Ended up buying Bioshock 1 and 2. I had never played them and they were cheap.
I started with 1 and the atmosphere is amazing, although I have this problem in which I have trouble understanding people talking by radio, so, while makes it more immersive, it bothers me that the only one I have this problem with is Atlas (Is that his name? I don't remember, to be honest)
A nice mix between shooters (although I find myself playing stealthy and only scoring headshots, like I tend to do in this kind of games) and horror. The Telekinesis augment makes me want a sequel to Psy-Ops so much...
I'm thinking about getting GTA V too, although I'm not sure... How's the game in PS3 and overall? I never played the story in San Andreas, just kept driving around and causing mayhem...