX and Ps5 silicon revisions were 2H 2019. Both are coming in hot. Your hope for the future :
Monkeygourmet
Banned
Vae_Victis
Banned
It's interesting that the game pretty much only drops frames during killcams on both versions, with the Series X being slightly worse there.
Both GPUs definitely hold 120 fps without a problem all the time, but there is a continued hiccup whenever the game has to fetch stored data to recreate a past occurrence. What is being used for it is probably a tiny amount of memory and is probably kept in RAM already, so the SSD is out of the equation.
So my layman best guesses are that there is either an inefficiency related to the CPU having to recreate a past event while keeping track in background of the current action still going on (even if it's not being rendered), or there is something related to reading stuff back from RAM while the game is still being run in the background (and consequently RAM could still also be written at the same time).
In any case, this seems more like a small optimization issue on both consoles, that for some reason hits the XSX version a bit harder.
Both GPUs definitely hold 120 fps without a problem all the time, but there is a continued hiccup whenever the game has to fetch stored data to recreate a past occurrence. What is being used for it is probably a tiny amount of memory and is probably kept in RAM already, so the SSD is out of the equation.
So my layman best guesses are that there is either an inefficiency related to the CPU having to recreate a past event while keeping track in background of the current action still going on (even if it's not being rendered), or there is something related to reading stuff back from RAM while the game is still being run in the background (and consequently RAM could still also be written at the same time).
In any case, this seems more like a small optimization issue on both consoles, that for some reason hits the XSX version a bit harder.
RoadHazard
Gold Member
I don't think this game is doing that in MP. Wouldn't really work on PS4/XB1. Pretty sure it loads the full map all at once.
Last edited:
FunkMiller
Gold Member
Becoming clearer and clearer that devs have been able to work with the Ps5 longer and better than they have XSX. The XBox will catch up over time, but will it be too late in terms of market share? If CoD is perceived to run better on Ps5, that’s a lot of sales going Sony’s way.
geordiemp
Member
Yep its multi, there wil be little streaming on small multiplayer maps at 120 FPS.
Physiognomonics
Member
They guy who made the video prefers to play on PS5. It's the best version apparently.
Yoboman
Member
Will it though? PS5s key features like the geometry engine and SSD aren't even being leveraged yet
Xbox was supposed to have the clear advantages on games developed for the last gen pipines but it clearly doesn't
30yearsofhurt
Member
Dat 2TF advantage right?
Monkeygourmet
Banned
It’s becoming clear the Series X has more brute force but the PS5 is more “tuned”.
That extra tuning of the PS5 will result in more stability overall. Less framedrops / less screen tear / less texture stream load in etc etc
That extra tuning of the PS5 will result in more stability overall. Less framedrops / less screen tear / less texture stream load in etc etc